Amazon Vehicles Beauty Return your textbook rentals STEM nav_sap_plcc_ascpsc Starting at $39.99 Wickedly Prime Handmade Wedding Shop Book House Cleaning americangods americangods americangods  Introducing Echo Show All-New Fire HD 8 Kids Edition, starting at $129.99 Kindle Oasis Trade it in. Fund the next. Shop Now toystl17_gno

Your rating(Clear)Rate this item

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

Showing 1-10 of 225 reviews(Verified Purchases). See all 314 reviews
on February 24, 2012
This is a solid read, and a promising start to a detective series that I'll probably try more of in the future. It's a hardboiled mystery, but generally avoids feeling too much like a cliche by using characters with a little more complexity than your typical crime fiction. The meticulous attention to historical detail adds a level of realism to the book. If it errs anywhere, it may be in cramming in so many historical references. By the last third of the novel, some of the celebrity cameos start to feel forced, in spite of the fact that, yes, they could have been around in that region at that time. A couple times I felt as if chapters existed mainly to spotlight the tremendous amount of research that must have gone into this book, but for the most part, the narrative still moves along quickly. If you like classic detective fiction, you should enjoy it.
0Comment| 31 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
True Detective is the first novel in the Nathan Heller series from Max Allan Collins, written in first person giving it a real noir feel and with many historical details adding to the realism of the story. It sets the stage for further Heller novels, describing how Heller chooses to leave the Chicago police force and strike out on his own as a private investigator, and takes the reader through several cases Heller takes on as his new career begins.

True Detective won the 1984 Shamus Award for Best P.I. Hardcover from the Private Eye Writers of America. Collins has followed this novel with 14 (soon to be 15) further novels and several short story collections featuring Heller.

I found this to be a very enjoyable read. Heller is a personality who has enough flaws to be believable but remain sympathetic. He's left the police force because of his unwillingness to be a party to the corruption that exists there, but he doesn't mind a certain amount of involvement with criminals himself as he finds his way as a PI. The relationship he has with Eliot Ness is is interesting, and Collins also sprinkles other real-life characters throughout the story, including an appearance by a young Ronald Reagan, who is working as a radio sports announcer, during Heller's visit to his girlfriends hometown, Franklin Roosevelt, Al Capone, and others.

Collins does not incorporate excessive violence (there is actually very little), profanity (some, probably appropriate to the era which was seemingly more polite than our society today), or sex (a small amount but tastefully handled) into his story. The plot is propelled by the strength of the personality of the characters and the drama of the story line. Black and white photos are sprinkled throughout the novel - they don't come through with very much detail or clarity on an e-ink Kindle (I do my reading on a Voyage or PaperWhite model) and are better when viewed on an iPad or Kindle Fire, but as the photos are real period black and white relics the poor quality actually adds to the period feel of the book, which is probably intentional.

It's a very satisfying read, and I plan to explore the further Heller novels as a result.

For those interested, here are the Nathan Heller novels in the order of their appearance (links are to the kindle versions available here on Amazon - see comment to this review for the links not shown below since Amazon limits reviews to 10 links maximum):


1. True Detective (November 1983)
2. True Crime (December 1984)
3. The Million-Dollar Wound (February 1986)
4. Neon Mirage (February 1988)
5. Stolen Away (May 1991)
6. Carnal Hours (April 1994)
7. Blood and Thunder (August 1995) (about Huey Long's assassination)
8. Damned in Paradise (October 1996)
9. Flying Blind (August 1998)
10. Majic Man (September, 1999)
11. Angel in Black (March 2001)
12. Chicago Confidential (June 2002)
13. Bye Bye, Baby (August 2011)
14. Target Lancer (November 2012)
15. Ask Not (October 2013)
16. Better Dead (not yet published, but Collins has mentioned on his website that it is now complete and so I assume it will be released later in 2015)

(A couple of the novels listed above are incorrectly numbered here on Amazon. I am 100% sure this listing is correct as I referred to both the wiki article on Collins as well as his own website to check the information and order of publication before finalizing here)

Short Stories and novellas:

- Dying in the Post-War World (October 1991) - Novella and short story collection (not available in Kindle edition. The novella Dying in the Post-War World appears in the later collection Triple Play, and the other short stories are included in the later collection "Chicago Lightning")
- Kisses of Death: A Nathan Heller Casebook (June 2001) - Short story collection
- Chicago Lightning: The Collected Nathan Heller Short Stories (October 2011)
- Triple Play: A Nathan Heller Casebook (April 2012) - Includes "Dying in the Post-War World", "Kisses of Death", and "Strike Zone"

