Buy new:
-20% $21.53
FREE delivery Thursday, October 24 on orders shipped by Amazon over $35
Ships from: Amazon.com
Sold by: Amazon.com
$21.53 with 20 percent savings
List Price: $26.99
The List Price is the suggested retail price of a new product as provided by a manufacturer, supplier, or seller. Except for books, Amazon will display a List Price if the product was purchased by customers on Amazon or offered by other retailers at or above the List Price in at least the past 90 days. List prices may not necessarily reflect the product's prevailing market price.
Learn more
Get Fast, Free Shipping with Amazon Prime FREE Returns
FREE delivery Thursday, October 24 on orders shipped by Amazon over $35
Or Prime members get FREE delivery Tomorrow, October 20. Order within 13 hrs 41 mins.
Only 9 left in stock (more on the way).
$$21.53 () Includes selected options. Includes initial monthly payment and selected options. Details
Price
Subtotal
$$21.53
Subtotal
Initial payment breakdown
Shipping cost, delivery date, and order total (including tax) shown at checkout.
Ships from
Amazon.com
Ships from
Amazon.com
Sold by
Amazon.com
Sold by
Amazon.com
Returns
30-day refund/replacement
30-day refund/replacement
This item can be returned in its original condition for a full refund or replacement within 30 days of receipt.
Returns
30-day refund/replacement
This item can be returned in its original condition for a full refund or replacement within 30 days of receipt.
Payment
Secure transaction
Your transaction is secure
We work hard to protect your security and privacy. Our payment security system encrypts your information during transmission. We don’t share your credit card details with third-party sellers, and we don’t sell your information to others. Learn more
Payment
Secure transaction
We work hard to protect your security and privacy. Our payment security system encrypts your information during transmission. We don’t share your credit card details with third-party sellers, and we don’t sell your information to others. Learn more
$12.93
Get Fast, Free Shipping with Amazon Prime FREE Returns
FREE delivery Thursday, October 24 on orders shipped by Amazon over $35
Or Prime members get FREE delivery Monday, October 21. Order within 12 hrs 26 mins.
Only 1 left in stock - order soon.
$$21.53 () Includes selected options. Includes initial monthly payment and selected options. Details
Price
Subtotal
$$21.53
Subtotal
Initial payment breakdown
Shipping cost, delivery date, and order total (including tax) shown at checkout.
Access codes and supplements are not guaranteed with used items.
Kindle app logo image

Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.

Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.

Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.

QR code to download the Kindle App

Follow the author

Something went wrong. Please try your request again later.

The Forgotten Man: A New History of the Great Depression Hardcover – Illustrated, June 12, 2007

4.4 4.4 out of 5 stars 1,593 ratings

{"desktop_buybox_group_1":[{"displayPrice":"$21.53","priceAmount":21.53,"currencySymbol":"$","integerValue":"21","decimalSeparator":".","fractionalValue":"53","symbolPosition":"left","hasSpace":false,"showFractionalPartIfEmpty":true,"offerListingId":"2KB4j%2BDclESYRegu75Jr0He3DrK%2Bpocpdnr%2FbBRuUW11PHoU2lB7rSF6GMQs9IisWd6n9Kk5PXCDRl4Ckkm3hyfUIFExQHOGzpbe6o9eeoRDIPn2JeRdUfCjmqmTw8FNLuqs4w%2FC3Zg%3D","locale":"en-US","buyingOptionType":"NEW","aapiBuyingOptionIndex":0}, {"displayPrice":"$12.93","priceAmount":12.93,"currencySymbol":"$","integerValue":"12","decimalSeparator":".","fractionalValue":"93","symbolPosition":"left","hasSpace":false,"showFractionalPartIfEmpty":true,"offerListingId":"2KB4j%2BDclESYRegu75Jr0He3DrK%2Bpocp0kT1GnBN2%2Bd4kU3Ou%2Bf%2BtDRy12HXEwVs3u1Z7ZklQ4508Yj4UXsp3%2BBx%2F3ziGUcVbsFZhqp0hpX2Ua%2FCuwqMWkxJJJwbB0ByQz14lWtOZFpA9ZxuFGJamhCVka1O7NCddXWcd9oarCuvvUB91boZ74V6cwSU1%2BG8","locale":"en-US","buyingOptionType":"USED","aapiBuyingOptionIndex":1}]}

Purchase options and add-ons

It's difficult today to imagine how America survived the Great Depression. Only through the stories of the common people who struggled during that era can we really understand how the nation endured. These are the people at the heart of Amity Shlaes's insightful and inspiring history of one of the most crucial events of the twentieth century.

