482 of 486 people found the following review helpful:
Excellent voice recorder with some limitations
I purchased this recorder so I could use speech recognition software if I wanted to, without paying for any additional microphones/headsets. In fact, the recorder is Dragon (a famous brand of speech recognition software) certified to produce "Maximum Accuracy Dictation."
Functionally, this recorder has an easy to reach (i.e. no plastic cover on it) USB...
76 of 84 people found the following review helpful:
Not a UPnP Device. Requires proprietary software to work. No support for Mac, Linux, or Windows 7
I bought this device to record conference speakers for our organization. I decided on this unit after reading that it has excellent sound quality and can record in mp3 format at 192kb encoding. Both of these are true: the only positive thing I can say about this unit is that the sound quality is fantastic. It's getting the files off of the device that proves next to...
This review is from: Sony ICD-PX720 Digital Voice Recorder with PC Link (Electronics)
I purchased this recorder so I could use speech recognition software if I wanted to, without paying for any additional microphones/headsets. In fact, the recorder is Dragon (a famous brand of speech recognition software) certified to produce "Maximum Accuracy Dictation."
Functionally, this recorder has an easy to reach (i.e. no plastic cover on it) USB port on the left hand side, an easy-to-distinguish recessed Record button, buttons to navigate between folders, play back existing recordings, split an existing recording, change recorder options, change playback volume, erase an existing recording, and a Hold button. The recorder itself is small, lightweight and easy to hold.
For storage, the recorder can hold as many as 99 separate recordings in each of 5 independent folders. This is useful to categorize various voice recordings, such as meetings in one folder perhaps speeches in another.
However, an easy to use recorder is meaningless if the recorder doesn't produce good recording quality. Here, this recorder delivers nicely. The built-in microphone is very good and has a wide dynamic range (i.e. it clearly picks up high and low frequencies). There are two sensitivity settings for the microphone---Low which is for individual dictation, and High which is for group meetings (or recording things farther away from the recorder). In addition, the recorder has a good built-in speaker.
If you need better recording quality (or want to play back the messages privately), the recorder provides a headset jack and a microphone jack.
As for recording quality, standard quality recording (44.1 kHz @ 48 KBPS) produces clearly understandable voice output. In this mode, the recorder can store up to 48 hours of voice recording and can run for up to 35 hours on 2 AAA batteries. This is the best mode for normal dictation (since it provides 4x as much space as the highest quality mode---which can only store 12 hours of data and run for 20 hours).
They have a super long recording time they brag about on the box. This is the LP mode (11.025 kHz @ 8 KBPS)---288 hours. This sounds impressive, but it is nearly useless. When I recorded a brief amount in this mode, my voice sounded very metallic and I heard weird high pitched metallic warbling in the background. There was somewhat less warbling at Low microphone sensitivity, but although my voice was understandable, but I don't recommend this mode for any real recording. The metallic warbling is very distracting.
In addition, the recorder can run on rechargable AAA batteries (NiMH) or even run from power provided over the mini-USB port. These are good options to save on batteries and perform very long recordings.
In my experience, the standard quality is fine for normal dictation. If I wanted to record music, EVPs, or for dictation into speech recognition software, I would use the maximum quality mode, since it is better at capturing higher frequencies and may better capture faint noises.
However, there are some downsides to this recorder. First, the recorder does NOT record data natively as MP3s (which it claims to on the box). This is why I gave it 4 stars instead of 5.
To access the recorder, Sony provides Windows software to copy voice files off it. The Windows software can store the files as MP3s, as well as encode MP3s so the recorder can play them back, so, if you are not using Windows, you cannot transfer recordings from the recorder.
Basically, if you are using Windows the recorder software is not a problem. If you are not, the computer will not see the recorder and you will be unable to use it. The recorder will still function very well as a normal voice recorder, but you will not be able to access the digital data on it.
Secondly, the recorder cannot accept any type of memory card to expand its capacity.
