Goliath: Life and Loathing in Greater Israel
4.3 en Goodreads
(771)
Se ha producido un problema al cargar esta página. Inténtelo de nuevo.
Comprar nuevo
-36% US$16.69US$16.69
Entrega entre el 3 - 14 de enero
Enviado por: Amazon.com Vendido por: Amazon.com
Comprar nuevo
-36% US$16.69US$16.69
Entrega entre el 3 - 14 de enero
Enviado por: Amazon.com
Vendido por: Amazon.com
US$16.69 con 36 porcentaje de ahorro -36% US$16.69
Precio recomendado: US$25.99 Precio recomendado: US$25.99US$25.99
El Precio listado es el precio de venta sugerido de un nuevo producto tal como lo proporciona un fabricante, proveedor o vendedor. Excepto para los libros, Amazon mostrará un Precio listado si los clientes compraron el producto en Amazon o si otros minoristas lo ofrecieron al Precio listado o a un precio superior al menos en los últimos 90 días. Los precios listados pueden no reflejar necesariamente el precio de mercado actual del producto.
Más información
Más información
Devoluciones internacionales gratis
Devolver gratis este producto
Las devoluciones gratis están disponibles para la dirección de envío que elegiste. Puedes devolver el producto por cualquier motivo, en estado nuevo y sin usar: no se aplican gastos de envío.
Más información sobre las devoluciones gratis. ¿Cómo devolver el producto?
- Ve a tus pedidos y empieza el proceso de devolución
- Seleccione su opción de envío gratis preferida
- Entregar y marcharse
Sin depósito de derechos de importación y US$14.93 de envío a Austria Detalles
Detalles de envío y tarifa
| Precio | US$16.69 |
| Envío de AmazonGlobal | US$14.93 |
| Depósito de cuotas de importación estimadas | US$0.00 |
| Total | US$31.62 |
Disponible
Cantidad:1
US$US$16.6916.69
()
Incluye las opciones seleccionadas. Incluye el pago mensual inicial y las opciones seleccionadas. Detalles
Precio (US$16.69x)
- US$16.69
Subtotal
US$US$16.6916.69
Subtotal
Desglose inicial del pago
Se muestran los gastos de envío, la fecha de entrega y el total del pedido (impuestos incluidos) al finalizar la compra
Las mejoras que elegiste no están disponibles para este vendedor. Detalles
Para agregar las siguientes mejoras a tu compra, elige un vendedor diferente.
%cardName%
${cardName} no disponible para el vendedor que elegiste
${cardName} no disponible para cantidades mayores a ${maxQuantity}.
Enviado por
Amazon.com
Enviado por
Amazon.com
Vendido por
Amazon.com
Vendido por
Amazon.com
Devoluciones
Se puede devolver hasta el 31 de enero de 2025
Se puede devolver hasta el 31 de enero de 2025
En la temporada navideña de 2024, los artículos elegibles comprados entre el 1 de noviembre y el 31 de diciembre de 2024 se podrán devolver hasta el 31 de enero de 2025.
Devoluciones
Se puede devolver hasta el 31 de enero de 2025
En la temporada navideña de 2024, los artículos elegibles comprados entre el 1 de noviembre y el 31 de diciembre de 2024 se podrán devolver hasta el 31 de enero de 2025.
Pago
Transacción segura
Tu transacción es segura
En Amazon, nos esforzamos por proteger tu seguridad y privacidad. Nuestro sistema de seguridad de pagos encripta tu información durante la transmisión de datos. No compartimos los datos de tu tarjeta de crédito con vendedores externos, ni vendemos tu información a terceros. Más información
Pago
Transacción segura
En Amazon, nos esforzamos por proteger tu seguridad y privacidad. Nuestro sistema de seguridad de pagos encripta tu información durante la transmisión de datos. No compartimos los datos de tu tarjeta de crédito con vendedores externos, ni vendemos tu información a terceros. Más información
Ahorra con Usado - Bueno
US$13.32US$13.32
Entrega el martes, 14 de enero
Enviado por: Amazon Vendido por: Boise Book Rescue
Ahorra con Usado - Bueno
US$13.32US$13.32
Entrega el martes, 14 de enero
Enviado por: Amazon
Vendido por: Boise Book Rescue
US$13.32 US$13.32
Devoluciones internacionales gratis
Devolver gratis este producto
Las devoluciones gratis están disponibles para la dirección de envío que elegiste. Puedes devolver el producto por cualquier motivo, en estado nuevo y sin usar: no se aplican gastos de envío.
Más información sobre las devoluciones gratis. ¿Cómo devolver el producto?
- Ve a tus pedidos y empieza el proceso de devolución
- Seleccione su opción de envío gratis preferida
- Entregar y marcharse
Sin depósito de derechos de importación y US$14.93 de envío a Austria Detalles
Detalles de envío y tarifa
| Precio | US$16.69 |
| Envío de AmazonGlobal | US$14.93 |
| Depósito de cuotas de importación estimadas | US$0.00 |
| Total | US$31.62 |
Ships directly from Amazon. Good used condition. May be some dogears, minor cover blemishes (i.e. dust cover bend, wrinkles, or minor tears), possible writing, possible highlighting, possible dedication.
Entrega el martes, 14 de enero. Realiza el pedido en 9 hrs 45 mins
O entrega más rápida el martes, 7 de enero
Solo queda(n) 1 en stock (hay más unidades en camino).
US$US$16.6916.69
()
Incluye las opciones seleccionadas. Incluye el pago mensual inicial y las opciones seleccionadas. Detalles
Precio (US$16.69x)
- US$16.69
Subtotal
US$US$16.6916.69
Subtotal
Desglose inicial del pago
Se muestran los gastos de envío, la fecha de entrega y el total del pedido (impuestos incluidos) al finalizar la compra
Las mejoras que elegiste no están disponibles para este vendedor. Detalles
Para agregar las siguientes mejoras a tu compra, elige un vendedor diferente.
%cardName%
${cardName} no disponible para el vendedor que elegiste
${cardName} no disponible para cantidades mayores a ${maxQuantity}.
Lo sentimos. Amazon ha encontrado un error. Inténtalo de nuevo.
Hubo un problema
Hubo un problema
{"mobile_buybox_group_1":[{"displayPrice":"US$16.69","priceAmount":16.69,"currencySymbol":"US$","integerValue":"16","decimalSeparator":".","fractionalValue":"69","symbolPosition":"left","hasSpace":false,"showFractionalPartIfEmpty":true,"offerListingId":"6OFfixv4tvibXYqxqlzmBD7r7Vrorf0ddbyWkgKWbeKT%2FEqeyggLD8RxMYV1aV%2FcBInWA0n64GwCXmXUaC6swsKKoORWbOe6eeoj5dcRnz3pNtk2L%2FsqBHQ9NxaKGNTk6ts181n2nVWF1XEZyhTMXw%3D%3D","locale":"es-US","buyingOptionType":"NEW","aapiBuyingOptionIndex":0}, {"displayPrice":"US$13.32","priceAmount":13.32,"currencySymbol":"US$","integerValue":"13","decimalSeparator":".","fractionalValue":"32","symbolPosition":"left","hasSpace":false,"showFractionalPartIfEmpty":true,"offerListingId":"6OFfixv4tvibXYqxqlzmBD7r7Vrorf0dWqQNEKHy3ad4USEM3B%2B0P6xditvV%2BxMNzTxWIYHf2g0Z618VZVjvgWOERL1azcJg95UC%2FcpfJ%2Befe7OIWI0eCE6sMGSIvVsUAEgtQ2Plrp%2BnZinDtCNaFyQI5Z2mwZQSs2htpzFDGhusCy4tNm6%2BjjOVG%2BJiGwaS","locale":"es-US","buyingOptionType":"USED","aapiBuyingOptionIndex":1}]}
Detalles del libro
- Número de páginas520 páginas
- IdiomaInglés
- Fecha de publicación26 Agosto 2014
- Dimensiones6.13 x 1.5 x 9 pulgadas
- ISBN-101568589514
- ISBN-13978-1568589510
2014 Lannan Foundation Cultural Freedom Notable Book Award
In Goliath, New York Times bestselling author Max Blumenthal takes us on a journey through the badlands and high roads of Israel-Palestine, painting a startling portrait of Israeli society under the siege of increasingly authoritarian politics as the occupation of the Palestinians deepens.
