10,713 of 10,924 people found the following review helpful
Fantastic device - pick your Kindle!,
Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Kindle, 6" E Ink Display, Wi-Fi (Graphite) (Electronics)
Having been a little overwhelmed by the choices between all the new Kindles and which one to get, I ordered this new basic $79 Kindle first to take for a spin. So far, I like what I see. I also own a Kindle 3 so that's the only device I can really compare it to at this time (I think a comparison between other tablets and this Kindle is meaningless, this device is all about content and delivery):
1. Form-factor - Compared to the Kindle 3, this Kindle feels more compact, lighter and easier to hold. My hands wrap around this better than K3. Reading books for a few hours at a stretch will be easier on this device compared to the K3. It is the lightest such device I have used compared to all previous Kindles and other tablets.
2. Screen - I personally like the fact that there are no keys on the device and that keys come up on the screen when you need them. Delivers a better overall reading experience. However, navigating through the on-screen keyboard with the 5-way controller can be taxing if you need to do a lot of searching, and you might miss the full physical keyboard. I hardly search on the Kindle itself, I search for books on my laptop so this is a non-issue.
3. Price! - At $79, you can't go wrong. Compared to buying paperback or hardcover editions, you will recover the cost of this in a matter of a few months because most Kindle content is priced cheaper than print editions (and you get it instantly, and can access it wherever you are). Not to mention all the free Kindle downloads available in the catalog.
4. Display - almost the same E-ink display at the K3. No glare no reflection. You can sit in bright sunlight and read it just like a book. Page turns seem a lot faster on this compared to the K3. Screen size of the Kindle 3, this new Kindle, and the Touch is exactly the same in size.
5. Wi-Fi - this can be a pro or a con (no 3G) depending on a user's personal preference. If you travel often and would like to be able to download content anywhere without worrying about getting a wi-fi connection, you're better off sticking with the K3 or waiting for the Touch/Fire. For me, 3G is not a major issue.
6. Text to Speech and Audiobooks - These two features are lacking in this device. I personally have never used these features on my K3. If you listen to audiobooks or TTS or music on your Kindle, again the K3/Touch/Fire might be better options.
7. Storage - this device can store 2GB which they claim is approximately 1400 books. For me, that's a massive storage capacity and it will be years before I get close to that capacity. Again, if you download books occasionally and have a moderate Kindle downloaded content on your device, 2GB is plenty. Of course, think ahead and see how much you would expect to download in the coming 2 years (I am assuming the device will be outdated and replaced within this time-frame).
8. Battery life - too early to tell but Kindle battery life tends to be great. Specs state that the battery life of this device is 1 month compared to 2 months for the Touch or K3. 1 month is plenty (Android phones need to be charged every hour!). At least I know that if I'm going on a long flight, this device won't need charging if I charge it up in advance.
9. Power adapter - this Kindle does not come with a power adapter, only a USB charging cable. You can either buy it separately for $8-10, or use your existing USB power adapter. Any USB adapter would work with the charging cable (previous Kindle versions, Apple's portable devices, and most HTC phones, come with a standard USB power adapter that would work for this device). There are also plenty of $2-3 adapters available here if you search for USB chargers.
Bottom line - the choice between this basic Kindle, the K3 Keyboard, the Touch, and the Fire is really a personal preference. This device itself is meant for the minimalist Kindle user who, like me, reads say a 2-3 books a month, wants a device comfortable to hold, and doesn't need any fancy bells and whistles on the device. I guess it depends on what you use your Kindle for. If it's just the basics, this is the perfect device to get.
In my humble opinion, the choices:
(i) If you have a DX or an old Kindle version, or if you don't have a Kindle yet and are an average book-reader, this is definitely the one to get - baseline model that is affordable and is a pure e-reader.
(ii) If you have Kindle 3 and don't really need an upgrade, I recommend sticking with the K3, it's a better device than this one in terms of features. If you do need to upgrade, the Touch is probably a better option because of all the additional features, at a small incremental cost.
(iii) If you're looking for the loaded full-on Amazon content experience with access to all the apps, streaming audio and video, and playing the "strangely therapeutic" Fruit Ninja, wait for the Fire!
I sincerely hope this review helps you decide whether this Kindle is right for you. If you are still unable to make a decision, it may be worthwhile to wait for the Touch and Fire to be released, and see the reviews on those devices before making a final decision.
