70 of 80 people found the following review helpful
Once Again The Best Baseball Game,
This review is from: MLB 12 The Show - Playstation 3 (Video Game)
I've been playing The Show since the 2006 iteration, and have purchased every version since. Last year marked the biggest changes to the series by adding full analog controls, Move support (if only in the Home Run Derby mode), and completely revamping the Road to the Show mode. They also replaced Rex Hudler (bleck!) with Eric Karros (yes!) which appealed quite a bit to my Dodgers blue blood. While this year's version doesn't offer the same type of sweeping changes, the game continues to improve on the functions added last year and continues to strive for realism.
Here's a breakdown of the game with strengths and weaknesses.
GAMEPLAY: The biggest change this year is the pitching format. Pulse pitching replaces the meter with a pulsing circle that you place around the strike zone. Time the circle so that it's at its smallest point, and you get the most accurate pitches. The better the control of the pitcher (and the particular pitches), the slower and smaller the circle will be. Erratic pitchers will have fast pulsing circles. And as the pitcher tires, the pulsing increases. It's a neat innovation that does solve the problem of never having walks. It does also give you less control over the pitches and may feel unfair at times. Sometimes you'll feel that you've pinpointed the circle exactly at it's smallest point, and the ball will still manage to find the edge of the circle that's outside the strike zone. However, it does increase the realism, that you may want to pinpoint your pitch exactly, but in reality it is hard even for the best pitchers to place the ball exactly where they want it to go. Overall, I think it's a good addition, but if you feel it's unfair, you can always switch back to metered pitching.
Other than that, most of the gameplay remains unchanged. Analog batting now has the option to add left-stick zone control, but if you're uncoordinated like me, that becomes difficult to manage. Analog batting does seem a little more forgiving this year, but it's still a steep learning curve for beginners. Fielding remains mostly unchanged, as does baserunning. Again, if you're not a fan of the analog controls, all of button/digital controls remain in the options. In terms of Move Support, pitching and hitting are ok, fielding and baserunning are subpar. It's neat to try, but you'll most likely switch back to the dualshock after a few at-bats.
ROAD TO THE SHOW: Much of this remains unchanged. The point evaluation system implemented last year is back, and seems much more accurate to the situations than last year (and a little less forgiving). Your player begins as a Double-A starter instead of a bench player which is a plus. And there are a lot more customization options this year for aesthetics. Overall, nothing major different here, but still one of the best aspects of the game.
AUDIO/VISUAL: The graphics have been a selling point for this game for quite awhile, and this year is no different. Player models are much more accurate (I had to do a double-take the first time I saw Kershaw in the game). The stadiums look great, the crowd is a bit more diverse, and the player movements are more fluid than in previous years. I did notice some frame rate issues here and there, not enough to be a deal breaker, but enough to be noticeable.
The sound is still great. The sound of the bat crack is a little different, but overall the ambient noise and the sounds of the game make you feel like you're at the ballpark. The broadcasting trio are once again great, though many of their lines are rehashed from previous years. Still, Eric Karros took some more time in the studio this offseason to add good commentary, and it does bring the game to life. The broadcast presentation is definitely more realistic, but this will also add more time to a game. In previous years with full broadcast mode, I could get through a game in 45 - 60 minutes, but if you plan on taking in the full effect the broadcast mode this year, expect your games to last over an hour, even if you skip through some scenes. Still, this is a stand-out part of the game.
ONLINE: (UPDATED) The access to the online features has changed a little bit this year. In order to access the online features, you have to have an online pass which enables these features. Your online pass code is printed on the back on the manual in the box (not sure if you have to buy it separately if you buy from PSN, but that's outside the scope of this review). So there's no extra cost, though one hopes this isn't setting up a precedent for future releases. If you're planning on borrowing a friend's game to play online features, prepare to be disappointed. All of the online modes are immediately available from the main screen now, rather than being in a separate login area. The game rooms seem a little better organized than in previous years, with leagues and game rooms getting their own separate areas rather than being in one big online lobby.
The new online feature for this year is diamond dynasty. You create your own team and customize it, start with a group of 25 random players, and then purchase, sell, and trade player card packs (much like baseball cards) to improve your team. You can also spend points you earn to upgrade players in all their various aspects. It's a fun aspect, but it is also very time consuming, so a casual fan may not want to put in the extra effort to improve their team. But for those who enjoy taking a team of low-ability players and turning them into a super team, this will provide hours of new gameplay.
LOAD TIMES: This has been the worst part of this game for years. Especially last year, the load times were oppressively long, even to save games. This year, this aspect has been improved, but still only comes up to about average. You now have the option install 10 GB of game data instead of 5 GB onto the hard drive, and that does make a significant difference. Saves take just a couple seconds, while loads still take 10-15 seconds, sometimes a little longer. If you have the space (and unless you have a ton of games or an old PS3 model, you should), use it to install that extra game data. It makes a difference. Don't expect it to be lightning fast though.
OTHER: The updated stadiums and Marlin uniforms look good (well, good in the game; I personally am not a huge fan of the Miami Marlins uniforms, but to each his or her own). The little details are still what makes this game standout. There are now different options and styles for batting gloves and cleats. Your players can now wear the new giganto-helmets that have been sported by some players (such as David Wright), and all minor league players in the game wear them. The mascots, the grass, the random crowd members, all continue to bring the game to life.
