84 of 91 people found the following review helpful:
Borders on Game of the Year territory...
this is my first review, hope it's helpful (feel free to leave a comment and tell me what i did wrong/right). anyway, on with the amateur ramblings!
when i first saw the trailers for Borderlands a couple of months ago, i said to myself "that looks amazing (in both the graphical and gameplay departments), but it seems to be trying way too hard". i also thought...
An Average FPS with Mild RPG Elements
When I first heard of the concept behind Borderlands I immediately got excited about the prospect of playing a cooperative Role-Playing-Game online with a good friend. In the gaming press more than one passing comparison was made between Borderlands and Diablo, "Diablo with guns!" was one term used. Being a huge fan of Diablo my anticipation for Borderlands only grew...
this is my first review, hope it's helpful (feel free to leave a comment and tell me what i did wrong/right). anyway, on with the amateur ramblings!
when i first saw the trailers for Borderlands a couple of months ago, i said to myself "that looks amazing (in both the graphical and gameplay departments), but it seems to be trying way too hard". i also thought it looked like what Fallout 3 would've been if it was a FPS with RPG elements as opposed to the RPG with FPS view that it is.
as a bit of side information, i got Killzone 2 a week ago and have been playing it nonstop. i've already beaten it twice and i've spent pretty much every waking moment (to my girlfriend's annoyance) playing the campaign or the multiplayer. when i woke up today there was a delivery on my stoop. i told myself i'd open up Borderlands first (i also bought Resistance 2 and a few old school PS1 games (FFIX!)) and play it til the first save or checkpoint. this was at 11am, i'm writing this review at 11:30pm and save for going to dinner with my friends and dropping my sister off at the dorms, i've played the entire time. this game is just that engrossing and sheer fun
i don't think i can explain exactly what makes Borderlands so fantastic... there's just something about it. reviews i had seen on a few sites said that it takes a while for the game to get going and that by the 10th hour or so it really starts to be fun. well, if the game gets much more fun than this, it will be close to my game of the year. everything about Borderlands oozes style and love (meaning you can just tell how much the developers cared about this project). the pacing of the game is fantastic, the difficulty is a little up there, but it works and is never frustrating. the controls are spot on as far as responsiveness, but some of the button mapping is a bit strange (who maps fire to L2? and there doesn't seem to be a way to change it). the AI is fantastic with weapon-based enemies finding anyplace they can to duck behind and fire for cover, while the dog like creatures just get right up in your face. this can be frustrating, but it really makes you feel good when you finally blast them away.
the RPG elements are just kinda... there. while i don't think they detract from the game, i also think that they could have been implemented differently without the overall game changing on a base level. that being said, Borderlands does a great job of Diablo style leveling-up. part of the reason i couldn't stop playing is cause you're ALWAYS building up your character in some small way. it's just incredibly addictive and fulfilling. the one minor nitpick that i can throw in here is having to press square every. single. time. you wanna pick up an item. you can hold it down to pick up multiple items that are very close to each other, but you'll be pressing square A LOT. i know tehre's some things you might not want, but you spend so much time in your inventory screen anyway, they may as well have made it so you just run over something to grab it.
Borderlands sells itself on the concept of it's "87 Bazillion Guns". i've heard real estimates that say there's at least a few hundred thousand and that sure seems to be true. you'll NEVER stumble on the same gun twice. it's both a good and bad thing. obviously it's fun to try out all sorts of different combinations, but a lot more often than you'd like, you'll wind up with a weapon that, while not useless, is just pretty lame and underpowered. when you do find that perfect sniper rifle that shoots lighting, has a 500-round clip and a 120x zoom (just as one of soooo many examples), it'll all be so very worthwhile.
the rest of my nitpicks, and by the way, that's all they are, cause i don't see a single legitimate big complaint with this game, would be as follows: while the game looks cool in it's own way, it think it's almost like a cop-out art style, maybe they didn't feel like doing textures or something. there's also severe framerate issues where you're in the middle of large battles. the vehicles, which make getting around so much easier,don't handle good at all and you get less Exp when you kill an enemy with your car as opposed to being on foot. i wish there were large online multiplayer deathmatches and CoF battles and the like. i'll have to check out the online "duels" at some point, see if they almost make up for that.
