Customer Review

79 of 84 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Looks like Nintendo just might figure out these Anniversary Collections after all, September 18, 2012
= Fun:5.0 out of 5 stars 
This review is from: Kirby's Dream Collection: Special Edition (Video Game)
Mario is the leader of the Free Video Game World. He is the most commercially successful video game character of all time, and leads the best selling video game franchise of all time (including several different subseries set within the same universe, all equally best selling). And he has just been shown up a pink puff ball named Kirby.

In celebration for Kirby's 20th anniversary, Nintendo has published "Kirby's Dream Collection", an anthology of six Kirby games, including exclusive new content. At this point you are either a Kirby fan or not. If you don't like Kirby nothing here will change your mind. But for those Kirby fans this is a Godsend. Kirby was originally a stand in until the developers could come up with a more sophisticated character design when they made the first "Dream Land" game, but they got so attached to the little puff they decided to keep him. And that's Kirby's appeal for even the "mature" games. There is something irascibly attractive about the character.

In every way, shape, and form, "Kirby's Dream Collection" trumps the rather insipid "Super Mario 25th Anniversary Edition" Nintendo released in 2010 for the Wii. The "Super Mario" collection was simply the SNES ROM of "Super Mario All-Stars" thrown onto a Wii disk with no updates whatsoever. They didn't even update the SNES controllers represented graphically in the game itself and there's so much wasted storage space on that disk it should be criminal. I love "All-Stars" and bought the game, but as far as an Anniversary celebrating the biggest name in Video Gaming (and Nintendo's single most valuable character), the results were underwhelming to say the least. It's even better than the "Mega Man Collection" from 2004, released on the Gamecube, Playstation 2, and original XBOX. Unfortunately Nintendo did not issue a disk like this in celebration of "The Legend of Zelda" either. If they can put Gameboy titles on a Wii disk, then they can release the Oracle games! "Skyward Sword" did reference the twenty-fifth anniversary as did "Super Mario 3D Land" in level 5-3. Apparently Iwata and Miyamoto did not want to release a "Zelda" compilation because Mario had just gotten one, for whatever sense that makes.

NEW CONTENT: There are new challenge stages (13 in total), based on the Wii "Kirby's Return to Dreamland". These Challenge stages are just that: challenging and also quite fun. The Museum section details the various games released staring Kirby. There are also three episodes from the Kirby anime "Kirby: Right Back At Ya!" ("Waddle While you Work, Kirby Comes to Cappy Town, " and "Crusade for the Blade"). There is also a 48 page book included covering Kirby's history and is also an activity book. Note that one of the answers (Cupid Kirby) on the quiz on Page 28 in incorrect. Also some of the art work has been updated.

CONTROLS: You can play the anthology with the Wii Remote, a Gamecube Controller (with those who have the older model Wiis that support Gamecube Functionality) and the Wii Classic Controller. My recommendation is to use the Classic Controller for the SNES and 64 titles.

SOUNDTRACK: There are forty five tracks from 16 different Kirby games. Much, much better than the palty 28 minute CD included in the "Super Mario" Anniversary collection, which consisted of a handful of songs and a good deal of actual sound effects from the series.

As other reviewers have noted all games use save state technology, so if you decided to stop a game for whatever reason, you can return to it at the same spot later on. This is great news for the games that originally had no save functions.

The only real noticeable flaw is that of omission of one key title that should have been included. Notably, the collection is missing "Kirby and the Amazing Mirror", a Gameboy Advanced title currently available only to 3DS Ambassadors who bought their 3DS before the price cut. This is one of the best Kirby titles and quite extensive, being a "Metroidvania" type game. It's a real shame that they didn't include that game, as it's probably my favorite of the Kirby series. Although there are several spin-off games not included, "Kirby and the Amazing Mirror" is the most puzzling omission from the Collection, as it's easily one of Kirby's strongest games and is no longer available commercially. I'm actually docking the collection a star due to not including this game, it's that good!

At this point, I will go over the individual games, as well as the spin-off games that weren't included, and then end the review with the official tracklisting for the Soundtrack that's also included with the game and the 13 challenge levels. There's a lot of info there and the review is rather long, so if you want to skip those sections I understand. For Kirby fans they will already know the games. For new comers you may find the blurbs educational and helpful on informing your decision to purchase this or not.

