Top critical review
11 people found this helpful
1.0 out of 5 starsFew hiccups, but works great. EDIT: AVOID
ByMatthew Lenhardon January 9, 2014
EDIT UPDATE: Changed from 4 stars to 1 stars - I loved my new MOCA network so much, I bought four more and hooked them up around the house. I've had these for about 6 months, and now all of them are failing. They are all dying, burning out, etc. They no longer connect to coaxial or ethernet, and even when reset, they do not work. Great while they lasted, but I'm not out >$200 and my network is dead. Thanks, Actiontec for your crummy merchandise.
ORIGINAL REVIEW: I recently moved and bought a nice, older house and wanted to set up a network. I didn't want to shell out for a full ethernet, I have an old house so I didn't even attempt powerline (plus the bad reviews) and so I decided to try wireless. I was displeased with the speeds I got, the poor connections, the lag, and the poor coverage in the house in certain corners. After reading and researching range extenders (and the terrible reviews), I decided to give MOCA a try - so glad I did!
I have Comcast and was worried about needing a filter, worried about splitters and the frequencies, etc. I spent hours on the phone with baffled Comcast employees and "technicians" who had no idea what I was talking about. I eventually gave up, bought them, and gave them a whirl.
Few hiccups (which I'll get into), but nothing life-altering. They pretty much worked from the get-go. Plugged them in, hooked up the coax, both lights turned green and I had 100mbps connection! I eventually pulled an old N-router from storage and used it as an access point on the other side of the house, attached via these handy moca kits. For those wondering, it was super easy: Give both routers the same broadcasting name and password - one (the main router) with a non-static IP that usually defaults to .1, gave the second router a static IP of .2 and VOILA - strong, fast wireless internet that reaches all corners of the house.
OK, onto the pros-cons:
Pros: -worked really well with Comcast. I didn't need a filter on my line, as my nearest neighbor is >100 feet away
-was essentially plug-and-play. For me, I didn't have any of the problems others have had. All lights were green and it was much more stable than powerline and much faster than wireless. For those that game, the lag is quite low. Not ethernet low, but sure works in a pinch.
Cons: -no matter what I did, if I had a splitter (even the one they gave me) put on before the MOCA adapter, it wouldn't work. I had to always run coax a bypass through to the cable box, rather than having both the modem AND a cable box from the same coax outlet. Not the end of the world, but I really had to rearrange where I was using them.
-If you place the MOCA adapter before your cable modem, occasionally if you have to reset, it won't recognize the IP address of the modem the first time. I've had to turn off and reset sometimes 5-10x before it would recognize. If I just plug the modem directly into the wall, it hooks up immediately. So despite these being "pass through", there has to be some sort of interference.
-cost. While cheaper than installing ethernet, it will still set you back several hundred $$ to have 3-4 rooms hooked up, and for some it may be an experiment as most people have no idea about the cable connections, splitters, etc in their homes. Also, keep this on price check. I just bought a twin pack for $89, and 3 days later, they are $119.
-No gigabit. Because they still use 10/100 protocol, despite being able to have 270mbps max, you can't ever use it due to the 10/100 bottleneck. Not sure why this was done, to be honest. Again, not a deal-breaker for me.
Overall, very pleased.