Customer Review

56 of 66 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Desktop Replacement? Almost there!, March 21, 2012
This review is from: Apple iPad MD367LL/A (32GB, Wi-Fi + AT&T 4G, Black) 3rd Generation (Personal Computers)
I've had the pleasure of trying out most of the new Apple products for the last few years. If you have any questions or requests for clarifications you can leave a comment, and I'll be emailed, or you can email me directly by clicking on my name and looking for the link.

I mostly use an iPad 1, but I have the opportunity to use an iPad 2 often.

A lot has changed since the iPad came out, and I wrote my original review (located here:Apple iPad (first generation) MB292LL/A Tablet (16GB, Wifi) titled with a quote from Woz, saying "Everyone wants things to be simpler, and along comes this simple thing" and its still very true. Tablets aren't like PCs, you don't need to maintain them or worry about software requirements at all. Its wonderful for people who hate that. My friend can tell you exactly what processor his last laptop had, but what processor does his iPad have? He'll say "Don't know, don't care". If you are wondering why to get a tablet at all, I would recommend that you read that review. Its the second review on that page.

So I bought the new iPad, the 2.5, or whatever you want to call it. I'm not going to go into the tech specs, because, they are posted everywhere and unless you are a geek you will also fall into the "don't know/don't care" category. I'm going to try to focus on just telling you what I would want to know before I bought it. This review will be about real use.

I chose a 32GB version. Why?
1) The new apps that will support the retina display are supposed to take more memory, so you should expect that whatever you had on your older iPad will take more space on this new one.
2) I feel that the days of 16GB being enough may soon be passing. With my 16GB iPad I was actually having to start managing my memory. I had to start leaving things off it.
3) The more powerful the iPad becomes, the more I expect to use it. And this means, more memory will be needed. The iPad has never been my primary "computer", but with this iteration it might be there: I can plug an HD screen into it via HDMI now, and use a nice bluetooth keyboard. However, you have to use the iPad itself as a gigantic touchpad, as you can't use a pointing device. It mirrors whats on the screen, so, its clumsy-but-possible. Still, we are getting so close to throwing the ipad down on the desk at work and just... working.
So for the first time I plunked down my hard earned money for the 32GB version. I think the 16GB version will be like having a 4GB iPhone 2G.

I'd also like to point out that despite the improvements and upgrades, Apple is maintaining the same starting price that it did for the iPad 1 and the iPad 2. This is very nice.

The main new things -for me- in order of importance are:
1) The 4G LTE network (I have the AT&T version). We'll skip the cell phone enthusiast argument over whether this is really a 4G device, because 4G was actually supposed to be (clears throat) even better. Because in spite of that, the 4G LTE may be the primary reason I plunked down my change and bought it. I want to be able to do my work remotely without problems.

I ran some tests on the new iPad.
--In my office, which has a 6mbps DSL and wifi, I saw a 3.6Mbps upload and a 512k upload. You might say "who cares?" Ah but wait.
--I signed up for the 3GB Data Plan at $30/mo, and when using the 4g LTE network, I saw a 17Mbps connection.
--And at home, where we have the fiber optic connection, I only saw an 11Mbps connection.
--And finally, my iPhone 4s got a lousy 2.5Mbps on the AT&T 4G non-LTE network.
So there you have the relative speeds. All calculated using the Speed Test app.

So here's the point... the new 4G service is a major upgrade. On the LTE network it is very fast - however, I did experience some latency when just checking emails traveling in a car driving 70 mph. This is typical for this technology, it seems to have problem switching from tower to tower. But if you are sitting at a park downtown then I don't think you'll see those problems. What does this mean? You should see a movie download in 1/2 to 1/4 of the time. And the iPad will be able to act as a wifi hub for all your devices. In other words, I will be able to use the iPad for internet for my laptop too. Now, at the time of this writing, it should be noted that you cannot use your iPad as a wifi hotspot with AT&T. At this time only Verizon supports that feature. (Maybe you want to pick the Verizon version if this is important to you).

