109 of 137 people found the following review helpful
Grand Spectacles Can't Save It From Some of the Gameplay Issues,
This review is from: Resident Evil 6 - Playstation 3 (Video Game)The Good:
+It's a rather good looking game
+The atmosphere in some of its moments are great
+Some creative set piece moments
+Fairly decent voice acting
+A less frustrating AI to deal with
+Some neat little gameplay mechanics make it in such as the melee combat
+Four different campaigns keep things going for a long time
-Far too many quick time events
-Inventory management is a pain
-It's easy to suffer cheap deaths due to poor setups, unless you know the danger is coming you might not be able to do much about it in time
-Despite four campaigns the game has some unusual pacing; there are definitely moments where the game is padding out its length and they're clearly noticeable
Resident Evil has a long and varied history. As gaming moves on Resident Evil has spent quite a bit of time trying to find it's footing. It's not necessarily an identity crisis so much as it is that the gaming landscape has changed so much that Resident Evil has to keep up in an area it used to dominate. The approach with Resident Evil 6 seems to be trying to mend as much as they can to give you what may be one of the most varied gameplay experiences you'll find in the entire series. In part because there are times Resident Evil 6 just isn't sure what it really wants to be. It's not really survival horror at this point, but that's far from some of the questionable choices made with Resident Evil 6.
The story is rather simple this time around. There's a big virus outbreak only this time it's of epidemic proportions. It's been a long time since the outbreak in Raccoon City and the President believes it's time to let everyone know the truth. Unfortunately, someone doesn't want this to happen. And before long the President is infected and Leon has to put him down. Beyond that the game mostly spans a narrative that tries to weave everything together. The cutscenes themselves and the narrative actually aren't bad. As it's easy to be taken in by some of the games cinematic moments. The writing, however, isn't very strong at all. There are moments that are quite laughably bad. This is to be expected from Resident Evil but some of the writing moments are bad even for Resident Evil. The voice acting isn't too bad, however, and overall the story can be satisfying--even if it feels a little overly long. There are four different campaigns to play, each consisting of five chapters. There are the three standard characters: Leon, Chris and Jake. Each of them has a partner. Leon works with a woman named Helena, Chris works with a member of the BSAA named Piers and Jake works alongside Sherry Birkins, who hasn't been seen in a Resident Evil game since the second installment over fourteen years ago. Complete these three campaigns and you'll be able to play as Ada.
It's the three campaigns where it seems Resident Evil 6 is unsure of what it is. As each of the campaigns plays drastically different. Leon's campaign feels more survival horroresque as the mood and tone of it recall a few things from Resident Evil's past. The lighting is done in such a way that you can't always see. You don't always know if you have enough ammo to survive what's around the corner and the audio is sometimes eerie. Chris, on the other hand, feels incredibly like an action shooter through and through. Jake's campaign, however, focuses heavily on set piece moments and quick button presses. It's a strange mesh of things that helps each campaign feel almost like an entirely different game. Playing through one campaign doesn't prepare you for what you'll face in the next.
Resident Evil 6 tries a few new things and tries to revamp others. The gunplay is perhaps the most noticeable difference right off the bat. Resident Evil: Revelations had a targeting system similar to that of Resident Evil 4 and 5 but the sixth installment does away with that entirely. It's a new system that makes aiming slightly easier and less problematic, although there's a lot one can do. You can finally move and shoot at the same time, although you walk kind of sluggish when you're aiming. Likewise, you can be knocked to the ground and shoot while you're on the ground. When you're on the ground you can also roll or shift away from the enemy or slide past them. There are also moments when you can take cover behind objects, though the game's cover system is incredibly clunky and almost not worth utilizing.
A lot of the controls may take time to get adjusted to as it's all been reworked from the previous game. Some things work out fantastically while others haven't been worked out well at all. Melee combat, for instance, is better here than it's ever been before. You can perform melee attacks much more easily now. Instead of them all being relegated to button prompts when they appear, you can now use melee attacks any time you do not have a weapon raised. Just a simple tap of a button and you can start performing combos. You can also go in for stealth attacks or change up some of your power depending on the weapon you've got equipped (for instance, with a rifle you may actually hit the enemy with said rifle). It's simple and at times can be more helpful than actual fire power as these attacks are incredibly powerful.
