Beatles - Composing Outside The Beatles: Lennon & McCartney 1973-1980
Frequently Bought Together
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
Top Customer Reviews
Whether you agree with the conclusion or not, Composing Outside The Beatles does a good job of outlining Lennon's and McCartney's work and presenting its case. It generally gets closer to McCartney's life, thanks to contributions from Laine and Wings drummer Denny Seiwell, but manages to show how a rough patch in Lennon's marriage to Yoko Ono affected his music--and led to a reunion with McCartney. Music videos and concert clips are plentiful, excerpted to give viewers reminders of songs such as McCartney's "My Love," "Live and Let Die," "Band on the Run," and "Coming Up," and Lennon's "Whatever Gets You Through the Night" and "Woman." Comments from critics and acquaintances help present a rounded picture of the artists' decade.
Composing is a little long, clocking in at over two hours, but it rarely bogs down. It's apparently a three-part television documentary released as one long unit on DVD; it would have been helpful to keep any divisions so viewers could watch at their own pace. I also noticed that there's another volume available on Amazon.com.
As you'd expect, picture quality varies widely, depending on the clips. It's an all-regions disc. Some extra Laine comments, particularly on his "friendly competition" with McCartney, and contributor bios are included. The DVD box gives a rundown of the contributors so you know who's who among the talking heads.
-Full review at dvdverdict.com
The `now-in-total' four disc set, (sold separately), reveals the trials and tribulations regarding the `Lennon-McCartney' partnership, as some would say, the greatest songwriting team of all time...but...
In the first disc of The Beatles early years, it was indeed a team effort that quickly grew apart where the songwriting was concerned, and, by disc 2, it was all over but the memories. This `team', although credited as such, rarely wrote much together, and it's evident to all those questioned, as well as to all those who listen, who really wrote what.
Disc 3 and 4 go under the paraphrased titles of "Composing Outside The Beatles", and take a look at the solo careers of John and Paul, after the breakup.
Clearly, in all four discs, the consensus is that John was indeed the better writer of the two, and that never becomes more clear than on disc 3, where their early solo efforts contrasted like night and day.
While John released brilliant efforts like "Imagine" and the `Plastic Ono Band' l.p., Paul was struggling with efforts like "Wild Life" and "Ram".
But, on disc 4, the newest entry, Paul's fortunes change, and, though he still isn't given much credit as far as being a songwriter goes, the charts told a different story, as he skyrocketed to #1 with the album still considered his post-Beatle magnum opus, "Band on The Run".
John, at this point, was not very focused on the music, and personal issues took him away from it for a while.Read more ›
Most Recent Customer Reviews
Forthright , clearheaded --offers interesting juxtapositions between Paul and John at each choronological phase of their post Beatles careers. Read morePublished 3 months ago by mystifying mind
Decent, but used some cover band playing the background music that sounded like the Beatles, but the songs weren't Beatle songsPublished 4 months ago by Michael Harrington
I didn't think this would be very interesting and was surprised. It takes you back through history when at the beginning Lennon looked to be the one with a commercial future. Read morePublished 6 months ago by G. A. Jacobs