when you get right down to it though, this is just an amazing game all around. the graphics have a sheen and polish that not many games have (it's fun to see little HP numbers rolling off someone as you shoot them in the face). i still think Borderlands is trying a bit too hard to be "cool" in the way a Tarentino or Guy Ritchie movie would be, but it just works anyway (much like a Guy Ritchie movie haha). in the end there's just something about Borderlands, some intangible quality, that makes it such a worthwhile experience. i haven't played the online co-op yet, so i can't speak to that, but the single player is one hell of a ride. the areas might all look a tad samey, there's only four character classes to choose from. the driving physics are pretty bad and there's not much variety in your enemies. thing is, none of that matters, Borderlands is amazing in spite of all of it's very minor flaws.
if you've ever liked an FPS, if you've ever liked level-up-fests like Diablo, etc, hell, even if you wanted more action from Fallout 3, you owe it to yourself to at least give Borderlands a chance. this, along with Killzone 2, BlazBlue, Uncharted 2, Dirt 2 (and i can only assume the new Ratchet and Clank game) is one of the top 5 best games of 2009. there's a damn good chance that this game is considerably better than any other videogame you're looking to get on Amazon... pick Borderlands immediately. you won't be let down.
enjoy. hope this helped. =)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Borderlands is a heck of a lot of fun. As a guy who has played a lot of post-apocalyptic games (yes, including Wasteland/Fallout -> Fallout 3), I have to admit that Borderlands hits that nice sweet spot between pure FPS and pure RPG. In Borderlands, you pick one of four characters and get to go for a romp in a fun quasi-post apocalyptic wasteland that is part Mad Max and part Pitch Black. Basically, you are on a different planet that is a rough and tumble outback world filled with nasty aliens, rogue humans, and lots of gunfights. It's a good time.
Borderlands is not as much an RPG as Fallout 3, for example -- your character is more of a Diablo style with skill trees rather than fully customizable. Quests are also less elaborate, and a bit more on rails with areas unlocking for exploration only as you advance the plot. Borderlands also reminds one of Mass Effect for its combat heavy emphasis and shield technology, but let's get down to some specifics:
1) Guns, guns, guns. I knew Borderlands was hyping its "17 trillion guns" bit, but didn't realize quite how awesome this would be until I really got into it. It really is amazing how varied the weaponry is. With just a 20th level character, I've already found sniper rifles that launch explosive rounds, rocket launchers that set everything on fire in a 10 foot radius, scoped shotguns that put 8 slugs in a tight circle on target from 200 meters away, SMGs that fire 4 shots at a time and electrocute the target, and everything in between. A good gun can really make a difference in a fight, such as finding a strong sniper rifle early, or getting a machine gun with a +60 round magazine that lets you walk up to someone and put a hundred rounds into their face. Sometimes enemies drop guns, but more often you'll find yourself giddy as you open a sealed gun case and see a gleaming new rifle. Really addictive.
2) Weapon proficiencies. Instead of putting points into weapons skills as you level up, you gain bonuses for them the more you use them. This is more realistic and a lot more fun, since it gives you a way to reinforce your powers through use. Clearing a few caves with a shotgun will quickly net you added weapon bonuses that really pay off. Separately you can also (starting at level 5) put points into your skill trees, so you can get some nice cumulative overlap.
3) Second wind. One great concept is the "second wind" -- when you get KO'd, you get a few seconds to kill one of your foes and get a "second wind" that pops you back onto your feet. This is particularly nice when you get overrun by mutant dogs or flying enemies without warning. In a number of fights, I killed nearly every foe only to have the last couple take me down at close range. With a second wind, you manage to survive -- and it is extremely gratifying.