In The Forgotten Man, Amity Shlaes, one of the nation's most respected economic commentators, offers a striking reinterpretation of the Great Depression. Rejecting the old emphasis on the New Deal, she turns to the neglected and moving stories of individual Americans, and shows how through brave leadership they helped establish the steadfast character we developed as a nation. Some of those figures were well known, at least in their day—Andrew Mellon, the Greenspan of the era; Sam Insull of Chicago, hounded as a scapegoat. But there were also unknowns: the Schechters, a family of butchers in Brooklyn who dealt a stunning blow to the New Deal; Bill W., who founded Alcoholics Anonymous in the name of showing that small communities could help themselves; and Father Divine, a black charismatic who steered his thousands of followers through the Depression by preaching a Gospel of Plenty.

Shlaes also traces the mounting agony of the New Dealers themselves as they discovered their errors. She shows how both Presidents Hoover and Roosevelt failed to understand the prosperity of the 1920s and heaped massive burdens on the country that more than offset the benefit of New Deal programs. The real question about the Depression, she argues, is not whether Roosevelt ended it with World War II. It is why the Depression lasted so long. From 1929 to 1940, federal intervention helped to make the Depression great—in part by forgetting the men and women who sought to help one another.

Authoritative, original, and utterly engrossing, The Forgotten Man offers an entirely new look at one of the most important periods in our history. Only when we know this history can we understand the strength of American character today.


The Amazon Book Review
The Amazon Book Review
Book recommendations, author interviews, editors' picks, and more. Read it now.

Frequently bought together

This item: The Forgotten Man: A New History of the Great Depression
$21.53
Get it as soon as Thursday, Oct 24
Only 9 left in stock (more on the way).
Ships from and sold by Amazon.com.
+
$19.38
Get it Oct 25 - Nov 1
Only 1 left in stock - order soon.
Ships from and sold by Rich Lutfiye.
+
$17.59
Get it as soon as Thursday, Oct 24
In Stock
Ships from and sold by Amazon.com.
Total price: $00
To see our price, add these items to your cart.
Details
Added to Cart
spCSRF_Treatment
Some of these items ship sooner than the others.
Choose items to buy together.

Editorial Reviews

From Publishers Weekly

This breezy narrative comes from the pen of a veteran journalist and economics reporter. Rather than telling a new story, she tells an old one (scarcely lacking for historians) in a fresh way. Shlaes brings to the tale an emphasis on economic realities and consequences, especially when seen from the perspective of monetarist theory, and a focus on particular individuals and events, both celebrated and forgotten (at least relatively so). Thus the spotlight plays not only on Andrew Mellon, Wendell Wilkie and Rexford Tugwell but also on Father Divine and the Schechter brothers—kosher butcher wholesalers prosecuted by the federal National Recovery Administration for selling "sick chickens." As befits a former writer for the Wall Street Journal, Shlaes is sensitive to the dangers of government intervention in the economy—but also to the danger of the government's not intervening. In her telling, policymakers of the 1920s weren't so incompetent as they're often made out to be—everyone in the 1930s was floundering and all made errors—and WWII, not the New Deal, ended the Depression. This is plausible history, if not authoritative, novel or deeply analytical. It's also a thoughtful, even-tempered corrective to too often unbalanced celebrations of FDR and his administration's pathbreaking policies. 16 pages of b&w photos. (June 12)
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.

