- Audible Audio Edition
- Listening Length: 13 hours and 16 minutes
- Program Type: Audiobook
- Version: Unabridged
- Publisher: Tantor Audio
- Audible.com Release Date: April 17, 2012
- Whispersync for Voice: Ready
- Language: English
- ASIN: B007V5SZMM
- Amazon Best Sellers Rank:
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
Bad Religion: How We Became a Nation of Heretics Audiobook – Unabridged
|New from||Used from|
|Free with your Audible trial|
Customers who bought this item also bought
Would you like to tell us about a lower price?
Top customer reviews
As is often the case with adult converts to Catholicism, Douthat carries that particular hypervigilance regarding disintegration of something he has worked long and hard to attain, in this case a tradition of faith that brings order out of secular chaos. He is not a theocrat, but he does believe that some sixty years ago the major Christian Churches provided the backbone for a kind of good order and reform. The term "bad religion" used here is less a criticism of personal practice as it is a denunciation of polluted theology and religious philosophy that the author believes has wounded the churches since then.
Douthat is a better journalist than he is historian. His designation of post-1945 American religion as a kind of high water mark rings of Adam and Eve in pre-serpent paradise; the Times' own review [April 18, 2012] calls the author to task over this arbitrary designation. This is a serious methodological flaw, because all of the frenetic religious activism of 1950-2000, most notably Vatican II [1962-65], is interpreted as a frivolous, dangerous dissipation of moral authority.
Douthat is not the first observer to make this mistake, but as a journalist he is still on the hook for it. The moral horrors of Nazism and the death camps had originated in ostensibly Christian countries. That the Tridentine brand of Catholicism was toothless to prevent such sin was evident to thoughtful Catholics around the world. It was particularly evident to Angelo Roncalli, Papal Nuncio to Turkey and later to occupied France, greatly respected for his work on behalf of Jews. Roncalli was never the jolly, perhaps reckless, John XXIII that many would like to make him, perhaps even the author.
Instead, John XXIII was the honest reformer who blessed the efforts of Catholics [and all Christians, to whom the Council Documents are addressed] to make things right. We forget that barely days after the Council began, the Cuban Missile Crisis threatened global annihilation. The author's absence of any sense of gravitas as the motivation of reform is lost, and it is hard for me to understand how any treatment of Christianity, a universal church, can be as parochial or American-centered as this work.
That Catholicism and its sister churches fumbled the reform through the balance of the twentieth century is beyond contestation. But the reasons are much more complex than Douthat would have us believe; he wastes considerable ink on Bishop James Pike, of all people, as an errant pied piper of the late 1960's. Douthat is on safer ground in discussing Harvey Cox and "The Secular City," for religious liberals of the time labored mightily to harmonize the Christian Church with "modern man," a notoriously empty concept.
In Douthat's paradigm, a half century of experimentation with mixed results at best left Roman Catholics and Evangelicals still standing as the best hopes for a fresh start in the new millennium. But the sex abuse scandals of 2002 effectively sidelined American Catholicism, and the author turns a critical eye toward Evangelicals. Here Douthat is at his very best in his analysis of the Religious Right. Once something of the apocalyptic conscience of America, the Evangelical movement came to occupy the ground held by Billy Graham in Eisenhower's time as America's house religion. Theologically and strategically this was accomplished in two ways:  a merger of American exceptionalism with the Biblical symbol of the "City on the Hill;" and  an uncritical embrace of capitalism in a pragmatic theological message that "God wants you to be rich."
In his chapter, "The City on the Hill," the author dismantles possibly the most pernicious form of "bad religion," that the success of God and the success of America are biblically and cosmically intertwined. I was concerned when he began this chapter with Glenn Beck, the Religious Right's contemporary answer to the long deceased Bishop Pike, both essentially media creations. But Beck simply serves up for the reader the heretical equation of America=the New Israel. Douthat observes that American presidents themselves--Washington, Lincoln, even Coolidge--labored to discourage such thinking. Their wisdom, however, was superseded by Woodrow Wilson [257ff], whose theologically driven political ideology of national righteousness begot a century of what amounts to international US crusading and buttressed military adventures as recently as the presidencies of George W. Bush and Barack Obama.
In his chapter "Pray and Grow Rich" Douthat scorns the theology of economics blessings preachers such as Joel Osteen. He illustrates the irony that the message of such cloth worn preaching appeals less to the rich themselves and more to those who wish to be affluent. He marvels that at the height of the Recession, March 2009, Osteen sold out Yankee Stadium. For the author such theology combines manipulation and gullibility.