Beginning with the national elections carried out during Israel's war on Gaza in 2008-09, which brought into power the country's most right-wing government to date, Blumenthal tells the story of Israel in the wake of the collapse of the Oslo peace process.
As Blumenthal reveals, Israel has become a country where right-wing leaders like Avigdor Lieberman and Bibi Netanyahu are sacrificing democracy on the altar of their power politics; where the loyal opposition largely and passively stands aside and watches the organized assault on civil liberties; where state-funded Orthodox rabbis publish books that provide instructions on how and when to kill Gentiles; where half of Jewish youth declare their refusal to sit in a classroom with an Arab; and where mob violence targets Palestinians and African asylum seekers scapegoated by leading government officials as "demographic threats."
Immersing himself like few other journalists inside the world of hardline political leaders and movements, Blumenthal interviews the demagogues and divas in their homes, in the Knesset, and in the watering holes where their young acolytes hang out, and speaks with those political leaders behind the organized assault on civil liberties. As his journey deepens, he painstakingly reports on the occupied Palestinians challenging schemes of demographic separation through unarmed protest. He talks at length to the leaders and youth of Palestinian society inside Israel now targeted by security service dragnets and legislation suppressing their speech, and provides in-depth reporting on the small band of Jewish Israeli dissidents who have shaken off a conformist mindset that permeates the media, schools, and the military.
Through his far-ranging travels, Blumenthal illuminates the present by uncovering the ghosts of the past -- the histories of Palestinian neighborhoods and villages now gone and forgotten; how that history has set the stage for the current crisis of Israeli society; and how the Holocaust has been turned into justification for occupation.
A brave and unflinching account of the real facts on the ground, Goliath is an unprecedented and compelling work of journalism.
In Goliath, New York Times bestselling author Max Blumenthal takes us on a journey through the badlands and high roads of Israel-Palestine, painting a startling portrait of Israeli society under the siege of increasingly authoritarian politics as the occupation of the Palestinians deepens.
Beginning with the national elections carried out during Israel's war on Gaza in 2008-09, which brought into power the country's most right-wing government to date, Blumenthal tells the story of Israel in the wake of the collapse of the Oslo peace process.
As Blumenthal reveals, Israel has become a country where right-wing leaders like Avigdor Lieberman and Bibi Netanyahu are sacrificing democracy on the altar of their power politics; where the loyal opposition largely and passively stands aside and watches the organized assault on civil liberties; where state-funded Orthodox rabbis publish books that provide instructions on how and when to kill Gentiles; where half of Jewish youth declare their refusal to sit in a classroom with an Arab; and where mob violence targets Palestinians and African asylum seekers scapegoated by leading government officials as "demographic threats."
Immersing himself like few other journalists inside the world of hardline political leaders and movements, Blumenthal interviews the demagogues and divas in their homes, in the Knesset, and in the watering holes where their young acolytes hang out, and speaks with those political leaders behind the organized assault on civil liberties. As his journey deepens, he painstakingly reports on the occupied Palestinians challenging schemes of demographic separation through unarmed protest. He talks at length to the leaders and youth of Palestinian society inside Israel now targeted by security service dragnets and legislation suppressing their speech, and provides in-depth reporting on the small band of Jewish Israeli dissidents who have shaken off a conformist mindset that permeates the media, schools, and the military.
Through his far-ranging travels, Blumenthal illuminates the present by uncovering the ghosts of the past -- the histories of Palestinian neighborhoods and villages now gone and forgotten; how that history has set the stage for the current crisis of Israeli society; and how the Holocaust has been turned into justification for occupation.
A brave and unflinching account of the real facts on the ground, Goliath is an unprecedented and compelling work of journalism.
Críticas
"Brave reporting of a sad, even tragic tale. Makes me wish he wrote for the New York Times."
Stephen Walt, Professor of International Affairs at Harvard University's John F. Kennedy School of Government
"Erudite, hard-hitting, [Goliath has] the potential to influence American public opinion on Israel..."
Rayyan Al-Shawaf, Mondoweiss
"[Blumenthal is] genuinely interested in the truth, and knows that the truth in politics often lurks in those dark caves of viciousness... [Goliath is] the kind of book that you just open to any chapter and quickly get a sense of both the particular and the whole. You'll find yourself instantly immersed in an engrossing family romance-one part tender, one part train-wreck-and wish you had the entire day to keep reading. Put it down, and pick it up the next day, and you'll have the exact same feeling."
Corey Robin, associate professor of political science at Brooklyn College and the CUNY Graduate Center
"A rich, roiling examination of 'the State of Israel during a period of deepening political and societal crisis' ... Blumenthal is an enterprising reporter."
Kirkus Reviews
"[A] bold and shocking book, presenting persuasively a major theoretical and polemical argument about Israel almost completely at odds with the image most Americans have of it... Even those generally well-informed about Israel and its occupation of the Palestinian territories will have their views challenged by Blumenthal's sharp eye and deadpan factual presentations."
The American Conservative
"[A] scathing critique of the Jewish State... Supporters of Israel should be encouraged to read this book...As Israel's greatest supporters, American Jews who care at all about the future of the country need to understand what's happening within the borders."
The New York Observer
"I would like to send a copy [of Goliath] to every Jew I know...This is the sort of book that even if you want to diss it, you can't dismiss it."
Charles H. Manekin, Professor of Philosophy, Director of the Joseph and Rebecca Meyerhoff Center of Jewish Studies at the University of Maryland
"Blumenthal's new book offers an unflinching look at the racist reality of Israel that America's establishment media simply does not have the guts to confront."
Ali Abunimah, Electronic Intifada
"There is much in its gruesome vignettes of modern Israeli hypernationalism in action ... heart-wrenching."
David Shulman, New York Review of Books
"[A] bold, personal and unapologetic book."
Salon
"Goliath is a particular kind of exposé-minded, documentary-broadside journalism whose place we generally recognize and respect... Blumenthal has made a sobering prima facie case that there are extreme forces [within Israel's current political-social dynamics] to be aware of, and reckoned with more fully that American discourse usually does."
James Fallows, The Atlantic
Goliath shows in forensic detail the reality of the Israeli mainstream's embrace blatant racism against Arabs and Africans.”
Antony Loewenstein, TheGuardian.com
"[A] heart stopper... Goliath is a threat to the Israeli status quo...because it tells too many inconvenient truths."