Now, I live in a metro area in one of the biggest cities in the USA, so, your 4g service may vary. And they are charging a super premium price: $10 per GB. A full length movie on iTunes is 2GB or 3GB, so it can't replace my home connection, but its great for work and casual use.

Back to the countdown:
2) The "resolutionary" screen. It is true that this screen is amazing and a pleasure to look at. You can't see the pixels, and I love that. I love that on my iPhone 4 too. It will take a while for the App makers to really utilize this to its full extent, so I don't think you need to got all excited and upgrade tomorrow.
3) The faster processor. I actually did not have a problem with my old iPad processor, but soon my old iPad will be like using a 2G iPhone. But it will take a while for the App makers to really utilize this to its full extent. Once again, I don't think you need to upgrade tomorrow, but, a few months after release it should be a lock (I happen to know that many iPad developers wait until they can actually get their hands on a retail unit before upgrading their existing apps, although once they get the retail unit its like a race to finish).
4) Dictation. I have used this with success. However, like most voice recognition software its usefulness is reduced by the fact that I'm seldom in a quiet place. Still, I like it. I think its a valuable addition, and I typically use it when I only would have to type a few words. I don't use it to type long letters, as its not completely accurate and I think editing out all the mistakes would take longer than typing it out. (I do use an Apple brand bluetooth keyboard for serious typing: Apple Wireless Keyboard MC184LL/B [NEWEST VERSION] I have also tried a chicklet style one but it didn't work well for me: Kensington iPad 2 Case with Wireless Bluetooth Keyboard for Apple iPad 2 3G Tablet, WIFI Model K39521US.
5) The camera. I don't think I'll use this much. Mostly when taking pictures of things that I'm writing about, which isn't that often. Maybe for some FaceTime. But I don't think this makes it worth it to upgrade from the Original Ipad. (the iPad 2 had a camera, so you can ignore this if you have an iPad 2)

Other usage changes since iPad 1:
1) I bought an HP envy (HP Envy 110 e-All-in-One Printer for the wireless printing from iPad and iPhone. This has worked out VERY well. I think the AirPrint implementation has worked nicely.
2) One thing I was disappointed with the original iPad for was the inability to see what was on the iPad screen on a TV. Since then I have purchased an Apple TV Apple TV MC572LL/A (2010) [OLD VERSION] which is now the old version. And Apple has made it possible to see whatever is on the screen of the iPad on a bigger screen, and you can buy HDMI adapters now: Apple Digital AV Adapter (MC953ZM/A)
3) On my first review I talked about the ability to put your iPhone sim card into your iPad and share your existing data service. I tried this out, putting my iPhone microsim in the new iPad and I was invited to purchase a new data plan. So apparently that little moneysaver has been eliminated.

Other things that stay the same:
You still won't be able to use Flash, a website programming language that allows websites to act more like computer programs. I've read that the reason that Apple won't allow this is that Flash is often the gateway to getting viruses and other nasties. As a result, there is no need to have antivirus software on your iPad, its very very safe. The iPad is rock solid reliable. In fact, the only virus I've heard of for the iPad is where someone had to send you a Pdf via email and get you to open it. And of course, thats threat was removed before I even heard about it.

On my last review, I talked about usage. Apps I use a lot now:
1) Logmein: to do anything on my computer that I can't do on an iPad. This would include Flash based software. I connect to a computer THROUGH my iPad, and control the computer to go to flash sites. Ordinarily I would say this is not worth it, but the computer also runs engineering programs and other programs that don't really exist for the iPad.
2) Gopayment to accept credit cards, although Quickbooks Online usage is hampered by the fact that Quickbooks makes you use a stripped down version through the safari web browser. Once again, use LogMein Ignition.
3) I find the spreadsheet program (numbers) to be highly annoying. However, there was recently an announcement that MS Office programs Excel Word and Powerpoint will soon be available for the iPad with an interface similar to MS OneNote. I'll be buying a copy of Excel and hoping that it doesn't suck.
4) Find my Friends: I see where people are without having to call them and say "where are you?" which is nice. Because I can see where my wife is without calling her, I get less honeydos. Wipe that smirk off your face >:( But also if you know they are driving you don't have to worry about distracted driving causing an accident.
5) I don't end up playing many games on the iPad. I play a lot of games on the iPhone. But thats just my usage experience. Maybe that will change with the new screen.
You can read my original iPad review (linked above) for more usage ideas, if you are new to tablets.