From Booklist

Its duration and depth made the Depression "Great," and Shlaes, a prominent conservative economics journalist, considers why a decade of government intervention ameliorated but never tamed it. With vitality uncommon for an economics history, Shlaes chronicles the projects of Herbert Hoover and Franklin Roosevelt as well as these projects' effect on those who paid for them. Reminding readers that the reputedly do-nothing Hoover pulled hard on the fiscal levers (raising tariffs, increasing government spending), Shlaes nevertheless emphasizes that his enthusiasm for intervention paled against the ebullient FDR's glee in experimentation. She focuses closely on the influence of his fabled Brain Trust, her narrative shifting among Raymond Moley, Rexford Tugwell, and other prominent New Dealers. Businesses that litigated their resistance to New Deal regulations attract Shlaes' attention, as do individuals who coped with the despair of the 1930s through self-help, such as Alcoholics Anonymous cofounder Bill Wilson. The book culminates in the rise of Wendell Willkie, and Shlaes' accent on personalities is an appealing avenue into her skeptical critique of the New Deal. Gilbert Taylor
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved

Product details

  • Publisher ‏ : ‎ Harper; Illustrated edition (June 12, 2007)
  • Language ‏ : ‎ English
  • Hardcover ‏ : ‎ 480 pages
  • ISBN-10 ‏ : ‎ 0066211700
  • ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-0066211701
  • Item Weight ‏ : ‎ 1.5 pounds
  • Dimensions ‏ : ‎ 6 x 1.49 x 9 inches
  • Customer Reviews:
    4.4 4.4 out of 5 stars 1,593 ratings

About the author

Follow authors to get new release updates, plus improved recommendations.
Amity Shlaes
Brief content visible, double tap to read full content.
Full content visible, double tap to read brief content.

Amity Shlaes is proud to announce the publication of GREAT SOCIETY: A NEW HISTORY (HarperCollins). Many readers will remember THE FORGOTTEN MAN, a history of the 1930s. This book is the sequel, treating the Great Society programs of the 1960s, as well as the underdescribed efforts of the private sector-- far more important than we remember.

Miss Shlaes is the author of four New York Times bestsellers, COOLIDGE, THE FORGOTTEN MAN, THE FORGOTTEN MAN/GRAPHIC and THE GREEDY HAND.

Miss Shlaes chairs the board of the Calvin Coolidge Presidential Foundation. She chairs the Hayek Prize, a prize for free market books given by the Manhattan Institute.

She is a presidential scholar at the Kings College/New York.

Miss Shlaes has been the recipient of the Hayek Prize, the Frederic Bastiat Prize of the International Policy Network, the Warren Brookes Prize (2008) of the American Legislative Exchange Council, as well as being a two-time finalist for the Loeb Prize (Anderson School/UCLA).

She is a magna cum laude graduate of Yale College and did graduate work at the Freie Universitaet Berlin on a DAAD fellowship. She and her husband, the editor and author Seth Lipsky, have four children.

Customer reviews

4.4 out of 5 stars
1,593 global ratings

Customers say

Customers find the book valuable, fun to read, and worth their time. They also appreciate the compelling insights and fine information on how we got to where we are today. Readers describe the history as interesting and engrossing. Opinions are mixed on the pacing, with some finding it well-written and easy to follow, while others say it's difficult to follow.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

211 customers mention "Readability"193 positive18 negative

Customers find the book valuable, fun to read, and worth their time. They say it keeps their interest through every page. Readers also mention the textures of the 1930s come delightfully alive in the book.

"...It is very well written, lively, interesting, witty, and a source of knowledge not covered this thoroughly elsewhere...." Read more

"...1940 presidential candidate; it's all there and it's a great story that reads like today...." Read more

"...That brief section is well worth reading and it is a pity Schlaes did not put much more similar analysis throughout the text...." Read more

"...It was well worth my struggle." Read more

181 customers mention "Insight"159 positive22 negative

Customers find the insight compelling and fine. They say it's a wonderful book on a very important subject that brings it to life. Readers also mention the book provides an important viewpoint that is essential in coming to their conclusions. They appreciate the remarkable level of detail and openness about the Great Depression.