For the fan wanting to have all of the Heller stories, they can all now be obtained for the Kindle. In addition to the novels, simply obtain the Chicago Lightning and Triple Play collections, and you've got it all.
11 comment| 3 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on October 23, 2013
Our story opens in December 1932, and our hero is Nate Heller. He's a Chicago cop, and as Chicago cops go, he's an honest one. "Which means anywhere else, I'd be in for twenty years," Heller says at one point. It's true: he takes the occasional bribe, and rumour has it he sleeps around. One day, while Heller is off-duty, he's picked up by Harry Lang and Harry Miller, two brutish cops who act like Mayor Anton Cermak's unofficial Brute Squad. They take him along for a police raid on an operation run by Frank Nitti, Al Capone's successor. Only it turns out to be an assassination attempt, as Lang shoots Nitti in the back. Things get a bit out of hand, and in the ensuing melee, Heller guns down one of the gangsters.

The dead man was a nobody, an orphan from the old country. But the death bothers Heller. He was brought into the raid unawares, and he resents it. He helped cover something up in the past, and so now cops like Lang and Miller think he'll help them clean up any dirty work. Heller isn't perfect, but he has some standards. He's the best of a rotten bunch, if you will. So the long and short of it is, he quits the force and decides to go into business for himself as a private eye. And thus begins the complex plot web that forms "True Detective".

This is a *stunning* novel. I was absolutely floored by it. I enjoyed every single page. The true genius of True Detective is that Nate Heller is not just running around with famous historical figures like Elliot Ness: he's also investigating real-life crimes. The beauty of it all is, fact and fiction are blended together so neatly that I couldn't tell where fact ended and where fiction began. And even when I knew what was going to happen, such as in the scene in Miami, I found myself on the edge of my seat, wondering how it would all end.

The plot is well-done. It's a complex plot web with a satisfying resolution. Heller investigates multiple cases throughout the book, and at the end you feel they've all come to a close. The story is exciting, full of action and suspense. I *really* liked the ending, though I don't want to specify why. Oh, and there's plenty of sex. It's used wisely, to develop Heller's character, and it isn't as explicit as it could have been. In fact, let me linger on this whole sex issue for a bit. One of the most famous scenes in Raymond Chandler's "The Big Sleep" occurs when Carmen Sternwood shows up at Marlowe's house, naked, giggling, and perfectly willing. (I personally hate this scene, but it's been influential.) Despite having made out with her and every other woman in the book, Marlowe refuses to sleep with her and boots her out. Heller is not quite as stoic as Marlowe, and faced with the same situation, he probably would have succumbed to temptation and deflowered the girl. He's no knight in shining armour - his armour is tarnished, but compared to the other people in this novel, it's positively pristine. Heller isn't perfect and he knows it, but he tries, and that's what makes him a hero in my eyes.

The character of Nate Heller is one of the things that justify this book's length--the print edition runs to 480 pages. In my opinion, far too many books nowadays are bloated beyond all belief, but this book never *feels* padded. Heller is a fascinating character and I was genuinely interested in his moral dilemmas, his love life, and his family history. This includes his father's suicide, a tragic moment, especially when we find out why he did it that way. It's every bit as fascinating as the plot, which is fairly complex but which, on its own, mightn't even fit 300 pages.

Heller's narrative voice is also great, and he manages to sound tough without swearing constantly. I'm annoyed by characters whose mother tongue seems to be Profanity, but Heller isn't like that. He says the F word on more than one occasion in the novel, and it isn't censored. But these work--they're at highly-charged emotional moments where "Darn it!" just wouldn't cut it. And back in the 1930s, such an expletive had quite a bit of shock value, a detail that Collins doesn't forget.

Overall, Max Allan Collins' "True Detective" is a stunning achievement. I'm positively floored by it. The plot is terrific, and the main character of Nate Heller is fascinating. He's tough, he's sensitive. He takes bribes. He sleeps around. He isn't perfect, but he's the best we've got. Collins' style is excellent and keeps you invested in the book easily, despite its length. The book's conclusion is brilliant in its own way. And somehow, Collins manages all this with real historical figures and real historical crimes.

