Shop top categories that ship internationally
Buy new:
-8% $25.68
Delivery Monday, January 20
Ships from: Amazon
Sold by: Arena Books Store
$25.68 with 8 percent savings
List Price: $27.95
FREE International Returns
No Import Fees Deposit & $10.60 Shipping to Germany Details

Shipping & Fee Details

Price $25.68
AmazonGlobal Shipping $10.60
Estimated Import Fees Deposit $0.00
Total $36.28

Delivery Monday, January 20. Order within 12 hrs 18 mins
Or fastest delivery Friday, January 10
Only 1 left in stock - order soon.
$$25.68 () Includes selected options. Includes initial monthly payment and selected options. Details
Price
Subtotal
$$25.68
Subtotal
Initial payment breakdown
Shipping cost, delivery date, and order total (including tax) shown at checkout.
Ships from
Amazon
Ships from
Amazon
Returns
30-day refund/replacement
30-day refund/replacement
This item can be returned in its original condition for a full refund or replacement within 30 days of receipt.
Returns
30-day refund/replacement
This item can be returned in its original condition for a full refund or replacement within 30 days of receipt.
Payment
Secure transaction
Your transaction is secure
We work hard to protect your security and privacy. Our payment security system encrypts your information during transmission. We don’t share your credit card details with third-party sellers, and we don’t sell your information to others. Learn more
Payment
Secure transaction
We work hard to protect your security and privacy. Our payment security system encrypts your information during transmission. We don’t share your credit card details with third-party sellers, and we don’t sell your information to others. Learn more
$11.40
FREE International Returns
Book is in good condition and may include underlining highlighting and minimal wear. The book can also include From the library of labels. May not contain miscellaneous items toys dvds etc. . We offer 100% money back guarantee and 24 7 customer service. Free 2-day shipping with Amazon Prime! Book is in good condition and may include underlining highlighting and minimal wear. The book can also include From the library of labels. May not contain miscellaneous items toys dvds etc. . We offer 100% money back guarantee and 24 7 customer service. Free 2-day shipping with Amazon Prime! See less
Delivery Friday, January 17. Order within 12 hrs 18 mins
Or fastest delivery Friday, January 10
Only 2 left in stock - order soon.
$$25.68 () Includes selected options. Includes initial monthly payment and selected options. Details
Price
Subtotal
$$25.68
Subtotal
Initial payment breakdown
Shipping cost, delivery date, and order total (including tax) shown at checkout.
Access codes and supplements are not guaranteed with used items.
Added to

Sorry, there was a problem.

There was an error retrieving your Wish Lists. Please try again.

Sorry, there was a problem.

List unavailable.
Kindle app logo image

Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.

Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.

Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.

QR code to download the Kindle App

Follow the authors

Something went wrong. Please try your request again later.

Design in Nature: How the Constructal Law Governs Evolution in Biology, Physics, Technology, and Social Organization Hardcover – January 24, 2012

4.1 4.1 out of 5 stars 190 ratings

{"desktop_buybox_group_1":[{"displayPrice":"$25.68","priceAmount":25.68,"currencySymbol":"$","integerValue":"25","decimalSeparator":".","fractionalValue":"68","symbolPosition":"left","hasSpace":false,"showFractionalPartIfEmpty":true,"offerListingId":"D%2FINAq9mKlLFqNUx5mktjqh52hHOHaJ%2B6tg1CnugJjDOOXctyQgq9ShyQAugxIsv2VqPLF7KMXzqUdKmqUbewX3L836BqQhP%2Fy3kfjn7vgsRhR8wYFCfuDkE7P%2F1P7lqnspVjCJNdQAV%2Bo%2FEAuTigXf7343Qfbea5cRDnK3pnhW%2BdALk%2FUI3Jl1EOnkJaw1n","locale":"en-US","buyingOptionType":"NEW","aapiBuyingOptionIndex":0}, {"displayPrice":"$11.40","priceAmount":11.40,"currencySymbol":"$","integerValue":"11","decimalSeparator":".","fractionalValue":"40","symbolPosition":"left","hasSpace":false,"showFractionalPartIfEmpty":true,"offerListingId":"D%2FINAq9mKlLFqNUx5mktjqh52hHOHaJ%2BZO68BGnk6eWVHY8xWueVYxz%2BpCY2OMdf%2FmkBysoJPILZxNmlJOdJzOGS2m8B0y5pdvE1sEFKR3jDFhw%2BCoDVTmLDoUzPPoFqY155r6hH7npaRyZzNKsOdXEd5V6a7BrMZOiz1l7jW8cccP%2FK5POQ1n9nsuCKoBis","locale":"en-US","buyingOptionType":"USED","aapiBuyingOptionIndex":1}]}

