I’ve read a number of books concerning the operations on Saipan during the Pacific War with the Japanese. Some of the books were good, some not so good and some I personally would classify as semi-wretched. One thing all these books, including the one by Francis A. O’Brien being reviewed here is that I learned from each and every one of them.
O’Brien’s main premise in this work is the defense of the 27th Infantry Division and the long standing battle of Smith verses Smith. I personally have no dog in this particular fight. I am retired military; retired Air Force and was never a member of the Army or Marine Corps. I simply enjoy reading military history.
There were parts of this work I enjoyed and other parts I did not. The first half of the book was bogged down into minute details of which I normally enjoy but felt the details here were not handled all that well from a literary and historian’s point of view.
I did find the enter service infighting before and after the battle of some interest though as it is something to consider when reading any military history. Who was right and who was wrong will never, in my opinion, be absolutely decided. Old wounds run deep and even though all or most participants in the battle are no longer with us, we find we still have relatives and various service members who have definite opinions...O’Brian was one of these and the reader must take this into consideration.
I will say that the battle itself was quite well covered; better than in some of the other books I have read but most of this material was taken from after action reports and interpreted by the author.
Overall all I learned much from this work but have read better accounts. I suppose the one primary thing I took from reading this work is that it reinforced my long held belief that if you study any history at all you should read as many accounts and opinions as possible and make up your own mind.
Other Sellers on Amazon
$15.13
+ $3.99 shipping
+ $3.99 shipping
Sold by:
KnowledgePond
Sold by:
KnowledgePond
(8107 ratings)
88% positive over last 12 months
88% positive over last 12 months
Only 1 left in stock - order soon.
Shipping rates
and
Return policy
$16.09
+ $3.99 shipping
+ $3.99 shipping
Sold by:
Ambis Enterprises
Sold by:
Ambis Enterprises
(17176 ratings)
82% positive over last 12 months
82% positive over last 12 months
Only 10 left in stock - order soon.
Shipping rates
and
Return policy
Add to book club
Loading your book clubs
There was a problem loading your book clubs. Please try again.
Not in a club?
Learn more
Join or create book clubs
Choose books together
Track your books
Bring your club to Amazon Book Clubs, start a new book club and invite your friends to join, or find a club that’s right for you for free.
Flip to back
Flip to front
Follow the Author
Something went wrong. Please try your request again later.
OK
Battling for Saipan Paperback – February 4, 2003
by
Francis A. O'Brien
(Author)
|
Price
|
New from | Used from |
-
Print length400 pages
-
LanguageEnglish
-
Publication dateFebruary 4, 2003
-
Dimensions5.5 x 0.8 x 8.5 inches
-
ISBN-100891418040
-
ISBN-13978-0891418047
New releases
Explore popular titles in every genre and find something you love. See more
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
-
Apple
-
Android
-
Windows Phone
-
Android
|
Download to your computer
|
Kindle Cloud Reader
|
Frequently bought together
Customers who viewed this item also viewed
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
Breaching the Marianas: The Battle for Saipan (Marines in World War II Commemorative Series)Captain John C. Chapin, USMCR (Ret.)Paperback
Customers also viewed these products
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
Editorial Reviews
Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved.
1 Prelude to World War II
Following Germany’s attack on Poland on September 1, 1939, the U.S. War Department accelerated the training of the National Guard. Annual weekly drills increased from forty-eight to sixty per year, and summer field training was increased from fifteen to twenty-two days. President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed an executive order authorizing an increase in the size of the army. The cycle of field maneuvers was changed so that in the summer of 1940, all of the available army divisions in the First Army area (both regular and National Guard) were able to participate in the maneuvers held at De Kalb Junction, New York (near the Canadian border). One of the first obvious facts observed by the commanders of the participating units was that the National Guard units, in particular, were seriously understrength. The 27th Infantry Division, for example, had only 10,414 personnel, about one-half of the 22,000 authorized personnel. It was clear that these divisions had to be bulked up to full strength before they could become effective forces in the new war that had exploded in Europe.
Under these circumstances, the National Gusrd’s summer camp of 1940 was given high priority. The war in Europe was almost a year old, and it was inevitable that the United States would soon become involved. Large-scale maneuvers and war games between regular army and National Guard units from New York and other states took place August 13–14, 1940. More than 100,000 troops participated, including a mechanized brigade of tanks from Fort Knox, Kentucky, and more than 600 planes of all kinds. It was clear to everyone that something big was up.