"...It is very well written, lively, interesting, witty, and a source of knowledge not covered this thoroughly elsewhere...." Read more

"...As I said, this simple fellow enjoyed the book. I found it stimulating, contained good (excellent) prose, and provided me with plenty of opportunity..." Read more

"...Yes, the story is old and told many times in many ways. But this book brings it to life. Not just FDR and Hoover and the major players...." Read more

"...Most provocative and compelling is the insight and comparisons to the economic conditions in which the U.S. Economy finds itself today...." Read more

108 customers mention "History quality"97 positive11 negative

Customers find the history quality of the book interesting. They say it provides an account of some key players in business. Readers also mention the book is engrossing and compelling. They appreciate the relevant information of that time and the counter-narrative to the mainstream hive mind view that FDR could not do anything.

"...Incorporates lots of historical facts, names and some figures, but manages to do so with sufficient elan and flow, that 'readability' remains of a..." Read more

"...There are some enjoyable snippets of gossip, such as Roger Baldwin's unintendedly funny comment about the Soviet Union under Stalin: "There is much..." Read more

"...Most provocative and compelling is the insight and comparisons to the economic conditions in which the U.S. Economy finds itself today...." Read more

"...I have no doubt that most readers will find Ms. Shlaes narrative quite convincing...." Read more

12 customers mention "Look"12 positive0 negative

Customers find the book interesting and excellent. They appreciate the portraits of some key characters of the time. Readers also say the author has done a great job illustrating in detail the political and economic impact.

"...of FDR or of the New Deal but my take on this book is that it offers a balanced look at the multitude of factors surrounding Roosevelt, his advisors..." Read more

"...The book is a breeze to read and serves as a refreshing look at the well intentioned policies that help prolong and strengthen the severity of the..." Read more

"...Nonetheless, the book is a fascinating look at the politics of the Great Depression and how they impacted the country...." Read more

"...There are also interesting portraits of some of the key characters of the time, such as former treasury secretary Andrew Mellon, Chicago utility..." Read more

11 customers mention "Character development"8 positive3 negative

Customers find the book's character development detailed and balanced. They say it explores the real contributions of individual leaders. Readers also mention the author is an excellent historian and writer.

"...Forgotten Man" is a detailed account of the main characters and various federal programs they dreamed up and implemented...." Read more

"Amity Shlaes is an excellent historian and writer. I enjoyed her biography of Coolidge and I enjoyed this wonderful history...." Read more

"...If I had a complaint it would the number of names to keep up with." Read more

"Schlaes does a fair and balanced job of portraying the people, policies and politics that figured prominently in the Great Depression, sparing..." Read more

8 customers mention "Illuminating content"8 positive0 negative

Customers find the content illuminating and eye-opening. They say it allows them to see the bigger picture and provides an excellent background for a misunderstood period of history.

"Excellent background for a misunderstood period of history...." Read more

"...It is well written and allows the reader to see the bigger picture of what is really taking place in our economy!..." Read more

"...never liked history in my younger years this was one of the most powerfully illuminating books that I have ever read...." Read more

"...History can be a dry, sterile read but this book makes it come alive with brevity. It doesn't drag on...." Read more

135 customers mention "Pacing"90 positive45 negative

Customers have mixed opinions about the pacing of the book. Some mention it's well-written and an easy read, while others say it can be difficult to follow and has no theoretical guidance or coherence.

"...It is very well written, lively, interesting, witty, and a source of knowledge not covered this thoroughly elsewhere...." Read more

"...I found it stimulating, contained good (excellent) prose, and provided me with plenty of opportunity to see different points of view...." Read more

"...But the program proved so difficult that FDR penned a letter to the IRS telling them the form was so impossible to figure out that he didn't know..." Read more

"...The writing here is engaging, and it does flow well...." Read more

6 customers mention "Effectiveness"3 positive3 negative

Customers have mixed opinions about the effectiveness of the book. Some mention it's very effective and one of the best works covering the Great Depression, while others say it's unpredictable and unfulfilling.