Purchase options and add-ons

In this groundbreaking book, Adrian Bejan takes the recurring patterns in nature—trees, tributaries, air passages, neural networks, and lightning bolts—and reveals how a single principle of physics, the Constructal Law, accounts for the evolution of these and all other designs in our world.
 
Everything—from biological life to inanimate systems—generates shape and structure and
evolves in a sequence of ever-improving designs in order to facilitate flow. River basins, cardiovascular systems, and bolts of lightning are very efficient flow systems to move a current—of water, blood, or electricity. Likewise, the more complex architecture of animals evolve to cover greater distance per unit of useful energy, or increase their flow across the land. Such designs also appear in human organizations, like the hierarchical "flowcharts" or reporting structures in corporations and political bodies.

All are governed by the same principle, known as the Constructal Law, and configure and reconfigure themselves over time to flow more efficiently. Written in an easy style that achieves clarity without sacrificing complexity,
Design in Nature is a paradigm-shifting book that will fundamentally transform our understanding of the world around us.
The%20Amazon%20Book%20Review
The Amazon Book Review
Book recommendations, author interviews, editors' picks, and more. Read it now.

Editorial Reviews

From Booklist

When lightning flashes in the sky, showing off its characteristic pattern of zigzagging veins, it’s not hard to see its resemblance to branching trees or waterway tributaries. It’s also easy to assume those similarities are purely visual because these patterns occur in such different realms of nature. Yet according to veteran mechanical engineer and Duke University professor Bejan, these recurring shapes and structures obey a fundamental principle of physics known as the constructal law. Put simply, this law asserts that all things that live or move, from ants and animal herds to rivers and electric currents, persist and evolve according to their ability to facilitate flow. In this lucidly written overview of the constructal law, Bejan, with journalist Zane, describes all the circumstances and ways this law operates in the world, including blood vessels and man-made cooling systems. The authors’ language is never too abstract for the lay reader to easily grasp, and the insights offered here present a revolutionary, unifying vision of nature that could impact all branches of science. --Carl Hays

Review

"Fascinating...By reframing things as flow systems, they reveal how function determines form in everything from corporate hierarchies to Canada geese."--Nature

"Interesting....brings a useful new perspective to ubiquitous natural phenomena"--
New Scientist

"[I] found myself immediately sucked in....The Constructal Law is important because it not only describes the patterns of change in the world within and around us, but it allows us to predict how the configuration of those patterns will evolve over time."--
Forbes

"Provocative, witty, well written....makes a strong case"--
Charlotte Observer

"Brilliant. He effectively illustrates complex ideas for a general audience, provides real-world examples, and includes scholarly notes and references. A landmark publication."--
Library Journal

"Lucidly written....a revolutionary, unifying vision of nature that could impact all branches of science"--
Booklist

"Filled with fascinating observations and brainteasers....gracefully written"--
Macleans

"Presents complex ideas in an understandable context....source of food for thought....interesting....excellent reflection on the history of science."--
Winnipeg Free Press

“DESIGN IN NATURE is an elegant exposition of a unifying principle so simple that it demystifies our comprehension of the "flow" of the universe.  An absorbing and thoughtful account of why nature is designed that way it is; Bejan engages the reader from the very first sentence to last word.”
--
Donald Johanson, Founding Director of the Institute of Human Origins and noted discoverer of "Lucy"

“Why do riverbeds, blood vessels, and lightning bolts all look alike? It’s not a coincidence. This extraordinary book proposes a law of nature whose power is matched only by its simplicity. Everything you lay your eyes on will blow your mind with fresh interpretation.”
David Eagleman, The New York Times bestselling author of INCOGNITO and SUM, and Director of the Laboratory for Perception and Action at the Baylor College of Medicine

