742 of 765 people found the following review helpful
This review is from: Man's Search For Meaning (Mass Market Paperback)
The first section of this book (which makes up over half of the text) consist of Victor Frankl's account of his experiences in the concentration camp. This section seems unique among the Holocaust accounts that I've seen and read because Dr. Frankl approaches the topic from a psychological perspective. He discusses the ways in which the different prisoners react to their (note: men and women were seperated at the camps, so Frankl is mainly disscussing his experiences with the men in Auschwitz) imprissonment. He writes about the psychological effects of being completely dehumanized; of losing even your name, and becoming simply a number. Also he disscusses the effects of not being able to contact loved ones, or even know is they are still living. Another issue that Dr. Frankl talks about in this book is the idea that none of the prisoners of the concentration camp had an idea as to when there imprissonment would end (if ever). Thus, they were faced with the thought of living the rest of their lives as workers at the camps. Dr. Frankl discusses how people can find meaning to life in these conditions. He also describes how finding meaning in life, or a reason to live, was extraordinarilly important to surviving the camp.
One of the most interesting, and disturbing, issues in the book was the idea of the Capo. These were were people put in charge of their fellow prisoners, in order to keep them in line. Dr. Frankl describes these people as, often, being more harsh than the actual guards. This seems to be a disturbing lesson in the abuse of power. This also goes along with Dr. Frankl's discussion of how the camps brought out the true personality of the people within it (after all the social trapping had been stripped away): The cretins, the saints, and all of those in between.
The second half of the book is made up of two sections "Logotherapy in a Nutshell," and "The Case for Tragic Optimsism." These two sections basically describe Dr. Frankl's theory on as to how to conduct therapy (Logotherapy). The idea behind this therapy is that man is driven by his search for a meaning in life. This differs from the psychoanalysis perspective (driven, at this time, by the ideas of Sigmund Freud) in that the psychoanalytic school believed that humans were driven by their unconscious desires. For Frankl, the need for meaning seems to outway the unconscious. In fact, he goes into detail about the negative effects that the abscence of meaning, or what he calls the "existential Vacuum," has on people. To illustrate many ideas, he often uses his experiences in the concentration camps, as well as various cases for treatment (which help to solidify his view of life, and therapy).
I would recomend this book to almost anybody. I feel that it's interesting, and worthwhile. I would especially recomend this to people interested in psychology, as well as those who wish to learn something about the experiences within the concentration camps.
Tracked by 4 customers
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-2 of 2 posts in this discussion
Initial post: Sep 10, 2011 4:21:44 AM PDT
J. A. Gild says:
This reviewer's contrast between VF's view of what motivates humans and Freud's view of the importance of the unconscious hit home with me, as I have discovered the importance of the unconscious in my own life's successes and failures. I am interested in reading VF's book.
In reply to an earlier post on Jan 2, 2015 12:50:14 PM PST
There is something that I want to ask about this book. I have over 1,000 Holocaust books in my library and Kindle fire. I have read that many in the camps, called the victims muzzelmen or musslemen before they died. It was the opposite of being strong with muscles. Your book is the only book where I have found you use the term Muslem. The victims form Poland used the term Musslemen too. Your book is a great new perspective than the others that tell the day to day horror. I see that and am grateful for a new look at the horrible Shoah. It goes beyond being starved, beaten, with the threat of death hanging over you every minute...and you saw death every day...to rising above to the spirit and I believe that is what got many through the Holocaust or God. I look and see a very clear path of how they made the choices to go this way or that way. or go for a selection. HOPE...and of course as I said GOD had plans for you. I just had questions about the use of Muslem or Muslam when I have not came across that in about 1,000 books on the Shoah. I haven't got my kindle fire out to flip back to see the way you spelled it for that I am sorry.
‹ Previous 1 Next ›