This is one of my favorite Timothy Olyphant movies that just so happens to have an excellent ensemble cast, all around. He is truly a romantic lead. This film is a Chick Flick, a Rom-Com, folks. It's not based on a great literary read. But it does takes a heavy subject, the unexpected loss of a loved one, and explores the different ways the loss is experienced by each character of the ensemble cast. And it doesn't necessarily show them all in their best light.
The way the deceased's fiancee, Gray (Jennifer Garner), and his LA party buddy Fritz (Olyphant) meet in the beginning of the film shows the two to be about as polar opposite as two people can be. Then, you have the deceased's business partner, Dennis (Sam Jaeger), falling for Garner's character at such an inappropriate time. Fionna Shaw is excellent casting as the grief stricken mother. The comedy standouts have to be the deceased's good friend, Sam (Kevin Smith is surprisingly excellent) and Maureen (played by the incomparable Juliette Lewis who is a jewel in everything she touches).
Garner and Olyphant have serious chemistry going on that translates over the screen. Garner is able to demonstrate a full range of emotions as she progresses through the stages of grief, while Olyphant is the cool, handsome, seemingly superficial Fritz who hits all the right notes opposite Garner's evolving character. There is a kiss between these two that is one of the hottest I've ever seen in the movies.
This film is a road picture, a jaunt. It's mindless and heartwarming fun, against a heavy backdrop. Not to be taken too seriously. Have you ever seen David Duchovny and Minnie Driver in 'Return to Me?' A Chick Flick, Rom-Com against the serious subject of a heart transplant? These two films are similar in that way and tone; however, 'Catch and Release' has a younger ensemble cast and is set in a different city. And I found the chemistry between Garner and Olyphant to be more combustable than I did between Duchovny and Driver.