“After reading this deeply inspiring and liberating book, you will never look at the world—the whole world—the same again. It not only helps us to better understand the natural environment, but it has profound implications for how we all need to act if we want to sustain success. This perspective is not just for scientists—it helps to reframe agendas for entrepreneurs, business executives, educators, and policy makers. Go with the flow!”
John Hagel, co-author of The Power of Pull, and Co-Chairman of the Deloitte Center for the Edge

“Bejan masterfully unifies—under a deep common law—physics, chemistry, biology, and even part of the social sciences. His treatment of natural design, flow systems, and complex order as spontaneously arising from flow optimization is novel, powerful, and highly plausible.”
Massimo Piattelli-Palmarini, author of What Darwin Got Wrong, and Professor of Cognitive Science at the University of Arizona

“The most amazing thing about life is that it exists at all. The second most amazing thing about life is that living things seem to be so very good at it. In his bold new book Bejan asks why, and his answer cuts to the very core of what life is—organized flows of heat, electricity, matter, and energy. From this deceptively simple idea, Bejan takes us on an incredible expedition through life’s vast scope, from tiniest cell to organism to societies to ecosystems to the entire planet. It is a bracing journey.”
J. Scott Turner, author of The Tinkerer’s Accomplice, and Professor of Biology at SUNY College of Environmental Science and Forestry in Syracuse

“With wide-ranging examples and the iconic pictures to go with them, Bejan illustrates that nature is inherently an outstanding designer of flow configurations, which raises philosophic issues beyond the remit of thermodynamics. Is the distinction between animate and inanimate blurred by their common constructal design? These and many more issues are raised by Bejan’s distinguished and original work, fittingly presented in
Design in Nature.”
Jeffery Lewins, Deputy Praelector at Magdalene College at Cambridge University

“A most stimulating thought principle, framed in a nice and lively personal story. What I really find most exciting is the exceptionally broad perspective that Bejan adopts for developing his concepts.
Design in Nature is a fascinating read.”
Ewald Weibel, Professor Emeritus of Anatomy at the University of Berne

“Thought provoking! Thermodynamics may determine where you’re going; here’s a rule that tells how you get there. And so simple—the more efficient the pathway, the more likely is its persistence, whatever the mechanism behind that persistence. This is science at its biggest and boldest.”
Steven Vogel, author of Cats’ Paws and Catapults, and James B. Duke Professor of Biology at Duke University

Product details

  • Publisher ‏ : ‎ Doubleday; First Edition (January 24, 2012)
  • Language ‏ : ‎ English
  • Hardcover ‏ : ‎ 304 pages
  • ISBN-10 ‏ : ‎ 0385534612
  • ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-0385534611
  • Item Weight ‏ : ‎ 1.35 pounds
  • Dimensions ‏ : ‎ 6.43 x 1.16 x 9.53 inches
  • Customer Reviews:
    4.1 4.1 out of 5 stars 190 ratings

About the authors

Follow authors to get new release updates, plus improved recommendations.

Customer reviews

4.1 out of 5 stars
190 global ratings

Review this product

Share your thoughts with other customers

Customers say

Customers find the book provides a profound sense of intellectual discovery and explores an interesting concept. They appreciate the accessible, detailed explanation and precise language. The book is described as a wonderful, compelling read for all levels of readers. Readers mention it's valuable for understanding design in nature and flow. However, some feel the pacing is repetitive and difficult to keep their interest.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

25 customers mention "Explanation"18 positive7 negative

Customers find the book's explanation accessible and detailed. They appreciate the precise language and thought, which leads to clear concepts. The concept is simple yet intuitive, reminiscent of Plate. It is written as a story for a general audience.

"...In its deceptive simplicity, the Constructal Law is reminiscent of Plate Tectonics, a theory derived from Alfred Wegener's ability to perceive what..." Read more

"...This man is exceptionally precise in language and thought, and that precision leads to clear explanations...." Read more

"...It is likely to stimulate the creativity of other authors and researchers...." Read more

"...the "access to flows" terminology brings with it is vagueness and ambiguity...." Read more

24 customers mention "Insight"24 positive0 negative

Customers find the book provides a profound sense of intellectual discovery. They appreciate the author's exploration of an important concept and new ideas. The book is a source of new ideas and a new way of looking at reality for those with genuine interest in the underpinnings of reality. It is informative and gratifying for those with a genuine interest in the underlayings of reality.

"...over time, provides a big picture of the natural world, intellectually gratifying to seekers after a broader understanding of our origins and..." Read more

"...Bejan and J. Peder Zane, this is probably one of the most important books on the social and political aspects of thermodynamics written in the past..." Read more

"...It's an okay read: get his big idea, which could be a new perspective to the uninitiated, and there's also some good nuggets throughout.***..." Read more

"Some interesting ideas in here but it doesn't seem like the author's premise qualifies as a "Law"...." Read more

19 customers mention "Readability"19 positive0 negative

Customers find the book readable and interesting for all levels. They describe it as a compelling work that explains the operation of the Hubble telescope. Readers mention it's a must-read for physics enthusiasts and those interested in the underpinnings of science.

"Bejan and Zane have written a compelling work, one that displays the thought processes of a beautiful mind in contemplation of a unified theory of..." Read more

"...I have enjoyed the work of Gerald Diamond, in particular, Guns, Germs and Steel, which takes a more geographical approach to our historical narrative..." Read more

"...It's an okay read: get his big idea, which could be a new perspective to the uninitiated, and there's also some good nuggets throughout.***..." Read more

"...in the sciences, the chapter 6 on Hierarchy is an excellent stand alone chapter...." Read more

9 customers mention "Design"9 positive0 negative

Customers find the book's design engaging. They say it explains how nature conforms to the Constructal Law, which is simple yet powerful. The book provides an entertaining introduction to the concept.

"...all, this is a book of theory rather than practice, I find Design in Nature compelling and convincing, with a stunning insight on nearly every page...." Read more

"...an implicit law or potential first principle of nature, the Constructal Law, which describes how the tendency for an increasing and more efficient..." Read more

"...the value of this book is as a source of new ideas and a new way of looking at design...." Read more

"...impact in education, philosophy and many areas, including engineering and design...." Read more

5 customers mention "Flow"5 positive0 negative

Customers find the book's flow interesting. They mention that society itself is a source of flow and contributes to more efficient flows over time. The book teaches about flows in economics, biological systems, flows of information, and ideas. It provides a big picture of how things change to become more efficient.

"...systems acquire configurations that make for easier and more efficient flows over time, provides a big picture of the natural world, intellectually..." Read more

"...we see in nature are the result of a constructal law that favors efficiency of flow. He posits the 3rd law of thermodynamics. &#..." Read more

"...Rivers change to move water efficiently, animals evolve to compete and survive and breed more effectively, human designs change over time to work..." Read more

"...my opinion The James Burke series, Connections, was a better treatment of the flow of ideas...." Read more

8 customers mention "Physics content"5 positive3 negative

Customers have mixed opinions about the physics content. Some find it profound and a fundamental law of physics expressed, while others say there is no rigor in the quantification and the book lacks equations to support the theory.

"...makes the case that adaptation is not confined to biology, and applies to physics. Just so...." Read more

"...7. The book lacks any equations to prop up the theory...." Read more

""Design in Nature" is an inspiring book presenting a new law of physics which teaches about flows...." Read more

"This powerful book is a profound breakthrough that expresses a law of physics so fundamental it's been with us forever but never actually captured..." Read more

7 customers mention "Pacing"0 positive7 negative

Customers find the book's pacing repetitive and boring. They find it hard to keep their interest, with excessive repetition that gets annoying quickly. The style and word choices are not enjoyable for them, making the book seem laughable.

"...Repetition: As my title suggests, the author is seemingly trying to drill his term of "Constructural Law" into your head by massive repetition that..." Read more

"...a "unifying principle for all evolving phenomenon", this book comes off a laughable. What a ridiculously arrogant book. Not recommended." Read more

"...Despite my support, I must add that this book is highly repetitious, if not redundant...." Read more

"This book was very difficult to read and it was hard to keep my interest. I bought this book because it was mentioned in Michio's book...." Read more

4 customers mention "Aggrandizing"0 positive4 negative

Customers find the book self-aggrandizing and arrogant. They say it indulges in generous praise and describing past scientists.

