TL/DR: bloated article about other's people thoughts on the matter. Zero understanding of search-algos and popular culture in general. Ridiculous solutions. If you'd like to know more about bias in algorithms and modern tech, look into: "Weapons of Math Destruction" and "Technically Wrong", which were actually written by qualified professionals in the field.
OK. So, a book about search algorithms by a professor of African American Studies...
Next in this series is a book by a Michelin Star Chef on the censorship of overtly phallic garden variety edibles by algebraic "foodie" algorithms on social media: "Veggies of Erection: how Instagram and Pinterest are destroying green libido, and ten delicious ways to prepare them!"
Give me a break...
Seriously, I gave this one a chance but the book is a tease in the first half and a disappointment in the second.
The writing is obtuse, riddled with circular arguments, name dropping, unsubstantiated claims, and the use of other people's better arguments about the very thing you're supposed to be an expert about. Which is a shame because it is an important subject that deserves better treatment. Ms. Noble's arguments ultimately devolve into "trust me, I'm right because such-and-such wrote about it already and I agree!" Don't believe me?
"Recent research on Google by Siva Vaidhyanathan...who has written one of the most important books on Google to date, demonstrates its dominance over the information landscape and forms the basis of a central theme in this research."
And here again,
"Frank Pasquale, a professor of law at the University of Maryland, has also forewarned of the increasing levels of control that algorithms have over the many decisions made about us, from credit to dating options...."
and again,
"The political economic critique of Google by Elad Segev, a senior lecturer ... charges that we can no longer ignore the global dominance of Google and..."
and wait, there's more,
"Molly Niesen at the University of Illinois has written extensively on the loss of public accountability by federal agencies such as the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), which is a major contribution..."
Alright, I know some of you are going to say that it is ok to cite other people's work, but beyond her statements, no further exposition is offered. The whole thing is like this.
What's worse, It takes Ms. Noble roughly half the book to end her long intro about her plan of attack. Thirty-seven pages in she's still telling you:
"This work is addressing a gap in scholarship on how search works and what it biases, public trust in search, the relationship of search to information studies, and the ways in which African Americans, among others, are mediated and commodified in Google."
Can we get on with it?
Oh, and her solution for all this is a tad comical, if not heroically ironic:
“In my own imagination and in a project I am attempting to build, access to information on the web could be designed akin to a color picker tool or some other highly transparent interface, so that users could find nuanced shades of information and easily identify the borderlands between news and entertainment, entertainment and pornographers, or journalism and academic scholarship.”
Oh snap! Break out your crayons and stop your engineers Google, all you need is color! Please...
Ugh. If only the absence of color-blindness could be fixed with more color eh? Search results are not primarily the problem, lack of critical thinking skills is. Blocking misleading, inflammatory results for black-on-white crime cannot be the solution when there are people out there with racial anxieties worked to a frenzy that will keep looking until they find what matches their worldview.
If all this weren't sad enough, in a last-ditch effort to end on a strong note, she caps the book off with a piece about Yelp and its business model, but I thought we were talking about Google?
Cannot recommend.
Algorithms of Oppression: How Search Engines Reinforce Racism Illustrated Edition
by
Safiya Umoja Noble
(Author)
|
Safiya Umoja Noble
(Author)
Find all the books, read about the author, and more.
See search results for this author
|
ISBN-13:
978-1479837243
ISBN-10:
1479837245
Why is ISBN important?
ISBN
Scan an ISBN with your phone
Use the Amazon App to scan ISBNs and compare prices.
This bar-code number lets you verify that you're getting exactly the right version or edition of a book. The 13-digit and 10-digit formats both work.
Use the Amazon App to scan ISBNs and compare prices.
Add to book club
Loading your book clubs
There was a problem loading your book clubs. Please try again.
Not in a club?
Learn more
Join or create book clubs
Choose books together
Track your books
Bring your club to Amazon Book Clubs, start a new book club and invite your friends to join, or find a club that’s right for you for free.
In Stock.
More Buying Choices
Journey into Reading
Explore reading recommendations for children ages 6 - 12. See this week's recommendations.