A bit more about usage, someone pointed out in a comment that you don't need the HDMI adapter if you intend to use AirPlay. Airplay includes the ability to wirelessly stream audio and video from your iPad to a TV. Typically this is only from apps that share music and movies, which is the functionality of Airplay (You PLAY things over the air). There are Airplay adapters, including the AppleTV. However, the HDMI connector does more than the Airplay allows: You can share the actual screen of your iPad, no matter what it shows, to a TV as a mirror image. If you were to want to use the iPad as your primary "computer", you would probably want an HDMI adapter for big screen use. I meet more people each month who do use a Tablet as their primary computer, so I felt this was an important point to clarify. I own the AppleTV and the HDMI adapter, and use them in different ways at different times.

Will this Ipad 2.5 make my original iPad as useless as a 4GB iPhone 2G? For the first 6 months, no. But after that, its likely. Overall I am happy I bought it, mostly for the native 4G LTE internet. Followed by the beautiful screen. The faster processor is the 3rd reason, and as soon as the app developers start utilizing it to greater advantage, it will likely become the #1 reason. And I think I'll feel that that has happened in about 6 months.

After MS Excel comes out I may make an attempt to make the iPad my primary computing device, using the HDMI out and a bluetooth keyboard. Wish me luck.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

[Add comment]
Post a comment
To insert a product link use the format: [[ASIN:ASIN product-title]] (What's this?)
Amazon will display this name with all your submissions, including reviews and discussion posts. (Learn more)
This badge will be assigned to you and will appear along with your name.
There was an error. Please try again.
Please see the full guidelines here.

Official Comment

As a representative of this product you can post one Official Comment on this review. It will appear immediately below the review wherever it is displayed.   Learn more
The following name and badge will be shown with this comment:
 (edit name)
After clicking the Post button you will be asked to create your public name, which will be shown with all your contributions.

Is this your product?

If you are the author, artist, manufacturer or an official representative of this product, you can post an Official Comment on this review. It will appear immediately below the review wherever it is displayed.  Learn more
Otherwise, you can still post a regular comment on this review.

Is this your product?

If you are the author, artist, manufacturer or an official representative of this product, you can post an Official Comment on this review. It will appear immediately below the review wherever it is displayed.   Learn more
System timed out

We were unable to verify whether you represent the product. Please try again later, or retry now. Otherwise you can post a regular comment.

Since you previously posted an Official Comment, this comment will appear in the comment section below. You also have the option to edit your Official Comment.   Learn more
The maximum number of Official Comments have been posted. This comment will appear in the comment section below.   Learn more
Prompts for sign-in


Tracked by 3 customers

Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-10 of 10 posts in this discussion
Initial post: Mar 24, 2012 10:40:09 PM PDT
Last edited by the author on Mar 24, 2012 10:46:39 PM PDT
sandvfan says:
Product Guru,

This is one elaborate and great review. Thank you and I hope other people will appreciate it too. I did want to tell you though it seems like you have missed (or may be I am wrong) one really important feature of the the Apple TV which is probably the selling point for people with iOS devices. Airplay! It allows you to mirror your iPad's screen wirelessly on your TV as well as stream audio and video. You don't need any HDMI cables. All you need to do is to make sure your Apple TV and iPad is on the same wifi network. Then you can bring the multitasking bar on your iPad's screen (double click home button) and swipe left where you can see volume control. You will notice a new button appearing. It looks like a triangle on a screen. Click that and you will be able to set mirroring option. Airplay button appears on almost any app that uses control functions like play, pause, slideshow, etc. so music app, youtube, pictures, netflix, video, pandora, etc will have the airplay button. While iPad 2, The New iPad and iPhone 4S are the only ones that are capable of "mirroring" your screen, iPad 1, iPhone 4, 3GS, iPod Touches are limited to streaming audio and video.