4) Level resets. One nice feature is that quitting and reloading the game resets all the areas, so you can farm areas repeatedly for EXP, different guns, and the like. This lets you level up if you are having problems, make money, and get those weapons you wanted.
Now, a few negatives:
1) No armor. Your character gets a wide array of selections between guns, grenades, and shield generators. However, there is no other armor in the game. This seems like a big oversight and cuts into the customizability of your character a fair amount. It would be nice to have slightly less guns in exchange for boots, gloves, helmets etc.
2) Level-specific foes. Enemies have a high respawn rate and scale somewhat based on your level. This usually works fine, although you will face a lot of dangerous and accurate enemies. One problem however is that you seem to do less damage against higher level enemies. In particular, if a foe is much stronger than you, your weapons do almost no damage, while theirs will destroy you. This might be an effort to keep your level growth under control, but you usually find out through trial and error. I had a character go up a level in the middle of a fight, and he went from doing 20 damage to some high level raiders to doing over 100. It was pretty strange.
3) The graphics in the game are interesting and appealing, but there are some unfortunate bug effects. Despite a nice strong jumping ability, it is possible to get stuck in the terrain, which can also effect enemies. NPC scripts can sometimes get broken if interrupted by fights or the like, usually requiring a reload (for example, I've had that little droid from the start of the game freeze up a few times, meaning you can't get through a gate and the game is basically broken).
4) There are vehicles you can drive around in, which is another nice feature. They also make good heavy weapons platforms if you are having problems with higher level monsters. However they are also a little buggy -- I had one simply blow up for no reason (and with full shields), and another get stuck on some rocks that wouldn't let me exit and required a reload. And reloads take forever.
All in all, Borderlands is a fun game with much to recommend itself. Popping people with a sniper rifle and then cleaning up with a shotgun or assault rifle is a simple joy that is endlessly repeated. If you're looking for a FPS with character development, or an RPG with lots of fighting, this is your game.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
This game is very fun to play online! I think the single player option is nice but not the true way the game was meant to play. Its easy to pick this game up and run through a couple quests in half an hour or even join on someone else's game. the action is great and if you minimize travel time between action can be rather short. cars are fun and the addition of challenges make for a fun addition to the game. The four classes are a nice idea but the ability to develop their skill trees differently give these classes more variability.
The mods for the grenades and class skills are excellently done. Also the ability to level up in weapon skills prevents any class from being limited in weapon choice. This game has many layers to it that keep it more fresh than other MMO-type games.
i would recommend it to anyone that liked Diablo/Diablo II's action/RPG elements. The First person shooter element of this game is great!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
If you could only describe a game in one word, that word would be "insane." I've just stayed up till 7:30am and it was all worth it. It's like Killzone2 frantic and the RPG elements of the first Baulder's Gate on PS2. I'm a level 28 soldier. Now the weapons are insane, I've had a shotgun that shot rockets, an SMG with explosive rounds, an SMG with a four spread shot so each round is four projectiles, a heavy machine gun with fire rounds, and a revolver with 303 damage and zoom scope (meaning it's my sniper rifle for medium range, HAND CANNON!). The only thing that sucks is if you have a rocket launcher it has no hit detection (if you think your going to hit a target aim at the ground at its feet, its the only way to cause damage, GEARBOX please send us all a patch!).
Other than that, see you on the Pandora on PS3.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
==What I was expecting==
After all the hype and reviews I was expecting a ripe-off, albeit a fairly good one, of Fallout 3. Of course, Diablo II with it's randomly generated baddies and weapons (and drops in general) was also mentioned. Seeing as how I played Diablo II and its expansion quite a bit when they were released, and absolutely enjoyed Fallout 3 (purchasing all of the DLC and even getting into the double-digit levels for a second evil/neutral player), this sounded like something I would enjoy. One thing I wasn't sure about was the first-person aspect, having a generally weak stomach for 'twitch' games.
Because of this I decided to hold off until the price dropped, after a handful of months. But as I had a coupon that I wanted to use towards a game (since I was in one of those moods where I just needed something new to play) I decided to pick this up.