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
-
Apple
-
Android
-
Windows Phone
-
Android
|
Download to your computer
|
Kindle Cloud Reader
|
Frequently bought together
Customers who viewed this item also viewed
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
What other items do customers buy after viewing this item?
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
Editorial Reviews
Review
"Rather than being a neutral arbiter that sorts content by quality, Noble argues that search engines are easily gamed in ways that reflect discriminatory practices. Even without malevolent actors, search engines may be perpetuating racist stereotypes." ― Chicago Tribune
"Nobles thesis is a new tune in the ever-louder chorus that, in light of the dominance of the big tech companies, is singing for 'protections and attention that work in service of the public'." ― The Financial Times
"[P]resents convincing evidence of the need for closer scrutiny and regulation of search engine[s].A thought-provoking, well-researched work." ― Library Journal
"Noble argues...that the web is ...a machine of oppression...[Her] central insight - that nothing about internet search and retrieval is political neutral - is made...through the accumulation of alarming and disturbing examples. [She] makes a compelling case that pervasive racism online inflames racist violence IRL." ― Los Angeles Review of Books
"A distressing account of algorithms run amok." ― Kirkus Reviews
"Algorithms of Oppressionis a wakeup call to bring awareness to the biases of the internet, and should motivate all concerned people to ask why those biases exist, and who they benefit." ― New York Journal of Books
"Noble offers a compelling look into the structure of digitized informationmost of it driven by advertising revenueand how it perpetuates racist assumptions and ideologies." ― Pacific Standard
"Noble makes a strong case that present technologies and search engines are not just imperfect, but they enact actual harm to people and communities." ― Popmatters.com
"50 Best Book of 2018 So Far, "There's been a growing swell of concern in the academic community about the stranglehold that commercial (for-profit) search engines have over access to information in our world. Safiya Umoja Noble builds on this body of work...to demonstrate that search engines, and in particular Google, are not simply imperfect machines, but systems designed by humans in ways that replicate the power structures of the western countries where they are built, complete with all the sexism and racism that are built into those structures." ― Popmatters.com
"Noble demolishes the popular assumption that Google is a values-free tool with no agenda...She astutely questions the wisdom of turning so much of our data and intellectual capital over to a corporate monopoly.Nobles study should prompt some soul-searching about our reliance on commercial search engines and about digital social equity." ― STARRED Booklist
"Nobles incisive work centers around the fact that, at present, Googles search engine promotes structural inequality through multiple examples and that this is not just a & design problem but an inherent political problem that has shaped the entirety of twentieth-century technology design. In addition to her illustrative examples and incisive criticism, Noble offers practicable policy solutions." ― Metascience
"In Algorithms of Oppression, [Noble] offers her readers a lens to discover, analyze, and critique the search engine algorithms that perpetuate stereotypes and racist beliefs[This] book will be of great interest to academic librarians who teach information literacy courses, as well as students and faculty in computer science, ethnic studies, gender studies, and mass communications." ― Choice
"A good read for anyone interested in how bias can be expressed by lines of code. Even those already familiar with the issues will find new insight in the connections and impact Noble outlines. The book is accessible even to those who are not well-versed in the technology of search engines." -- The International Journal of Information, Diversity, & Inclusion
"
"Often assumed by both developers and the general public to be value-neutral, the algorithmic structures through which human beings create, organize, and access content online are, Noble effectively argues, inescapably shaped by the logics of oppression that shape our interconnected lives … Algorithms provides a strong introduction, with concrete and replicable examples of algorithmic oppression, for those beginning to think critically about our internet-centric information ecosystem. For those already steeped in the rapidly growing literature of critical librarian and information studies, Algorithms will be a valuable addition to our corpus of texts that blend theory and practice, both documenting the problematic nature of where we are and the possibility of where we might arrive in future if we fight, collectively, to make it so." -- New England Archivists
"Algorithms of Oppression offers a sobering portrait of the impact of our reliance on quick, freely accessible searches. Foregrounding her discussion in the context of the technological mechanisms and decision‐makers that drive results, Noble forces the reader to confront the rarely discussed risks and long‐term costs associated with easy‐to‐access, corporate‐sponsored information." -- Teachers College Record