• • •
On August 23, 1940, the day before summer training at De Kalb Junction ended, the men were reviewed by President Roosevelt. The 105th Infantry (known as the “Apple-knocker” Regiment) was lined up along the roadway as the president and his entourage sped by in open vehicles. It was brutally hot, and the men were passing out by the score. It was clear to everyone, and certainly the Apple-knockers, that they would shortly be inducted into federal service and would soon be at war.
On September 16, 1940, President Roosevelt signed the Selective Service and Training Act, the first peacetime conscription law in U.S. history, a tacit confirmation that the country would soon be involved in the brutal war in Europe. The act required that all men aged twenty-one to thirty-five years register and, if selected, serve for a training and service period of twelve consecutive months and then serve in one of the reserve forces for ten years or until age forty-five. Moreover, under the act, if Congress declared a national emergency, the president could extend the period of service indefinitely. One month after the signing of the bill, 16 million men were registered for military service. The “selectees,” as they became known, would augment the understrength National Guard divisions about to be mobilized.
On September 25, 1940, the mobilization order was signed inducting the 27th Division into federal service beginning October 15, 1940, for one year of active duty. Under the terms of the mobilization order, all men with dependents were authorized to request honorable discharges. On October 1, 1940, those men in the 105th Infantry Regiment who were not eligible for dependency discharges received notices from their company commanders. They were directed to report to their respective armories in their local communities on October 15 at 0800 for induction. The “Apple-knockers” were going back into active service.
Since World War I, there had been several changes in the structure of the 27th Infantry Division, many of which were significant. The 107th Infantry Regiment (formerly the 7th New York of Civil War fame) was transferred out of the division and redesignated the 207th Coast Artillery. To replace the 107th, the 165th Infantry Regiment (formerly “the Fighting 69th” New York) famous from Civil War and World War I, was assigned to the division. The 165th and the 108th Infantry Regiment from the Syracuse area of New York formed the 54th Infantry Brigade.
In September 1940, the 106th Infantry Regiment from Brooklyn, New York, was redesignated the 186th Field Artillery Regiment and was transferred out. Its place in the 53d Infantry Brigade was taken by the 10th New York Infantry from Albany, Utica, and other New York communities. In November 1940, the 10th New York was designated the 106th Infantry and became known as the “Knickerbocker” Regiment. The Apple-knockers, which had served with the 27th during World War I, joined the Knickerbockers to form the 53d Brigade.
For the 105th Infantry, this was the fourth time in less than one hundred years that the regiment, or one of its predecessor units, had been called into active duty to serve the United States. One of the oldest military organizations in the country, the 105th’s predecessor militia units served in the French and Indian War during the 1750s, the Revolutionary War in the 1770s, and the War of 1812. The New York State Militiamen particularly distinguished themselves at the Battle of Saratoga, where the British were forced to surrender in September 1777. One of the 105th’s core units, Company A, was formed as the Troy Citizen’s Corps by the New York state legislature on September 23, 1835. During the American Civil War, this unit served as Company A of the 2d New York Volunteers for two years, from April 1861 to April 1863, and participated in numerous battles throughout the state of Virginia. Company A existed as a separate unit until the late 1870s when it was incorporated into the New York National Guard.
The National Guard in the northeastern part of New York had its origins in the late 1870s and 1880s when twelve separate companies of militia were formed in a number of upstate New York communities and organized as the 2d New York Infantry Regiment. This unit was called into active service during the Spanish-American War in 1898 and the Mexican border war in 1916. On July 12, 1917, shortly after the United States declared war on Germany, Pres. Woodrow Wilson called the entire National Guard into federal service. The 2d New York then became a part of the newly designated 27th Infantry Division, also known as the New York Division. On October 1, 1917, the 2d New York was redesignated the 105th Infantry Regiment and was augmented by approximately 1,500 officers and enlisted men from the 12th and 71st Infantry Regiments of the New York National Guard. It served with distinction in France and Belgium and participated in the successful assault on the Hindenberg line. It was mustered out of federal service on April 1, 1919, after precisely two years and seven days of service, and after demobilization, reverted to National Guard status and once again became the 2d Regiment, New York National Guard.
During the period between the notice of induction and the actual induction, an extensive reorganization took place. The division needed to be brought up to war strength as soon as possible, with some 7,000 men needed immediately. Details were sent to Fort Dix, New Jersey; Camp Upton, New York; and Fort Niagara, New York to begin the process of moving recruits from reception centers to Fort McClellan, an abandoned military reservation near Anniston, Alabama. The new recruits were expected to begin arriving in January 1941. On October 9, 1940, approximately six weeks after completion of the De Kalb maneuvers, Lt. Gen. Hugh Drum, in command of the II Army Corps, ordered the 27th Division to concentrate at Fort McClellan for field training. Major General William N. Haskell, commander of the 27th Division since 1926, established a regiment to facilitate initial combat training of the recruits. After completing their training, these men would be added to the four infantry regiments—105th, 106th, 108th, and 165th—already at Fort McClellan.