==What I got==
A pleasant surprise. Having just beaten the game after playing for around 2 weeks (with two batches of the flu in there) this is probably one of my favorite games of the last year; definitely in the top 5.
==RPG elements==
Borderlands has a fairly robust skill tree, for each of the four character classes, similar to Diablo II versus Fallout 3; the former having a small set of skills, within a couple of skill trees, that you can increase in skill, and the latter having a wide variety of skills, without too much in the way of skills requiring other skills. This makes it extremely simple, ignoring the decisions you have to make when gaining new skill points, to work with this element. In fact, the decision making process is fairly flexible, as you can always reset your skill points (without losing any) to try a different style.
Having played a game with a skill implemention like this, I'll honestly have a slightly harder time going back to games that don't allow you to reset (although within the story this element makes sense).
Speaking of story, it's actually much better than what I thought it would be, after the various reviews. The ending seems a bit abrupt, but everything is tied together, so it may be more an issue with the open-endness of the game. Which brings us to mission structure.
There are seemingly well over a hundred missions, only a small quantity of which are required to advance the story. The rest serve to help increase your level (more on this later) to what is required for the story missions. Generally they tie into the story enough that it makes sense to just do them, especially for the rewards (whether you're going to just sell them or not).
Back-tracking, an essential element of RPGs, is present in this game, but isn't too bad once you gain access to an 'instant-travel network.' With enemy respawns being fairly quick (approximately two in-game days, which seems to be less than an hour) and vehicles available for most large areas, the travel isn't tedious.
==Shooter elements==
Borderlands is a fairly standard FPS, made interesting by the art style it uses and the plethora of weapon choices. While there are a handful of weapon types, most weapons are randomly generated, making it fairly hard in the beginning and middle of the game to choose just four weapons (the most you can have equipped). Generally you'll probably have at least one or two kept in your backpack to swap in.
This randomization and weapon type scope is what really makes this aspect of the game interesting, in my opinion. But when you add in class-specific skills, you end up with something completely more. In fact, I think it's fairly easy to miss out on the importance of your core skills, often forgetting to use them. I personally didn't use my character's skill all that often until near the end of the game, and having played with others online, that seems to be fairly common for lower-level first-timers. Perhaps that just serves to show the deepness of this game.
As already mentioend, I have a hard time with FPS games usually, if they're twitch. While Borderlands can be, generally you survey the area and come up with some kind of plan; rushing straight at enemies at or above your level is suicide.
Which brings us to the level aspect. Each enemy has a set level, excluding one-off mission-related enemies, which is consistent throughout the game. Higher level enemies give great rewards, but are also more difficult. This is the same with the quests/missions. Thankfully there's almost no grinding required (although I should note that I did all optional missions in addition to the story-related ones). Experience also changes based on this, so targeting lower level enemies eventually becomes near useless.
Death is interesting in this, allowing you to get a 'second wind' if you kill an enemy before you bleed out. Failing that, a certain amount of money is deducted and you are resurrected at the nearest 'station' (saying no more in case of minor spoilers) ready to go back up against them.
==Multiplayer==
Borderlands offers on- and offline cooperative play. Offline coop is okay, with the split screen (side-by-side) a little hard to use. Online multiplayer (using Playstation Network) was fairly quick and without issue. You can choose what game you join, making it fairly easy to find a group at your level (or higher/lower if you so choose). (Unlike on Xbox, Playstation owners typically don't have mics, so I can't comment on communication.)
Having let my Xbox Live Gold subscription lapse a few weeks ago, online multiplayer was actually the reason I picked this up for the Playstation 3; surprising since I usually don't care too much about online play with games.
==Replayability==
With a new game plus mode (keep everything, replay the story again with enemy levels increased) and four classes, as well as the online multiplayer and two currently DLC (with one more in the works), replayability is pretty high. Once I finish the DLC and a few upcoming games - Mass Effect 2, BioShock 2, and probably Heavy Rain - I'll be back on Pandora.