Also, Apple's free Remote app is another really useful app to use it as a remote control for Apple TV and iTunes. You can use your iPad to type on search terms on Apple TV and you can remotely browse and control your whole itunes library on your computer.

I hope this helps to make it even more convenient for you by getting rid of the HDMI cable ;)

Edit: Yea, I think I misinterpreted your explanation. You do know about Airplay. Sorry.

In reply to an earlier post on Mar 25, 2012 2:21:57 PM PDT
You are correct that I wasn't really clear, I bought an apple tv which allows wireless streaming of videos. I use the hdmi cable primarily in my car (which has HDMI input) and at other peoples houses. The cost of the hdmi adapter is half the cost of and apple tv!! More or less. But doesn't reqUire external power like the apple tv. I know there are other airplay adapters but the apple tv is my favorite.

Thanks for the props and for clarifying for others.

Posted on Apr 5, 2012 8:06:57 PM PDT
Nice review

Posted on Jun 14, 2012 1:57:49 PM PDT
Mark Victor says:
I don't even own any kind of computer yet (I'm using library computers) so I still need some clarification about using airplay. I'd like to purchase the Ipad and an Apple TV to stream video to a TV, either taken with the Ipad camera or downloaded from a Library or Cafe hotspot, and I don't want to pay for net access at home. Yet Apple says "just connect to your wireless network" and I don't know what that means exactly - am I still going to be able to wirelessly connect the Ipad to an Apple TV, even if I don't have internet access at home? Thanks.

Posted on Sep 5, 2012 11:47:25 AM PDT
Jflo says:
Great review! I am currently viewing into buying an iPad 3 and this was actually very helpful.
Perhaps you can orient me about this: Do you know if there is a major difference between the AT&T and Verizon versions? I ask because I now have an unlocked Samsung Galaxy phone which was originally configured for AT&T and it comes with a bunch of annoying applications I cannot remove, are there any of these in the iPad?
I won't be using it in the US, so I don't really need operator specific apps.
Any inputs are welcome!

In reply to an earlier post on Sep 5, 2012 1:37:39 PM PDT
sandvfan says:

Perhaps I can answer your question since I posted here before. Non of Apple's iOS devices come with carrier's layer of additions so no at&t or verizon loaded apps which is one of the great things about iOS devices. It comes with only Apple's pre loaded apps that you actually need and use such as mail, calendar, app store, etc. Plus, all the software updates come directly from Apple and not from carriers so no waiting or loosing support within months of your purchase. Apple is known to stand behind their product support for very long time so you are guaranteed to have software updates for at least few years which is usually equal to 2-4 generations. They still support iPhone 3GS even with their soon to be released iOS 6 (possibly next Wednesday 9/12/12) which was released in 2009. It may not get all the new features but that is mostly because of hardware limitations. Long story short, apps wise, the carriers involvement between the iPad and you is zero. It's all between you and Apple.

As for the differences between ATT and verizon, Apple says iPad is world ready (which is true) but there are some differences in their LTE sim cards. They are designed to work with ATT or Verizon, not both. Get the whichever version you will likely use when you are in the US. if you are going to use it mostly out of US, I suggest to go with ATT because ATT has always been more compatible one since they use GSM and not CDMA. Verizon will also be ok out of US but I don't know if it will equally be compatible compared to ATT. I am not 100% sure if their differences in their LTE slot makes any difference outside of US. I would ask that around but not those guys in ATT or Verizon. They will twist things around if you mention anything about not using it in the US.