Meanwhile, on October 9, 1940, plans for rail and motor movements of the 105th Infantry were discussed at a meeting of the commanders and staff at the Troy Armory. The plans called for the main body of troops to leave by train for Fort McClellan on October 23, 1940, a trip of more than 1,100 miles. One train of twenty cars would carry units of the 1st Battalion, 105th Infantry, from Troy, Cohoes, and Hoosick Falls. A second would originate at Malone, New York, and pick up the 3d Battalion along the Delaware and Hudson Railroad Line. A third train would move from Schenectady, New York, with Companies E, F, and H of the 2d Battalion; G Company of the 2d Battalion would be picked up at Amsterdam. All trains were scheduled to arrive at Anniston no later than October 25.
Following Germany’s attack on Poland on September 1, 1939, the U.S. War Department accelerated the training of the National Guard. Annual weekly drills increased from forty-eight to sixty per year, and summer field training was increased from fifteen to twenty-two days. President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed an executive order authorizing an increase in the size of the army. The cycle of field maneuvers was changed so that in the summer of 1940, all of the available army divisions in the First Army area (both regular and National Guard) were able to participate in the maneuvers held at De Kalb Junction, New York (near the Canadian border). One of the first obvious facts observed by the commanders of the participating units was that the National Guard units, in particular, were seriously understrength. The 27th Infantry Division, for example, had only 10,414 personnel, about one-half of the 22,000 authorized personnel. It was clear that these divisions had to be bulked up to full strength before they could become effective forces in the new war that had exploded in Europe.
Under these circumstances, the National Gusrd’s summer camp of 1940 was given high priority. The war in Europe was almost a year old, and it was inevitable that the United States would soon become involved. Large-scale maneuvers and war games between regular army and National Guard units from New York and other states took place August 13–14, 1940. More than 100,000 troops participated, including a mechanized brigade of tanks from Fort Knox, Kentucky, and more than 600 planes of all kinds. It was clear to everyone that something big was up.
• • •
On August 23, 1940, the day before summer training at De Kalb Junction ended, the men were reviewed by President Roosevelt. The 105th Infantry (known as the “Apple-knocker” Regiment) was lined up along the roadway as the president and his entourage sped by in open vehicles. It was brutally hot, and the men were passing out by the score. It was clear to everyone, and certainly the Apple-knockers, that they would shortly be inducted into federal service and would soon be at war.
On September 16, 1940, President Roosevelt signed the Selective Service and Training Act, the first peacetime conscription law in U.S. history, a tacit confirmation that the country would soon be involved in the brutal war in Europe. The act required that all men aged twenty-one to thirty-five years register and, if selected, serve for a training and service period of twelve consecutive months and then serve in one of the reserve forces for ten years or until age forty-five. Moreover, under the act, if Congress declared a national emergency, the president could extend the period of service indefinitely. One month after the signing of the bill, 16 million men were registered for military service. The “selectees,” as they became known, would augment the understrength National Guard divisions about to be mobilized.
On September 25, 1940, the mobilization order was signed inducting the 27th Division into federal service beginning October 15, 1940, for one year of active duty. Under the terms of the mobilization order, all men with dependents were authorized to request honorable discharges. On October 1, 1940, those men in the 105th Infantry Regiment who were not eligible for dependency discharges received notices from their company commanders. They were directed to report to their respective armories in their local communities on October 15 at 0800 for induction. The “Apple-knockers” were going back into active service.
Since World War I, there had been several changes in the structure of the 27th Infantry Division, many of which were significant. The 107th Infantry Regiment (formerly the 7th New York of Civil War fame) was transferred out of the division and redesignated the 207th Coast Artillery. To replace the 107th, the 165th Infantry Regiment (formerly “the Fighting 69th” New York) famous from Civil War and World War I, was assigned to the division. The 165th and the 108th Infantry Regiment from the Syracuse area of New York formed the 54th Infantry Brigade.
In September 1940, the 106th Infantry Regiment from Brooklyn, New York, was redesignated the 186th Field Artillery Regiment and was transferred out. Its place in the 53d Infantry Brigade was taken by the 10th New York Infantry from Albany, Utica, and other New York communities. In November 1940, the 10th New York was designated the 106th Infantry and became known as the “Knickerbocker” Regiment. The Apple-knockers, which had served with the 27th during World War I, joined the Knickerbockers to form the 53d Brigade.