==Overall==
Overall, Borderlands is, again, one of the top 5 games I've played in the last year (in no particular order, Fallout 3, Muramasa: The Demon Blade, Uncharted 2: Among Thieves, and Lost Odyssey, with Batman: Arkham Asylum getting bumped). A good, long, game, with an interesting story, and high replayability means I give Borderlands 5 of 5 stars.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
I bought this in-store right after it came out and my wife and I became immediately addicted. This game is Definately the baby of an RPG and a first person shooter. We've only played it with us two and it still was a great experience.
Having said that, the game is still not without its flaws. First off it is a grind fest. If you like blasting baddies into next week all day and night, or if you're in-tune with leveling and loot gathering this is the game for you. Take into account though that enemies respawn at an alarming rate. This wasn't so bad closer to the end of the game after leveling up and learning the game's mechanics but closer to the beginning it was a nightmare. Enemies would respawn every few minutes giving no break inbetween. Once, we cleared out an entire town of bandits only to have them all respawn, including turrets, all at once. Other times they would spawn faster than we could kill them, having to re-kill every enemy if we had to go backward or after respawning ourselves. Also, there were technical difficulties like not being able to sign in from multiple accounts on the same system, or having to reset the brightness(we have a very dark TV) every time we play even if it said it was up all the way(you have to turn it down and back up again to get it to work right). The driving could also have been better(no splashes when driving through water?), and the frame rate dropped pretty far a couple of times. Last but not least some of the textures look last-gen. I actually forgot that I wasn't playing our Wii a few times.
The good, however, out weigh the bad. The game has TONS of guns and loot and the guns(although most of the "bazillions" are just better versions of the same ones) really do give the playstyle a different spin, I especially like the elemental damage that some guns have. The game has what I like to call keep-play, in other words, playing on after the main quest-line has ended so you can go back if you miss something. It also has high replay value as you can keep your stats and equipment and play through again. The enemies are verried and you have to change up your tactics so it isn't just a shoot till they die affair. The best news in my opinion though is that you can play two player local(on the same system and TV) without the need of an internet connection. All in all it could have been polished a lot more but in the end it was worth it and I look forward to playing thought it again.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
A challenge. A real challenge. Thank you Gearbox. Thank you.
Don't be scared. This game isn't insanely difficult, it just doesn't follow the watered down gameplay rules that game studio consolidation has rammed down our throats recently. This means that, if you are a skilled player, you won't fail a mission two out of three times as a matter of chance regardless of your best efforts to succeed. If you are an inexperienced gamer, or a complete goob (Forest Gumpian gamer), you are not going to be given a victory screen one out of three tries just for showing up to a firefight while failing to put forth an honest effort to win it. You don't get to conquer this game simply by laying down sixty dollars for the disc as seems to be the expectation nowadays. Forest Gump is the only one who gets to dumb luck his way through life like that.
An honest effort in Borderlands involves a mix of military tactics, patience, and common sense. No soldier in the real world wins a battle by running into the crossfire and taking a hundred rounds to the forehead. In Borderlands you aren't going to 'Level Up' by making this terrible mistake on a habitual basis. You are going to find yourself in this situation occasionally but for the most part just being smart about your actions will save a lot of grief. This game isn't hard. Just don't steal defeat from the clutches of victory because some other popular game let you get away with it.
The graphics are a refreshing change from the norm as other FPSs are beginning to all look alike. Yeah, cel shading is easier to program but ease of programming is not a rating category that I will ever care about. The controls do mimic many other FPSs out there which makes learning them a bit easier. You aren't going to waste hours waiting to feel comfortable with the button layout. The action is intense and achieving a 'Level Up' is an addictive element that feeds on itself and makes mission successes very gratifying. Guns are both weapons and currency in the game. You can't say you don't like a gun in Borderlands without implying that you don't like getting paid. It's a colonial apocalyptic wasteland and firearms are definitely in high demand. Be an in-game entrepreneur and not just another angry consumer when it comes to arms dealing.
