99 of 109 people found the following review helpful
Abbygail age 6 review,
This review is from: This Is Not My Hat (Hardcover)
Received as a review book at the PNBA Bookseller convention Tacoma WA.
Reviewer: Abbygail aged 6
and her Grammy, aged old
Abbygail says: My (first grade) science teacher read "I Want My Hat Back" and I liked it. I read "This Is Not My Hat" by myself with Grammy's help.
The words were easy or hard to read. I sounded-out the hard words and now they are easy.
I liked the story and I liked the big fish. The bubbles create movement.
The little fish was bad and the big fish was just a big fish. You don't steal from a big fish.
Grammy says: Jon was kind enough to speak at the bookseller convention and explain his thought process in creating this book. I was going to take notes but I was laughing too hard.
I found the colors muted - mostly in browns, greens, greys, and black. The drawings were simple. The language was limited and the story line very straight forward. The dialog is all little fish comments. The big fish actually shows all the emotions Jon Klassen proves himself an expert at editing both language and content. In other words, Jon is a genius.
My first grade Abbygail has taken to reading and easily read most of little fish comments. The words she had problems with like "probably" and "won't" were repeated over and over and she quickly recognized them. This is a quick read even for a noobie reader and at first she wanted to race through the story until she noticed the EYE... and then later the bubbles which she explained to me shows movement. "See grammy big fish isn't moving because bubbles go up... and now big fish is moving."
Be prepared to read this book over and over. There is a moral. The ending is open for discussion.
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-2 of 2 posts in this discussion
Initial post: Jan 29, 2013 4:27:33 PM PST
Love your review. :)
In reply to an earlier post on Feb 4, 2013 6:09:43 PM PST
Last edited by the author on Feb 4, 2013 6:13:02 PM PST
I think it is great that you and your grandaughter did this review together, but I do not know I love the "moral," which your granddaughter states clearly: You don't steal from a big fish - and if you do, you deserve to be eaten!
‹ Previous 1 Next ›