2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Worthless, September 12, 2011
This review is from: The truth about Toyota and TPS (Paperback)
I originally picked this up as my company is going through a transition to a Lean system, and I wanted a bit of a counterbalance to some of the more dogmatic cheerleaders. I was completely disappointed. This screed seems to be nothing more than a graduate student pontificating against "corporate greed" of the most succesful company he could find when it came time to pick a PhD topic.
Rampant spelling and grammar mistakes throughout the book show poor editing and occasionally extremely confused thought. Most of the analogies made to other industries demonstrates the limited nature of the authors experience in productive industry. Very few of the significant claims are backed by any data or even a suggestion that any real research was done.
The analogy to CPU design at Intel takes a single quote from a non-technical manager, misinterprets it, and then draws conclusions that are so obviously wrong that it completely derails his argument.
There are many examples of "original research" without the "research" bit. About the "5 Whys" system, he claims "most operators end up falling back to deduction without truly searching for the root causes". Really? "most"? As they say on wikipedia, "Citation Needed". After a completely unsupported paragraph about how the "5 Whys" system fails to examine root causes or solve anything, including such gems as "[the system results] in a total confusion about the problem root cause" (no citation, why would there need to be?), the concluding sentence is "Toyota accumulated and built this operators' knowledge of root causes into its equipment, processes and procedures which allowed it to gain a competitive advantage over other carmakers."
The claim that "most western companies that have adopted TPS have not been succesful"(paraphrased), is also completly unsupported, and left me wondering how you would define "adopted TPS", given the complexity of converting an entire system, even if you were attempting to prove the point.
For an explanation of why TPS isn't a silver bullet, NPRs radio show on the NUMMI plant was far more informative, particularly as they talked about the attempts to replicate its success at other GM facilities. For a sophomoric rant against a company, this book is a fine substitute for the Che T-shirt wearing undergrad at your local Starbucks.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Intersting and usefull, November 15, 2010
This review is from: The truth about Toyota and TPS (Paperback)
There are so many books written about Toyota and its TPS today, mainly presenting only positive and spectacular issues about the firm. Eichi Kobayashi has produced a highly intersting and usefull book, which should be red by all person using or teaching the lean approach.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
0 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An interesting book about Toyota and TPS!!, January 10, 2010
This review is from: The truth about Toyota and TPS (Paperback)
Somebody has to find a way to make the Toyota and TPS subject realistic and interesting and this book does that. It is easy to read and understand with no sophisticated and boring material such as charts and diagrams (except one or two) and is more up to date regarding Toyota success and failure. This is not the "standard" book about this topic. It is much better.
Joyce Akesson, author of Love's Thrilling Dimensions,
The Invitation and
Majnun Leyla: Poems about Passion
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No