555 of 680 people found the following review helpful
I /wanted/ to give it a better rating...,
This review is from: Wonder (Hardcover)
...but I couldn't. Here, I'll explain why.
First Sentence: I know I'm not an ordinary ten-year-old kid.
How I Acquired the Book: Borrowed from my town's library.
The Review: When I first read the synopsis of this book, my thoughts instantly turned to a friend of mine who had a facial anomaly, just like the main character, August, in this book. So I was excited to read it, to get a glimpse of what my friend's life could be like.
In that aspect, it did not disappoint. Auggie's voice is brilliant, and you can tell R.J. Palacio definitely spends a lot of time around kids. Auggie sounds just like my friend when he was in fifth grade, and is highly believable. It is this that makes the book so heartwarming and realistic. A book full of Auggie would be great.
But this book is /not/ entirely full of Auggie. The first and last 80 pages or so of it are AMAZING, definitely the best parts, because they're told from Auggie's point of view. But the rest of the book is told from different characters' points of view, like Auggie's friends and family. This just does not work. Each character gets 20 to 50 pages, and as I just was getting used to and liking their voice, BAM, the point of view changed again. In the middle of the book I found myself scanning the book to get to Auggie's part more quickly. Not only that, but the plot is lost in these parts, and these supporting characters are not well-developed.
That said, I completely respect and admire Ms. Palacio for doing something so ambitious. It may have not been the best it could be, but Wonder has absolutely raised my awareness and sympathy of people like Auggie. While this novel doesn't deserve a standing ovation, I will be waiting to see if Ms. Palacio's next novel deserves one.
-reviewed by a teenager. (I apologize for any teenagery and/or snarky comments in this review, if they have offended you. I understand they can be very annoying, just like teenagers themselves. In any case, thanks for dealing with them and thanks for reading this review.)
Tracked by 12 customers
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-10 of 41 posts in this discussion
Initial post: Jun 29, 2012 6:45:54 AM PDT
Shoshanna Friedman says:
You're teenager?? Don't apologize for anything...kudos to you for writing such a sophisticated and well thought out review. I'm an English teacher and am quite impressed! Keep on writing and you'll get your standing ovation!
Posted on Jun 30, 2012 10:05:53 AM PDT
You're a good writer, hydrogenpoptart. Keep reviewing! Perhaps, you'll have a story of your own someday.
In reply to an earlier post on Jun 30, 2012 10:21:27 AM PDT
Dear Ms. Friedman and Anonymous-
Thank you! Really, I mean it. Thank you for reading and commenting on my review! People like you guys are why reviewers keep on reviewing. And writers can't be writers without readers, right? So, again, thank you so much for reading my review! :D
Posted on Aug 19, 2012 9:43:03 AM PDT
Laura Robles says:
Really great review. I was looking for a reviewer that had first hand experience with someone with a facial deformity. I knew someone in High School with one. And I also went to a disabled grade school. I was 13 before I went to a regular school. So I was curious if I would like it or would be reminded of terrible memories. I enjoyed what you had to say and will buy this book today. Thank you.
In reply to an earlier post on Aug 20, 2012 3:59:03 PM PDT
Dear Ms. Robles--
Thank you for your kind comment! I found what you had to say very fascinating too. I knew I couldn't be the only one out there who knew someone with a facial deformity. Even though I didn't enjoy Wonder that much, I hope that you will find something that you'll like in it. Again, thanks for reading!
In reply to an earlier post on Aug 25, 2012 6:55:08 PM PDT
very well written piece...but in my opinion it is important to see how others view auggie and how their day to day life changes based upon him being in his life...via loves him to death but you can see at some points she needs to have her own life and people know her for who she is and not just auggies sister ...others narrating the book brings important aspects into the book..how everyone perceives august...miranda mr. tushman...etc etc
In reply to an earlier post on Aug 27, 2012 11:31:41 AM PDT
Hi there, pfs63!
I think I see what you're saying, as the thought did cross my mind a few times. I suppose it is important, but not necessary for readers to see the viewpoint of characters other than Auggie. I also think it was very daring and creative for the author to think of that concept. However, I thought that the execution of the switching points-of-view concept wasn't that great, and some characters sounded very similar to one another. I hope that explains things a bit more. And even with that said, thank you for your compliment; I really appreciate it!
Posted on Oct 1, 2012 10:41:19 PM PDT
Last edited by the author on Oct 1, 2012 10:42:47 PM PDT
N. Sumstine says:
Thank you. I am going to read this and it is nice to know the voices change. If it is done well the narrative voice change can really add to a story. I know you don't think this one did, but I was wondering if your anticipation of the story from Auggie's perspective might have affected your perception of the story.
If you would like to try another book with multiple voices that was done well, try YOUR OASIS ON FLAME LAKE by Lorna Landvik. This was the first book I read with changing voices and it surprised me. I think it is done well. There is a twist to the story that involves the teenage daughter of the initial characters (her voice is heard) which brings intrigue and depth to the story.
Good review, keep reading and writing!
In reply to an earlier post on Oct 4, 2012 4:47:54 PM PDT
Hi N. Sumstine--
That's an intriguing idea, the idea that perhaps my anticipation did affect my perspective of the story. I truly try and not rate/review based on what I was expecting (in this case, for the whole book to be narrated by Auggie). Do know that for the first few voices I was not expecting the shift back to Auggie, and yet I still found the other voices not distinct enough. And quite honestly, this review was written quite a few months ago, so I'm forgetting a lot of the stuff I read :S
I believe the first book that I remember reading with distinct voices was The Lost Hero by Rick Riordan, although that was told from the third-person point of view. I thought that was done really well. I'll take a look into the book you suggested too. As a reader, I've never thought that creating distinct voices was an exceptional achievement. Perhaps as a reviewer, I really should.
Thanks for reading, thanks for commenting!
In reply to an earlier post on Oct 5, 2012 12:00:23 PM PDT
N. Sumstine says:
I think it does. It takes skill to reveal a character, to flesh them out. It takes more skill to hear the character's voice and then write it in such a way that it is clear to a reader. I think it would take so much more skill to write distinct voices for more than one character.
I've read several books narrated this way and some are just abysmal. One author I read recently has two different series, both written in first person, and even though the characters narrating are completely different, they have the same voice. It seems to be the only voice the writer can hear (probably her own).
Have you read THE ILLUMINATION by Kevin Brockmeier? It was my number one book of 2011. He switches perspectives, but I can't remember if he switches voices. It is a beautiful piece of literature.