For the 105th Infantry, this was the fourth time in less than one hundred years that the regiment, or one of its predecessor units, had been called into active duty to serve the United States. One of the oldest military organizations in the country, the 105th’s predecessor militia units served in the French and Indian War during the 1750s, the Revolutionary War in the 1770s, and the War of 1812. The New York State Militiamen particularly distinguished themselves at the Battle of Saratoga, where the British were forced to surrender in September 1777. One of the 105th’s core units, Company A, was formed as the Troy Citizen’s Corps by the New York state legislature on September 23, 1835. During the American Civil War, this unit served as Company A of the 2d New York Volunteers for two years, from April 1861 to April 1863, and participated in numerous battles throughout the state of Virginia. Company A existed as a separate unit until the late 1870s when it was incorporated into the New York National Guard.
The National Guard in the northeastern part of New York had its origins in the late 1870s and 1880s when twelve separate companies of militia were formed in a number of upstate New York communities and organized as the 2d New York Infantry Regiment. This unit was called into active service during the Spanish-American War in 1898 and the Mexican border war in 1916. On July 12, 1917, shortly after the United States declared war on Germany, Pres. Woodrow Wilson called the entire National Guard into federal service. The 2d New York then became a part of the newly designated 27th Infantry Division, also known as the New York Division. On October 1, 1917, the 2d New York was redesignated the 105th Infantry Regiment and was augmented by approximately 1,500 officers and enlisted men from the 12th and 71st Infantry Regiments of the New York National Guard. It served with distinction in France and Belgium and participated in the successful assault on the Hindenberg line. It was mustered out of federal service on April 1, 1919, after precisely two years and seven days of service, and after demobilization, reverted to National Guard status and once again became the 2d Regiment, New York National Guard.
During the period between the notice of induction and the actual induction, an extensive reorganization took place. The division needed to be brought up to war strength as soon as possible, with some 7,000 men needed immediately. Details were sent to Fort Dix, New Jersey; Camp Upton, New York; and Fort Niagara, New York to begin the process of moving recruits from reception centers to Fort McClellan, an abandoned military reservation near Anniston, Alabama. The new recruits were expected to begin arriving in January 1941. On October 9, 1940, approximately six weeks after completion of the De Kalb maneuvers, Lt. Gen. Hugh Drum, in command of the II Army Corps, ordered the 27th Division to concentrate at Fort McClellan for field training. Major General William N. Haskell, commander of the 27th Division since 1926, established a regiment to facilitate initial combat training of the recruits. After completing their training, these men would be added to the four infantry regiments—105th, 106th, 108th, and 165th—already at Fort McClellan.
Meanwhile, on October 9, 1940, plans for rail and motor movements of the 105th Infantry were discussed at a meeting of the commanders and staff at the Troy Armory. The plans called for the main body of troops to leave by train for Fort McClellan on October 23, 1940, a trip of more than 1,100 miles. One train of twenty cars would carry units of the 1st Battalion, 105th Infantry, from Troy, Cohoes, and Hoosick Falls. A second would originate at Malone, New York, and pick up the 3d Battalion along the Delaware and Hudson Railroad Line. A third train would move from Schenectady, New York, with Companies E, F, and H of the 2d Battalion; G Company of the 2d Battalion would be picked up at Amsterdam. All trains were scheduled to arrive at Anniston no later than October 25.
Start reading Battling for Saipan: The True Story of an American Hero on your Kindle in under a minute.
Don't have a Kindle? Get your Kindle here, or download a FREE Kindle Reading App.
Don't have a Kindle? Get your Kindle here, or download a FREE Kindle Reading App.
Product details
- Publisher : Presidio Press; Reprint edition (February 4, 2003)
- Language : English
- Paperback : 400 pages
- ISBN-10 : 0891418040
- ISBN-13 : 978-0891418047
- Item Weight : 1.03 pounds
- Dimensions : 5.5 x 0.8 x 8.5 inches
-
Best Sellers Rank:
#710,879 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
- #2,410 in WWII Biographies
- #7,558 in World War II History (Books)
- #11,481 in United States Biographies
- Customer Reviews:
Customer reviews
4.0 out of 5 stars
4 out of 5
14 global ratings
How are ratings calculated?
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzes reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Top reviews
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
3.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting and I learned much but this was not the best book I have read on the subject of Saipan
Reviewed in the United States on May 31, 2017Verified Purchase
4 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Reviewed in the United States on October 28, 2015
Verified Purchase
Painful reading way to much detail in the beginning, okay great you discovered all this neat stuff in your research, doesn't mean the reader can wade through it and survive.
