15 of 16 people found the following review helpful
The REAL Sonic 4!!!,
This review is from: Sonic The Hedgehog 4 Episode 2 [Download] (Software Download)
I love Episode 1 and all, but as much as I enjoy playing it, it's easy to see why others bashed it. It was a good Sonic game, but we were expecting a Sonic 4. And since the game was composed nearly entirely of rehashed materials of Sonics 1 & 2 (It may as well be called Sonic Pocket Adventure 2), it did not deliver the experience a sequel should.
What's important about Episode 2 is that it IS that Sonic 4 we've been waiting for! It's complete with all-new zones, Tails, catchy music (Catchier than Episode 1, too), and even more elements that made the Genesis Sonics so great (It has momentum, people!).
As with the gameplay itself, it's pure 2D Sonic platforming action remastered, and boy has it held up pretty well! Everything has that exciting feel from the original Genesis games. The graphics are beyond-awesome (Check out them backgrounds!), the music is catchy as heck, and the game as a whole is just flowing with excellence! 4 zones (Not counting Death Egg Mk. II Zone) may sound like this would be a short game, but the levels themselves last for 2 to 4 minutes (Sonic 3 and Knuckles did this as well)! I timed myself once, and the game lasted 1 hour and 35 minutes, which is just as long, if not slightly longer, than a Genesis Sonic title. And that's without collecting the Chaos Emeralds, via Special Stages, and Red Rings scattered around in levels. Both of those elements make for some nice replayability.
And of course, we have Tails. How does Sonic's sidekick help enhance the gameplay? Well, if you have played Sonic 3, you would know that he could fly, and even helped lift Sonic out of danger. This game has that feature, but now you can also have him hold onto Sonic as you control him swimming underwater! This is a MUST for me, because I really don't enjoy playing water levels so much. It's not as cheap as you may think it is, because you still have to worry about the surrounding enemies and Sonic's amount of air. And of course, we have the cool-lookin' Rolling Combo attack (Think Sonic's Spin Dash x 2).
The story is being followed amazingly here. In Episode 1, we can't focus on that so much since we're seeing Sonic go through suspiciously familiar environments as he did before. Here, BOOSH! Metal Sonic comes into the action, after being revived by Eggm-er... Robotnik, except he's more badass than ever! Metal Sonic doesn't mess around. In Sonic CD, he's just introduced and you have to instantly race him (He kidnapped Amy, too, but...you know what I'm trying to say. He didn't play a BIG role). And let's not forget Robotnik, who has went on to create HUGE machines used for boss fights! Speaking of which, unlike Episode 1, this game manages to actually be challenging! I usually beat Episode 1 in a walk. Meanwhile, there's actually some difficulty here! You may get a couple Game Overs during a first try at the game.
Although this is one heck of a Sonic game (especially as a Sonic 4), there's still a few minor things I'll have to mention. For example, I think the boss fights could last a little shorter (1 or 1 1/2 minutes) rather than 3 minutes, and I still think the price tag is a bit steep for a classic Sonic game (Hey. It deserves being in that category in my book).
But overall, this is it. This is Sonic 4! And it definitely proves itself worthy of the name. If you are on the fence for a Sonic game, you should go get this game, even if you don't own the classic Sonic games already. If you are wondering to buy either Episode 1 or 2, WHY THINK ABOUT IT? Skip Episode 1 and go straight to here (Although owning both results in allowing you to download "Episode Metal", letting you play as Metal Sonic through enhanced levels)! But before downloading, BE SURE TO HAVE STEAM INSTALLED. That program/service is required for this great game.
UPDATE: I've recently gotten ahold of Sonic 4: Episode Metal. Really, it's Metal Sonic traveling through 4 levels, with each based off of the 4 zones of Episode 1. The only real problem I found is that Mad Gear Zone has a few pretty cheap areas that'll cost you some lives. Other than that, it plays just fine, and it's a nice way to kill 15 minutes.
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-3 of 3 posts in this discussion
Initial post: May 20, 2012 7:25:16 PM PDT
Silverback Godzilla says:
All your Sonic reviews are spot on and really informative. Unfortunately some of the press reviews for this excellent game have been less than stellar. Game Informer had the nerve to award the game with an abysmal 5/10. Makes me sad to see the bashing continues for a franchise that in my opinion has redeemed itself tenfold in recent years thanks to some truly outstanding entries in the series. Then again, it's the same man who gave Sonic Generations a 6.75, so I shouldn't be surprised.
In reply to an earlier post on May 21, 2012 1:35:49 PM PDT
Last edited by the author on May 21, 2012 1:52:26 PM PDT
It's really nice to see that you actually caught up with all my other Sonic reviews. It makes me feel like a gaming magazine myself :-)
Perhaps when I get to the Sonic Advance games (and Sonic Adventure 2...and Sonic Rush Adventure..), there would just be more to fill your satisfaction ;-)
I don't really read GameInformer too much, but when I do, I moan inside at what they review and the scores they give them. They always praise games that aren't Nintendo, and while they do rate games on Nintendo systems highly, that's only on rare occasions. GameInformer isn't bad, but they could do so much better.
You should check out Nintendo Power instead, if you already haven't. They are a lot more fair with the games they review (Generations 3DS got an 8/10, and Sonic Colors Wii got a 9/10), and everything they do is a lot more colorful and interesting (I love reading their replies to fan letters, as well as the letters themselves).
In reply to an earlier post on May 22, 2012 4:27:39 PM PDT
Silverback Godzilla says:
Sounds like a great idea. I haven't read Nintendo Power in over a decade. Maybe it's time to renew my subscription. Thanks for the heads up, and keep up the good work.
‹ Previous 1 Next ›