"...This was very effective and resulted in the roaring 20's. Hoover thought he was smart enough to "fix" the economy and caused the depression...." Read more

"...Utopian socialism won't work if history is any guide...." Read more

"...of the Roosevelt era compares as well as the effectiveness of policy results are apparent." Read more

"...And again it is failing, and extending or exacerbating our economic recession...." Read more

Top reviews from the United States

Reviewed in the United States on October 22, 2012
I read this book back in 2008 as a requisite for better understanding the Great Recession that was just getting started. Prior to this, my thinking was primarily influenced by what I had learned in high school and college history classes. Our school learning basically tells us that despite the great and noble effort by FDR, the depression was so bad that it defied any cure, and the only thing that could cure it was a world conflagration. So the question on my mind in '08 was, is it necessary to repeat this same history? Are we destined to suffer a full decade of miserable economic performance and to have it capped by a world on fire? Wouldn't it be better if we all took a more exhaustive look at history in order to avoid a foolish repeat? This book takes an unvarnished look at the Great Depression an uncovers a multitude of bungling and missteps our leaders made during this era. It's a must-read for anyone with a discerning spirit.

The book starts with a cameo story about a young man who commits suicide. The note he leaves behind reveals the despairing mood of the time. The reader fully expects (like we learned in our sugar-coated stories in history classes) that this story will be contrasted with the story about having a brave and heart-lifting man elected as the US president, and he is soon revelling the masses with hope and optimism and heartwarming fireside chats. The shocking truth is the setting is not in 1932, it's 1939! The brutal truth is that the late 30's was even worse than the early 30's. During the late 30's the US suffered a recession within a depression. FDR had been the champion for the Forgotten Man for nearly a full decade, but things only got worse.

The book then does a rewind and begins a detailed and honest look at FDR history in order to catalog his war on the rich, flirtation with Communism, court packing and power grabbing, and an honest revelation of the economic history of the era. At this point, a reader might be perplexed. If the depression was so awful, why was FDR elected to 4 terms? If the answer was hinted at in this book, it wasn't clear to me. BUT! I feel this question is more directly addressed in the book, "FDR, New Deal or Raw Deal?", by Burt Folsom, Jr. The short answer is that socialism is a vote buying scheme, pure and simple. Beyond that, elected officials can (and will) divvy out taxpayer financed rewards to where they will buy the most votes.

The author also gives an account of the origins of the Forgotten Man theory, and how FDR bastardized it for his own use. Let's see if I can get the original theory right without looking at the book. Person A and B are socialistic do-gooders and want to help distressed person X. Instead of A and B contributing directly to the plight of X (or convincing Gates or Buffet that X is a worthy cause), they con their gov't to prey on C to finance the cause. C is the forgotten man! He's the middle class working stiff struggling to make ends meet through honest endeavor. Despite this, he is bludgeoned into forking over what little wealth he has, by socialistic do-gooders who are too cowardly to put their own money where their mouths are. C is the forgotten sap who is forced to pay for contraceptives for promiscuous brats who think that big gov't is the answer to everything.

Oops! I just fully revealed my strong conservative bias. All the better, I guess. If asked, I would offer with no embarrassment that I strongly dislike socialism. It's not I begrudge a better life for those in distress. But who would be so foolhardy as to trust big government with their hamfisted inefficiency to handle such delicate and lofty goals? You need to ask yourself: How good a job is our gov't doing with core responsibilities like protecting our borders, balancing the federal checkbook, and saving us from gross predators like like Madoff? Yet our political leaders would have us believe that with little funding they can heal the sick and raise the dead! Thank God I am a conservative!

With that in mind, I have to confess my frightening vision for the future. I can't help but shake my head negatively when I see so many parallels between FDR and the Obama admin. The hallmarks are class warfare, creeping socialism, and extreme deficit spending. It's like Obama is repeating FDR's script. And it seems like we are reaping the same results - the economic suffering seems protracted and Europe and the middle east are sinking into a contagion. Am I wrong to think that our elected leaders are suspects when I hear them say, "Let no good crisis go to waste"? Hey! You say predatory lenders, I say PREDATORY GOVERNMENT!

