Gr 4-7-Simon hasn't been the same since he looked into Mr. Hawkins's antique mirror. When unnerving visions and a confounding new illness leave Simon feeling inexplicably changed, he begins hunting down answers. Mr. Hawkins, once an archeologist, discloses that ancient Egyptian people used to believe mirrors could capture a person's soul. Now, Simon finds himself having to quickly solve a puzzle that involves the ancient mirror and his mysterious new neighbor before his visions get worse. Bedard's story is an intriguing premise that doesn't quite hit its mark. The canny reader will notice that the simplistic characters are not in a contemporary setting, but might have a difficult time placing them properly in the 1980s from the scant references (such as Jesse Barfield and transistor radios). Simon's promising mission to uncover the mystery of the Egyptian mirror is bogged down by drawn-out chapters where time flies (months pass); yet the narrative yields little progress because of his illness. Throughout the majority of the novel, the reader believes Simon's illness has a supernatural origin. However, he's diagnosed with chronic fatigue syndrome right at the novel's conclusion, something that deserves to be explored in depth or reworked entirely to suit the historical, supernatural theme. VERDICT What should be a dark, exciting mystery is overshadowed with a lackluster narrative, providing an adequate but humdrum tale.-Emily Walker, Lisle Lib. Dist., ILα(c) Copyright 2011. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Praise for The Egyptian Mirror
“The place and setting are strongly developed as each clue quietly builds to a suspenseful climax, and the slow pace contributes to an old-fashioned feel....A quiet story for patient readers.”―Kirkus Reviews
“Bedard's story has an intriguing premise.”―School Library Journal
“Do you enjoy stories with a hint of dark magic, spells that threaten to trap you into a world of ancient sorcery? Then The Egyptian Mirror by acclaimed Toronto author Michael Bedard is the book for you.”―Winnipeg Free Press
About the Author
Michael Bedard is a multi-award-winning author of middle-grade and young-adult novels that blend his love of literature with a flair for the ominous. His novels include A Darker Magic, The Green Man, and Redwork, which won the Governor General’s Literary Award and the CLA Book of the Year Award for Children. Michael was born and raised in Toronto, where he still lives.