Bottom line: Buy this for the Kirby fan in your life! And if you never played a Kirby game, pick this up and see what you've been missing all these years! For those looking for a great compilation this is the one to get! And it shows hope: maybe Nintendo is on the path and will figure out this Anniversary collection after all, given how badly they botched Mario's anniversary. With only one glaring omission (not including the Gameboy Advance "Kirby and the Amazing Mirror", arguably one of his best games), this collection does everything right that Mario got wrong.
---------
THE GAMES: Like any good anthology, the stars of the overall package are the games themselves, and here they are:

"Kirby's Dreamland": Kirby's debut, and probably the only Gameboy title ever available to play on the WIi itself. Rather basic compared to subsequent installments, "Kirby's Dreamland" is a rather charming platformer from the early 1990s. Although many of the series' conventions get their start right here, Kirby's famous copy ability doesn't show up until the next game. Originally there was no save in this title.

"Kirby's Adventure": released in May of 1993 (the penultimate year of the NES's lifespan), this platforming game is Kirby's only NES release and also the first appearance of the popular Metal Knight and Kirby's copy ability. The game features seven different worlds and several boss fights. Kirby must collect the seven fragments of the Star Rod to return order to the Fountain of Dreams so others may dream again. Graphically, this is one of the best NES titles, featuring quasi 3D backgrounds and parallax scrolling. The game was 6 megabytes, one of the largest NES titles ever released in terms of memory. As a late generation NES title, like "Little Samson", "Duck Tales 2" and "Little Nemo: Dream Master" this is one of the key titles from this era of the NES's lifespan. Unfortunately (myself included), many gamers missed this title when it was first released, having moved onto the SNES and Sega Genesis. The game has also been released back in 2007 on the Wii's Virtual Console. The game does have a save feature.

"Kirby's Dreamland 2": Kirby's second Gameboy appearance, this game builds on the previous two titles, as well as including three new playable animal characters (think of the four playable characters from the NES "Castlevania III: Dracula's Curse". Kirby can jump, swim, fly, and inhale his enemies for to shoot as projectiles or to eat and heal himself. The three new characters are Kine the Ocean Sunfish who carries Kirby on the swimming levels even against harsh currents (but isn't good, naturally, onland), Rick the Hampster who Kirby rides and who doesn't slip on the ice, Coo the Owl who navigates harsh winds and allows Kirby to inhale on the flying stages. The Super Gameboy version includes limited color and each stage has a specific color theme. The version on the disk is the regular Gameboy title.

"Kirby's Super Star": released in 1996, this was one of the last SNES titles released and also has had a DS remake called "Kirby's Super Star Ultra". The game comprises eight smaller games. "Spring Breeze" is a simplified remake of the original Gameboy "Dream Land". "Dyna Balde" is a four level platforming game where Kirby must battle a giant bird that is disrupting Dreamland's crops. "Gourmet Race" is a simple racing game (and probably the least substantial mini-game here). Kirby must collect treasures in a cave in the "The Great Cake Offensive" . Some of the treasures are winking nods to other Nintendo IPs, such as Captain Falcon's Helment, Mr. Saturn, the Screw Attack from Metroid, and the Triforce which is of course Zelda religious artifact pivotal to that series. Kirby must battle the Meta Knight's battleship in "Revenge of the Meta Knight" . "Milky Way Wishs" is the largest game in "Kirby Super Star", where Kirby must travel through nine different planets to battle evil. "The Arena" is an endurance challenge where Kirby must fight all the bosses from the various other games (a total of 26 boss battles spread across 19 stages).

"Kirby's Dreamland 3" is the second SNES title and third "Dream Land" tile, released within a year of "Super Star". Abandoning many of the game play conventions of "Super Star", "Dream Land 3" is based heavily on the first two "Dream Land" titles; as a result, critics were harsh on the game for not utilizing the conventions established in "Super Star". For those who like the original Gameboy titles and NES title you'll love this, though playing this after playing "Super Star" does make you feel that the series was regressing backwards. This was the last first party game released for the SNES.

"Kirby 64: The Crystal Shards": in the era of 3D obsession, "The Crystal Shards" along with "Yoshi's Story" is one of the very few 2D platformers (in this case, 2.5D) available for purchase on the N64. The game is rather short but fun while it lasts. This one is available for purchase on the Wii's Virtual Console and featuers three minigames in addition to the mian quest. These support up to four players with difficulty settings of "Easy, Medium, Hard, Intense".

THE SPIN-OFF GAMES NOT INCLUDED
There are seven games that are spin-offs and subgames of the Kirby series and not part of the lineage of the main series, and none of them are included. These are the following:

"Kirby's Pinball Land" which appears on Gameboy and the second title Kirby appears in, as it was released even before the NES game). Available on the 3DS Virtual Console.

"Kirby's Avalanche": an SNES puzzle game and a localization of the Japan exclusive "Super Puyo Puyo". The game was never released in Japan. The game uses sprites from the Sonic game "Dr. Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine". Available on the Wii Virtual Console.

"Kirby's Toybox": eight minigames broadcast over the Satellaview back in 1996. These games are not commercially available in any form whatsoever since the discontinuation of the Satellaview

"Kirby's Dream Course": An SNES golf game played form an isometric point of view, available on the Wii's Virtual Console.

"Kirby's Block Ball": a Breakout type puzzle game for the Gameboy, available on the 3DS Virtual Console.

"Kirby's Star Stacker": a Gameboy Puzzle game similar to "Dr. Mario" and "Tetris", released in 1997 and available on the 3DS Virtual Console. The game was remade as a Super Famicom exclusive called "Kirby no Kirakira Kizzu". This SNES version was never released outside of Japan, and is available on the Wii Virtual Console in Japan.

"Kirby Tilt 'n' Tumble": a Gameboy Colour title, this one is built around motion controls and tilting and tumbling the Gameboy itself to control what is happening on the screen. Humourously enough, if you play this game on the Gameboy Player for the Gamecube, the only way to control what is happening on the screen is moving the Gamecube itself.

A List of the Challenge levels:
Happiness Hall:
Sword Challenge
Parasol Challenge
Spark Challenge
Magolor Race Level 1

Apricot Atrium:
Whip Challenge
Fighter Combat Chamber
Wing Challenge
Magolor Race Level 2

Last Land:
Smash Combat Chamber
Normal Challenge
Magolor Race Level 3
Smash Combat Chamber EX
Magolor Race EX

SOUNDTRACK:

Kirby's Dream Land
1. Welcome To Dream Land
2. Green Greens

Kirby's Adventure
3. Vegetable Valley
4. Grape Garden

Kirby's Dream Course
5. Iceberg Ocean

Kirby's Dream Land 2
6. Coo's Theme
7. Real Dark Matter

Kirby Super Star
8. Get Up and Go-urmet!
9. Havoc Aboard the Halberd
10. Meddlesome Marx

Kirby's Dream Land 3
11. Ripple Field: Ocean Waves
12. The Last Iceberg

Kirby 64: The Crystal Shards
13. Planet Popstar
14. Studying the Factory
15. 0˛ Battle

Kirby: Nightmare in Dream Land
16. Rainbow Resort
17. Tower of Midbosses

Kirby Air Ride
18. Fantasy Meadows
19. Fountain of Dreams
20. City

Kirby & the Amazing Mirror
21. Forest/Nature Area
22. Boss Battle Theme

Kirby: Canvas Curse
23. Tiny Town
24. Canvas Canyon
25. Drawcia the Sorceress

Kirby: Squeak Squad
26. Prism Plains
27. Vocal Volcano
28. Squeak Squad Appears!

Kirby Super Star Ultra
29. The Masked King
30. Helper's Rest
31. The Greatest Warrior in the Galaxy

Kirby's Epic Yarn
32. Fountain Gardens
33. Greens Greens: Epic Yarn
34. Butter Building

Kirby Mass Attack
35. Meadow Breeze
36. Kirby Conflict
37. Piggy Enemy
38. Down To One

Kirby's Return to Dream Land
39. Cookie Country
40. Bring on the Super Ability
41. C-R-O-W-N-E-D
42. Returning to Dream Land

Bonus Tracks:
43. Electro Kirby
44. Gourmet Race to Green Greens: Chamber Music
45. Dream a New Dream for Tomorrow
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

[Add comment]
Post a comment
To insert a product link use the format: [[ASIN:ASIN product-title]] (What's this?)
Amazon will display this name with all your submissions, including reviews and discussion posts. (Learn more)
Name:
Badge:
This badge will be assigned to you and will appear along with your name.
There was an error. Please try again.
Please see the full guidelines here.

Official Comment

As a representative of this product you can post one Official Comment on this review. It will appear immediately below the review wherever it is displayed.   Learn more
The following name and badge will be shown with this comment:
 (edit name)
After clicking the Post button you will be asked to create your public name, which will be shown with all your contributions.

Is this your product?

If you are the author, artist, manufacturer or an official representative of this product, you can post an Official Comment on this review. It will appear immediately below the review wherever it is displayed.  Learn more
Otherwise, you can still post a regular comment on this review.

Is this your product?

If you are the author, artist, manufacturer or an official representative of this product, you can post an Official Comment on this review. It will appear immediately below the review wherever it is displayed.   Learn more
 
System timed out

We were unable to verify whether you represent the product. Please try again later, or retry now. Otherwise you can post a regular comment.