Update: 140616. Here we go again. History is repeating itself. A prolonged lagging economy, high unemployment caused by the administrations never ending class warfare and reckless high deficit spending. And now the Middle East is going up in flames and the Soviets and Chinese are flexing their muscles aggressively. Thanks to elected officials who love to milk a crisis for all it's worth and keep an electorate cowed in submission to big governement, the final results will be the same. Get ready for WW3.
48 people found this helpful
Report
Reviewed in the United States on March 11, 2009
(Note: I own, and have READ, all of this book) (...)

(396 pages)
Short Review: Definitely a very interesting and enjoyable book. Deals with a lot more than just the economic history of the Great Depression. Incorporates lots of historical facts, names and some figures, but manages to do so with sufficient elan and flow, that 'readability' remains of a very high quality. Yes, there ARE a lot of names mentioned. Some reviewers have struggled with that, and complained. But then, remember, this is not a novel, and there were indeed lots of players strutting the stage at the time. Chapter 2, "The Junket", details the surreal meeting with Stalin, at the Kremlin, of some of our later 'Great Leaders'. It was almost like a pilgrimage. Many of these intellectuals later became influential members of FDR's intelligentsia. They had a massive impact on public opinion and hugely affected the American public's perception of Stalin. This aspect of the book, for me, was very well written. Many of these pilgrims were prominent in later New Deal thinking. We ask ourselves: were they gullible? Sincere, well meaning, but naive? Absolutely fascinating. The growth of the Stalin cult, its subtle later influence on FDR, who many claim, was no great thinker or scholar, culminating in the accusation of 325 confirmed Soviet spies in FDR's administration (as per Venona decripts), and ultimately the furiously controversial events at Yalta.
This book really does do an excellent job of showing how grotesquely distorted a view of the Soviet Union was served up to the American people. And not just for a few years, but for a couple of decades. We read how people who started having doubts, seemingly preferred to ignore those doubts, and still went along with the fairy tale. And then of course, there were the legions of dreamy idealists, who bought the whole "Soviet workers' paradise" story, hook-line-and sinker, and who wished only to emigrate to the workers' paradise of the Soviet Union, and never -ever- come back to the sullied shores of corrupt, capitalistic Americay...

A hard book to put down. You kind of might end up (I did) shaking your head wearily: how is it possible that such a distorted view became mainstream thinking, and how is it possible that 'we, the people' can be manipulated so easily and effectively. Can it still happen today?

This book will NEVER be described as an apology of FDR's New Deal. I have some sympathy with those who are angry that the positive accomplishments of the New Deal are glossed over. The well meaning idealism, arguably misguided at times, on the part of many of the rank and file, does not come out very well. If at all. The poverty, the despair, is not painted in depth to us. Miss Frances Perkins, secretary of Labor, first woman cabinet minister, one of my favorite characters, is relegated to a very minor role. (she gets my sympathy vote as being this book's 'Forgotten Woman') But to accuse the writer of bias is too strong. I see it more as being the case that the author was more preoccupied with the economic aspects of the crisis, rather than any in depth description of the humanitarian aspect. Other books do that for us.
However, read the book, with an open mind, and draw your own conclusions.
Very topical, as we all ponder the economic future, as of March 2009. With certain politicians advocating the "New New Deal", and returning to increased 'Central Planning' thinking, and a strong drift towards European style government (and hence rapidly growing government share of GDP, I believe approaching 40%) this book could hardly be in the news at a more controversial time. The subject matter is furiously relevant to today's political debate. Especially if we are going to be told that the debate is "over". And that the 'winner' is FDR and the New Deal.
Not so fast...

An easy, solid, four star. I do have some minor grumbles. The biggest one for me is the lack of numerical source notes embedded in the text. Amity does have 'bibliographic notes' in the back, but it's not the same.
From, admittedly, the perspective of March 2009 the biggest oddity (and some wry thoughts) for me was the very last paragraph, on page 396. It seemed to me be a bit of an internal contradiction, from an author who spends 395 pages dissecting the many flaws and outright, expensive, failures of the New Deal. It's open to assault, now, for sure, but I don't hold that against the author. How times change.
"In fact, infrastructure spending is often just a nicer name for what we used to call pork. Given the depth of modern capital markets, the new Deal's old argument that "only the government can afford this" looks particularly weak. The New Deal edifice is solid enough, but it doesn't form the best basis for the national future."