The same cannot be said about the inventory system at least. Inventory management is needlessly complicated in Resident Evil 6. One does not simply pick up an herb and use it, they must assign it to their case to be able to use them. While it's great to be able to heal at the simple press of a button once it's there, it's hard to be able to manage say your healing items in the thick of combat. You'll also find weapon and ammo. It's pretty easy to switch to your weapons as you can cycle through easily, and even getting to first aid sprays is pretty simple (but strangely not the same as using an herb), once you really start filling your inventory out you may find you'll spend quite a bit of time combining herbs and the like. But once your inventory is full you'll find yourself having to dump things from your inventory a lot. Once that item is gone it's gone for good. The problem isn't that Resident Evil 6 has a very limited inventory. It's actually that it's hard to manage in the thick of combat. You'll love to get some downtime to be able to requip some herbs or to use a first aid spray or rearrange your weapons and dump things you don't need. It's just odd that in 2012 inventory management is one of Resident Evil 6's shortcomings.
Combat is often satisfying, but CAPCOM hasn't exactly gotten rid of the partner aspect. You'll always have someone at your side. This time around you don't have to babysit the AI by any means. They'll never take ammo away from you or waste your resources and they will never be in danger of dying on you because they're pretty much invincible. Meaning you can have them soak up damage if you want. So it's unusual, then, that the AI is still fairly useless. They'll shoot enemies more here than they did in Resident Evil 5 or Revelations, but a lot of the time they'll still be off doing dumb things. You can praise or thank them for saving you and they'll start to use more powerful weapons as a result, but the point is that the AI is still mind numbingly bad. It's just that this time around you don't have to worry about it. Nevertheless, having a human partner is still better. And luckily you can play online or locally. You can set it so people online can join you or keep it private. You'll also be able to invade other players game as the enemy if they've allowed for you to do so. The downside to a human partner, though, is that the game can be mind-numbingly simple. Not that Resident Evil 6 is too hard, but most of your enemies aren't very smart. When you're on the brink of death they strangely take forever to take that final blow. A lot of enemies will stand there and simply let you wail on them with physical attacks while the zombies around them strangely sit around and watch. Even when hordes of zombies are around you'll find the game is pretty relaxed in most moments. That's not to say you won't die... it's only to say you may die unfairly.
In 2005, Resident Evil 4 introduced the concept of Quick Time Events into Resident Evil and since then you get the feeling that the games should probably do away with them by now. You'll never feel this to be more true than Resident Evil 6. It makes more use of quick time events than just about any game in recent memory. The quick time events come around constantly and are sometimes longer than you expect. Certainly it'll keep you on your toes, but it'll also cause you to die constantly because you simply aren't aware they're coming. It's not just quick time events that can cause cheap deaths in Resident Evil 6. Some moments you may needlessly die at because the danger just isn't pronounced. Meaning, if you don't know what's around the corner you might die first (but at least you won't die a second time). Early on in Leon's campaign, for example, I was busy fighting zombies underground that I simply had no way to prepare for the train that killed me. And my AI partner simply didn't warn me fast enough. It's not that I wasn't warned it's that it came too late for me to get out of the way on account of me fighting zombies so that I wouldn't, ya know... die (But I guess that really didn't matter, did it?). It was easier the second time because I knew it was coming, but it seemed like I died needlessly just to prepare for it.
These moments are pretty constant throughout the campaign. Bad setups and quick time events run rampant throughout. When the game gets on a good flow it can actually be rewarding. There is just a bit of a learning curve to it and a bit of patience required on behalf of the player. Some of Resident Evil 6's set piece moments are actually really good and shouldn't be missed.
The only problem is that going through all the campaigns sometimes feels rather long and unusually paced. You'll have to play through all of them to get the full story, but there are some excellent moments that are marred by slower paced moments that you wonder why they're included in the first place. There are definitely moments of padding in Resident Evil 6 that are used to make each campaign last. And by that I mean, each campaign is about the same length, which means there are moments when each campaign is given moments JUST to make sure they're all roughly the same length. At least the moments of fun and progress outnumber the moments where the game is clearly padding.
Graphically a Resident Evil game has hardly looked better. The environments are really detailed and sometimes there are little things worth noticing. When you slide across a table filled with papers, for instance, they go flying everywhere. The lighting is especially good here as you'll traverse moments that are brightly lit and go down hallways that are dark with very little light to see. It makes good use of technology. The audio is also very good. The screams and groans of the baddies you'll face are pretty good. The sound effects are amazing and even the voice acting isn't too bad (though they haven't exactly been given the best script to work with). If there's one thing that will always remain true, it's that CAPCOM will never skimp on the presentation of a Resident Evil game.
It's a shame then that Resident Evil still can't manage to be scary, however. The atmosphere is sometimes there with the lighting and eerie noises. There are even moments when Resident Evil 6 will honestly try to be what it was at the height of the franchises popularity. Of course, Resident Evil can't really be scary anymore when the fans are so used to all of the tricks it tries to do. So it goes a more action oriented route. Resident Evil 6 manages to take some steps forward with some of it's melee combat mechanics and even some of its gunplay. But it takes some steps back with it's unusual amount of quick time events, clunky cover system and poor inventory management. Players may certainly have fun with Resident Evil 6 but it isn't going to come without some frustration that could've easily been avoided with some slightly better game design.
