A decent review overall... but you make a parallel which I disagree with. I love this film because it treats Superman with respect... not as a "campy cartoon." And this film is very faithful to the source material... ie, the comics (as opposed to the 1979 movie which some reviewers seem to associate with "the source material"). But I find the "Star Trek Reboot" to be deeply DISAPPOINTING, because it took the story into a far more campy, less serious, less intellectual realm, and instead of going closer to the source material and showing respect for it, it purposefully disregards the source material (and not just in "history is different now" ways, I really mean "tone and philosophy," and even more, CHARACTERIZATION, at least as much if not more)
So... your positives on this movie are spot-on, in my view, but comparing this (which HONORS THE SOURCE MATERIAL) to Abrams' Star Trek (which purposefully mocks the source material) is... well... it's a bad comparison.