Okay, so I don't typically write movie reviews, because we all know I showed up for the big name here: Chris Evans. And if you didn't, well, now you do.
That being said, I don't think this movie is what I expected. Nor do I like it just for him.
I knew it was a romance. I saw the trailer yesterday, and wanted to see this more than ever before. I expected a typical romance--the guy and girl meet, they go through stuff to help each other, they fall in love forever. And those traits can apply to this movie, but in that same breath, it was so different from typical format. The ending threw me, the events weren't everyday. Everything about it was familiar, yet unexpected.
Nick is pining for this woman he's loved for a long time. Brooke is married and having issues of her own. They meet as Nick is trumpeting in Grand Central and Brooke is running to chase down a train and drops her phone as she passes him, effectively breaking it and missing her train. And so begins a journey through a night in NYC where old loves are confronted, issues arise, a lifetime opportunity is revealed...they find they don't have to have sex or make out every three seconds to see flickers of love beginning to spark.
That's where this is so different. You get to know the characters through their own stories as well as their story together. It's not rushed or forced between them. It's almost infuriating that it seems to be moving so slow at times, but I think that's what makes it more a true-to-life experience. So refreshing. Evans as Nick was almost heartbreaking at some parts, because I swear he seriously looks on the verge of tears himself--the sad eyes he naturally has, I'm sure, help with that. Alice Eve's Brooke was played well. She made her character strong when she needed Brooke to be, weak when Brooke had to be. Both were fantastic together as though maybe Nick and Brooke could be a couple, but maybe it could never work between them.
This is also Chris Evans' directorial debut. And don't let thoughts of his RomCom goofiness, his pompous Johnny Storm or Lucas Lee rolls, or stints as the GREATEST Captain in all of America cloud your judgment about this. He brought a feel to the movie that I hadn't experienced before...or maybe in a really long time. The camera work was brilliant, keeping the focus on Nick and Brooke, quite literally. On long shots, the world around them was not perfectly clear, but they were. Close-ups were them and a very blurred background/foreground. It felt like a very intimate setting where it's just you watching or spying on these two characters. It was really a great way to make it seem more personal. The score works well with the story, the soundtrack as well. The way the music was pieced into the movie reminds me of Bright Lights, Big City...Recent updated music, mixed with the old, mixed with something jazzy. It blended with the story very well.
All in all, I am very surprised that I loved this more than I thought I would. I mean, with the exception of Johnny Storm (because he was so pompous and arrogant...Chris Evans did that one a little too well), I admit to liking the majority of Chris Evans' projects. (Fangirl, what can I say?) But even if I had neutral feelings about him, I would love this movie all the same. The story and the characters alone should win it, and I think here, they did. I recommend at least one watch. I also recommend keeping a box of tissues handy for when you watch, because it did make me cry. You have been warned.