Gifts Differing: Understanding Personality Type 2nd ed. Edition
Use the Amazon App to scan ISBNs and compare prices.
"Happy This Year!" by Will Bowen
A practical, yet inspirational work that proposes it’s the inner world of our psyches that determines happiness, not outside forces. | Learn more
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
Frequently bought together
About the Author
- Publisher : CPP; 2nd ed. edition (January 1, 1995)
- Language : English
- Paperback : 248 pages
- ISBN-10 : 089106074X
- ISBN-13 : 978-0891060741
- Item Weight : 10.6 ounces
- Dimensions : 6 x 0.63 x 9 inches
- Best Sellers Rank: #41,852 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
- Customer Reviews:
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
It's a shame that I read this book after reading several different treatments of the MBTI, because I was expecting so much more depth and analysis from Myers, herself. But as I understand it, her aim was to make a test that people could take to ascertain which career or vocation would be suitable to their unique talents, from a Jungian cognitive theory perspective. So, keep this in mind as you read and understand that she was simply laying the groundwork to legitimize her self-assessment tool and demonstrate its usefulness.
This is easy to read, and if you aren't interested in delving deep within the theory of cognition and cognitive functions, then this will probably be a satisfying read for you. However, I found the definitions of cognitive functions limiting and too general, and at times I could not tell if Myers valued preferences more or functions more. In fact, there were several instances in which she makes the distinction between, for example, those with extraverted sensing and introverted sensing (cognitive functions), but then goes on to refer to merely those who scored higher on "sensing" (preference), as if there is no difference between the extraverted or introverted sensing type, and thus no difference between function and preference. As well, I found the pages and pages of tables showing how each of the 16 types scored on several different job categories to be pretty tedious, to the point that I skipped over this section.
But I did find the definitions of cognitive functions, however simplistic, clear and thought-provoking. Better than that, I think this book helped to clearly conclude for me which of the 16 types I most closely resemble, which is more than I can say for all of the type assessments out there online, including the "official" MBTI you can purchase.
So, all in all, I would say, if you're a fan of MBTI, then you need to read Myers' book.
Gifts Differing has a tremendously important message: studying the 16 different personality types is essential to better understanding and relating to one another.
Overall, I liked this one much better because it didn't completely focus on the four temperaments.
The book is split into four sections: Theory, Effects of the Preferences on Personality, Practical Implications of Type, and Dynamics of Type development.
The theory part is good for anyone who wants to know the theoretical grounding for the MBTI and the linkage to Jung's theories. It's definitely more geared towards people unfamiliar with the MBTI, because it more or less tries to give validity to the theories by referring to Jung, who is much more respected and well-known.
The second part, Effects of the Preferences on Personality, goes through the effects of each of the preferences: E/I, S/N, T/F, and J/P. The descriptions of each of the types themselves are really nothing special; you can find them online anywhere. However, the book includes a fascinating statistical analysis on the effects of type on career choice. For example, people who study law are overwhelmingly T, while science students are overwhelming N. I personally found the descriptions of the cognitive functions themselves to be fairly good, although I have heard that Beren's books are more specialized in that topic.
The third part, Practical Implications of Type, talks about the implications of type on marriage, learning styles, child development, all the while emphasizing the need for people of different types to work together to balance each other's weaknesses. Most of this information you can find on the internet nowadays, but Myers' analysis goes a little bit deeper than what you would find online.
The last part, Dynamics of Type Development, really just emphasizes one important concept: healthy personal development requires the development of an auxiliary function. Most of this section shows you the negative implications for not developing a strong auxiliary.
The MBTI is really not everybody's cup of tea. As someone who types ISTJ, I have always been highly skeptical that "personality tests" have any validity at all. The MBTI is really no different: there's no real empirical evidence to prove that the theoretical portions are valid. However, I cannot deny the positive impact studying these theories have had on my attitudes toward people. I would approach all these theories (MBTI, Big 5, Socionics, etc) with a healthy dose of skepticism, but I have learned that it also pays to be open-minded to the possibilities these theories offer.
Top reviews from other countries
Will instil in you a little (or a lot) more love for all your fellow human beings...and that has to be a good thing! If only everyone would read this book.
To me the book seemed to be divided into two sections.The first half deals with breaking down the personality into 8 components comprising of four sets of two,which are then assembled into the 16 basic types according to preferences of use.The theory is verified by extensive testing and the results presented in tables.
The second section of the book leans more towards the practical implications of the theory,such as employment,how and why the differing personalities can come into conflict and suggests how type development may overcome unbalanced areas in the personality.This second section is more speculative and strays into areas where the authors have less authority from a psychological standpoint and I felt that other authors I'd read, particularly; M L,von Franz and Jung, covered in a more comprehensive fashion with deeper insight.
On the whole,the book is understandable and written in an 'accessible to all' manner without betraying its academic qualities.If you are at all interested in human behaviour and interaction and wonder why certain people seem to operate from a totally different standpoint which you conflict with, then this book will be a valuable tool to aid your understanding of human nature.