Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
Before They Were Giants: First Works from Science Fiction Greats (Planet Stories (Paizo Publishing)) Paperback – August 24, 2010
|New from||Used from|
50% off featured books
Select books are up to 50% off for a limited time. Learn More
From Publishers Weekly
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
Top Customer Reviews
I also want to point out that of the 15 "giants" included here, exactly one of them is a woman. I would say that Le Guin, for example, is far more a "giant" than, say, R. A. Salvatore, just as an example. But no- only one female "giant" was included (Nicola Griffith, whose work I admire.. but still- only ONE???). I read a lot of f/sf written by women who are at least as good as some of the male "giants" here. This is an ongoing problem in the field, and Sutter- the editor- did pretty much nothing to bring us a broader scope.
In short: this book has serious flaws, only some of which were obvious from the premise. If one is a huge fan of several of the authors included, one will probably want to read it, since most of these stories are otherwise hard to find. Else? skip it.
When I was a teenager I read many of these authors pretty religiously, including Greg Bear, Piers Anthony, and a few others. What I didn't realize until reading this collection, though, was that I knew almost nothing about their short stories, having read mostly novels.
This collection is fantastic at doing three things. First, it connects you with some authors you have probably heard of but might not have read, it exposes you to some pretty great short stories, and it confirms what most of us have suspected. Most of these guys and girls DID start out as amazing authors. But that's not to say that some of the stories, or sections within stories, weren't a bit rough.
But that's what I loved most about it. It made the authors more human, and really laid bare the craft of writing that these people were developing and honing. A few of the stories I didn't care for at all (I won't name names so as not to offend) but unlike other anthologies where I'd feel slighted, here it was illustrative and interesting. Some of these authors had no idea what they were doing at all and were still writing compelling stories!
Editor James Sutter does a good job in the foreward of setting the expectation-level by introducing the collection as the first published short stories by these amazing sci-fi writers. A few had already published novels, or written elsewhere, but these were their first published shorts, which many novel-writers struggle with even after they are professional/succesful.Read more ›
As a result, by operation of the simple law of averages, there are bound to be a few things here you like. The bad news is, its probable there will be quite a bit more you either dislike or are indifferent to. Its also billed as a primer for aspiring writers - which it may very be of some use as, I have no idea - but as a result it also straddles into teachiness in places at the expense of fun. Throw in the fact that this is, by definition, the rawest works of the authors involved, and the book becomes of more use as a curiosity striving for "importance" than a book trying to be "fun".
Two and half stars might be fairer than two, but I cant rate in half stars, and can't give it three stars just for meaning well and trying hard.