Beyond that, this recorder does not record sound in stereo, although it will accept stereo microphones. For me, since I'm only using it for voice dictation, this is not an issue, but for anyone who wants to use it to record music (such as an impromptu jazz session), it might be.
Finally, the recorder does not act as a USB drive or as an MP3 player. You can load music files (converted to Sony's proprietary sound format) onto it, but it doesn't have shuffle, playlists, or other standard MP3 player features. For me, these aren't issues since I have separate gadgets to fulfill these needs far better, but some voice recorders have these features.
In conclusion, if you are using Windows and you need a high quality, reasonably priced voice recorder, this will fit the bill nicely. If you want a recorder that is more of a Swiss Army knife of gadgets, this won't work for you.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
This review is from: Sony ICD-PX720 Digital Voice Recorder with PC Link (Electronics)
After having a Sony micro cassette recorder for years, I realized I rarely used the thing because the tape hiss was so bad. It still works, but it's a shame they never came out with a low-cost, small digital tape format in the 80's...or perhaps put in dbx noise reduction. In fact it's ridiculous that they're still selling those machines with basically 60's technology and people keep buying them. Well, I'm here to say, "Stop!" If you've suffered with tape hiss for years, here's a great machine that will get you into the 21st century.
This model just came out in January '09. I use its native SHQ format, which I believe stands for Super High Quality. I think Mac users are out of luck as far as transferring digitally to their computers. But I use Vista and the software installed seamlessly. I had made five or six test recordings ranging from ten seconds to two minutes. They all transferred via USB within seconds. The software is called Digital Voice Editor and is pretty cool. You can use it to make some settings on the recorder like recording formats, mic sensitivity and file-naming conventions. You can play back the files at variable speeds, good for transcribers. You can also set it so that the files are automatically deleted from the recorder once they're transferred to PC. I haven't tried the MP3 player feature. I didn't buy it for that. I bought this as a means to record musical ideas, melodies, or lyrics while on the road. In my view, the quality is good enough that once on the computer, those files could be used as samples in my next song.
I looked at about ten different Sony models in the store before getting this one. Some of the higher-end models had smaller displays. I like the larger display, as well as this being one of the few models in black. The buttons are larger than most models and well-placed. The speaker is decent, but even the cheapest Sony headphones are better. One reviewer says this will not record in stereo. I'm not sure this is correct. The specs state it does, but I haven't tested it enough to determine for myself. I use a cheap little PC microphone that came with some old Dell computer. It has a stereo jack and produced audio much better than the built in mic. I may upgrade to a Sony ECM-DS70P Electret Condenser Stereo Microphone in the future, as it will also work well on my camcorder.
If you're a Windows user this is a great portable recorder for getting ideas onto the PC for editing, pod casting, etc. Those who have no need to transfer files will find it is a great field recorder with very clean audio, suitable for recording lectures, conducting interviews or the occasional "note to self."
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
This review is from: Sony ICD-PX720 Digital Voice Recorder with PC Link (Electronics)
I use this recorder for recording class lectures and meetings. Once the file is transferred to the computer, the quality of sound is excellent. The software (comes in a CD with the recorder) allows you to increase/decrease the volume. Even if you are sitting very far (30-40 feet) from the speaker, you could record and listen to the speech later on. Memory space allows you to record for about 12 hours.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
This review is from: Sony ICD-PX720 Digital Voice Recorder with PC Link (Electronics)
First, let's correct the Amazon specs on the size and wt. of this item. The true dimensions are 4.25 in. tall, about 1.5 in. wide, and .75 in. thick. The recorder weighs in at 3 oz., with batteries installed. I've included an uploaded photo of the recorder hand-held.