'Fun' is the appropriate word to describe the Borderlands experience and Mad Max can't compete with this level of apocalyptic entertainment. Grab a friend. Grab three friends if you're playing online. You are all going to enjoy this experience and you'll appreciate the fact that the sense of accomplishment you are all feeling comes from actually trying, not just simply showing up. Thank you Gearbox.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
As an owner of a PS3 and the Wii I have purchased over 30 games this year. By far, this is my favorite game. Since receiving this for Christmas I have put over 50+ hours in and am still not close to being finished. (I started playing this after getting bored with the one-dimensional, most over-hyped game of all-time, MW2.)
You could read all the rest of the reviews for game specifics, but this game is PURE FUN. I am not a fan of RPG's but this game makes it very entertaining. There are missions upon missions to unlock and play. The amount of weapons is mind-boggling. (Although sometimes it gets annoying pressing square and pickign up the same low-level guns over and over again.) Enemy AI gets increasingly difficult but not to the level that you throw down the controller and give up. I am currently at Level 34 as a soldier. When I finish I plan on replaying it as one of the other characters. Haven't even touvhed online yet. Solid game all-around. Highly engaging. Can't wait for Borderlands 2. Let's get working on it 2K. I definately got my money's worth (or I should say my wife's) with this one. BUY IT!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Borderlands is a great game. It is actually what I wanted Fallout 3 to be. Its an FPS but has the mission structure and length of a full blown RPG.
Hours and hours of co-op or single player fun. You can do either and the game just scales based on how many players are playing at once.
The art style is great and really sets this game apart from the crowd. It is colorful and vibrant. There is a twisted humor underlying the entire game which helps give it a great atmosphere.
If you like FPSs and or RPGs and are looking for something that will last you a while (like 50 hours) (even longer for multiple play throughs) this is a great deal.
Worth every penny! Get it!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
I heard a little bit about this game in the last few months, but not too much, and after seeing pictures of the game and its unique art style I was a little put-off by it. However the thought of a first person shooter / role-playing action game you can play with up to 4 players online with a million different weapons to find has kept me interested. I did pick up Uncharted 2 last week but that game has been hijacked by my cousin so with a gift card I had for Bestbuy I figured what the Hell and picked this up yesterday.
I got home around 3:00pm and didn't stop playing until it was time for dinner around 7:00pm and even then I did not want to put down the controller. As far as the graphics go the pictures online do not do them justice, when you are playing in this world full of machines, broken down towns, and creatures it looks beautiful. Their hasn't been much of a story so far as far as I can tell you are on some fictional planet where their are stories about a treasure full of alien weaponry and wealth beyond your dreams this place is called the Vault and countless mercenaries are on a quest to find it including you. The quests are your usual go here collect certain amount of items, return them, then go somewhere else kill certain enemy, return, however it's a blast doing them and I haven't got tired of it yet. I played online with two other players I did not know, but they did have headsets and were very mature and helpful, together we did a few quests and earned some cash to upgrade our gear and refill ammo and such via vending machines in the town, which is how you do your shopping. I would best compare this game to a Diablo meets Call of Duty meets Mad Max, you gain levels through XP and can upgrade your characters abilities through a tree like system similar to Diablo, and their is tons of loot that drops which is color coded based on rarity, and the game plays like your modern first person shooter.
This review is for the PS3 version, however at its core I'm sure the Xbox 360 version is pretty much the same thing, I only got it for the PS3 becasue most of the people I know in my life have that system at this time. I am going to give this game a 5 out of 5 as it is truly a fun game and I can see it holding my attention for a long time with it's loot and leveling system and enemies that adjust in difficulty with the more you play, plus the whole co-op play. I hope this game does well, so maybe they will update it with more content over time as well, if you haven't heard of this game and are into either the first person or role-playing action genre you owe it to yourself to check it out.
MY RATING FOR THIS GAME: 5 out of 5
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
