| Kindle Price: | $1.50 |
| Sold by: | Amazon.com Services LLC |
Your Memberships & Subscriptions
Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
OK
DIAGRAMS & DOLLARS: Modern Money Illustrated Kindle Edition
- LanguageEnglish
- Publication dateJanuary 12, 2014
- File size923 KB
Customers who bought this item also bought
Product details
- ASIN : B00HUF6POI
- Publication date : January 12, 2014
- Language : English
- File size : 923 KB
- Simultaneous device usage : Unlimited
- Text-to-Speech : Enabled
- Screen Reader : Supported
- Enhanced typesetting : Enabled
- X-Ray : Not Enabled
- Word Wise : Enabled
- Sticky notes : On Kindle Scribe
- Print length : 36 pages
- Best Sellers Rank: #368,629 in Kindle Store (See Top 100 in Kindle Store)
- Customer Reviews:
About the author

My journey as an architect and writer has come to focus entirely on two goals:
First, to lay out an understanding of the operations of modern fiat money and the astonishing implications this understanding has for what we can undertake and accomplish as a collective society.
Second, to share specific concepts for Affordable Housing and Urban Architecture that are made possible by the operations modern fiat money.
These two topics intersect—with different emphasis and perspectives—on my website www.jdalt.com.
Customer reviews
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on Amazon-
Top reviews
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
Well, no.
Easy counterexample: I buy land for $100K, raw materials for $100K, labor for $300K, and build a $1M home for $500K costs. The county assessor comes round, says "Yes, that's a $1M house", and I can sell it for $1M the next year or keep it. Either way, I JUST CREATED $500K WORTH OF NET WEALTH TO THE ECONOMY by being an entrepreneur and CREATING valuable, desirable durable goods OUT OF THIN AIR. My BALANCE SHEET has gone up by $500K. The balance sheet of the entire nation has gone up by $500K. I never printed a single paper dollar, and yet both me and my country's economy are now worth substantially more in both wealth and value.
The author confuses money, which is just a way of measuring value, with wealth. He ignores the velocity of money:
I pay Joe Laborer $1K. Joe buys an original painting for his wife for $1K. The painter goes to the hairdresser and pays $1K for a super weave. The hairdresser goes to the grocer and buys $1K worth of oranges for a party.
Total amount of paper/electronic dollars: $1K, issued by the government OR BANKS (banks do create money/debt at will, it's called a "loan").
Total amount of value: $4K received, and $4K tallied in GDP.
Total amount of income taxes paid: ~25% of $4K, NOT ~25% of $1K, because, when you have decent velocity of money, the money flows 'round and 'round and keeps on flowing, while the value and ideally the wealth just keeps adding up.
(This is why slowing down the velocity of money during a recession is so deadly.)
If you work for a salary, every day you are creating more wealth out of thin air than you get paid, just by showing up to work and doing your thing. Or else your employer would not stand for it, and would fire you. The whole is greater than the sum of its parts, and the company creates a profit from all the workers doing their thing together. Or else the company wouldn't do it. The company's durable products or services are worth more in wealth to the consumer, even more than the price, or else the consumer wouldn't pay for them. The whole economy runs like this, pulling itself up from its bootstraps, creating wealth out of thin air when one person buys something that is more valuable to THEM than it is less valuable/mundane/boring to the person who is selling. Thus the net value / net worth of the economy as a whole magically increases, like yeast growing to make bread and beer.
MMT is completely clueless on this.
Well, the e-book is nice. The author clearly demonstrates these wrong ideas with useful flow diagrams based on cistern "pots of money" and pipes. He clearly lays out what the MMT people are thinking, and his explanations are spot on and easy to understand.
It's just the theory itself that is based on government self-centered thinking.
Even more looney-tunes ideas: "U.S. Tax moneys paid are destroyed (and thus do not flow into the Treasury)". I am sure all those accountants at the Treasury are happy now that they can go home, 'cause their work is not needed. The Treasury's balance is always 0! Wow! "The only REAL value of a dollar is paying U.S. taxes; it's a TAX certificate." "People only PRETEND to use them for everyday money, because eventually they're going to have to pay their taxes with them." Ha! Won't China be surprised! All this time they thought they were investing and buying trillions of future dollars, but because China doesn't have to pay any U.S. income tax, they are actually COMPLETELY WORTHLESS!!! China and Russia should start their own bank, and issue real MONEY that is not based on the I.R.S.!!
actually, that last one is not so funny.
Here are some things the book gets right:
1) A sovereign government that owns/controls its own central bank is PROFOUNDLY AND COMPLETELY different from a captive government that cannot issue its own currency, such as U.S. state or local governments or Greece. In this case, surplus and deficit budgets become mere score-keeping, instead of vital survival issues, as the central bank can, at least in theory and to a first order of approximation, print its way out of any external debts. That is, as long as inflation is under control, and people still believe in the worth of the currency. Thus, and this is important, an independent SOVEREIGN government should not concentrate on balancing its budget, but rather allocating stimulus properly.
So NONE of the theory of the book has ANY relevance to state or local governments. Don't Try This At Home.
...Whether the complex relationship between the Treasury and the U.S. Fed actually qualifies is a knotty issue TBD.
