Customer Review

278 of 281 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Still the best "pure fitness" game you can get for the Xbox Kinect, November 10, 2011
= Fun:4.0 out of 5 stars 
This review is from: Your Shape Fitness Evolved 2012 (Video Game)
The original Your Shape: Fitness Evolved provided an excellent showcase of what the Kinect was capable of in regards to fitness and exercise. Its motion detection was revolutionary in terms of how well it detected how well you were performing exercises, and the mini-games it included were both tons of fun and moderately good exercise.

I'm happy to say that Your Shape: Fitness Evolved 2012 does push the platform forward, in an evolutionary if not a revolutionary way. Still, it is by far the best "pure workout" game that you can get on the Kinect.

When you start out the game, you see a blue screen which adjusts the sensor and detects who you are. You're then brought to a home screen, where you see a stylized cartoon image of yourself. That's right, there's no need to create an avatar, because you ARE the avatar. This little change was a huge improvement over the first version, where you played as a brightly colored silhouette. It makes a world of difference, because now you can see your limbs and your body position much clearer than before and match them against the on-screen trainer. More on that below.

The home screen shows a number of different counters: medals won, badges won, and percent of content you've played through. On the right you can see the total number of calories you've burned playing the game. I do like the fact that there are clear milestones and targets to aim for, which will keep you coming back to the game. (One question a lot of people have is--did Ubisoft fix the annoying bug from the first version where it'd lose track of which sessions you've finished in a given routine. The happy answer is yes--now, no matter what order you do the exercises in the system will keep accurate track of which ones you've completed).

At the main menu, you have a variety of choices which are color-coded into categories. The blue icons represent your tools. You can keep track of your overall progress, set objectives and take a fitness quiz so the system can recommend specific workouts for you, or go online to share your progress with the community. I do like that they made the fitness test optional in this version, so those who want to can just jump into the exercises.

There are three remaining categories: Yellow icons represent "Activities", which are mini-games. Red icons represent "Workouts" which are traditional generic calisthenics and strength building exercises of the kind you might find at a gym. Finally, purple icons represent "Classes", which are essentially themed Workouts.

Under the yellow "Activities", you have the following mini-games:

1) Wallbreaker: This is essentially the same game as "Virtual Smash" in last year's version. In it, you have to punch across your body to hit blue blocks that appear next to your virtual character's body. The more blocks you punch accurately and quickly, the higher your multiplier will go up and the more a grid behind you will fill up--fill it up completely and it'll collapse. As you get to higher levels you'll have to kick blocks as well and avoid red blocks and giant anvils swinging at you. Even though this is basically a rehash of last year's version, it's still immensely fun, and the fact that you're controlling "you" and not just a silhouette of you adds a certain dimension to the game. I'd rate this one a 4 of 5 for workout intensity and a 5 of 5 for fun.

2) Stack 'Em Up: This one is essentially the same game as the game from last year's version called..."Stack 'Em Up". This is the one where you're holding a plank and trying to catch and balance blocks that are falling from the sky. There are some new twists this year--to make your bar longer you have to raise a leg in the air. Also, the blocks come in different sizes, and they can even turn into ice or catch on fire (you need to kick a giant water drop to make it rain). Interestingly, I found the graphics of last year's version much clearer than this year's, especially when it tells you where to drop your blocks. This one gets a 3 of 5 for workout intensity and a 5 of 5 for fun.

3) Run the World: Ah, finally something brand new. This is an activity where you "run in place". But there's a twist. You can choose either New York or London and basically "run through" the city from landmark to landmark. When I first heard about this one, I was excited--I thought it might be a virtual reality experience where you could literally run through actual streets (if this sounds outlandish, remember that the technology is already there with Google Maps and Bing Maps, not to mention driving games that have mapped out those cities' streets). But in reality, the experience was much less impressive than that. You basically just run in place on a blank white screen following a line of stylized "yellow dots" on the road. As you run, you do see buildings to your left and right, but they're just generic grey outlines. As you "approach" a famous landmark you'll see that building's distinctive outline, see a tiny photo of the building, and read some trivia about it. Note also that the distances you run are not literal--I'm quite familiar with downtown New York, and there's no way you can run from 40 Wall Street to the Woolworth Building to City Hall in 5 minutes. Still, I did like how the system was able to detect how fast I was "running" and how at least captured the feeling of running through a city. Overall, this activity definitely made what was otherwise a tedious activity pretty interesting. Workout intensity of this one was a 5 of 5, but for fun I give it a 3 of 5.

4) Jump Rope: This is another new activity, and it's a winner. It's a twist on jump rope. You start out by holding your hand as if you're holding a jump rope, and an energetic beat will start playing. You'll see icons of two feet under you, and need to jump to the beat while matching the pattern of feet (either two close together, two far apart, or just the left or the right). Even on Easy mode I was wiped out after this one, but I found it immensely fun. 5 of 5 for workout intensity, 5 of 5 for fun.