Long Review: Right from the beginning, the Introduction, this book had me in its grip. The author sets us a small trap on page 5 (into which I promptly stumbled) and quickly shows her firm grasp on History. There are many, many quotes, and detailed references to contemporary events, which quickly gave me confidence that this work has been exhaustively researched. Some reviewers deny that fact, however. This is about the tenth specific FDR/New Deal book I have recently read, and the sixth I'm trying to review. I'm going to try something different this time from my other reviews: Let's go straight to the negative reviews and comments, and summarize some of these -furiously- hostile critiques.
Arnold Kling had the temerity to post a soft spoken 'five star' review, and even says, very diplomatically:

"I should stress that these are my own views, and that TFM is much less prone to making generalizations and drawing conclusions. Readers with a variety of backgrounds and predispositions can appreciate the book and learn their own lessons..."

And THEN, if you read the comments (hopefully including mine) you will quickly see that all hell broke loose.
'Diane', bless her, says words to the effect of:
" The author has cherrypicked her information to write a history that supports her ideological bias that government intervention in the economy is always bad, conveniently leaving out information that does not support her ideology. Useful to read to find out what the anti-FDR Republican party believes; not useful to read if one desires a true history of the 1930s."
T.Carlsen has a lot to say. And gives us -helpfully- a lot of details of his thinking. More than can be said for the many gray variants you read everywhere of "I HATED this stupid book", with no references to the book, and no explanations why...
And Michael Emmet Brady also wades in, furiously plastering the label "libertarian economist" on poor Mr Kling, and giving us some jargon you should look at, that I do not pretend to understand. I'm not actually sure if I am even meant to. I have some University level mathematics, and if I was pointed helpfully in the right direction, I might learn something, but that comment is for chosen insiders, the exalted ones, and excludes the vulgar plebs.
Also check out the review by Jim Powell, the author of "FDR's Folly" (see my review). I personally love it when busy authors take the trouble to be involved in these discussions.
In the review by Prof. CJ "The Eclectic Professor", there is a reference to an ominous press statement by Mr Obama. I have not been able to find a link on the web to the exact wording of that statement, but do check it out, aswith my comment.
So... what do we make of all that then?
As I said, this simple fellow enjoyed the book. I found it stimulating, contained good (excellent) prose, and provided me with plenty of opportunity to see different points of view. Some conclusions I took with a pinch of salt, and I've read enough to be able to "filter" the overall aspect. The New Deal to me was not 'all bad'. I agree wholeheartedly with Mr Kling, when he says:
" Readers with a variety of backgrounds and predispositions can appreciate the book and learn their own lessons..."
I'm also inclined to believe that a book that can stir such vitriolic passion against it, must have some achievement and merit. There seem to be people who are most anxious that we do NOT read it.
Diane's comment I found singularly unhelpful. It is, however, an excellent example of a particular attitude. I would ask: Did you actually READ the book, m'dear? We seriously wonder. Forgive me for suspecting a closed mind, that would rather avoid the undoubted cerebral effort to read the book, and does so by conveniently sticking a label on it. Such an unhelpful, entrenched, boring, class warfare statement.
Thank goodness for Mr Carlsen. He not only says he doesn't like the damn book, but he tells us WHY. He goes to some trouble to tell us WHY. His review you should read, before you buy the book. I mostly do not agree with him, but I respect him for a detailed argument.
I have replied with a comment to his. If I am missing the boat, quite possibly, please comment constructively, and let me know. Suggestions for further reading always very much appreciated.
In summary: The New Deal era was a pivotal time. What we are sailing into, as a troubled nation, in March 2009, has profound echoes from that time. My instinct is to examine every possible point of view. The debate, far from being "over" is once again hotting up.
To reject this book, without even reading it, because somebody stuck a label on it of "ideological bias", and "untrue history", and describes it as a prop for the "anti-FDR Republican party", to me, would be a great pity.
But such are the odd, polarized polemics of Amazon. Watch the "unhelpful" votes descend on this -perfectly honest- review, from a simple chap trying hard to understand our History, and be open-minded!