"...What a ridiculously arrogant book. Not recommended." Read more

"...A defect of the book is a tone of grandiosity that detracts more than it adds...." Read more

"...law as a universal all-unifying theory, while indulging in generous helpings of self praise and describing past scientists as having stumbled around..." Read more

"...The book is boring, self-aggrandizing and insufferable. Youtube interview with the first author only confirms the impression from the book...." Read more

Complexity Made Simple
5 out of 5 stars
Complexity Made Simple
I'm not a scientist or academic. My background is being in the trenches of building businesses. So I err on the side of practicality. I've spent decades exploring what makes human organizations thrive. In addition to my professional practice with clients, I've turned over every stone from management protocol, financial ratios, psychology and Leadership theories to Systems Thinking and Complexity Science.This book brought it all together for me and revealed what is outdated and what is relevant. Our understanding of the nature of structure is remiss without The Constructal Law. As the authors explain; "This single law of physics shapes the design of all around us".If you want to make sense of your life, your organization and your world, this book is like the Hubble telescope. Like the law of Gravity, this offers a new lens to understand why the best laid plans often fall off a cliff.Thank you, Adrian Bejan, for dedicating your life to discovering and sharing a remarkably practical way to better understand the power in the path of least resistance. When we value freedom in ourselves and others, flow naturally moves us to new heights.
Thank you for your feedback
Sorry, there was an error
Sorry we couldn't load the review

Top reviews from the United States

  • Reviewed in the United States on May 6, 2012
    Bejan and Zane have written a compelling work, one that displays the thought processes of a beautiful mind in contemplation of a unified theory of the universe. Bejan's Constructal Law, which posits that flow systems acquire configurations that make for easier and more efficient flows over time, provides a big picture of the natural world, intellectually gratifying to seekers after a broader understanding of our origins and evolution. His Law is a corollary of the Second Law of Thermodynamics, which states that temperature, pressure and gases seek equilibrium in a physical system, and thus flow from areas of higher concentration to those of lower concentration.

    This is not, however, a technical work. Design in Nature's crystalline language elucidates for a lay audience Bejan's contention that all of nature, animate and inanimate, conforms to the Constructal Law. Thus we find similarities in the organization of river deltas, pulmonary branching and trees. "Rivers, lightning bolts, trees, and animals are designs that emerge to handle the currents that flow through them and along with them. They do not exist in service to themselves but in service to the global flow. Though we can look at flow systems in isolation, they work hand in glove with all that flows around them, evolving to enhance the movement of everything on Earth."

    For Bejan, the biosphere, atmosphere and hydrosphere are all one integrated system of flows, powered by energy from the sun. This makes evolution purposive, not random, although it is influenced by such apparently random events as the meteorite that exterminated the dinosaurs. Nevertheless, its aim is to improve flows in the course of conforming to the Second Law. The flow that Bejan is primarily concerned with is water: "It's no coincidence that animals hover close to sources of water. Almost all animals are composed mostly of water. You can think of animal mass flow as this mass of water moving across the landscape." And consider this mind-bending notion: Bejan suggests that water does not exist to facilitate the growth of trees, but that trees are pumps to distribute water to the drier atmosphere, as the Second Law would dictate.

    Time after time, Bejan and Zane clarify for us basic physical processes and phenomena that we assume we're familiar with, casting them in a new light. "Consider the snowflake. The prevailing view in science is that the intricate crystals formed by the snowflake have no function. This is wrong. In fact, the snowflake is a flow design for dispersing the heat--called the latent heat of solidification--generated on its surfaces during freezing."

    Reading this book induced in me an almost religious sense of awe. One has the feeling that the real secrets of the universe are being revealed chapter by chapter. And the chapters cover varied aspects of the physical and even cultural worlds: design, evolution, hierarchy, academia, the golden ratio and vision, as well as history. But Bejan makes quite clear from the outset that his "design in nature" has nothing to do with so-called intelligent design. He is talking, rather, about the completely natural forces of physics. One has the feeling that only an engineer could have come up with this theory, one who works with real materials in the real world, yet must employ theory to manipulate them on a broader scale.