Tracked by 32 customers
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-10 of 182 posts in this discussion
Initial post: Sep 30, 2011 12:22:59 PM PDT
Last edited by the author on Oct 3, 2011 3:12:17 PM PDT
Hey. Can you tell me how PDF viewing is on this new Kindle? How much, if any, of an improvement is it from the previous Kindles. Does the "black flash every 5 pages" make panning through PDFs much more pleasant? One of the big reasons I'm looking into Kindles is so I can put my textbooks onto it instead of having to lug 2 textbooks to school everyday.
Edit:And I use Calibre, highly recommended for any ebook reader user.
Edit: I understand I can convert PDFs to other formats such as mobi but I'm just curious of the native PDF reading ability.
In reply to an earlier post on Sep 30, 2011 12:35:06 PM PDT
Lisa Davis says:
There may be "issues" with getting your textbooks onto any Kindle. Are they in Kindle format now? There is a fee for converting to the PDF form that Kindles can handle.
Posted on Sep 30, 2011 12:50:39 PM PDT
Constance L. Eby says:
excellent and comprehensive review. Thank you. Helped me with my choice.
In reply to an earlier post on Sep 30, 2011 4:24:23 PM PDT
Diana Anderson says:
Get a free download,......Calibre
It will convert anything including PDF to Mobi.(Kindle format)
I always get PDF or LIT downloads, I take a couple minutes to convert and off you go :-)
Posted on Sep 30, 2011 10:04:24 PM PDT
John Salerno says:
"Compared to buying paperback or hardcover editions, you will recover the cost of this in a matter of a few months because most Kindle content is priced cheaper than print editions"
Where is this the case? I did a few quick comparisons and it seems that mass market paperbacks are still $7.99 on the Kindle, if not more. Trade paperbacks tend to be $9.99, but then again not always, and even compared to most paperbacks it's only about $1-2 difference.
I suppose over the very long run that will add up to $79, but then again I read too many horror stories about certain types of books (science books, anything with charts, maps, footnotes, etc.) never being formatted right for the Kindle. I figured, okay, maybe I can just use the Kindle for mass market fiction that doesn't have illustrations of that sort, but it seems they are no cheaper at all.
Posted on Oct 1, 2011 5:30:28 AM PDT
M. Richards says:
Good review. I was thinking about getting the basic Kindle for my wife who is not a techie, but who may appreciate not having to lug a paperback around with her.
Posted on Oct 1, 2011 7:35:35 AM PDT
M. Koschwitz says:
Don't forget that you can "check out" ebooks through local libraries (over the internet using wifi) now using a Kindle! They just introduced this and if you haven't looked into it you really should. It makes the Kindle that much more valuable.
Posted on Oct 1, 2011 7:36:33 AM PDT
Last edited by the author on Oct 1, 2011 7:48:12 AM PDT
Thank you so much for taking the time to write such a nice, complete review! I only wish this device had been available 2 mos. ago when I bought my $139,00 6¨ 3G, which is working quite well for me and I love it, but all I do is read books on it and don't plan on ever using the speakers and the keyboard (bells and whistles) that came w/ it, so like yourself, I too could do w/out. I'll get the new, $79 one next time. For my simple everyday book only reading I think will be perfect!
Now I also plan on checking out books from the library.
In reply to an earlier post on Oct 1, 2011 8:09:14 AM PDT
Last edited by the author on Oct 1, 2011 8:10:46 AM PDT
First off, I think this was an excellent review. I think the reviewer was very clear that this Kindle was for the individual that just wants to use it for reading. Thanks for the time to write the review & put it in such a clear, easy to follow manner.
@John Salerno. If you travel to a bookstore or any other retailer to purchase books, is your gas free? If you order it online is your shipping free? Even if it is free through a program such as Amazon's Prime or being a Barnes & Noble member, those memberships have yearly fees, or you have to order so many $$ in merchandise for free shipping. Also once you decide to purchase, do you get your book in under 60 seconds? That's just a couple of examples. I find it interesting how people forget all the 'invisible' costs of obtaining books. It's not just the price of the book itself. Remember to figure in ALL expenses to get that book or books.
Yes, I think for $79 this easily would pay for itself in a relatively short period of time.
In reply to an earlier post on Oct 1, 2011 8:52:19 AM PDT
There's also a boatload of Kindle content that is available as a free download. This collection is growing by the day.