Larry Gross, Director of the USC Annenberg School for Communication
"Max Blumenthal's Goliath: Life and Loathing in Greater Israel is the most important political and investigative journalist book of 2013."
TarheelDem, Firedoglake Reader Diaries
Stephen Walt, Professor of International Affairs at Harvard University's John F. Kennedy School of Government
"Erudite, hard-hitting, [Goliath has] the potential to influence American public opinion on Israel..."
Rayyan Al-Shawaf, Mondoweiss
"[Blumenthal is] genuinely interested in the truth, and knows that the truth in politics often lurks in those dark caves of viciousness... [Goliath is] the kind of book that you just open to any chapter and quickly get a sense of both the particular and the whole. You'll find yourself instantly immersed in an engrossing family romance-one part tender, one part train-wreck-and wish you had the entire day to keep reading. Put it down, and pick it up the next day, and you'll have the exact same feeling."
Corey Robin, associate professor of political science at Brooklyn College and the CUNY Graduate Center
"A rich, roiling examination of 'the State of Israel during a period of deepening political and societal crisis' ... Blumenthal is an enterprising reporter."
Kirkus Reviews
"[A] bold and shocking book, presenting persuasively a major theoretical and polemical argument about Israel almost completely at odds with the image most Americans have of it... Even those generally well-informed about Israel and its occupation of the Palestinian territories will have their views challenged by Blumenthal's sharp eye and deadpan factual presentations."
The American Conservative
"[A] scathing critique of the Jewish State... Supporters of Israel should be encouraged to read this book...As Israel's greatest supporters, American Jews who care at all about the future of the country need to understand what's happening within the borders."
The New York Observer
"I would like to send a copy [of Goliath] to every Jew I know...This is the sort of book that even if you want to diss it, you can't dismiss it."
Charles H. Manekin, Professor of Philosophy, Director of the Joseph and Rebecca Meyerhoff Center of Jewish Studies at the University of Maryland
"Blumenthal's new book offers an unflinching look at the racist reality of Israel that America's establishment media simply does not have the guts to confront."
Ali Abunimah, Electronic Intifada
"There is much in its gruesome vignettes of modern Israeli hypernationalism in action ... heart-wrenching."
David Shulman, New York Review of Books
"[A] bold, personal and unapologetic book."
Salon
"Goliath is a particular kind of exposé-minded, documentary-broadside journalism whose place we generally recognize and respect... Blumenthal has made a sobering prima facie case that there are extreme forces [within Israel's current political-social dynamics] to be aware of, and reckoned with more fully that American discourse usually does."
James Fallows, The Atlantic
Goliath shows in forensic detail the reality of the Israeli mainstream's embrace blatant racism against Arabs and Africans.”
Antony Loewenstein, TheGuardian.com
"[A] heart stopper... Goliath is a threat to the Israeli status quo...because it tells too many inconvenient truths."
Larry Gross, Director of the USC Annenberg School for Communication
"Max Blumenthal's Goliath: Life and Loathing in Greater Israel is the most important political and investigative journalist book of 2013."
TarheelDem, Firedoglake Reader Diaries
Biografía del autor
Max Blumenthal is the author of Republican Gomorrah, a New York Times and Los Angeles Times bestseller, and Goliath, winner of the Lannan Foundation Cultural Freedom Notable Book Award. His writing and video documentaries have appeared in the New York Times, the Los Angeles Times, the Daily Beast, the Nation, the Guardian, the Independent Film Channel, the Huffington Post, Salon.com, Al Jazeera English, and many other publications. He blogs at maxblumenthal.com.
Sobre el autor
Sigue a los autores para recibir notificaciones de sus nuevas obras, así como recomendaciones mejoradas.Comprados juntos habitualmente
Comprar los 3: $00$00
Comprados juntos habitualmente

Este producto: Goliath: Life and Loathing in Greater Israel
US$16.69US$16.69
Precio total: $00$00
¡Intenta de nuevo!
Agregado al carrito
También podría interesarte
-  
-  
-  
-  
-  
-  
-  
Información de producto
| Editorial | Bold Type Books; Reimpresión edición (26 Agosto 2014) |
|---|---|
| Idioma | Inglés |
| Tapa blanda | 520 páginas |
| ISBN-10 | 1568589514 |
| ISBN-13 | 978-1568589510 |
| Dimensiones | 6.13 x 1.5 x 9 pulgadas |
| Clasificación en los más vendidos de Amazon |
nº806,149 en Libros (Ver el Top 100 en Libros)
nº742 en Geografía Humana (Libros)
nº951 en Política de Medio Oriente
nº987 en Historia de Israel (Libros)
|
| Opinión media de los clientes | 4.7 de 5 estrellas 595Opiniones |
Los clientes que compraron este producto también compraron
También podría interesarte
-  
-  
-  
-  
-  
-  
Opiniones con imágenes
1 11 1
Reporta una opinión
Algunas razones frecuentes por las que los clientes reportan opiniones:
- Acoso, lenguaje ofensivo
- Spam, publicidad, promociones
- Otorgado a cambio de efectivo, descuentos
Cuando obtengamos tu reporte, verificaremos si la revisión cumple con nuestras pautas de la comunidad. Si no lo hace, lo retiraremos.
Reportar
Cancelar
Lo sentimos, no pudimos cargar la opinión
Gracias por tus comentarios
Lo sentimos, se produjo un error
Inténtalo de nuevo más tarde.Cerrar
Opiniones destacadas de los Estados Unidos
- 5.0 de 5 estrellasCompra verificadaCongratulations to the Author of this IMPORTANT , well written and researched book!Calificado en Estados Unidos el 16 de febrero de 2014This is a hard book to put down, but I found I needed to come up for a breath of fresh! clean air a few times. And I started it with a distinctly pro-Israeli worldview. I cannot believe this book describes the country my Jewish then to be husband and I visited... Ver másThis is a hard book to put down, but I found I needed to come up for a breath of fresh! clean air a few times. And I started it with a distinctly pro-Israeli worldview.
I cannot believe this book describes the country my Jewish then to be husband and I visited in 1997 or early 1998. I vividly recall the hours at the airport talking to a series of interrogators about why we're there. NOTE: My husband was 62, a professor of medicine invited to give a talk in Haifa! and I was 48, dressed like the lawyer I was, yet security questions went on in excess of 1.5 hours. SAME thing on our return home, ( and why did it matter then)????
Yet my frustration was nothing compared to the experiences of Palestinians who wait at checkpoints at least twice a day to go thru checkpoints to farm their fields and tend orchards. A small point in this sprawling, fascinating book, but one that impatient Americans can relate to.
We were not there in a peaceful time. within an hour of my arrival in Tel Aviv, as I stepped toward the beach outside the Hilton Hotel, a truck full of of soldiers with M-16s(.????)--- assault rifles-- poured out of a truck and ran down the broad sidewalk. Something similar happened each day we were there.
I read a great deal to prepare for that trip, including both Tom Segev's books ( as well as biography of T. Hertzl, Zionism, history of the Balfour Agreement WWI in the Middle East. In general, WWII, the Holocaust , essentially the history of the European Wars in the 20th Century and their consequences, and on and on. I write this not to impress, but to establish my credentials for reviewing this book.