The manual is extensive, although the odd labeling of the recorder's keys makes it a little hard to follow. A slide switch on the upper left side of the recorder labeled "Hold" turns it on and off. You can select one of the five message "folders" (A-E) by going through a menuing process. Each folder can hold up to 99 messages, depending on your chosen recording quality level. Once you have selected a folder, creating a message is accomplished just by hitting the large red "Rec/Pause" button. You can pause and continue a message just using this button. Playback is also simple, using the large "Enter" (Play/Stop) button.
More complicated features allow you to add-on to a previously recorded message (one which has been "Stopped"), split a message into two separate messages, record with voice-activation, etc., etc. Messages can be erased one at a time or folder-by-folder.
The included software lets you upload the contents of your recorder to your PC and play the messages from the recorder or the PC. I have run mine on an XP-Pro machine, and checked to see that there was a Sony update for Vista 64-bit compatibility, which downloaded and installed just fine. Once the messages are on your PC, you can re-name them (just like any other files), delete them, or split them up. You can also convert them from native format to MP3.
The recorder has four different recording quality levels and two levels of mike sensitivity. An editing feature lets you boost the sound for otherwise unintelligible portions of your messages (I didn't try this).
The playback volume range seems acceptable even for use outdoors, and I haven't yet tried recording in a windy environment.
All in all, it's slick--much better than I anticipated. Back in the day, you had to spend several hundred dollars for a recording/transcription device like this, and it chewed through tape cassettes.
One thing to be aware of: the recorder is so small that it might be easy to lose. There is a string lanyard thread-through point in the lower right top edge of the device, and I am ordering a string lanyard connector for use with a neck lanyard for it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
This review is from: Sony ICD-PX720 Digital Voice Recorder with PC Link (Electronics)
I bought this device to record conference speakers for our organization. I decided on this unit after reading that it has excellent sound quality and can record in mp3 format at 192kb encoding. Both of these are true: the only positive thing I can say about this unit is that the sound quality is fantastic. It's getting the files off of the device that proves next to impossible if you use Windows 7.
The ICD-PX720 does not support UPnP (Universal Plug and Play). UPnp is pretty much the standard for audio devices be they voice recorders or mp3 players. It allows Windows (all versions) and Mac (OSX 10.xx) to view the device as a hard disk and add/remove files to it using Windows Explorer or Finder in Max OSX. Without UPnP, the only way to move files on or off the recorder is using Sony's proprietary Digital Voice Editor software 3.2.01. This software is Windows only (read this voice recorder does not support Macs or Linux!). It also DOES NOT SUPPORT Windows 7. I tried using various compatibility modes in Windows 7, but to no avail.
I've always considered Sony as a brand to be a little more expensive, but worth it because of quality and service. Sadly, in this case they have dropped the ball. Not having a Windows 7 tool set available at the end of November 2009 when the Windows 7 release candidate and beta have been out for almost a year is just inexcusable. This is literally the only device I've found in 6-months of using Windows 7 (beta, then RC, then the final release) that does not support Windows 7. Add in that it is unusable by those who prefer Macs & Linux, and it really is an inferior device to the other, similarly priced voice recorders on the market. I intend to return this device. I've already bought a Olympus Digital Voice Recorder (VN 6200PC) that is UPnP and doesn't require proprietary software to access my audio recordings--it's not perfect but it's 5x better than this piece of trash.
Conclusions:
1) Has great audio quality
2) Is not a UPnP device
3) Does not support Mac or Linux, nor does it currently (Nov. 2009) support Windows 7
4) Requires a proprietary software to function
5) Inferior to other similarly priced options
1.5 stars out of 5. Not recommended unless you run Windows XP or Vista only and don't mind being locked into using a proprietary software to access your files.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
This review is from: Sony ICD-PX720 Digital Voice Recorder with PC Link (Electronics)
I bought this little recorder in a hurry for a lecture the next day. I was ACTUALLY ready to buy a microcassette recorder before I woke up & realized the potential lack of hiss & flexibility in recording voice MP3s. The recorder is simple to learn (took me 3 minutes) & worked flawlessly. Crystal-clear recordings, great & easy downloading to PC, terrific Digital Voice Editor software.
