Amazon Prime includes:
| Prime Benefits |
|
|---|---|
| Award winning movies and TV shows with limited ads on Prime Video | ✓ |
| On demand, ad-free music streaming with Prime Music | ✓ |
| Early access to deals and savings with Prime Exclusives | ✓ |
Buy new:
$19.99$19.99
Delivery Friday, August 30
Ships from: Amazon.com Sold by: Amazon.com
Save with Used - Good
$12.99$12.99
Delivery Monday, September 2
Ships from: Amazon Sold by: SGWU BOOKS
Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
Confucius Never Said Paperback – April 28, 2014
Purchase options and add-ons
- Print length218 pages
- LanguageEnglish
- Publication dateApril 28, 2014
- Dimensions6 x 0.5 x 9 inches
- ISBN-101499185278
- ISBN-13978-1499185270
Frequently bought together

Customers who bought this item also bought
Customer reviews
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on AmazonCustomers say
Customers find the book worth reading, providing valuable insight into life during the Spanish Civil War. They also describe the story as compelling, relevant, and chock full of interesting information. Readers praise the writing quality as well-written with only a small number of minor errors. They mention it provides a wonderful perspective on freedom, the rule of law, and different forms of law.
AI-generated from the text of customer reviews
Customers find the book very readable and spellbinding. They also say it provides the details in a very believable tale.
"...The book is very well constructed and very engaging, and I was left with a feeling of deep respect toward the author and her family...." Read more
"...The book is outstanding as a close up look at Communism and intriguing biography of the woman who escapes it...." Read more
"...at a fairly high level, but with enough detail and substance to make for engaging reading...." Read more
"One of the very best books I've ever read. Learned so much about China and how its Communism effects the lives of its people...." Read more
Customers find the book provides valuable insight into what life was like for the Chinese in the 1930s. They also say it's a great book to remind Americans of what happened in China.
"...Second, even if you don't agree with the author, her points are very interesting...." Read more
"I just finished this book and highly recommend it for providing valuable insight to what life was like for most Chinese during the 1950s through the..." Read more
"...This book has inspired in many different ways. I laughed and cried reading it! :)" Read more
"The book was very well-written and incredibly informative...." Read more
Customers find the book compelling, honest, and engaging. They also say the story is relevant to our times.
"...Not only is the story compelling and relevant to our times, it is chock full of the author's opinions about governments, bureaucracies, values, and..." Read more
"Helen Raleigh has an amazing story to tell. Her hard work, close family and luck led to a much better life in America...." Read more
"...At times heroic and harrowing, the core narrative is masterfully crafted and compelling...." Read more
"...Her personal stories on the other hand are fascinating and worth the read however you think about her political alliance." Read more
Customers find the book well-written, with only a small number of minor errors. They also say it's relevant to our times, chock full of the author's opinions about governments, and has a wonderful perspective on freedom, rule of law, and different forms of it.
"...the story compelling and relevant to our times, it is chock full of the author's opinions about governments, bureaucracies, values, and philosophies..." Read more
"The book was very well-written and incredibly informative...." Read more
"...The book is well written, with only a small number of minor errors, and has several family photographs...." Read more
"...seventy years by Ms Raleigh’s first hand accounts and enjoyed her reflections and critiques of what the US is going through today based on her..." Read more
-
Top reviews
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
Based on the fact that I'm now writing a five-star review, you can guess how wrong I was.
This story was in many ways a punch in the gut. This isn't just a biography of an ordinary family; it's the biography of a family that survived in horrific circumstances. They lived through the Great Famine in China, even as most of their village died of starvation. They somehow lived under Mao without joining the Communist Party. They endured decades of hunger, poverty, disrespect (as it, your neighbors all turning on you and the government unfairly punishing you), and they survived it all -- because they were both clever and lucky, and because they met truly good people who helped them. In one anecdote, the author's father is at school and he's very hungry, because he can't afford lunch. One of his teachers secretly gives him his lunch -- not only his lunch, but his entire food ration for the day, and for one day, the boy isn't hungry. That teacher later, during the Great Famine, dies of starvation.
I am not a person whose emotions are generally on the surface, or who makes a display. But as I sit and write this, weeks after reading the book, there are tears streaming down my face. It's that powerful.
Don't get me wrong: the book isn't just a sobfest. There are plenty of funny bits. For example, the author mentions that when she was a child growing up in China, her mother told her to finish her food -- because there were starving children in America.
The book is very well constructed and very engaging, and I was left with a feeling of deep respect toward the author and her family.
A note on politics: at the end of each chapter, there is a "Food for Thought" section. This section details the author's observations on China and America, and sometimes draws parallels. It does make distinctive political statements. Do NOT let this put you off, whichever party you subscribe to -- or even if you're not American at all. First of all, these sections are short. Second, even if you don't agree with the author, her points are very interesting. Third, if you really can't stand them, just skip them; the narrative is complete without them if you really only want to read a biography.
Yes, I am going to buy my own copy.
"My grandfather was eager to help because he was tired of decades of war, violence, and uncertainty. He craved a peaceful life. Like most people in China, he didn't know what communism stood for, but he figured that he would give his support if the communists delivered the peace and prosperity they promised. He didn't realize that would be the last time he saw his boat."
Raleigh's father and grandfather have a front row seat for the redistribution she is witnessing today. Their close-knit community is ripped apart when her family, though popular, is cast as villainous oppressors.
"Initially, some poor farmers were hesitant to identify their neighbors as rich. However, the work team brainwashed the poor farmers into believing that disproportionate property ownership was the main cause of social injustice and that landowners were evil class enemies and exploiters of the poor. With a certain amount of coercion, some poor farmers turned their old grievances or frustrations into hatred for their well -to-do neighbors. Since my great-grandfather owned land, he was classified as a landlord even though he wasn't the richest man in the village."
Once identified as "rich," life becomes unbearably hard for the family, and Raleigh chronicles the difficulties. We know the horrors of the famine (though many Chinese do not), but one is struck by the small things. There are a few train trips to seek education, better opportunities, and finally the author's chance o study in America. We complain about travel, but there is a "papers, please" mentality that makes every stop suspenseful. Communism will starve you if you stay put and administer the death of a thousand cuts if you seek life elsewhere.
The book is outstanding as a close up look at Communism and intriguing biography of the woman who escapes it. The best of Raleigh's book, however, is Raleigh's interest in philosophy and the power of ideas. The title refers to "All men are created equal." Confucius never said that. Confucianism accepts the caste system and a hierarchical society that was overturned in The Enlightenment.
Raleigh quotes FA Hayek, Milton Friedman, and William Easterly. In a couple decades here, she has absorbed the philosophical foundations of liberty and prosperity. In "Confucius Never Said" she shares those with us.
Five stars.
Why did I not give the book 5 stars? Because the style of writing is good, but not great (although the simplicity of the style makes for quick reading). Also, because the author does generalize quite a bit and thus loses some credibility for skimming over the complexities of human society in condemning the bad aspects of both Chinese and American society. These are minor criticisms. An understanding reader will easily overlook these trivial flaws and recognize that the author's life experiences entitle her to have firm opinions about the evils that humanity still struggles to overcome and the important role of individual liberty in the achievement of national prosperity. Valuable lessons for all.