As I said, every good thing has been said by other reviewers, but one thing that especially struck me was the government's (and society's) persecution of it's own Jewish citizens for any degree of dissent from what have become the state's present ethno-fascist policies. Senator Joseph McCarthy and president Nixon's deep suspicions of his own people, with the accompanying wiretaps, bullying, surveillance, etc., seem almost moderate when compared with 6 hour interrogations of dissidents, and seizure of their computers, at Tel Aviv's Ben Gurion Airport.And these are liberal leftists, not anarchists or terrorists-- the sort of people my husband and I are.
Economic blacklisting, removal of prominent professors, scholars and intellectuals from positions in which they could teach young Israelis to think for themselves, the demotion of Mr Segev's from his once HIGHLY regarded status as journalist and historian, the enforce of "groupthink" by lower class and Russian thugs---- as a good liberal pro-Israel (with some misgivings about Palestinian repression) American I am SHOCKED by the Israel described by this book, and grateful that Mr. Blumenthal wrote it. Now I know! and what I learned is unforgettable.
Americans spent serious dollars supporting Israel, and should know what they are REALLY supporting, as opposed to the Israeli image created by their enormous public relations machinery.
A MUST READ indeed.
This is a hard book to put down, but I found I needed to come up for a breath of fresh! clean air a few times. And I started it with a distinctly pro-Israeli worldview.
I cannot believe this book describes the country my Jewish then to be husband and I visited in 1997 or early 1998. I vividly recall the hours at the airport talking to a series of interrogators about why we're there. NOTE: My husband was 62, a professor of medicine invited to give a talk in Haifa! and I was 48, dressed like the lawyer I was, yet security questions went on in excess of 1.5 hours. SAME thing on our return home, ( and why did it matter then)????
Yet my frustration was nothing compared to the experiences of Palestinians who wait at checkpoints at least twice a day to go thru checkpoints to farm their fields and tend orchards. A small point in this sprawling, fascinating book, but one that impatient Americans can relate to.
We were not there in a peaceful time. within an hour of my arrival in Tel Aviv, as I stepped toward the beach outside the Hilton Hotel, a truck full of of soldiers with M-16s(.????)--- assault rifles-- poured out of a truck and ran down the broad sidewalk. Something similar happened each day we were there.
I read a great deal to prepare for that trip, including both Tom Segev's books ( as well as biography of T. Hertzl, Zionism, history of the Balfour Agreement WWI in the Middle East. In general, WWII, the Holocaust , essentially the history of the European Wars in the 20th Century and their consequences, and on and on. I write this not to impress, but to establish my credentials for reviewing this book.
As I said, every good thing has been said by other reviewers, but one thing that especially struck me was the government's (and society's) persecution of it's own Jewish citizens for any degree of dissent from what have become the state's present ethno-fascist policies. Senator Joseph McCarthy and president Nixon's deep suspicions of his own people, with the accompanying wiretaps, bullying, surveillance, etc., seem almost moderate when compared with 6 hour interrogations of dissidents, and seizure of their computers, at Tel Aviv's Ben Gurion Airport.And these are liberal leftists, not anarchists or terrorists-- the sort of people my husband and I are.
Economic blacklisting, removal of prominent professors, scholars and intellectuals from positions in which they could teach young Israelis to think for themselves, the demotion of Mr Segev's from his once HIGHLY regarded status as journalist and historian, the enforce of "groupthink" by lower class and Russian thugs---- as a good liberal pro-Israel (with some misgivings about Palestinian repression) American I am SHOCKED by the Israel described by this book, and grateful that Mr. Blumenthal wrote it. Now I know! and what I learned is unforgettable.
Americans spent serious dollars supporting Israel, and should know what they are REALLY supporting, as opposed to the Israeli image created by their enormous public relations machinery.
A MUST READ indeed.
- 5.0 de 5 estrellasCompra verificadaExcellent BookCalificado en Estados Unidos el 7 de octubre de 2024Excellent investigative journalism. A must read, if you want to learn the truth about the Israel/Palestine conflict. Everyone should read this book.
Excellent investigative journalism. A must read, if you want to learn the truth about the Israel/Palestine conflict. Everyone should read this book.
- 5.0 de 5 estrellasCompra verificadaThe awful truthCalificado en Estados Unidos el 27 de septiembre de 2013I've been following Israeli news and politics and visiting the region for ten years, so there was little in this book that was fundamentally new to me. But for anyone who didn't have time to keep up with the evolution of Israeli culture and politics over the last... Ver másI've been following Israeli news and politics and visiting the region for ten years, so there was little in this book that was fundamentally new to me. But for anyone who didn't have time to keep up with the evolution of Israeli culture and politics over the last several years, this book is an excellent (and grimly entertaining) way to catch up.
An increasingly proudly racist segment of Israeli society has become mainstreamed and acceptable, saying things about Palestinians (or rather 'Arabs,' since they won't deign to use the word 'Palestinian') that would make any Jim Crow partisan cringe with shame, kicking Bedouin off of land they have lived on for generations and into ghettos/reservations simply because they are not Jewish, forming vigilante groups to keep Jewish women from dating Arab men, and marching provocatively through Muslim neighborhoods in shows of force, contempt, and intimidation.
And this is in Israel proper. In the Palestinian territories, the situation is even more dire. From "price tag" operations to rabbis who advocate the killing of non-Jewish children, it's a parallel universe, a parade of horrors of blind hatred and violence likened in many cases to "pogroms" even in the Israeli press.
When the vast majority of the Jewish Israeli public supported the grisly, pointless slaughter of Operation Cast Lead, it was truly a new low. The US government supports the Israeli government and its policies to the tune of $8 million every day, yet the American press tells us virtually nothing about these trends.
There are good people and great activists in Israel doing terrific and genuine work toward peace. But to understand what they are really up against -- not to mention what the Palestinians are up against -- this is an important book to read and an important set of realities to understand.
I've been following Israeli news and politics and visiting the region for ten years, so there was little in this book that was fundamentally new to me. But for anyone who didn't have time to keep up with the evolution of Israeli culture and politics over the last several years, this book is an excellent (and grimly entertaining) way to catch up.
An increasingly proudly racist segment of Israeli society has become mainstreamed and acceptable, saying things about Palestinians (or rather 'Arabs,' since they won't deign to use the word 'Palestinian') that would make any Jim Crow partisan cringe with shame, kicking Bedouin off of land they have lived on for generations and into ghettos/reservations simply because they are not Jewish, forming vigilante groups to keep Jewish women from dating Arab men, and marching provocatively through Muslim neighborhoods in shows of force, contempt, and intimidation.
And this is in Israel proper. In the Palestinian territories, the situation is even more dire. From "price tag" operations to rabbis who advocate the killing of non-Jewish children, it's a parallel universe, a parade of horrors of blind hatred and violence likened in many cases to "pogroms" even in the Israeli press.
When the vast majority of the Jewish Israeli public supported the grisly, pointless slaughter of Operation Cast Lead, it was truly a new low. The US government supports the Israeli government and its policies to the tune of $8 million every day, yet the American press tells us virtually nothing about these trends.
There are good people and great activists in Israel doing terrific and genuine work toward peace. But to understand what they are really up against -- not to mention what the Palestinians are up against -- this is an important book to read and an important set of realities to understand.