"All search results are not created equal. Through deft analyses of software, society, and superiority, Noble exposes both the motivations and mathematics that make a & technologically redlined internet. Read this book to understand how supposedly race neutral zeros and ones simply dont add up." -- Matthew W. Hughey,Author of White Bound: Nationalists, Antiracists, and the Shared Meanings of Race
"Safiya Noble has produced an outstanding book that raises clear alarms about the ways Google quietly shapes our lives, minds, and attitudes. Noble writes with urgency and clarity. This book is essential for anyone hoping to understand our current information ecosystem." -- Siva Vaidhyanathan,Author of The Googlization of Everything ― and Why We Should Worry
"Safiya Nobles compelling and accessible book is an impressive survey of the impact of search and other algorithms on our understandings of racial and gender identity. Her study raises crucial questions regarding the power and control of algorithms, and is essential reading for understanding the way media works in the contemporary moment." -- Sarah Banet-Weiser,Author of Authentic™: The Politics of Ambivalence in a Brand Culture
"Algorithms of Oppression shines a light not only on the way that new technologies both reaffirm hegemonies of the past and impose constraints on our futures, but also on how we ourselves are interpellated daily and voluntarily into these algorithmic processes." ― This Year’s Work in Critical and Cultural Theory
"Illustrates not only how the platforms and programmes we use in our daily life are created and built within a specific economic, racial, and gendered context, but that that context and those platforms enact and reinforce oppressive social relationships as we use them." ― Archifacts
"Nobles thesis is a new tune in the ever-louder chorus that, in light of the dominance of the big tech companies, is singing for 'protections and attention that work in service of the public'." ― The Financial Times
"[P]resents convincing evidence of the need for closer scrutiny and regulation of search engine[s].A thought-provoking, well-researched work." ― Library Journal
"Noble argues...that the web is ...a machine of oppression...[Her] central insight - that nothing about internet search and retrieval is political neutral - is made...through the accumulation of alarming and disturbing examples. [She] makes a compelling case that pervasive racism online inflames racist violence IRL." ― Los Angeles Review of Books
"A distressing account of algorithms run amok." ― Kirkus Reviews
"Algorithms of Oppressionis a wakeup call to bring awareness to the biases of the internet, and should motivate all concerned people to ask why those biases exist, and who they benefit." ― New York Journal of Books
"Noble offers a compelling look into the structure of digitized informationmost of it driven by advertising revenueand how it perpetuates racist assumptions and ideologies." ― Pacific Standard
"Noble makes a strong case that present technologies and search engines are not just imperfect, but they enact actual harm to people and communities." ― Popmatters.com
"50 Best Book of 2018 So Far, "There's been a growing swell of concern in the academic community about the stranglehold that commercial (for-profit) search engines have over access to information in our world. Safiya Umoja Noble builds on this body of work...to demonstrate that search engines, and in particular Google, are not simply imperfect machines, but systems designed by humans in ways that replicate the power structures of the western countries where they are built, complete with all the sexism and racism that are built into those structures." ― Popmatters.com
"Noble demolishes the popular assumption that Google is a values-free tool with no agenda...She astutely questions the wisdom of turning so much of our data and intellectual capital over to a corporate monopoly.Nobles study should prompt some soul-searching about our reliance on commercial search engines and about digital social equity." ― STARRED Booklist
"Nobles incisive work centers around the fact that, at present, Googles search engine promotes structural inequality through multiple examples and that this is not just a & design problem but an inherent political problem that has shaped the entirety of twentieth-century technology design. In addition to her illustrative examples and incisive criticism, Noble offers practicable policy solutions." ― Metascience
"In Algorithms of Oppression, [Noble] offers her readers a lens to discover, analyze, and critique the search engine algorithms that perpetuate stereotypes and racist beliefs[This] book will be of great interest to academic librarians who teach information literacy courses, as well as students and faculty in computer science, ethnic studies, gender studies, and mass communications." ― Choice
"A good read for anyone interested in how bias can be expressed by lines of code. Even those already familiar with the issues will find new insight in the connections and impact Noble outlines. The book is accessible even to those who are not well-versed in the technology of search engines." -- The International Journal of Information, Diversity, & Inclusion
"
Algorithms of Oppression succeeds as a critical intervention, one with a clear commitment to engaged scholarship that should lead to policy changes as well as changes in a field too white, American and male. For readers of this journal, the book is a powerful example of the vital contributions of Black Feminist
Technology Studies... Noble demonstrates that engaged, intersectional and accessible writing can and indeed does make a difference.