2) Sovereign governments are limited by the quality and quantity of the people, raw materials, technology, and energy they can get for projects. Funding can be a secondary issue, limited mainly by having to keep inflation under control.
3) Federal Budget surpluses drain the private sector. This can eventually result in a recession or a private debt crisis. The job of the Federal government is to inject money wisely into the economy, not to be balanced. Many people miss this.
4) Federal Budget deficit spending increases net savings in the private sector, and can increase investment and growth. (Note unfortunately that this needs to be targeted better, as current deficit spending goes largely to banks--which, technically, are part of the private sector--and not private individuals or tech companies.)
The author therefore proposes renaming the Deficit as "Net Spending Achievement", and the National Debt Clock as the "National Savings Clock". He has a good write-up on these. These are all interesting ideas that should be weighed thoughtfully. Just for this reason alone, it is probably worth it to buy this e-book and think about all the questions that it raises.
Anyway, remember, entrepreneurs create wealth. People who treasure the wealth are willing to pay more for it, and that creates value. And the money is only used to track the value, and indirectly the wealth. Start screwing with these basic concepts, and you'll come up with very wrong conclusions.
My education in system dynamics began back in the 1960s working as a civilian engineer for the US Air Force. At that time, digital computers were too large and too slow to be used for navigation and bombing calculations on-board our aircraft. Instead, we used analog computers, and these had all the elements needed for system dynamic models. The differences were simply different names for the elements, for example, mathematical integrators correspond to the stock tanks or dollar storage tanks of this book.
Since that time, I've used system dynamic concepts to develop Monte Carlo simulations for a missile (Maverick), economic development of petroleum production fields, and an analysis of a proposed research process. It is a useful tool for better understanding many complex processes.
My only complaint about the book is that the author ignores fractional reserve banking, which seems to indicate that dollars are, in fact, created in the private sector, but his analysis is still correct because the federal government must supply the reserves making those new dollars possible.
Some of the comments seem to confuse dollars and value. We are used to thinking of value as being measured in dollars, but they are not the same. When we say an object has a value of so many dollars, we usually mean it cost that many dollars to create, or it could be exchanged for that many dollars. Value is indeed created in the private sector, and the dollars are there only to facilitate that creation.
I would love a second diagrammes book on how the banking system works and how bank created money ties into the sovereign money creation process. I think I understand that central bank reserves are sovereign money but this does not appear on the diagrammes. .
Top reviews from other countries
I have given this book the highest rating because it is a hard hitting combination of clear easy to read text supported by clear easy to follow diagrams that delivers a clear easy to understand message to the topic of political economy that is bathed and cloaked in neoliberal myths and half truths and false assumptions.
This quick and easy to read book should be standard issue to every elected official when seeking public office and also for all government employees upon employment. Further this sort of material should be taught in schools, colleges and universities everywhere.
国家とは何か。通貨発行権を持ち、その通貨でもって税金を徴収する権利を有する組織のことである。政府が懸念すべきはインフレのみで通貨発行は自由。マネーを創造するのは国家のみ、民間部門ではない(銀行とは国家発行のマネーにレバレッジをかける組織)。国家は民間部門から財とサービスを購入し、マネーを民間部門に流入させる。そして民間部門に満ちたマネーを徴税という形で吸い上げ、「破壊する」。「税収」というが、税金は国家の収入ではない。国家はマネーを創造できるのだから「収入」など必要ない。マネーとは実際のところ「国家による約束」である。何の約束か。「この通貨で税金を受け付けます」って約束。この「約束」があるからこそ、国民通貨は国民通貨たり得ている(脱税すると獄に下るってペナルティ付きだ)。そして国債を売るということは、「国家が借金する」ということではない。国家が民間部門の中のドルをspendingからsavingに移行させることである。そして国家は国債の金利を払うことによりドルを民間部門のspendingに再移行させる。「National Debt」は国債残高のことであるが、これは相方の民間部門から見れば 「National Savings」である。よって、予算を均衡させるという考え方自体がナンセンスなのだ。国家の歳出は税収の制限を受けないのだから。むしろ予算を均衡させたら国家が民間部門に流し込むマネーが滞るのだからよろしくない。この構図では、国家が懸念すべきはインフレのみなのである。
これが真実なら私のJGB投資は安泰…というのは置いといて、「あるべき姿」ではなく「現実のマネー機能」を描き出したらこうなる、という感じなのかもしれないが、これが現実ならば、「財政政策と金融政策分離」という面妖な構造でもって成り立つEUが「大いなる勘違い」によって作られたカタストロフェ装置だったということが明らかになるのである。「当時の欧州エリートたちはいったいナニを考えてた?」と後知恵で唖然とするのが大勢であろうが、おそらく、モダンマネーについて「知らなかった」ってな単純な話であろうと思う。しかし後半に行くに従って目が点々化したのだが、シロートの私としては一応、金本位主義者の方々に「ゴールドで税金が払えます?」ってな反論が可能になったかもしれない、くらいの感想である。それから通貨量の話ばかりで流通速度に関する考慮がないのはちょっと心許ない。ちなみに本書を読んだせいで、本書主張とは真逆を行く「Money is gold」派のジム・リカーズ氏の『The New Case for Gold』を衝動買いしてしまった。