- 4.0 de 5 estrellasCompra verificadaThe one-star reviews of this book highlight the emotional backlash to being presented unwanted truths.Calificado en Estados Unidos el 25 de marzo de 2018Max Blumenthal is an award-winning investigative journalist whose insight and integrity I trust, and I don't really trust all that many people. I put off reading this book for quite a while, even for two months after purchasing it sat on my bookcase waiting its... Ver másMax Blumenthal is an award-winning investigative journalist whose insight and integrity I trust, and I don't really trust all that many people.
I put off reading this book for quite a while, even for two months after purchasing it sat on my bookcase waiting its inevitable turn. I knew that I would face emotional and ethical conflicts from its contents, this is not a book to be read lightly.
Simply put, "Goliath" is powerful, much like the mythical character that is its namesake. It is a brutal reminder of the uncivilized origins of Judaism and not only through the state of Israel, but in its influence around the world as Judaism's barbaric offspring continue daily to assault reason.
You find that Israel learned too well the cruelties of ethnic and religious persecution from the Spanish Inquisition, Russian pogroms, Nazi Germany, Apartheid South Africa, and pre-Civil Rights United States and used these places as blueprints for their new ethno-state starting in 1947.
The tactics employed daily throughout the occupied territories are eerily reminiscent of these historic mistakes and its tactics and propaganda are now being reimported to the United States in particular.
I now find myself reluctant to call Israel a nation as that lends an air of respectability to what has be perpetrated. Interestingly, utilizing largely American taxpayer money to foster the narrative of "civilization", "democracy" and "progress", a ethno-fascist regime has grown in place of these ideals.
The culture of Israel shamelessly continues to use the atrocities of The Holocaust as a propaganda smokescreen to obscure the behavior that so well mirrors the villains of that same history. I never thought I would feel a sense of shame in participating in the opening ceremonies of my local Holocaust Museum as a child, but the quoted words and fanatical behavior of Israelis definitely pushes me in that direction. As I continued to read of the daily desecration of that memory in the name of ethnic nationalism I must say that I am disgusted.
"Goliath" covers some of the background of the Israeli colonial territories in the Arabic Peninsula as far back as 1947, but mainly focuses on the era of 1990-2012, with an emphasis on the 5 year period Blumenthal spent witnessing history in Israel firsthand. He came to know its internal politics and struggles intimately as this was made easier for him due to his Jewish ethnic background. From besieged Gazan villages to the halls of the increasingly fascist Knesset, Blumenthal probes the striated layers of Isreali-Palestinian social constructs to the best of his ability.
I won't go into too much detail, but I must say that this book will turn your stomach one way or another. It may also turn your views on the subject as well, whether you actually care for human rights, international integrity and democratic ideals or whether you have fallen for the Israeli propaganda that the revisionists have sold to the world and US in particular. You will not forget this document, ever.
If Israel is truly the shining beacon of democracy in the middle-east, then religious ethno-nationalism should be its mortal enemy. However, in this troubled land, that enemy has been embraced with open arms and panicked heart, a slap in the face to all Holocaust victims and survivors, Jewish or otherwise, alike.
"Tapuz, a website for Israelis living abroad, hosted a 2005 forum on the topic of leaving Israel. According to the site's administrator, Limor Abis, the most frequently cited explanation for why they left was, 'The question is not why we left, but why it took so long to do so'." (Chapter 73, "Exodus")
This discussion is not over, unfortunately in many ways it is still just warming up and beginning to burn through the fog of state and religiously-sanctioned propaganda shrouding this small territory. All it may take for this fascist kettle to boil over is one more rash action. Whether the action of a government with no standing Constitution after 70 years, its ghetto-living minority, or of their neighbors, the cousins of the ghetto-living minority. If you wish to be prepared to understand this nearly inevitable day, this book is an excellent place to begin your education.
Max Blumenthal is an award-winning investigative journalist whose insight and integrity I trust, and I don't really trust all that many people.
I put off reading this book for quite a while, even for two months after purchasing it sat on my bookcase waiting its inevitable turn. I knew that I would face emotional and ethical conflicts from its contents, this is not a book to be read lightly.
Simply put, "Goliath" is powerful, much like the mythical character that is its namesake. It is a brutal reminder of the uncivilized origins of Judaism and not only through the state of Israel, but in its influence around the world as Judaism's barbaric offspring continue daily to assault reason.
You find that Israel learned too well the cruelties of ethnic and religious persecution from the Spanish Inquisition, Russian pogroms, Nazi Germany, Apartheid South Africa, and pre-Civil Rights United States and used these places as blueprints for their new ethno-state starting in 1947.
The tactics employed daily throughout the occupied territories are eerily reminiscent of these historic mistakes and its tactics and propaganda are now being reimported to the United States in particular.
I now find myself reluctant to call Israel a nation as that lends an air of respectability to what has be perpetrated. Interestingly, utilizing largely American taxpayer money to foster the narrative of "civilization", "democracy" and "progress", a ethno-fascist regime has grown in place of these ideals.
The culture of Israel shamelessly continues to use the atrocities of The Holocaust as a propaganda smokescreen to obscure the behavior that so well mirrors the villains of that same history. I never thought I would feel a sense of shame in participating in the opening ceremonies of my local Holocaust Museum as a child, but the quoted words and fanatical behavior of Israelis definitely pushes me in that direction. As I continued to read of the daily desecration of that memory in the name of ethnic nationalism I must say that I am disgusted.
"Goliath" covers some of the background of the Israeli colonial territories in the Arabic Peninsula as far back as 1947, but mainly focuses on the era of 1990-2012, with an emphasis on the 5 year period Blumenthal spent witnessing history in Israel firsthand. He came to know its internal politics and struggles intimately as this was made easier for him due to his Jewish ethnic background. From besieged Gazan villages to the halls of the increasingly fascist Knesset, Blumenthal probes the striated layers of Isreali-Palestinian social constructs to the best of his ability.
I won't go into too much detail, but I must say that this book will turn your stomach one way or another. It may also turn your views on the subject as well, whether you actually care for human rights, international integrity and democratic ideals or whether you have fallen for the Israeli propaganda that the revisionists have sold to the world and US in particular. You will not forget this document, ever.
If Israel is truly the shining beacon of democracy in the middle-east, then religious ethno-nationalism should be its mortal enemy. However, in this troubled land, that enemy has been embraced with open arms and panicked heart, a slap in the face to all Holocaust victims and survivors, Jewish or otherwise, alike.
"Tapuz, a website for Israelis living abroad, hosted a 2005 forum on the topic of leaving Israel. According to the site's administrator, Limor Abis, the most frequently cited explanation for why they left was, 'The question is not why we left, but why it took so long to do so'." (Chapter 73, "Exodus")
This discussion is not over, unfortunately in many ways it is still just warming up and beginning to burn through the fog of state and religiously-sanctioned propaganda shrouding this small territory. All it may take for this fascist kettle to boil over is one more rash action. Whether the action of a government with no standing Constitution after 70 years, its ghetto-living minority, or of their neighbors, the cousins of the ghetto-living minority. If you wish to be prepared to understand this nearly inevitable day, this book is an excellent place to begin your education.