"Often assumed by both developers and the general public to be value-neutral, the algorithmic structures through which human beings create, organize, and access content online are, Noble effectively argues, inescapably shaped by the logics of oppression that shape our interconnected lives … Algorithms provides a strong introduction, with concrete and replicable examples of algorithmic oppression, for those beginning to think critically about our internet-centric information ecosystem. For those already steeped in the rapidly growing literature of critical librarian and information studies, Algorithms will be a valuable addition to our corpus of texts that blend theory and practice, both documenting the problematic nature of where we are and the possibility of where we might arrive in future if we fight, collectively, to make it so." -- New England Archivists
"Algorithms of Oppression offers a sobering portrait of the impact of our reliance on quick, freely accessible searches. Foregrounding her discussion in the context of the technological mechanisms and decision‐makers that drive results, Noble forces the reader to confront the rarely discussed risks and long‐term costs associated with easy‐to‐access, corporate‐sponsored information." -- Teachers College Record
"All search results are not created equal. Through deft analyses of software, society, and superiority, Noble exposes both the motivations and mathematics that make a & technologically redlined internet. Read this book to understand how supposedly race neutral zeros and ones simply dont add up." -- Matthew W. Hughey,Author of White Bound: Nationalists, Antiracists, and the Shared Meanings of Race
"Safiya Noble has produced an outstanding book that raises clear alarms about the ways Google quietly shapes our lives, minds, and attitudes. Noble writes with urgency and clarity. This book is essential for anyone hoping to understand our current information ecosystem." -- Siva Vaidhyanathan,Author of The Googlization of Everything ― and Why We Should Worry
"Safiya Nobles compelling and accessible book is an impressive survey of the impact of search and other algorithms on our understandings of racial and gender identity. Her study raises crucial questions regarding the power and control of algorithms, and is essential reading for understanding the way media works in the contemporary moment." -- Sarah Banet-Weiser,Author of Authentic™: The Politics of Ambivalence in a Brand Culture
"Algorithms of Oppression shines a light not only on the way that new technologies both reaffirm hegemonies of the past and impose constraints on our futures, but also on how we ourselves are interpellated daily and voluntarily into these algorithmic processes." ― This Year’s Work in Critical and Cultural Theory
"Illustrates not only how the platforms and programmes we use in our daily life are created and built within a specific economic, racial, and gendered context, but that that context and those platforms enact and reinforce oppressive social relationships as we use them." ― Archifacts
About the Author
Safiya Umoja Noble is an Associate Professor at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) in the Department of Information Studies where she serves as the Co-Director of the UCLA Center for Critical Internet Inquiry. She is the co-editor of two books, The Intersectional Internet: Race, Sex, Culture and Class Online and Emotions, Technology & Design.
Start reading Algorithms of Oppression on your Kindle in under a minute.
Don't have a Kindle? Get your Kindle here, or download a FREE Kindle Reading App.
Don't have a Kindle? Get your Kindle here, or download a FREE Kindle Reading App.
Product details
- Publisher : NYU Press; Illustrated edition (February 20, 2018)
- Language : English
- Paperback : 256 pages
- ISBN-10 : 1479837245
- ISBN-13 : 978-1479837243
- Item Weight : 13.6 ounces
- Dimensions : 6 x 0.56 x 9 inches
-
Best Sellers Rank:
#40,326 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
- #2 in Gender Studies (Books)
- #5 in Electric Machinery & Motors
- #8 in Digital Design (Books)
- Customer Reviews:
Customer reviews
4.7 out of 5 stars
4.7 out of 5
376 global ratings
How are ratings calculated?