One person found this helpful
Report abuse
Reviewed in the United States on August 5, 2015
Verified Purchase
SO WELL WRITTEN.
Reviewed in the United States on August 10, 2015
Verified Purchase
A good read from the Army's point of view.
5.0 out of 5 stars
I found that my brother was mentioned it this book. He was one of two to survive in his company so I was told.
Reviewed in the United States on January 8, 2013Verified Purchase
It was so true to what I was told by my brother who survived. It is hard to believe such atrosities were committed by the Japanese.
2 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Reviewed in the United States on June 8, 2014
Verified Purchase
Didn't realize I'd ordered the Army version of the Battle. What littleI've read, looks like O'Brien has done a lot of research.
However, I served in the Marines and Gen. H. M. Smith was an
Alumni of present day Auburn University so naturally I believe his side of the events and if he felt the Army let the Marines down, then they did.
However, I served in the Marines and Gen. H. M. Smith was an
Alumni of present day Auburn University so naturally I believe his side of the events and if he felt the Army let the Marines down, then they did.
One person found this helpful
Report abuse
Reviewed in the United States on June 7, 2004
Like your Reader from Texas, I am not a marine but I have read many books about the war in the Pacific and the Smith vs. Smith incident.
HM Smith was not one of the great captains of WWII. As Professor Harry Gailey points out in "Howlin' Mad Versus the Army", Saipan was the first and only time HM Smith ever had hands on responsibility for troops in battle. He did not conduct a very brilliant campaign. He constantly underestimated the strength of Japanese resistance on the island, made his plans based on his underestimates, and then blamed the Army Division and its Commander, MG Ralph Smith, when his plans did not work.
The 27th Infantry Division was the most unfairly maligned unit of WWII, Its commander, MG Ralph Smith was the most unfairly vilified leader of WWII. This happened because the Marine Corps and its advocates needed to create and maintain the legend that HM Smith was a great captain, needed to explain away HM Smith's less than brilliant performance on Saipan.
This book, while not a thoroughly researched as Edmund Smith's 27th ID's History or Professor Gailey's "Howlin' Mad Versus the Army", it is an honest attempt to tell the correct history, that the 27th ID fought hard and fought well on Saipan.
HM Smith was not one of the great captains of WWII. As Professor Harry Gailey points out in "Howlin' Mad Versus the Army", Saipan was the first and only time HM Smith ever had hands on responsibility for troops in battle. He did not conduct a very brilliant campaign. He constantly underestimated the strength of Japanese resistance on the island, made his plans based on his underestimates, and then blamed the Army Division and its Commander, MG Ralph Smith, when his plans did not work.
The 27th Infantry Division was the most unfairly maligned unit of WWII, Its commander, MG Ralph Smith was the most unfairly vilified leader of WWII. This happened because the Marine Corps and its advocates needed to create and maintain the legend that HM Smith was a great captain, needed to explain away HM Smith's less than brilliant performance on Saipan.
This book, while not a thoroughly researched as Edmund Smith's 27th ID's History or Professor Gailey's "Howlin' Mad Versus the Army", it is an honest attempt to tell the correct history, that the 27th ID fought hard and fought well on Saipan.
16 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Reviewed in the United States on September 21, 2003
I found Francis O'Brien's work on the 27th Division to be moving account of an army unit that served its country well at the expense of criticism. His account of the 1st battalion, 105th Infantry Regiment, was especially touching, and, I feel, deserves mention along with other memorable units of WWII.
However, I do agree that O'Brien's work does lack much objectiveness at the expense of defending the reputation of the 27th Division. This was essentially the purpose of his book, and there are certainly more objective accounts of the 27th to be found elsewhere, some of whom O'Brien refers to in his book.
Nonetheless, I found this book to be an enjoyable read and quite a service to those who fought and died with the "New York Division" in WWII.
As O'Brien states at the end of his preface: "I trust I have shown that [the families'] fathers, sons, uncles, and brothers served their country honrably and well in WWII."
However, I do agree that O'Brien's work does lack much objectiveness at the expense of defending the reputation of the 27th Division. This was essentially the purpose of his book, and there are certainly more objective accounts of the 27th to be found elsewhere, some of whom O'Brien refers to in his book.
Nonetheless, I found this book to be an enjoyable read and quite a service to those who fought and died with the "New York Division" in WWII.
As O'Brien states at the end of his preface: "I trust I have shown that [the families'] fathers, sons, uncles, and brothers served their country honrably and well in WWII."
7 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Customers who bought this item also bought
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1