- 5.0 de 5 estrellasCompra verificadaA SAD STATE OF AFFAIRSCalificado en Estados Unidos el 26 de noviembre de 2013This book which I highly recommend, is certainly an eye opener. The author went to extremes researching his book by visiting Israel and traveling extensively around the country while conducting numerous interviews of government officials, politicians military officers and... Ver másThis book which I highly recommend, is certainly an eye opener. The author went to extremes researching his book by visiting Israel and traveling extensively around the country while conducting numerous interviews of government officials, politicians military officers and enlisted IDF personnel, Living with Israeli and Palestinians, interviewing illegal immigrants and the lower classes of society which include Jews who's ancestry was from Arab countries, Ethiopians and Russians and any Africans. He personally witnessed improper and outrageous behavior by Israeli citizens and their soldiers and he brings the Israeli Knesset into full perspective.Israel was originally founded by well educated European Jewry who formed an idea assisted along by European imperial powers who recognized the Zionist movement as an opportunity to have a European presence strategically placed in the Middle East to assist with controlling the Arab population, strictly for their own personal gain. Behind the idea of Zionism was the centuries old European Jewish experience of anti-Antisemitism which included murderous pogroms, and severe restrictions, thus the idea of a Jewish state was formed. The idea basically arose in the late 19th century with the primary purpose of gathering together the Jewish diaspora and than return to the land of Israel where the Jewish people would have their own independent state as promised in the bible. Luckily for the Zionist movement Britain took control of the Palestine area after the defeat of the Ottoman Empire during WW I. To achieve these goals Zionism had to create a strong mythology, first and foremost was that the area they wished to claim was almost totally uninhabited and, left to ruin since the forced cleansing of the Jewish people 2000 years earlier by the Roman Empire who had referred to the area as Palestine. European Zionist began a campaign to mystify the history of the Jewish people who largely were unmoved by Zionism at the turn of the century and only saw themselves as a persecuted minority in their respective native countries and had no desire to live and work in some desert in the Middle East. The book of course takes us to WW II, which needs no further explanation. Unfortunately the Zionist now had the Holocaust to hold over the world and their argument now seemed to have some true merit, the Jews had earned the right to their own state. Israel comes into being after a 1947 U.N. resolution and the new State of Israel's founding fathers are basically European socialist, with a tinge of Communists along with some religious Zealots who wished to demonstrate to the world that the Jewish people will never again be the victim of ethnic cleansing and bigotry. The author clearly explains how the State led by a very militaristic, ultra nationalistic culture, particularly after the 1967 War, begins to displays it's true colors by their very racist ideas of who is a proper Jew, (White Europeans) not Middle East/Arab Jews, African's or Asians. Racism is always present throughout the society as a whole and mimics everything the Jews themselves went through in Europe. What sets in eventually is a highly militaristic society who are totally controlled by fear of another holocaust which is always left hanging over their heads. They develop a total hatred and intolerance of Arabs and most foreigners. The book brings us up to the present state of affairs in the so called Middle Easts only democracy. The author more than makes his point, that the very corrupted Israeli government and their vaunted military primarily used on defenseless Arabs and in many cases visiting journalist and peace nix leads most often to a deadly conclusion. The author again, demonstrates through his research how this in-conceived religious state has morphed into a true Fascist, apartheid society that excludes large numbers of it's so-called citizens and feels no compulsion to, without prior notice remove portions of its non-Jewish residents from their homes which are than demolished, sending many of the disposed to "The camps." Frighteningly the book reminds one of of Germany, during the period covering 1933-1940. The same racist ideas, the ultra nationalism the physical attacks on Arabs and foreigners, the cold blooded murder by the Israeli Border Guards and IDF troops, the existence of the camps,forced segregation by walls, wire, machine guns and snipers. Any American who reads this book and is not moved by the brutality of the Israeli state is missing a chip. This is the only known nuclear power that has never allowed any inspection of their nuclear facilities. This is a State that feels because of the sordid history of the Jewish people it is exempt from universal rules and laws and basically calls its own shots while it accepts billions of dollars from the(U.S.) government to continually strengthen its military capabilities while its settler population slowly devours what's left of Palestinian land by force, which includes assaults, murder and intimidation of Arab men, women and children regardless of age. What the author brings forth is a picture of a ruthless Israeli government who basically wishes to stand for and by itself, but runs a very sophisticated propaganda machine and cannot under normal circumstances which is non-existent in Israel, be trusted as an ally. Israel has it's own agenda and it has nothing to do with promoting democracy in the Middle East. One need only to research the attack on the U.S.S. LIBERTY a technical research ship in international water on June 8, 1967 by the Israeli air force jets who bombed and machine gunned the ship and Israeli navy torpedo boats, machine gunning, and killing 34 U.S. servicemen all members of the U.S.S. Liberty and wounding 171 others, leaving the ship badly damaged in international waters. This book is expertly written and difficult to put down. You will loose all your false allusions of our Middle East democratic ally, falsely claiming it is surrounded by hostile countries who wish to drive it into the sea on any given day. Israel is the elephant in the room, a true Goliath.
This book which I highly recommend, is certainly an eye opener. The author went to extremes researching his book by visiting Israel and traveling extensively around the country while conducting numerous interviews of government officials, politicians military officers and enlisted IDF personnel, Living with Israeli and Palestinians, interviewing illegal immigrants and the lower classes of society which include Jews who's ancestry was from Arab countries, Ethiopians and Russians and any Africans. He personally witnessed improper and outrageous behavior by Israeli citizens and their soldiers and he brings the Israeli Knesset into full perspective.Israel was originally founded by well educated European Jewry who formed an idea assisted along by European imperial powers who recognized the Zionist movement as an opportunity to have a European presence strategically placed in the Middle East to assist with controlling the Arab population, strictly for their own personal gain. Behind the idea of Zionism was the centuries old European Jewish experience of anti-Antisemitism which included murderous pogroms, and severe restrictions, thus the idea of a Jewish state was formed. The idea basically arose in the late 19th century with the primary purpose of gathering together the Jewish diaspora and than return to the land of Israel where the Jewish people would have their own independent state as promised in the bible. Luckily for the Zionist movement Britain took control of the Palestine area after the defeat of the Ottoman Empire during WW I. To achieve these goals Zionism had to create a strong mythology, first and foremost was that the area they wished to claim was almost totally uninhabited and, left to ruin since the forced cleansing of the Jewish people 2000 years earlier by the Roman Empire who had referred to the area as Palestine. European Zionist began a campaign to mystify the history of the Jewish people who largely were unmoved by Zionism at the turn of the century and only saw themselves as a persecuted minority in their respective native countries and had no desire to live and work in some desert in the Middle East. The book of course takes us to WW II, which needs no further explanation. Unfortunately the Zionist now had the Holocaust to hold over the world and their argument now seemed to have some true merit, the Jews had earned the right to their own state. Israel comes into being after a 1947 U.N. resolution and the new State of Israel's founding fathers are basically European socialist, with a tinge of Communists along with some religious Zealots who wished to demonstrate to the world that the Jewish people will never again be the victim of ethnic cleansing and bigotry. The author clearly explains how the State led by a very militaristic, ultra nationalistic culture, particularly after the 1967 War, begins to displays it's true colors by their very racist ideas of who is a proper Jew, (White Europeans) not Middle East/Arab Jews, African's or Asians. Racism is always present throughout the society as a whole and mimics everything the Jews themselves went through in Europe. What sets in eventually is a highly militaristic society who are totally controlled by fear of another holocaust which is always left hanging over their heads. They develop a total hatred and intolerance of Arabs and most foreigners. The book brings us up to the present state of affairs in the so called Middle Easts only democracy. The author more than makes his point, that the very corrupted Israeli government and their vaunted military primarily used on defenseless Arabs and in many cases visiting journalist and peace nix leads most often to a deadly conclusion. The author again, demonstrates through his research how this in-conceived religious state has morphed into a true Fascist, apartheid society that excludes large numbers of it's so-called citizens and feels no compulsion to, without prior notice remove portions of its non-Jewish residents from their homes which are than demolished, sending many of the disposed to "The camps." Frighteningly the book reminds one of of Germany, during the period covering 1933-1940. The same racist ideas, the ultra nationalism the physical attacks on Arabs and foreigners, the cold blooded murder by the Israeli Border Guards and IDF troops, the existence of the camps,forced segregation by walls, wire, machine guns and snipers. Any American who reads this book and is not moved by the brutality of the Israeli state is missing a chip. This is the only known nuclear power that has never allowed any inspection of their nuclear facilities. This is a State that feels because of the sordid history of the Jewish people it is exempt from universal rules and laws and basically calls its own shots while it accepts billions of dollars from the(U.S.) government to continually strengthen its military capabilities while its settler population slowly devours what's left of Palestinian land by force, which includes assaults, murder and intimidation of Arab men, women and children regardless of age. What the author brings forth is a picture of a ruthless Israeli government who basically wishes to stand for and by itself, but runs a very sophisticated propaganda machine and cannot under normal circumstances which is non-existent in Israel, be trusted as an ally. Israel has it's own agenda and it has nothing to do with promoting democracy in the Middle East. One need only to research the attack on the U.S.S. LIBERTY a technical research ship in international water on June 8, 1967 by the Israeli air force jets who bombed and machine gunned the ship and Israeli navy torpedo boats, machine gunning, and killing 34 U.S. servicemen all members of the U.S.S. Liberty and wounding 171 others, leaving the ship badly damaged in international waters. This book is expertly written and difficult to put down. You will loose all your false allusions of our Middle East democratic ally, falsely claiming it is surrounded by hostile countries who wish to drive it into the sea on any given day. Israel is the elephant in the room, a true Goliath.