    At the same time that I enjoyed the profound sense of intellectual discovery, I couldn't help fearing that a theory as wide-ranging and comprehensive as this one might be a tautology: Everything flows because it flows. I countered this doubt partly with my subjective experience. That awe I spoke of, unique in my fairly wide-ranging reading, I feel could only arise in the presence of a genuine new revelation. The flow of ideas through my mind perhaps seeks out the ease of this new intellectual configuration, as the Constructal Law would predict. More importantly, Bejan has conducted many experiments proving his law and is able to make accurate mathematical predictions using it.

    For example, he describes assigning a computer the task of moving a steady stream of water from a center of a disk to users on the periphery. It came up with the branching pattern observed in river deltas, lungs and trees. He also elucidates the mathematical ratios that operate in rivers and the branching of trees, which obey laws that govern the relationship of the number of tributaries to the main channel, and their relative sizes, as well as the placement of branches and the ratio of branch size to trunk size. Suspending what he knew empirically, he used the Constructal Law to predict these scaling ratios. In its deceptive simplicity, the Constructal Law is reminiscent of Plate Tectonics, a theory derived from Alfred Wegener's ability to perceive what everyone else overlooked or refused to take seriously: that the world's continents fit together like the pieces of a jigsaw puzzle.

    However, in spite of the beauty of Bejan's theory, I find it somewhat lacking with regard to practical environmental concerns. It's strange, in a book written by a heat transfer specialist, not to find a single reference to climate change. After all, both the National Academy of Sciences and the American Association for the Advancement of Science find climate change fully substantiated. Furthermore, Bejan's gleeful endorsement of the notion that man will use more energy, ever more, almost sounds like the academician's version of "Drill, Baby, Drill," although he does make favorable reference to green energy.

    These cavils aside, for after all, this is a book of theory rather than practice, I find Design in Nature compelling and convincing, with a stunning insight on nearly every page. It is a source I expect to reread more than once. Zane's exemplary prose is integral to the successful realization of Bejan's ideas and the impact of this remarkable book.
    8 people found this helpful
    Report
  • Reviewed in the United States on February 5, 2019
    There are, at present, only four laws of thermodynamics acknowledged by science. A recent book, deeply rooted in the four laws but going in a new direction is, Design in Nature: How the Constructal Law Governs Evolution in Biology, Physics, Technology and Social Organization.

    Written by leading thermodynamics theorist Adrian Bejan and J. Peder Zane, this is probably one of the most important books on the social and political aspects of thermodynamics written in the past ten years but for two very different reasons. One: the author brilliantly describes an implicit law or potential first principle of nature, the Constructal Law, which describes how the tendency for an increasing and more efficient movement of mass and energy through time is ruled by a physical law. This, the book asserts, naturally creates many complex designs that we see in nature that do not violate the laws of thermodynamics. The second reason, which is not quite so flattering, is that his book clearly describes the approach of the modern mind—that despite all his arguing to the contrary, points in the direction that consciousness is either a feature of matter and energy or “the designer” cannot be conceived properly using the imagery of Bejan’s schoolboy God.

    Bejan absolutely fails to describe what should be obvious to all but not to those who refuse to look: that the universe is, from the point of view of common sense, not unintelligently self-assembling and that a postulated Fifth Law, negentropy, which assumes some sort of teleology in the universe, really needs to be looked at more closely for a more accurate and scientific accounting of the universe.

    Let’s look closely at what Bejan says:

    “Of course, there is no conscious intelligence behind these patterns, no Divine Architect churning out brilliant blueprints. To pre-empt any confusion, let me make this perfectly clear: The constructal law is not headed toward a creationist argument, and in no way does it support the claims of those who promulgate the fantasy of intelligent design… [How can he possibly know this from a scientific perspective? Better to take a more agnostic and humble position as in: “we don’t know-period”]. Bejan goes on to say: this raises the question: How come? What causes the constructal law? The short answer: we don’t know. The constructal law is what is known in science as a first principle, an idea that cannot be deduced or derived from other laws (if it could, it would be a theorem. It just is—a law of physics that governs the emergence of macroscopic shape and structure in nature. The constructal law tells us why those patterns arise and empowers us to predict how they should change in the future. It reveals that it is not love or money that makes the world go round but flow and design.”

    This is quite amusing from a metaphysical perspective. He knows that intelligent design is a “fantasy” but he doesn’t know why the constructal law works. Just make up first principles and poof—no need to inquire further. This sort of argument, much like natural selection being pimped as the only motor of evolution, is a partial explanation posing as a final theory.

    Entropy does create efficient dispersion patterns from original energy sources, and it is also observably true that all flow systems tend to generate better and more complex conduits for the currents that flow through them due to relational factors such as gravity, pressure, time and temperature. This “tendency” simply described doesn’t tell us why such systems should accumulate ever increasing amounts of energy, but it does very well describe the energy output of vice. The tendency of flow systems towards complex arrangements for dispersal, and even self-organization, does not adequately describe moral and intellectual excellence or the human tendency to invest enormous amounts of energy into beliefs and other systems, except as a kind of contextual background for the way all material things behave. If we took Bejan’s analysis seriously, we would have to conclude that all human activity was simply a way of dispersing excess energy—perhaps more like a complex drainage system than the kind of meaning typically ascribed to human activity. What would be the point of organisms, considered as a whole, to harvest energy in ever more complex ways only to then disperse or get rid of it? There is no sense of teleology in Bejan’s system, although he would probably ascribe such meaning to the complex interplay of various forms of energy. I liken this to showing up at a sumptuous banquet in a palace with thousands of well-dressed guests in attendance and arguing that there is no host.

    The tendency to invest energy into complex systems of machinery and thought might be thought of as being somewhat alien to the constructal law, except by way of appearance, and much more closely related to negentropy or the tendency to wind things up. Note how negative entropy is described in the dictionary: “Negative entropy, or negentropy, roughly refers to the degree of order or organization within a closed system.” That is only part of what negentropy might mean. Here is an alternative scientific opinion.

    “There are, technically speaking, only Four Laws of Thermodynamics but a Fifth Law of Thermodynamics has been proposed by physicist Philip Carr:

    “The missing link in thermodynamics as taught in schools today seems to be a concise explanation of why order and structures abound in a universe purported to be driven by a Second Law [popularly known as the Law of Entropy] that states that disorder increases, always and everywhere. This short note is provided in order to stimulate discussion around a possible Fifth Law which predicts what we observe, which is that order and structures should actually predominate in the world in which we live.” Based on this model and observations the proposed 5th Law of Thermodynamics criticizes the notion of stochastically generated order.

    "An open system containing a large mixture of similar automatons, placed in contact with a non-equilibrated environment, has a finite probability of supporting the spontaneous generation and growth of self-constructing machines of unlimited complexity."

    This proposed Fifth Law of Thermodynamics is also known, in some circles, as negentropy. Negentropy was proposed by the physicist Schrödinger as a kind of free energy that accumulates within systems that store energy but it is facetious to assume that the storage of extra energy might necessarily result in greater order, (and complexity) except by way of increasing the means of storage. The Fifth Law of Thermodynamics supports the notion of creation by an outside force such as the Unmoved Mover or God.

    So, let’s get back to Existence. Existence does NOT exist—it IS. Something that does not exist generates all that exists. Energy and mass exist. Therefore, there are only two possible conclusions regarding origin. One: energy is eternal, and concomitantly, consciousness may only be a higher order feature of energy and mass. This is the position of an elevated atheism. Two: all that exists depends on something that does not exist. This is the philosophical and metaphysical explanation of Aristotle and St. Thomas Aquinas that leaves the door open to providence, grace, honor and beauty. The former is a closed universe going nowhere. When you die you return to energy for re-cycling. End of story. The world of negentropy preserves a universe where honor, beauty and goodness are desirable for more than just subjective reasons. Where is the goodness and beauty in the cold atheism of abortion or the moral weirdness of sexual perversion? The desire for a stochastic or randomly generated universe is a moral-free universe from the perspective of objective morality. A stochastic universe fits the process morality of pure subjectivity and is the universal choice of moralists on the left. Make no mistake about it. The present political tension in the US is really about atheistic morality versus the flawed but traditional morality of the Founders. Conservatives, for all their faults, tend to support the intent of the Founders. What the left thinks it is supporting, in regards to many issues, is nothing but entropy in the guise of concern.

    Throw a set of marbles down and watch them roll. They will describe a random pattern of energy dispersion based on various resistances of friction, gravity, direction, etc. What the pattern does not tell you is who threw the marbles.

    For a more interesting analysis of causality than that implicitly presented by Bejan, turn to God Has Skin in the Game: How a New Understanding of Politics and the Soul Could Change America by Sean O'Reilly
    28 people found this helpful
    Report

Top reviews from other countries

Translate all reviews to English
  • P. Jung
    5.0 out of 5 stars This is huge!
    Reviewed in Germany on April 21, 2024
    If you want to understand the world surrounding you from a fundamental physical perspective, no other book will give you such a complete account as this one.

    Why does structure arise despite the second law of thermodynamics? This seeming contradiction, that probably cost Boltzmann‘s life, is being resolved by Bejan in the most elegant, complete and profound manner yet, building on and transcending Prigogine‘s work.

    Of course many scientists won‘t like these ideas, because the constructal law’s explanatory power is far superior to their pet framework their job depends on.

    After this book, I believe Bejan will eventually get his place in the pantheon of greatest scientists of the world. This would be well deserved.
  • Yuri Theodoro Barbosa de Lima
    5.0 out of 5 stars Very good
    Reviewed in Brazil on March 24, 2018
    The book is incredible, the constructal law is easy to see in all places, and the possibiliti of application of the cobstructal theory la incredibile
    One person found this helpful
    Report
  • R.Ramachandran
    5.0 out of 5 stars A Should Read For Students Of Physics,Biology, History And Culture.
    Reviewed in India on January 20, 2018
    This is a very good book on the constructal law, which is a law of physics on the “design” phenomena in nature. It explains the evolution of culture too and I think it is a good tool to understand all such cultural vagaries. Phenomena of creativity, science, technology, networks, hierarchy and communication are evolutionary by default. The features of such constructal designs are well approached through this law to be understood in a new light. Culture and the evolution of culture are brought to light to be understood as manifestations of the phenomenon of design generation and that of the ever-present evolution. Adrian Bejan has done wonderfully to define the law and illuminate it beautifully.
    A book worth reading. I will strongly recommend it to students of Physics, Biology, History and Culture.
    One person found this helpful
    Report
  • Fabrice Vanden Broeck
    5.0 out of 5 stars Qué conecta los patrones en la Naturaleza entre sí?
    Reviewed in Mexico on April 5, 2017
    Extraordinariamente acertada e innovadora teoría unificadora sobre las formas en la Naturaleza. De aquí se deriva la logica que explica los patrones como la Esfera, la Espiral, el.Meandro y desfe luego, la Ramificación y su correlación.
    One person found this helpful
    Report
  • Hervé
    2.0 out of 5 stars A very personal theory book about flow in all domains
    Reviewed in France on August 18, 2012
    The good side of this book is that it can wake you up, if you like design.
    The bad side is, I'm afraid to say, much bigger.
    Reading the book you feel that the author needs to justify himself two times per page about how good the constructal law is.
    No fondamental proof is given about the fact that constructal law governs the Universe (yes, not less than the universe see page 16). Other explanations (minimum energy,..) are set aside in one page, Nobel scientists do not understand anything,... and so on. Only Bejan has understood everything. This is not science.
    If I use Mr Bejan's own flow theory to analyse his own book, I see in his "select bibliography":
    - 85% of the books are his own or co-author books
    - 13% is about heat transfert (Bejan's speciality, real science)
    Not much opposition or "natural" information flow indeed in this bibliography.

    A big mistake page p92 and p93, no fish lifts his own weight has it travels . If friction is 0, hydrodynamics says that there is no efforts. This is not acceptable in a book of somebody who tells that its vision will revolutionize knowledge