Most Helpful Customer Reviews
281 of 314 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Overrated, extremely light on content, January 22, 2009
This review is from: slide:ology: The Art and Science of Creating Great Presentations (Paperback)
I rarely review books, but this one was such a waste that I'd feel guilty if I didn't at least TRY to persuade you not to buy. The main problem with the book, as other reviewers have alluded to, is that it sort of tries to BE a design masterpiece rather than teach you. The design is interesting, but it is to the point that the content is subordinated to the design. There are maybe 5 pages worth of useful content.
Another irritant to me is that this is by far the most commercial book I've ever seen (more ads than a magazine). It seemed that every few pages I was being told to buy this book, or buy all of some other guys books. There is a two page section that is taken from Guy Kawasaki's blog. The whole thing is incredibly derivative (but shallow).
Finally, and this I can take responsibility for, it didn't meet my needs because I am not Al Gore, nor am I the CEO of a company. If I gave a presentation in the style of this book I'd be laughed out of the office. I'm an analyst, and the warm and fuzzy slides would not be good. Duarte's advice on data intensive slides? "Both [of Stephen Few's] books should be on your shelf along with everything Edward Tufte has written."
I have two Tufte books and they are virtually identical, I don't see myself buying his others (and they suffer from the same lack of relevance to corporate analysts). Disappointing.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
252 of 296 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Yet another designer's book, September 12, 2008
This review is from: slide:ology: The Art and Science of Creating Great Presentations (Paperback)
I have to rain on the parade of this book and Garr Reynold's book (and other ones).
The message is "I'm one of the best slide designers in the world (which is true) and I'm going to show you WHY."
The message should be "I'm one of the best slide designers in the world and I'm going to show you HOW."
You'll see plenty to interest you, but unless you're a full-fledged graphic designer you'll never recreate these slides. Imagine putting this book (and the Reynold's book) into a room with some of your worst slide creators, or even yourself. Would you see an improvement in their skills? I doubt it.
You might as well become a painter by reading books that have the world's greatest pictures in them. Even though there is explanatory text here it isn't enough to bridge the gap.
To see a book written for its audience, try the "Before and After" books by Jon McWade which deal with desktop publishing. Unfortunately John has not yet tackled slides, but you can see an page layout idea and make it yourself in minutes.
So, sorry about this, because both this and Reynold's book are "nice" books. The energy has gone into the book's design and production rather than the content. But that makes them coffee-table books, and unless you have a coffee table in your office I'd advise that you give both of them a miss.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
96 of 119 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Emperor's New Old Clothes, November 25, 2008
This review is from: slide:ology: The Art and Science of Creating Great Presentations (Paperback)
I had high hopes for this book. It looks very nice. It has the right nods to Tufte early on. But...
But the true content is very thin, includes a load of chart junk (the anti-Tufte - I guess the true cue is in the title, this is a PowerPoint book) and page after page of abstract diagrams demonstrating "flow" - much like the woeful second half of "Say it with Charts" which is about 50 pages of arrows.
Very very disappointing indeed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|