Tracked by 2 customers
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-10 of 19 posts in this discussion
Initial post: Oct 2, 2012 3:37:04 PM PDT
Easily the best review up so far.
You're very detailed, but not all, and imagine a high pitched voice for this, "Oh my God, Oh my God! I just love everything Resident Evil." And, you're not all, "Grrr Resident Evil was only good for these games." Though I'll admit I prefer 1-3 and Code Veronica over the action oriented games, but I still find 4 and 5 enjoyable.
Thanks for the review. I can't wait to play it.
Posted on Oct 2, 2012 4:17:43 PM PDT
Last edited by the author on Oct 3, 2012 6:54:13 PM PDT
Jason Bean says:
good review. So far I agree; I like it from a presentation standpoint but some of it's design baffles me. Instead of one story with different campaigns it's all the same story from different perspectives (with slightly different pacing). Some of the new controls seem a little overkill (I've never once found the need to dual-wield or slide into cover). I like the game but agree it's got some needless annoyances so far.
In reply to an earlier post on Oct 2, 2012 4:24:19 PM PDT
Joel Cigan says:
Is this a third-person type game? What kind of game is it?
Posted on Oct 2, 2012 7:17:19 PM PDT
Mark Shoe says:
Couldn't agree more with your review. I've only played the Leon campaign so far and I'm getting very annoyed dying from flying cars and ambulances that are impossible to foresee. It really kills the motivation. I think updating so many of the features is starting to reduce the resident evils. Maybe leaving the functions the same and only updating the look would help. Anyway, that's not what they did, and the result is pretty mediocre.
Posted on Oct 2, 2012 11:47:33 PM PDT
[Deleted by the author on Oct 3, 2012 10:17:55 PM PDT]
Posted on Oct 3, 2012 6:10:11 AM PDT
Mr. R. Forshaw says:
I feel that the gameplay was brain-dead easy, with over-powered melee and docile enemy-AI. The horror element has gone because 'horror' and 'kicking ass (without effort)' don't mix! This was just an interactive movie, a fancy spectacle to gawk at and nothing more.
Posted on Oct 3, 2012 7:02:46 PM PDT
Michael Azi says:
In reply to an earlier post on Oct 4, 2012 10:40:00 AM PDT
Have you read every single review on the internet or do you naturally belive that everyone who is a gamer has absolutely no writing skills?
Posted on Oct 4, 2012 1:03:45 PM PDT
I agree with this review, and I'd add another thing that RE6 is missing: There's hardly anything to figure out, beyond remembering when certain predetermined game actions will occur, so that the player knows, for example, that trains will be coming down that tunnel (which requires a specific quick time button press combination to survive), or how to perform any number of additional quick time events that will get the player out of a jam. The level maps, which were a staple of previous Resident Evil games, are gone and replaced by an onscreen homing indicator which provides not only the player's proper next destination, but that destination's general location and moment by moment distance from the player. And if that indicator isn't sufficient, the player can press a button to bring up an even more explicit beacon, which points the player in the right direction and brings up flashing arrows. There were mapped areas in RE4 and RE5, some where the player simply had to get from point A to point B. But those were few. In RE6, it seems as if that's the majority of what the player does in each area, despite the facts that most areas are more wide-open than narrow hallways or staircases, and those areas generally have plenty of enemies to deal with. There are few roadblocks, such as inaccessible areas, or puzzles, which require the player to figure out how to pass, or to explore and find the object or objects needed to move on. There don't seem to be instances in which the player, through thorough exploration, or just blind luck, finds an object or tool which initially doesn't seem to have an obvious practical use, and then the player later encounters the situation in which the object or tool comes in handy. Occasionally in RE6, a door will be locked, and the player might have to find a key or pass card to open the door. But how it works in RE6 is, the homing indicator leads the player to the locked door, then leads the player to the key, then leads the player back to the locked door, which opens now that the player has the key. The overwhelming majority of what the player will be collecting for inventory in RE6 is ammunition, herbs, and skill points (a new thing that replaces cash), the great majority of which are dropped by killed enemies. I don't think that the things in the original review or in my comments make RE6 a bad game or even keep it from being a good one. But these things do significantly stray RE6 from the series' origins. And I don't think that getting to play the further adventures of Leon, Chris, Sherry, and Ada negate that.
In reply to an earlier post on Oct 5, 2012 7:34:35 AM PDT
I'd rather read plagiarism than hear from somebody who cares about it. The concept of "plagiarism" hinges upon the acceptance of fraudulent imaginary property. I therefore reject it outright.