Having thus unburdened himself, Douthat is somewhat confused about what to do next. [Perhaps he now has more sympathy for the well intentioned reformers of the Vatican II era.] I think it is fair to say that the author would apply Gresham's Law to contemporary religious thought: disposing of bad coinage, the good currency of traditional faith and values might have renewed opportunity to provide an ecumenical renewal of the personal heart and the communities of Christian faith.
Ross Douthat's Bad Religion: How We Became a Nation of Heretics is a triumph. It describes in great detail how the center of American cultural and political life was pulled apart by the divisiveness of the Vietnam War, the sexual 'revolution,' and a weakening of orthodox Christian practice and belief. Douthat, the youngest conservative voice on the editorial staff at the New York Times, is a convert to Catholicism.
The book is broad. It has much to say about the intellectual antecedents of what Douthat calls accomodationism, the efforts to make Christianity fit in with American culture. He looks too at the strengths and limitations of the resistance to secularization, for example in Fr. Richard John Neuhaus' First Things journal and the attempt to bring prolife Evangelicals and Catholics together.
What I admire about this book is the insights into the necessity of maintaining the tension of Gospel messages. Reading the chapter 'Lost in the Gospels' is most eye-opening. Douthat examines the long history of struggles with the temptation to resolve the disquieting and unsettling messages of the Gospel. I've seen evidence of succumbing to this temptation. Some Facebook pages announce unabashedly that 'Jesus was a socialist.' Other people seem to think Jesus is that that big ATM in the sky, or maybe just the best fitness guru ever. There is much in Mr. Douthat's book for social justice Catholics to think about. There is also much for free market advocates like me to reflect on. The passages on the prosperity gospel delusion are very helpful. There's a world of difference between approaching Jesus as life coach slash stock broker, and worshiping Him as the Lord of History and Savior of All Mankind. In an age very adept at diminishing Christ to the status of any other Facebook 'friend," Douthat's book is perhaps a call to anchor faith in scripture, dogma, ritual, and community.
Douthat offers four touchstones for a renewal of Christianity in America. It is a hope, not a blueprint. 1.) There's a post modern opportunity for Christianity to be political without being partisan. There's no such thing as a political 'home' for orthodox Christians. 2.) Renewed Christianity needs to be ecumenical and confessional. Avoid the 'deeds not creeds' copout. 3.) Renewal of faith needs to be both moralistic and holistic. Yes, affirm the traditional teachings on human sexuality, but do not ignore the extraordinary loneliness that characterizes our age. 4.) A renewed Christianity needs to be oriented toward sanctity and beauty. Douthat expresses this effectively with the words of Joseph Ratzinger, just before Ratzinger became Pope Benedict XVI: "The only really effective apologia for Christianity comes down to two arguments, namely, the saints the Church has produced and the art which has grown in her womb."
The takeaway of this book for me is to be vigilant and humble. Don't cut ecclesiastical corners. The passion for social justice among my fellow Catholics is not without merit, and is not necessarily a condemnation of supply and demand, or at least shouldn't be. Confront the challenges of the Gospels. Reflect on them. Live them. Avoid the temptation to remake Jesus in my own image and likeness. It is Jesus who chose me, not me who chose Him. He doesn't need to come to me; I need to come to Him.
Reviewer: Acathanus Education President, Stephen Haessler
Douthat sometimes has a tough style to get a clear understanding of where he is going. That is a hindrance to getting through the book a little faster. It isn't that he can't write a clear sentence, but the editing fails to take out helper-skelter changes in chronology, quotation and subject, especially in the first four chapters.
I don't think the Old Testament was mentioned once in the entire book. Maybe that is an overstatement, but "core" Christianity includes both old and new. Was the lack of that development in the book because the changes in religion ignored the Old Testament? Maybe so. If so, it would have been good to say so, and if possible, why.
That said, if you want to relive or understand a lot of the religious culture of the sixties and seventies, you will find a good slice of it here. I think the intersection of the religious changes and political changes come off weakly though.
Most recent customer reviews
Look for similar items by category
- Books > Christian Books & Bibles > Churches & Church Leadership > Church History
- Books > Christian Books & Bibles > History
- Books > History > World > Religious > Christianity
- Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Politics & Government > Political Science
- Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Politics & Government > United States
- Books > Religion & Spirituality > Religious Studies > Sociology