5) Stomp It: This game is very similar to "Light Race" from last year's version, where you stand in the middle of something similar to a "Simon" game and move your feet to correctly hit the colored panels under your feet. This year, they've improved it by matching the colored lights to a beat and give you a visual cue of which panel will light up next, so it's more like a step aerobics exercise (versus last year's version where you were just randomly stomping). You still need a ton of room for this one, and if your Kinect doesn't have a clear view of your feet at all times it's not going to be fun for you at all. This one was a 4 of 5 for intensity, and a 4 of 5 for fun.

"Workouts", represented by the red icons, are basically traditional calisthenics, cardio, and strength building types of activities that a trainer would do with you at a gym. The workouts are categorized by the part of the body or the exercise goal you want to focus on. They include the following (the number of exercise routines under each is in parentheses):

1) Arms (12)
2) Abs (13)
3) Cardio (10)
4) Toning (9)
5) Back (12)
6) Sports Preparation (8)
7) Glutes (12)
8) Health (3)
9) Legs (12)

They've got all the basic exercises covered pretty well. For example, when I selected the first workout under "Arms", the exercises were knee push-ups and slow mountain climbs. A typical exercise under "Abs" will have you doing all kinds of crunches, from basic crunches, to V knees to the chest, to up and down planks.

As in the first version, to the left of the screen you'll observe your virtual trainer doing the exercise, using the proper technique. You'll see an image of yourself to the right of the trainer. I really liked how the cartoon trainer and the cartoony you looked very similar, both in terms of size and visual style. As I said, new to this version is the ability to see your arms and legs clearly, so you can work on matching the trainer's body position and moves precisely. There are also visual cues that'll show you exactly where your head should be and where your feet should be. Finally, there's music so that you can time your reps to the beat perfectly (you'd be surprised at how many workout games just play random music and don't bother to match it to your reps).

A woman's voice will talk your through all the exercises, calling out instructions and encouragement. Regarding the latter, I found that she tended to err a little on the "overly encouraging" side--even when I wasn't doing the exercises right, she'd be shouting out compliments and encouragement. Happily, the motion detection is definitely spot-on--after the workout you'll see precisely what percentage of the workout you nailed, and I found it to be remarkably accurate.

"Classes", represented by the purple icons, are very similar to workouts. You go through a series of set exercises, you have a virtual cartoon trainer who will demonstrate the proper moves, and you'll control the cartoony "you" standing next to him or her as you try to match the moves. The difference is that while "workouts" were like generic exercises you might do at the gym, "classes" all follow a specific theme, such as a certain style of dance, a boxing training session, and even a military bootcamp. Here are the options and the number of routines in each:

1) Africa Rhythms (12)
2) Boot Camp (6)
3) Hip Hop (12)
4) Cardio Boxing (14)
5) Destination: Bollywood (12)
6) Yoga (4)
7) Latin Dance (12)
8) Zen Energy (8)

I tried the boot camp one first. Sure enough, you and your virtual trainer (a gruff drill sergeant) are in the field of a military boot camp complete with a helicopter and occasional explosions happening around you. Even at the easy levels, you're taken through a grueling set of exercises, from running to "Olympian squats" to "stun attacks" to push ups. The trainer stays in character throughout, shouting instructions to you amid various random interjections ("you're tired? I don't care!", "does it hurt? Good!").

I also tried the Bollywood one. Like the rest of the dance-themed classes, it had different levels with names like "Learn it", "Rehearse It", "Speed It Up", and "Show it Off". I tried the beginning level, and it brought me through some very authentic Bollywood dance steps with names like "Bolly Arms", "Aarti Step" and "Blossom Step". The moves were very authentic. I wouldn't say this part of the game is exactly Dance Central, but it's not bad either.

Overall, I'd say this is a worthwhile purchase if you're serious about using your Xbox for fitness and exercise. Those who purchased last year's version (especially if you purchased a lot of the DLC) may find a lot of what's in this year's version redundant. But I'd say there are enough improvements to make it a worthwhile purchase. I loved the improved avatar, enjoyed the new activities they added, and appreciate the fact that they didn't skimp this year on the number of exercises you can do before resorting to purchasing more as downloadable content. From the title, I'm assuming Ubisoft intends to release one of these every year; here's hoping that they continue to innovate the series moving forward and don't get lazy and rest on past laurels.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

[Add comment]
Post a comment
To insert a product link use the format: [[ASIN:ASIN product-title]] (What's this?)
Amazon will display this name with all your submissions, including reviews and discussion posts. (Learn more)
Name:
Badge:
This badge will be assigned to you and will appear along with your name.
There was an error. Please try again.
Please see the full guidelines here.

Official Comment

As a representative of this product you can post one Official Comment on this review. It will appear immediately below the review wherever it is displayed.   Learn more
The following name and badge will be shown with this comment:
 (edit name)
After clicking the Post button you will be asked to create your public name, which will be shown with all your contributions.

Is this your product?

If you are the author, artist, manufacturer or an official representative of this product, you can post an Official Comment on this review. It will appear immediately below the review wherever it is displayed.  Learn more
Otherwise, you can still post a regular comment on this review.

Is this your product?

If you are the author, artist, manufacturer or an official representative of this product, you can post an Official Comment on this review. It will appear immediately below the review wherever it is displayed.   Learn more
 
System timed out

We were unable to verify whether you represent the product. Please try again later, or retry now. Otherwise you can post a regular comment.