- 5.0 de 5 estrellasCompra verificadaA Must ReadCalificado en Estados Unidos el 15 de febrero de 2014Zionism's founding document, "The Jewish State" written by Theodor Herzl in 1896, suffered from one oversight as noted by the Israeli historian Benny Morris: "Herzl's attitude towards Palestine's Arabs was that of the garden-variety European... Ver másZionism's founding document, "The Jewish State" written by Theodor Herzl in 1896, suffered from one oversight as noted by the Israeli historian Benny Morris: "Herzl's attitude towards Palestine's Arabs was that of the garden-variety European imperialist towards native populations. Thus he failed completely to predict the Arab nationalist antagonism to Zionism and to the emergence of a Jewish state, and the decades long struggle that would follow... Herzl's revolutionary, programmatic essay proposing a Zionist solution to the Jewish problem is truly remarkable in that it fails completely to note that Palestine already contained a sizeable Arab population and fails completely to take the Arabs into account in its scheme of future things. The Arabs are simply not there."
Herzl's oversight might be explained by the fact he had never visited the area prior to writing his book, but then did visit Palestine leading to his second book, the novel "Altneuland," that propels the reader into the future of 1923 with some passing references to the Arabs and we are introduced to one "Reschid, a prosperous cultivator of oranges who lauds the Jewish influx as having brought prosperity to him and his kind." The Balfour Declaration of 1917 put some starch in Herzl's vision, stating in part that "His Majesty's Government views with favor the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people and will use their best endeavors to facilitate the achievement of this object, it being clearly understood that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine..."
These fatuous visions were soon shattered by the Arab revolt of 1921 leading to a more muscular approach advocated by Ze'ev Jabotinsky's "The Iron Wall" published in 1923. An excellent writer and speaker who cut to the chase, a few of his words are worthy of repetition: "As long as the Arabs feel that there is the last hope of getting rid of us they will refuse to give up this hope in return for either kind words or for bread an butter, because they are not a rabble, but a living people. And when a living people yields in matters of such a vital character it is only when there is no longer any hope of getting rid of us, because they can make no breach in the iron wall... If you wish to colonize a land in which people are already living you must provide a garrison for the land, or find some 'rich man' benefactor who will provide a garrison on your behalf... Zionism is a colonizing adventure and therefore it stands or falls by the question of armed force. It is important to speak Hebrew, but, unfortunately, it is even more important to be able to shoot."
What has transpired in the century-plus since Herzl's initial impetus is the conflict between Zionism's ideals and the harsher realities of Jabotinsky's "gun Zionism," a grinding ethnic cleansing project of the indigenous population justified by democratic ideals. To, finally, get to the point at hand, Blumenthal's book, this is a series of fairly short - and very well written - essays about his real life experiences in Israel beginning in 2009, a period marked by the political rise of Avigdor Lieberman, a former bouncer and airport baggage handler from Moldavia who founded the far-right Yisrael Beiteinu Party in 1999, who teamed up with Netanyahu's Likud Party to set a new agenda that might be summed up in one of their followers' favorite phases, "Death to Arabs." Israel's political history, not unlike ours, has been characterized as battles between "the left" and "the right," albeit for the Palestinians a difference without a distinction, but at least in Knesset legal wrangles the leftists advanced arguments smacking of democratic ideals - and the Israeli Supreme Court often rendered decisions that were even-handed. A movement to the Hard Right began with the disintegration of the USSR.
In the early 1990s a million Soviet citizens emigrated to Israel, in part financed by the USA: Bush Sr. and Secretary Baker were adamantly opposed to a $10 billion loan guaranty to hasten this influx, but the bought-and-paid for members of Congress saw otherwise, voting overwhelmingly for the aid package as this would "promote peace in the region." The Russian immigrants, many of whom were quickly spirited to West Bank settlements such as Ariel, appear to have a near-universal visceral hatred of Arabs, a bias clearly reflected in Lieberman's agenda. What Blumenthal describes in rather chilling detail is the ascent of the Likud-Yisreal Beiteinu block in the Knesset where draconian new laws are passed to silence all opposition (including the Supreme Court) to an accelerated ethnic cleansing project. Worse yet, opposition parties, such as the middle-road Kadima Party, have become mute. Arab Knesset members still willing to fight on are easily silenced by new "laws" that make any mention of civil or political rights a "threat to national security" with the appropriate prison sentence. Blumenthal describes a dystopian security state that reaches down to the minutest levels of Israeli society as the country speeds up its project to cleanse the land of it indigenous inhabitants - with the unquestioned backing of the U.S. Congress.
Zionism's founding document, "The Jewish State" written by Theodor Herzl in 1896, suffered from one oversight as noted by the Israeli historian Benny Morris: "Herzl's attitude towards Palestine's Arabs was that of the garden-variety European imperialist towards native populations. Thus he failed completely to predict the Arab nationalist antagonism to Zionism and to the emergence of a Jewish state, and the decades long struggle that would follow... Herzl's revolutionary, programmatic essay proposing a Zionist solution to the Jewish problem is truly remarkable in that it fails completely to note that Palestine already contained a sizeable Arab population and fails completely to take the Arabs into account in its scheme of future things. The Arabs are simply not there."