I am looking forward to using this for dictation to make voicenote reminders to myself; also to possibly use with Dragon Naturally Speaking to write dictated e-mails (it's supposedly compatible), and also Microsoft OneNote. Highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
This review is from: Sony ICD-PX720 Digital Voice Recorder with PC Link (Electronics)
Here is the email I received from Sony when I tried to connect:
"Thank you for contacting Sony Support.
"I'm sorry that the Sony Digital Voice Editor Software does not recognize the Voice Recorder in the Computer. The IC Recorder is not compatible with the Windows 7 Operating System. The Digital Voice Editor software 3.2.01 is compatible with Vista and XP operating System only. In order to transfer the recording please use the analog interface. Connect the Headphone out from the IC Recorder to the Audio IN jack in your computer if available.
"Thank you for your time.
"The Sony Email Response Team"
UPDATE: Read the comments on this review. The first one links to a newer version of the software that is available from the Sony Asia website. The commenter says you can run the software in Vista compatibility mode. I have not been able to verify this, but changed my review title from "Does not work with Windows 7" to "Does it work with Windows 7?"
If and when I buy another digital voice recorder, it will be one that does NOT use proprietary software to transfer the resulting files to my computer. It should work like my MP3 player, where the files are visible to the operating system -- whether it's Windows, Mac, or Linux -- just like a USB drive.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
This review is from: Sony ICD-PX720 Digital Voice Recorder with PC Link (Electronics)
Absolutely love it! Easy to use and goes for 14 hours on highest quality recording. It is so easy to download and burn to discs so I can listen while I commute or listen with headphones directly from the recorder. I had to change the batteries after about 18 hours (including listening from headphones and the actual lecture). It doesn't look as expensive as some of my friend's recorders but it records better and has more functions. I LOVE IT!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
This review is from: Sony ICD-PX720 Digital Voice Recorder with PC Link (Electronics)
Sony has the market cornered on "Good, but.."
If you buy anything from Sony, its always the same thing: you must install their proprietary software to read their proprietary files, which means you will add steps to your workload simply by using Sony gear.
Sony's hardware is almost always high quality, but they all require some form of insane software. a special app to load songs onto their mp3 players, a special app to get sound files from this recorder onto your hard drive, yadda yadda yadda, I love and detest Sony.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
This review is from: Sony ICD-PX720 Digital Voice Recorder with PC Link (Electronics)
I am beyond disappointed with this voice recorder.
First of all, if all you want is a simple voice recorder that you carry around with you, record your voice memos, and then playback later on the device itself, this guy will do the job just fine, and you should feel totally comfortable buying this device. Plus, it's inexpensive. Those 2 things are why I gave it 2 stars instead of 1.
HOWEVER, if you have any desire whatsoever to transfer the recordings to your computer, this is not the recorder for you. Wouldn't it be nice if you just plugged it into your USB port and your computer recognized it, and you could just drag the files from the device onto your desktop--you know, like every other similar device out there these days? If you have a Mac (like half of the people who buy computers today), you are completely out of luck, as it does not interface at all with a Mac (or Linux) (WHY NOT??). If you have a PC, you must install Sony's propietary and highly complicated software in order to transfer the files.
Also, this device does NOT record directly to MP3. It records to some other obscure (possibly proprietary) sound format, which is then converted to mp3 by Sony's unnecessarily complicated software, which you must have installed on your computer in order to use it. So if you want to transfer the files to a different computer, you will need to download and install the software on that machine also. (WHY???)
I run a digital media computer lab--I am not someone who is uncomfortable with technology or complicated software.
Do yourself a BIG favor and avoid the Sony ICD-PX720. Sony used to be totally on the ball with their electronic devices, but they should be ashamed of themselves. It's like they WANT you to purchase from their competition instead.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
(
Saving...