On a side note, if you are not in an extreme rush to purchase the new iPad, I would wait and follow Apple news in September and may be until mid October the latest. Just yesterday they sent invitations to their big event next week Wednesday. They will announce the new iPhone and probably the new ipods but I have been hearing rumors that they may make minor changes to the New iPad such as updating its dock slot to their rumored small 9 pin connectors (current one is a 30 pin). They are saying they may do that at their separate event in October, again, for the rumored iPad Mini. As I said, it's all rumors so it isn't certain. I just don't want you to regret anything with 2-3 week difference. They usually send invitations for such announcement 1 week before so sometime towards the end of September, you may hear about it... IF the rumor turns out to be true.

In reply to an earlier post on Sep 5, 2012 6:31:41 PM PDT
Jflo says:
Wow thanks Sandvfan, you really helped me clear my doubts :)
I have one more question tho, maybe you can help me with this too... why is the price difference between the AT&T and Verizon versions? Is it because of the hotspot feature? Either way it shouldn't be a problem if I take the iPad out of the US...
Thanks again!

In reply to an earlier post on Sep 6, 2012 8:36:41 AM PDT
Last edited by the author on Sep 6, 2012 8:40:58 AM PDT
sandvfan says:
No problem, Jflo :)

Yes, there is a price difference between Wi-Fi Only and Wifi+Celular model. Wi-Fi Only model, as it states, works only with in places with Wi-Fi like your home, Starbucks, Airports, etc. Wifi+Celular model includes the card slot for the 3G and LTE networks if you decide to get a data plan from any carrier at some point. I think you have an assumption that the cellular feature is only for ATT and Verizon. NO! You should be aware of the fact that Wi-Fi only model doesn't have a slot for a card so if you buy the Wi-fi only model you won't be able to use the cellular network like 3G or LTE from any carrier in the world. What I am trying to say is you should consider what you might and might not do with your purchase. If you say you won't ever get data plans and you will be ok with being limited to Wifi hotspots, you can skip the model with cellular feature.

Also note that there is no commitment for data plans if that's what you are trying to avoid with Wifi+Cellular model. You are the one who decides when to activate and cancel those plans. You are not ever required to activate it at all if you don't want to. It is not like smartphone plans...

I still think you should call Apple and talk to them directly to make sure it doesn't limit your needs if you will be using cellular network from different carriers outside of US. You should may be tell them you spend 4 to 6 months out of US and ask if it would be possible to use data plans from carriers like Vodafone in, lets say in Hungary :). I honestly don't think it's the best idea to tell them you are buying it here but will be using it outside of US for the whole time because there are people coming here and buying them in bulk and selling them in Europe for profits so Apple does take some actions to discourage that. Keeping this in mind you can adjust your story accordingly :). You can either call them or chat with them ask your questions.
The number and chat button is in the upper right corner. As much as I try to help I don't want to misinform you in any way. US version iPad and its use with carriers outside of US isn't my strong suit :))

In reply to an earlier post on Sep 10, 2012 9:24:25 AM PDT
Jflo says:
Sandvfan super helpful again!
I will contact them and make sure to know all the details before I buy it...
Thanks again!

Posted on Sep 13, 2012 1:42:53 PM PDT
Stemple says:
Thanks for your helpful review. I've got money set aside in a coffee can (not really) to purchase a portable device/tablet. Is it really worth the extra money to purchase the iPad 3, or would I be happy with an iPad 2? The Apple site sells a refurb iPad 2 with 64 gb, wifi and 3G for about $550, versus $729 plus tax for iPad 3 32gb wifi 4G. Or should I just grit my teeth, pay the money, and have the latest technology? Thanks for your thoughts on the matter.
‹ Previous 1 Next ›

Review Details


4.4 out of 5 stars (1,621 customer reviews)
5 star:
4 star:
3 star:
2 star:
1 star:
$729.00 $419.99
Add to cart Add to wishlist

Location: USA

Top Reviewer Ranking: 184