Since you previously posted an Official Comment, this comment will appear in the comment section below. You also have the option to edit your Official Comment.   Learn more
The maximum number of Official Comments have been posted. This comment will appear in the comment section below.   Learn more
Prompts for sign-in
 

Comments

Tracked by 7 customers

Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-10 of 16 posts in this discussion
Initial post: Nov 11, 2011 6:21:40 AM PST
vgogte1 says:
Thanks for the detailed review. Could you please answer the question below, I find it little strange no review is talking about it:
Does this version have tne same problem/bug as the first: - the one where you lose all progress if you switch programs? (You can read specifics in top negative review if you dont understand what I mean)

In reply to an earlier post on Nov 11, 2011 6:35:07 AM PST
Last edited by the author on Nov 11, 2011 6:42:41 AM PST
Great question! Happily, that bug has been fixed! Next to the menu options for workouts, activities, and classes you'll see not only the total number of exercise routines within each, but also the number of ones you've successfully completed. I've switched between a lot of different exercises, and it always keeps track of where I've been perfectly (I've updated my review to reflect this). It even shows a new "% of content completed" statistic on the main page which shows me how much of the game I've played.

Note that you do need to be signed in to your Xbox Live profile (when you are you'll see your Gamertag to the top right of your screen, along with your total calories burned)

In reply to an earlier post on Nov 11, 2011 10:10:05 AM PST
vgogte1 says:
Thanks!

Posted on Nov 12, 2011 4:16:32 AM PST
S1MNICITY says:
brilliant review...thanks so much for taking the time to write such a detailed review. I'm going to purchase the game today!

Posted on Nov 12, 2011 6:44:52 AM PST
I have to strongly disagree that any one would find a lot of this redundant. Sure they've included some of the same excercises, but they are not the same routines -except for maybe Cardio Boxing which is almost exactly the same, but still isn't EXACTLY the same. If they'd left out what you're referring to as redundant, the game wouldn't be fully covering the scope of the exercise world! And the difference between the two games, with at least twice the content, better tracking, menus and a whole new look, if definetly worth the investement for those who loved the first game.

In reply to an earlier post on Nov 12, 2011 7:14:53 PM PST
You're very welcome, S1mn1city...I know you're going to love it!

Thanks for your comment Anthony. Actually, I don't think we're disagreeing at all here. That's why I gave the game a very positive review and followed my opinion about redundant content by saying that "there are enough improvements to make it a worthwhile purchase."

On the other hand, I felt it fair to advise people that they may see some familiar things, such as Virtual Smash, Light Race, and Stack Em Up (not to mention classes like Bollywood Dance which had been available as DLC). While I appreciated and enjoyed the improvements they made to these games, if I were a product manager at Ubisoft, perhaps instead of re-releasing a slightly improved versions of existing activities, maybe I'd try to think of additional virtual reality activities which are entirely new (such as the excellent Jump Rope). With the Kinect, the possibilities are endless.

Now that Ubisoft is naming the version by year, I'm guessing we'll be able to expect a new version each year. At $49.99 a pop, that's going to be a hefty investment at a time when most of our money is tight. As I said in my last sentence, I really hope they can avoid franchise fatigue by really being more "revolutionary" than "evolutionary" with each release--thinking of ways to push the series forward in big ways. Just to make it clear, I believe they were pretty successful with this release, but I just hope they keep it up. If they do, they'll have us as repeat customers year after year.

Posted on Nov 15, 2011 6:46:14 AM PST
jpm says:
I bought the prior game about 4-5 months ago now. Almost at the same time I developed ankle trouble and shelved it. Now I've dusted it off. I was tempted to buy some of the DLC (particularly Cardio Boxing). Are the DLC's relatively intact or trimmed down? Also can you use any of the prior game's DLCs that might not have be included?

Posted on Nov 15, 2011 8:56:51 AM PST
Got the first one and it seems from your review that everything annoying from the first one has been fixed. I stopped working out to it as it could not keep track of my progress when I changed workouts, but it 2012's has that, then I'll go get it.
this is the kind of review that helps stacks more than those critics' on the so-called professional websites. Thanks for your time in writing this.

Posted on Nov 15, 2011 11:07:39 AM PST
What a great review! Maybe we can work together somehow. I only do Kinect reviews, but maybe we can link to each other or something. Let me know if you are interested.

In reply to an earlier post on Nov 20, 2011 5:59:21 PM PST
Last edited by the author on Nov 20, 2011 6:01:17 PM PST
Rainer Rocks says:
WOW...This has to be one of the greatest reviews ever !

Just Dance should give you a lifetime worth of free games !

Thanks again !
‹ Previous 1 2 Next ›

Review Details

Item

4.4 out of 5 stars (577 customer reviews)
5 star:
 (351)
4 star:
 (141)
3 star:
 (56)
2 star:
 (21)
1 star:
 (8)
 
 
 
$19.99 $12.95
Add to cart Add to wishlist
Reviewer


Location: New York, NY USA

Top Reviewer Ranking: 1,396