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzes reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Top reviews
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
Reviewed in the United States on February 19, 2019
Verified Purchase
124 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Reviewed in the United States on March 9, 2019
Verified Purchase
Thank you to Dr. Noble for this incredible contribution to the body of work serving as a permanent record of resistance to algorithmic rearticulations of eugenics. Thank you for centering critical race theory (CRT) as the epistemic lens through which we must evaluate the social impact of predictive analytics.
There is sections that at first glance feel *jargon laden*, but a patient reader will be rewarded with rich insights brought in by the information/library science expertise. We’re in an era where the Google color palette is immediately recognizable on the cover but few people pause to consider the implications of our communal knowledge being processed and delivered by the multi billion dollar company that’s far from politically or ideologically neutral.
She does a good job forcing us to pause and consider why Google Search initially generated images of Gorrilas when ‘Black Woman’ was entered as a keyword. This error and similar cases have since been programmatically removed from the search engine but the more global questions-how did we transition our communal knowledge and it’s curation to neoliberal industry absent public comment, how do we intervene in the epistemic injustice wrought by systems embedded in the public conscious as beacons of progress and innovation-remain.
Algorithms of Oppression is a critical read for anyone tryna ‘Get Out!’ #JordanPeele style from the twin rise of the Trump regime and neoliberal technocracy. My only critique is the book could have benefitted from some stronger editing to elicit clearer synthesis of some of Noble’s unique insights specifically grounded in information science. The outrageous racism revealed in algorithmic outputs takes center stage and maybe rightly so, but there are points she makes along the way, that are being neglected by other scholars in the field that I would have like to seen greater focus on and more explicitly stated. I imagine it’s tough for brilliant women of color in tech to find editors that get CRT and the intersection of tech and humanities within the demographics of the American publishing world. Ultimately, the strength of the research goes along way to compensate for those shortcomings. I’m so curious to see what she will write next, the exhausting impotence of the agnostic left, weary soldiers propping up the failed project of “fairness” are not ready for this scholar’s revitalization of liberation theory post digital turn.
There is sections that at first glance feel *jargon laden*, but a patient reader will be rewarded with rich insights brought in by the information/library science expertise. We’re in an era where the Google color palette is immediately recognizable on the cover but few people pause to consider the implications of our communal knowledge being processed and delivered by the multi billion dollar company that’s far from politically or ideologically neutral.
She does a good job forcing us to pause and consider why Google Search initially generated images of Gorrilas when ‘Black Woman’ was entered as a keyword. This error and similar cases have since been programmatically removed from the search engine but the more global questions-how did we transition our communal knowledge and it’s curation to neoliberal industry absent public comment, how do we intervene in the epistemic injustice wrought by systems embedded in the public conscious as beacons of progress and innovation-remain.
Algorithms of Oppression is a critical read for anyone tryna ‘Get Out!’ #JordanPeele style from the twin rise of the Trump regime and neoliberal technocracy. My only critique is the book could have benefitted from some stronger editing to elicit clearer synthesis of some of Noble’s unique insights specifically grounded in information science. The outrageous racism revealed in algorithmic outputs takes center stage and maybe rightly so, but there are points she makes along the way, that are being neglected by other scholars in the field that I would have like to seen greater focus on and more explicitly stated. I imagine it’s tough for brilliant women of color in tech to find editors that get CRT and the intersection of tech and humanities within the demographics of the American publishing world. Ultimately, the strength of the research goes along way to compensate for those shortcomings. I’m so curious to see what she will write next, the exhausting impotence of the agnostic left, weary soldiers propping up the failed project of “fairness” are not ready for this scholar’s revitalization of liberation theory post digital turn.
31 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Reviewed in the United States on March 7, 2019
Verified Purchase
I refer to google a commercial search engine more than I visit library so for this commercial search engine to direct me to degrading porn sites when I enter search terms associated with "black girls" is teaching me how to view a population I belong to. As the #MeToo movement, laws are being passed the production and spread of unconsensual pornographic content at the state level. This book should be read by anyone who wants to understand the online victimization of black women and girls. This should be required reading for high school and undergraduate students
22 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Reviewed in the United States on March 9, 2018
Verified Purchase
I hope Google and Yahoo's executive teams take notice of this brilliantly written book by Dr. Safiya Umoja Noble. I appreciate her points that many times our internet searches are influenced by algorithms created by humans who potentially bring their gender and racial biases and in some cases racism into their mathematical outputs. I enjoyed this book and will recommend it to my colleagues.
