I have a problem with the writing style of this book. Here are just two sentences from the chapter on meditation and mindfulness:
"The more formal act of sitting meditation itself encourages and assists meditation-in-action by stabilizing, balancing, and fueling our overall mental energy, giving us greater clarity, vigilance, objectivity, and discernment in every aspect of our existence. It helps remedy our everyday absentmindedness, scatter-brained thinking, obsessiveness, hysteria, bias, and ignorance."
"stabilizing, balancing, and fueling... greater clarity, vigilance, objectivity, and discernment ... absentmindedness, scatter-brained thinking, hysteria, bias, and ignorance..."
That's three mouthfuls of ideas in just two sentences. It wouldn't be so bad if this stuff wasn't on every page. This points to a lack of focus that makes the book a slogging chore to read. This guy needs an editor, BADLY. It's a bit like listening to a speaker who inserts "uh" every other word. You start counting the "uhs" instead of listening to what they are saying. By the way, the very next sentence after the two I quoted above, he's off and running with "By enabling us to focus more intently on what we are thinking, saying, and doing..."
By contrast I've recently read Chogyam Trungpa's "Meditation in Action" which covers the same ground, the paramitas, and was first published in the 1960s. I would not presume to review such a high and mighty book, but I will say here that Trungpa was a much more focused writer, although more abstract and challenging in his own way. It is concise to the tune of 91 pages. It's the kind of book that's way over my head the first time through, and then starts to make sense as years go by. I had a similar experience with Thera's "The Heart of Buddhist Meditation" which baffled me at first, and then turned out to be a treasure by the third reading.
There are some positive things to say about "Buddha Is as Buddha Does" and first among them is that it helped me better understand what was going on in Trungpa. For that I am grateful and offer thanks to Lama Surya Das.
- File Size: 851 KB
- Print Length: 290 pages
- Publisher: HarperOne; Reprint edition (December 24, 2008)
- Publication Date: October 6, 2009
- Sold by: Amazon Digital Services LLC
- Language: English
- ASIN: B001ODEPNU
- Text-to-Speech:
Enabled
- Word Wise: Enabled
- Lending: Not Enabled
-
Amazon Best Sellers Rank:
#393,678 Paid in Kindle Store (See Top 100 Paid in Kindle Store)
- #47 in Mahayana Buddhism
- #114 in Tao Te Ching (Kindle Store)
- #251 in Buddhist Rituals & Practice (Kindle Store)
Would you like to tell us about a lower price?

