CONCLUSION: This was more of a "one small step for baseball video games" moment for this series rather than the giant leap from last year, but the improvements continue to make this the must-have baseball game. The learning curve is still steep, though moving from meter pitching to pulse pitching is an easier jump than digital-to-analog controls. Load times are still excessive but more bearable, and the realism is still there. If you want to get the most realistic baseball experience you can without going outside and playing a game, this is your game. Have fun and play ball! (And since I'm a huge Dodger fan: It's tiiiiiiiiiime for Dodger baseball!!!)
Tracked by 1 customer
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-9 of 9 posts in this discussion
Initial post: Mar 7, 2012 10:30:54 AM PST
I agree with everything in your review. I initially thought the pulse pitching was going to be cheesy and a failure but am so pleasantly surprised that I don't think I will ever go back to the analog/meter pitching. Before, I would go 4 innings having thrown 7 balls and 46 strikes. Obviously, that's not realistic. In one game I got 3 walks in the first 6 innings with Halladay of all people. Love the realism.
Also agree Go Doyers (fantasy draft)
Posted on Mar 7, 2012 3:34:44 PM PST
OJ Silk says:
Very good review, thanks for writing it. Great baseball game, hard to improve it year to year with how good it is to begin with. Enjoy!
Posted on Mar 11, 2012 2:49:52 PM PDT
Last edited by the author on Mar 11, 2012 2:50:18 PM PDT
Kent Stallard says:
I completely agree that this year's version is not a huge leap but rather an incremental (yet significant) improvement. However, the game has been great for the last few years so an overhaul is neither necessary nor desirable.
Posted on Mar 13, 2012 12:43:36 PM PDT
B. Odenkirk says:
"So there's no extra cost, though one hopes this isn't setting up a precedent for future releases" Get used to it man, every game you buy these days has some sort of online pass or DLC code packaged with it.
The game companies got tired of GameStop and the like making a killing on used games. Think about it, if you buy used, the game company isn't (or wasn't) making a dime. Now you have to purchase the online pass or whatever, so they can still make some money.
Also, great review! I agree with everything you said about it.
In reply to an earlier post on Mar 13, 2012 1:04:26 PM PDT
Jeff DeSurra says:
Ah, yes, that makes sense. I forgot about that aspect (which is silly of me since I buy a lot of games used). Thanks for pointing that out!
Posted on Apr 3, 2012 2:51:09 AM PDT
Great review and very informative! I've been a fan of the series since 2007. I'm gonna wait for a slight price drop on Amazon before picking this up...oh yeah, GO DODGERS! :)
Posted on Apr 10, 2012 7:46:53 AM PDT
Charles M. Strnad says:
Nice review, but wanted to add, after playing around 80 or so games myself (on Franchise mode, vs: the CPU), there continues to be several nagging gamepley issues, that surprisingly have never been fixed, in this otherwise excellent baseball sim.
1- Still WAY too frequent wild pickoff throws to first base, when you are trying to hold a runner close. Nothing you do with your gamepad will prevent this, either. Entirely random.
2- Still random assignment of errors to players, when NO error occurred at all on the field. Other simply wrong scoring decisions too- like when a rocket is hit past a defender, who doesn't even have a chance to get a glove on the ball, and yet he is assigned an error. Right.
3- Still little correlation with what you SEE on a play at a base, and the umpires' call. ie: the runner's entire body is across the base on a steal, he gets tagged on his foot, but he is called OUT, etc.
4- Still pretty lame, repetitive announcing. A few new lines, but ALL of the old lines STILL there, and STILL used over and over again. Pretty disappointing, after hearing about how much that had been "improved" this year. You won't notice it if you only play a game every now and then, but if you (like me) like to play through a whole season: be warned.
5- Still will see your fielder (outfielders most often) look like he is moving in cement, when you NEED him to get to the ball quickly, and get off a throw. These are still entirely random, have nothing to do with anything you do with your gamepad, and almost always seem to happen at a key point in a game. VERY annoying.
Still hands down the best baseball videogame on the market, but how the above things (and a few more) manage to "pass" the game testers each year, is beyond me.
Posted on Apr 11, 2012 10:23:58 PM PDT
Last edited by the author on Apr 11, 2012 10:25:06 PM PDT
S. EHRLICH says:
I can see right away from your review that for the umpteenth time they didn't get it right. Too steep a learning curve, too much play in the controls, AI nowhere near advanced enough all resulting in yet another sports game that you get bored with in ten minutes. We need a quantum leap in sports games, not just baby steps. The new technology of augmented reality needs to be employed in all sports games so that no game ever plays the same twice. Spontaneity in sports video games still looks like it's many years away, if it ever comes to fruition at all.
Posted on May 16, 2012 3:20:28 PM PDT
Scott D. Otto says:
i'm 14 games into a season on the veteran level (been playing since 08). so far i've had 7 balks called on mvp caliber pitchers, gold glove fielders routinely drop easy flyballs, and the MVP of the national league from last year is hitting .218 with zero home runs and 23 strike outs. most games i get 5 hits and 1 or 2 runs. but hey, it's realistic.
‹ Previous 1 Next ›