Since you previously posted an Official Comment, this comment will appear in the comment section below. You also have the option to edit your Official Comment.   Learn more
The maximum number of Official Comments have been posted. This comment will appear in the comment section below.   Learn more
Prompts for sign-in
 

Comments

Tracked by 2 customers

Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-6 of 6 posts in this discussion
Initial post: Sep 24, 2012 9:47:05 AM PDT
EFYevan says:
Fantastic review! I wish all reviewers gave the detail that you just did! The only thing that I would add is that there is a Zelda collection disc. It is in GameCube format, but I am sure if you look for it hard enough you will be able to find it. It includes all the Zelda games from NES to N64 with "A Link to the Past" missing.
Thanks again for a great review!

In reply to an earlier post on Sep 24, 2012 10:25:04 AM PDT
Mike London says:
Glad I could be informative. :)

As far as the Zelda Collection, that is true, they did come out with one back in 2003 as a free promo. I wrote a review several years ago of the disk itself The Legend of Zelda: Collectors Edition (Zelda / Zelda II: The Adventure of Link / Ocarina of Time / Majora's Mask) and also did a recent review of the game guide The Legend of Zelda: Collector's Edition Player's Strategy Guide.

However, as you note this came out on the Gamecube. In 2011 video game websites reported that Miyamoto and Iwata nixed a 25th anniversary disk because they had just released one for Mario. Boo.

Posted on Sep 25, 2012 5:17:35 AM PDT
Adriane Fox says:
As much as I do love Amazing Mirror (I really do, I was really psyched to get it on 3DS), I believe it was a reasonable omission from this title mainly because HAL didn't even develop Amazing Mirror: Flagship did. A lesser reason could be that they were on a 2000-and-before timeline and Amazing Mirror came significantly later at 2004.

Not a real critique of your review, just thought I'd put in my 2˘ of an explanation! I just wish this came out before I bought all of the titles (except Dream Land 2, obviously) on Virtual Console.

Posted on Oct 1, 2012 12:45:21 AM PDT
I've never commented on a review before, but you really know how to sell an item! I was on the edge about buying this collection, as I think most people tend to lean towards being cynical when it comes to these sort of items, but you've just reinforced to me that this still has a nice amount of Kirby in it for me, and I'm glad that the soundtrack is so extensive. Jun Ishikawa is one of my favorite Nintendo composers, so I'll be happy to have some of his work on CD finally! Thanks for the review!

Posted on Oct 21, 2012 10:28:34 PM PDT
TradeMark says:
Nintendo held The Legend of Zelda 25th Anniversary Symphony last year in Los Angeles, and the Symphony of the Goddess tour this year. A selection of the Symphony songs were put on a CD and included in Skyward Sword The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword with Music CD, which were even marked with the 25th Anniversary logo. Another CD was released as a reward for registering OoT 3D with Club Nintendo, the Official OoT 3D soundtrack The Legend Of Zelda Ocarina Of Time 3DS Offical Soundtrack. Plus, for a few months, Nintendo put a revised version of the Four Swords game included in the GBA ALttP, Four Swords Anniversary Edition, on the 3DS Eshop, which included 2 new stages and single player support. If that wasn't enough, there was also a The Legend of Zelda art/guidebook released in December last year known as the Hyrule Historia The Legend of Zelda: Hyrule Historia, unfortunately, though, it was only released in Japan. Fortunately, a translated version is being published by Dark Horse Comics and will arrive this January.

With all of this, I don't mind one bit that a collection wasn't released. I've already played every Zelda game (besides the CDi games and that Tingle game) and own most of them. Plus, most Zelda fans would have most likely already played/own the games that would've been in a 25th Anniversary collection. If not, then you can get pretty much every main Zelda game through the Wii (and eventually Wii U) and 3DS VCs (Oracle of Ages, Oracle of Seasons, Wind Waker, and Four Swords Adventure are missing, plus Minish Cap is a 3DS ambassador game).

Regardless, this is a great review. Good job!

P.S. As for the collectible book and soundtrack CD that would have been released with the collection, the CD is basically the 25th Anniversary Symphony CD (you can also throw in that OoT 3D CD) and the collectible book is the Hyrule Historia, which is much bigger and more detailed then the collectible book in the collection would have likely been.

Posted on Apr 29, 2013 7:30:15 PM PDT
Madge says:
Wow! Absolutely fantastic and thorough review. Thank you for taking the time to write this! I've been on the fence about this collection since I got my Wii, and your review has been very helpful.
‹ Previous 1 Next ›

Review Details

Item

4.6 out of 5 stars (174 customer reviews)
5 star:
 (135)
4 star:
 (20)
3 star:
 (10)
2 star:
 (3)
1 star:
 (6)
 
 
 
$79.99
Add to cart Add to wishlist
Reviewer


Location: Oxford, UK

Top Reviewer Ranking: 2,078