26 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Reviewed in the United States on April 16, 2018
Verified Purchase
An important text for anyone struggling to make sense of the troubling equity issues within the technology industry and platforms. I highly recommend Algorithms of Oppression.
18 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Top reviews from other countries
Bennett Gaverne
5.0 out of 5 stars
Book of genius
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on November 22, 2020Verified Purchase
This is undoubtedly a book of genius. We need to take care folks as we are the cusp of a major change that dictates who shall actually enjoy the fruits of the 21st century. This is one of the most important books of the 21st century.
One person found this helpful
Report abuse
Henny
5.0 out of 5 stars
An eye opener
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on November 19, 2020Verified Purchase
This is book is a great collection to my library. It is a great read for awareness.
One person found this helpful
Report abuse
Cliente Kindle
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excelente
Reviewed in Brazil on January 11, 2021Verified Purchase
Excelente livro
Cheguei a ele graças a recomendação de uma professora incrível que tive de Comunicação digital, cada dia tenho mais interesse pelo tema e penso que apesar de novo, esse livro já é referência no tema.
Trabalho necessário, potente e cuidadoso, que aponta como a falta de regulação, falta de pessoas negras no processo de construção dos algoritmos, podem trazer danos quase irreparáveis para a sociedade.
Recomendo o livro para todo mundo que usa, gosta de internet e mídias sociais no dia dia, seja para o lazer, estudo ou trabalho.
Cheguei a ele graças a recomendação de uma professora incrível que tive de Comunicação digital, cada dia tenho mais interesse pelo tema e penso que apesar de novo, esse livro já é referência no tema.
Trabalho necessário, potente e cuidadoso, que aponta como a falta de regulação, falta de pessoas negras no processo de construção dos algoritmos, podem trazer danos quase irreparáveis para a sociedade.
Recomendo o livro para todo mundo que usa, gosta de internet e mídias sociais no dia dia, seja para o lazer, estudo ou trabalho.
Kindle Customer
5.0 out of 5 stars
Mandatory Reading for Tech Enthusiasts or Professionals
Reviewed in Canada on September 30, 2018Verified Purchase
This book answers the question of: "Is Google Racist"? The answer is a well-reasoned and researched yes from a well-regarded and peer-reviewed professor at UCLA. Highly recommend if you have many friends in the tech sector who think their work is bias-free or if you work there yourself and want to more holistically understand the impact of search engines on marginalized communities.
3 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Samantha
5.0 out of 5 stars
Encourages us to think more critically about the information we get from the web
Reviewed in Germany on October 19, 2020Verified Purchase
This is an evidence-based book plus more on how search engines reinforce racism, stereotypes, and the negative consequences. Noble touches on the ranking system of Google and warns us about the dangers of prioritizing commercial interest over providing information that best serves the interest of all. Because we live in a world where there is an unequal balance of power certain populist views and values can be promoted on such platforms. Therefore, motivating the need for public policy to intervene in order to protect the public especially marginalized communities.
Noble also provides a black feminist perspective as she sheds spotlight on the history of oppression of Black women and how the negative stereotypes came about and how this image of black women is reinforced by search engines. This is part of the problem why the dismantling of unconscious bias etc is very difficult. We cannot achieve equality if different/diverse social context is left out in technology design.
This book really gives you a lot to think about and I am encouraged to learn more about bias in AI from a social and humanitarian perspective.
Noble also provides a black feminist perspective as she sheds spotlight on the history of oppression of Black women and how the negative stereotypes came about and how this image of black women is reinforced by search engines. This is part of the problem why the dismantling of unconscious bias etc is very difficult. We cannot achieve equality if different/diverse social context is left out in technology design.
This book really gives you a lot to think about and I am encouraged to learn more about bias in AI from a social and humanitarian perspective.
Customers who bought this item also bought
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
Pages with related products.
See and discover other items: digital design books, computer science and engineering books