Peace. Enjoy the read.
21 people found this helpful
Report

Top reviews from other countries

Translate all reviews to English
Jean Meanrd
5.0 out of 5 stars Five Stars
Reviewed in Canada on January 19, 2018
good book
Bookworm
5.0 out of 5 stars New Coths for the New Deal
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on April 10, 2018
This book challenges the received wisdom concerning the Wall Street crash and the Great Depression that followed. It begins by describing the suicide caused by the impact of the Great Depression - and then informs the reader that the suicide occurred in 1938, when unemployment and bankruptcy had returned almost to the level of 1931, the worst year of the recession. Indeed Shlaes contends that but for the war 1939 and 1940 might have been worse, and Roosevelt would not have won his third term, if he had chosen to stand again.
Shlaes argues that the twenties were not a frivolous decade - the USA made enormous advances and the companies that survived contributed to the post-war boom as well.
She disputes the idea that all Republicans were laissez faire - in particular Hoover both believed in state intervention, and did everything that he could to prop up the banks and stabilize the economy. That he failed was not the consequence of indifference, or indeed a lack of Keynesianism - he intervened more than Roosevelt did in his first term of office. Indeed Roosevelt's "we have nothing to fear but fear itself" is a Moneterist not a Keynesian proposition.
She then goes through some individual cases. Wenvil Wilkie, who went bust, went alcoholic, but then recovered both personally and financially, to unsuccessfully challenge Roosevelt in 1940. She follows the legal prosecution of the bankers, who got the blame - rather than the Stock Market. The outcome was a lot of money spent, no convictions, but some sizeable art donations that have enriched New York's galleries ever since.
There is a fascinating chapter on how whole counties - having lost faith with both the goverment and the financial institutions, just set up their own, including their own currencies. Other states set up a system of exchange, defining how much corn or meat a car repair or a dress might be worth. Though I do not think she comments on this - such a mass opt-out must have impacted upon goverment revenues, and limited the power of the state to intervene.
She describes how many American politicians and in particular the Democratic Party were both deceived and besotted by Stalin and the Soviet Union, and how some hoped to use the New Deal, which finally took off in Roosevelt's second term, to promote his policies in the USA.
In one area Roosevelt was very successful - he won over the entertainment industry - and securred its attachment to both the New Deal and the Democratic Party. As a baby boomer I found it interesting that far from being an hobo, Woody Guthrie was paid well for travelling round the country and writing socialist and fraternal hymns. By winning over the entertainment industry Roosevelt has influenced the way that we all see the Great Depression, and how economists and modern news media see the world through Keynesian eyes.
Though she does not explicitely say this, I could only conclude that WW2, allowed the New Deal to work. It suspended all normal economic intercourse, allowed the USA to sell to the combatants, but critically the USA won. It won big - for a generation all of its economic rivals, Britain, Germany, Japan and Russia were crippled by the cost or the damage of war. This is a very good read.
2 people found this helpful
Report
Dan Montgomery
3.0 out of 5 stars Good research poorly presented
Reviewed in Japan on June 18, 2009
Schlaes has done some good research and the material she presents is worth knowing. But I found her writing very hard to follow at times. She does not organize her material well and her writing style forces one to reread and re-reread at times to follow the thread of her analysis or narrative.
RENATO MONTEIRO OLINO
4.0 out of 5 stars Muito bom, mas cansativo em alguns momentos...
Reviewed in Brazil on August 14, 2020
O livro traz muitos detalhes sobre a vida dos políticos e demais pessoas influentes nos USA na época da depressão. Muitas histórias interessantes, mas por vezes a leitura ficava cansativa.
K-Nine
2.0 out of 5 stars Whose forgotten man?
Reviewed in Japan on October 15, 2009
Involuntary unemployment, in which there are people who are unemployed though willing and able to work, is looming larger. I was, indeed, shocked at the author's criticism of the New Deal, an argument that government intervention is inefficient and ineffective in saving jobs. For nearly three decades, though, the global economies had been prosperous under the auspices of the pro-marketed, small government. Now the pendulum has swung. The socialized government with democratic policies emerges, remembering the weak. You need more government.