[This review was adapted from a review posted on my blog, At the Scene of the Crime, on 20/10/2012.]
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on March 15, 2017
When I started reading this novel, I was immediately caught by the tone and aura of the writing style which draws the reader immediately of those old film noir flicks many of us grew up with - Humphrey bogart, George raft, etc. But as the story progressed, the attention to historical detail intertwined with a very well woven plot, became more and more impressive. I was pleasantly surprised and absolutely this book. Looking forward to reading more of this author.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on January 24, 2012
Nathan Heller is a private detective in the Sam Spade/Philip Marlowe mold (perhaps a little more morally ambiguous than they), and he works in the same milieu, on the shady side of the street. The first book in the series takes place mostly in the corrupt political world of 1930s Chicago and features various contemporary events and personalities that Collins manages to work in fairly smoothly without it seeming like too much of a checklist (a famous boxer, two iconic mob bosses, a couple of American presidents at different stages in their careers, a couple of second-line movie actors ditto, and of course Eliot Ness, who feels more real here than he does in any of his film/TV incarnations). Not on a par with Hammett or Chandler but certainly in the same neighborhood. When I read a historical novel (straight, mystery, alternate history, etc.), I like to learn things I didn't know as well as enjoy the story as story. And the things I learn had better be reasonably accurate because I WILL look things up. And I did learn quite a bit. There's some interpretation here, of course, but it's at least credible. All in all, I enjoyed the ride, and I'm glad AmazonEncore acquired this series and is promoting it (largely through discount pricing).
0Comment| 7 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on March 16, 2014
A realistic trip back in time to the Capone/Nitti era of the Chicago of the early 1930's. Told in first person by fictional Chicago cop turned detective, Nate Heller, it reveals the slimy underbelly of the city in vivid detail. Cops on the make, politicians on the take, and not even your own cookie baking grandma can be trusted!

Heller meets Al Capone and Frank Nitti face to face,watches helplessly as Chicago's Mayor Cermak takes a bullet for Prez Elect FDR in Miami Beach on February 15,1933.. Or was Cermak the true target? History unwinds here through the 1933 Worlds Fair, run by ex VP Charles Dawes, who's got some shaky background of his own to keep covered up.

All in all, quite a roller coaster ride, with great 1930's period settings. For a time you are transported back to this startling era in America, with the Depression, the hopelessness, the lawlessness, and yet at the end, the hope of a better day tomorrow.
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on November 15, 2014
I'll keep this short because I want to get reading my next Nate Heller mystery "True Crimes".

I had never heard of Max Allan Collins until I read one of his mysteries last week. I enjoyed it so much, I downloaded this book, "True Detective", and was not disappointed.

His characters are well-fleshed, including Nate Heller and the other fictional characters needed to round out the plot. His dialogue is believable, given the true-to-life personalities of each character he has created. The mobsters, Nitti, etc., are treated fairly. Collins shows them with all their cruelties, greed and avarice exposed. He also takes the time to expose those moments of humanity, which even the most evil individuals can express. That one spark of "something" that for whatever reason turns off the mobster facility and turns on the protector wanting to do "something right" for someone wronged with no pay-back required.

I was worried when I started the book that the author might have decided to "tweek" Nate Heller in some way, if he didn't' trust the winsome PI's believability. Man was I relieved when the opposite was true. My now favorite PI came back and just lived and moved on through the high times and bad times of mob controlled Chicago. His wit and intelligence remained intact and again served him well in tight spots.

To prove I'm hooked, I even enjoyed reading his list of published reference materials and now wish to read some of those as well.

Please give this author a read. I believe you will find him as enjoyable and addicting (in a good way) as I have.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on October 21, 2016
Awesome historical detail greatly enriches this kick-off novel to the Nathan Heller Series.

I think this book would especially appeal to those interested in classic hard-boiled detectives stories, old time prohibition era gangster crime, and Chicago nostalgia.

It would appeal less to those most interested in a plot driven story filled with lots of suspense and action. What I mean is that the author takes his time here to really flesh-out the historical context and setting of this story. This slows the pace of the story or greatly enriches it depending on your point of view.

I enjoyed it immensely and have started the next book in the series.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on November 21, 2016
This was well written with a good plot. The fictional main character interacted well with historical figures. Most of the dialogue was believable. My only complaint was how the author integrated some of his considerable historic research. There were too many incidental facts dropped into the story by the protagonist even though it is unlikely he would have known (or cared) about them (e.g. "this was the second largest one in the world"). I enjoyed the author's working with the unproven theory that the assassination was not an attempt on Roosevelt. I will likely read others by this author.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on August 10, 2016
Excellent book. I can't remember how I stumbled on this book and author, but I'm glad I did. The book is set in 1930s Chicago. The protagonist is a cop who ultimately gives up his badge and becomes a private detective. The author is an excellent writer and did a great job of research about the era and the people who were in the headlines in Chicago during that era. The author is a real pro. I'm surprised I hadn't heard of him previously. Anyway, I enjoyed him and the book so much, I immediately bought and started another one of his books. I give it a strong recommendation if you like historical fiction.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse