Black Moon (The Criterion Collection)
Frequently bought together
Customers who viewed this item also viewed
Customers who bought this item also bought
Louis Malle (The Lovers, Au revoir les enfants) meets Lewis Carroll in this bizarre and bewitching trip down the rabbit hole. After skirting the horrors of an unidentified war being waged in an anonymous countryside, a beautiful young woman (Cathryn Harrison) takes refuge in a remote farmhouse, where she becomes embroiled in the surreal domestic odyssey of a mysterious family. Evocatively shot by cinematographer Sven Nykvist (Cries and Whispers, Fanny and Alexander), Black Moon is a Freudian tale of adolescent sexuality set in a postapocalyptic world of shifting identities and talking animals. It is one of Malle’s most experimental films and a cinematic daydream like no other.
French writer-director Louis Malle attracted American moviegoers in the late 1970s and early '80s with Pretty Baby, Atlantic City, and My Dinner with André, but those looking for signs of things to come will be hard-pressed to find them in Black Moon, their immediate predecessor. Variously described as a "mythological fairy tale" (by the director himself) and "an elaborate surrealist fantasy," this is a film with no story line, little dialogue (some of which is delivered by animals), and much strangeness. In what might be the director's broad interpretation of Alice in Wonderland, we follow 15-year-old Lily (Cathryn Harrison, granddaughter of the British actor Rex Harrison) as she drives Malle's "wild, archaic landscape," where a war pitting men and women soldiers against one another is in full swing; the wild ride ends near a decrepit country mansion occupied by a pair of androgynous, silent siblings (Alexandra Stewart and Andy Warhol regular Joe Dallesandro, both also called Lily), their bedridden old mother (a vivid performance by Therese Giehse, by far the most accomplished actor of the bunch), and a menagerie of beasts, including a pig in a highchair, a cat on a piano keyboard, a talking unicorn (hey, it's surrealism), as well as gaggles of naked children gamboling about with the sheep. That's where the remainder of the action, such as it is, unfolds, as young Lily tries to find her place in what Malle calls "an irrational world." Her efforts are largely in vain, and so perhaps will many viewers' be--it's not for nothing that this was Malle's least commercially successful effort. And if there doesn't seem to be much of a point, well, perhaps that's the point.
The overall presentation is up to the Criterion Collection's usual high standards, including a new high-definition digital transfer (the better to appreciate the cinematography by Ingmar Bergman veteran Sven Nykvist), a booklet with an essay about the movie, and a brief interview with the director (in French; the film itself is in English, but this release also contains a version dubbed in French). --Sam Graham
- Aspect Ratio : 1.66:1
- Is Discontinued By Manufacturer : No
- MPAA rating : s_medNotRated NR (Not Rated)
- Product Dimensions : 7.5 x 5.5 x 0.5 inches; 3.2 Ounces
- Item model number : CRRN2028DVD
- Director : Louis Malle
- Media Format : Multiple Formats, NTSC, Widescreen, Color
- Run time : 1 hour and 40 minutes
- Release date : June 28, 2011
- Actors : Cathryn Harrison, Thérèse Ghiese, Alexandra Stewart, Joe Dallesandro
- Dubbed: : French
- Subtitles: : English
- Studio : Criterion Collection
- ASIN : B004S801YA
- Number of discs : 1
- Best Sellers Rank: #77,826 in Movies & TV (See Top 100 in Movies & TV)
- Customer Reviews:
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
As someone who has seen almost every Malle film and is a professed fan, I was excited about seeing this one, but midstream, I realized I was in for a huge letdown, and by the film's end, I was flabbergasted seeing the final scene approaching, the outcome of which would leave me perplexed, pissed, and feeling cinematically cheated by a good friend. There's more to be said about this film and the director's effort, but I simply cannot bring myself to care enough to do so - it might only succeed in making you want to see this flick and, unless you're a completist or a cinema sadist, what's the point? It seems most directors hit a wall at some point during the 70's for a variety of reasons we don't have time to delve into here. What could have been Lewis Carroll by way of Luis Bunuel as seen through the eyes of Louis Malle ends up a non-narrative mess that's not even character driven with little plot, no development or back-story, no emotional content and no ending. Sure, as arthouse junkies we can ruminate on this or that to make believe that there's something deeper there when in fact there probably isn't, so let's call it a day and declare it for what it probably is - Malle's most disappointing work, but one that pushed him into another chapter in his dynamic career during the 80's and beyond. So maybe we have this morsel of manna to be grateful for, in spite of the overarching 'Black Moon' that hangs above us when we indulge in this convoluted overindulgence. All great artists falter from time to time... but that doesn't diminish their greatness if they can rekindle the fire that made them memorable in the first place.
Top reviews from other countries
Qualifié tantôt de film fantastique, même de film de science-fiction et meilleur film de cette année- là pour moi avec l’excellent Hu-Man de Jérôme Laperrousaz.
Nous nous trouvons ici plongés avec Lily notre héroïne dans une fiction où les femmes et les hommes se livrent une guérilléra sanglante dans une campagne quasi déserte, où les prisonniers sont immédiatement achevés dans chacun des camps. Et Lily atterrit dans une vieille maison peuplée d’une vieille femme alitée, d’un jeune couple frère et sœur, au milieu d'une propriété où les enfants jouent et courent tout nus et où les animaux de toute sorte sont omniprésents, notamment une licorne.
Et cette maison et le jardin qui l’entourent sont comme un havre de paix par rapport à la violence qui fait rage tout autour.
J’ai été séduite par le mystère omniprésent qui laisse toute place à notre imagination.
La photo du film est due à Sven Nykvist, le chef-opérateur de Bergman et je la trouve particulièrement réussie.
Une belle et intrigante allégorie. Oui mais allégorie de quoi ? D’un futur proche (d’alors) expliquait Louis Malle. Sans doute mais ce ne sera pas dans une guerre des sexes que nous risquons de plus en plus d’être plongés un prochain jour. Et peut-être même sans havre de paix.