Herzl's oversight might be explained by the fact he had never visited the area prior to writing his book, but then did visit Palestine leading to his second book, the novel "Altneuland," that propels the reader into the future of 1923 with some passing references to the Arabs and we are introduced to one "Reschid, a prosperous cultivator of oranges who lauds the Jewish influx as having brought prosperity to him and his kind." The Balfour Declaration of 1917 put some starch in Herzl's vision, stating in part that "His Majesty's Government views with favor the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people and will use their best endeavors to facilitate the achievement of this object, it being clearly understood that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine..."
These fatuous visions were soon shattered by the Arab revolt of 1921 leading to a more muscular approach advocated by Ze'ev Jabotinsky's "The Iron Wall" published in 1923. An excellent writer and speaker who cut to the chase, a few of his words are worthy of repetition: "As long as the Arabs feel that there is the last hope of getting rid of us they will refuse to give up this hope in return for either kind words or for bread an butter, because they are not a rabble, but a living people. And when a living people yields in matters of such a vital character it is only when there is no longer any hope of getting rid of us, because they can make no breach in the iron wall... If you wish to colonize a land in which people are already living you must provide a garrison for the land, or find some 'rich man' benefactor who will provide a garrison on your behalf... Zionism is a colonizing adventure and therefore it stands or falls by the question of armed force. It is important to speak Hebrew, but, unfortunately, it is even more important to be able to shoot."
What has transpired in the century-plus since Herzl's initial impetus is the conflict between Zionism's ideals and the harsher realities of Jabotinsky's "gun Zionism," a grinding ethnic cleansing project of the indigenous population justified by democratic ideals. To, finally, get to the point at hand, Blumenthal's book, this is a series of fairly short - and very well written - essays about his real life experiences in Israel beginning in 2009, a period marked by the political rise of Avigdor Lieberman, a former bouncer and airport baggage handler from Moldavia who founded the far-right Yisrael Beiteinu Party in 1999, who teamed up with Netanyahu's Likud Party to set a new agenda that might be summed up in one of their followers' favorite phases, "Death to Arabs." Israel's political history, not unlike ours, has been characterized as battles between "the left" and "the right," albeit for the Palestinians a difference without a distinction, but at least in Knesset legal wrangles the leftists advanced arguments smacking of democratic ideals - and the Israeli Supreme Court often rendered decisions that were even-handed. A movement to the Hard Right began with the disintegration of the USSR.
In the early 1990s a million Soviet citizens emigrated to Israel, in part financed by the USA: Bush Sr. and Secretary Baker were adamantly opposed to a $10 billion loan guaranty to hasten this influx, but the bought-and-paid for members of Congress saw otherwise, voting overwhelmingly for the aid package as this would "promote peace in the region." The Russian immigrants, many of whom were quickly spirited to West Bank settlements such as Ariel, appear to have a near-universal visceral hatred of Arabs, a bias clearly reflected in Lieberman's agenda. What Blumenthal describes in rather chilling detail is the ascent of the Likud-Yisreal Beiteinu block in the Knesset where draconian new laws are passed to silence all opposition (including the Supreme Court) to an accelerated ethnic cleansing project. Worse yet, opposition parties, such as the middle-road Kadima Party, have become mute. Arab Knesset members still willing to fight on are easily silenced by new "laws" that make any mention of civil or political rights a "threat to national security" with the appropriate prison sentence. Blumenthal describes a dystopian security state that reaches down to the minutest levels of Israeli society as the country speeds up its project to cleanse the land of it indigenous inhabitants - with the unquestioned backing of the U.S. Congress.
- 5.0 de 5 estrellasCompra verificadaand as the great thinker of IsraelCalificado en Estados Unidos el 25 de julio de 2015There are two books that have been truly earth shaking revelations about the whole issue of Israel and the Talmudic philosophy that Netanyahu has boasted is the ruling premise for the state of Israel. This book and Michael Hoffman's stellar work, "Judaism's... Ver másThere are two books that have been truly earth shaking revelations about the whole issue of Israel and the Talmudic philosophy that Netanyahu has boasted is the ruling premise for the state of Israel. This book and Michael Hoffman's stellar work, "Judaism's Strange Gods" are bookends to clear the fog of obsfucation that is pandemic in both topics. I have been riveted by the fact based, carefully researched realizations that Blumenthal's work has revealed. It is nothing short of a must for those who want to know what is behind the rhetoric and fog that is so darkly hiding truths that will, I fear, destroy the state of Israel, and prove to be a dark stain on the morality of people and nations who allowed the evils of apartheid to flourish and wreck such umitigated evil in Gaza. But the work is far more than a expose of that tragic and evil episode, still being played out today. Blumenthal goes back to trace the actors and philosophies that have been rooted in Israel from its very beginnings to the present day. Facts are pesky things, but they are vital to deal with forces that charade as being valiant when in reality they are nothing new to the history of mankind, and as the great thinker of Israel,Yeshaayahu Leibowitz, holder of eight Ph.D's and often called, "The conscience of Israel" dared to state, "The Arabs would be the working people and the Jews the administrators, inspectors, officials, and police---mainly secret police. A state ruling a hostile population of 1-2 million foreigners would necessarily become a secret-police state with all that this implies for education, free speech and democratic institutions...There is also good reason to fear that the Israel Defense Force, wich has been until now a people's army, would, as a result of being a transformed into an army of occupaton, degenerate, and its commanders, who will have become military governors, resemble their colleaguesin other nations." He also presciently warned that "unpartitioned Eretz Israel" to the apartheid states lkording over indigenous blacks in southern Africa, warning htat a culture of racism would consume Jewish society." The hidden facts exposed in this must read book show how true this Jewish intellectual has proven to be.
There are two books that have been truly earth shaking revelations about the whole issue of Israel and the Talmudic philosophy that Netanyahu has boasted is the ruling premise for the state of Israel. This book and Michael Hoffman's stellar work, "Judaism's Strange Gods" are bookends to clear the fog of obsfucation that is pandemic in both topics. I have been riveted by the fact based, carefully researched realizations that Blumenthal's work has revealed. It is nothing short of a must for those who want to know what is behind the rhetoric and fog that is so darkly hiding truths that will, I fear, destroy the state of Israel, and prove to be a dark stain on the morality of people and nations who allowed the evils of apartheid to flourish and wreck such umitigated evil in Gaza. But the work is far more than a expose of that tragic and evil episode, still being played out today. Blumenthal goes back to trace the actors and philosophies that have been rooted in Israel from its very beginnings to the present day. Facts are pesky things, but they are vital to deal with forces that charade as being valiant when in reality they are nothing new to the history of mankind, and as the great thinker of Israel,Yeshaayahu Leibowitz, holder of eight Ph.D's and often called, "The conscience of Israel" dared to state, "The Arabs would be the working people and the Jews the administrators, inspectors, officials, and police---mainly secret police. A state ruling a hostile population of 1-2 million foreigners would necessarily become a secret-police state with all that this implies for education, free speech and democratic institutions...There is also good reason to fear that the Israel Defense Force, wich has been until now a people's army, would, as a result of being a transformed into an army of occupaton, degenerate, and its commanders, who will have become military governors, resemble their colleaguesin other nations." He also presciently warned that "unpartitioned Eretz Israel" to the apartheid states lkording over indigenous blacks in southern Africa, warning htat a culture of racism would consume Jewish society." The hidden facts exposed in this must read book show how true this Jewish intellectual has proven to be.
- 5.0 de 5 estrellasCompra verificadaTruth of IsraelCalificado en Estados Unidos el 29 de diciembre de 2013The author and publisher are both commended for their courage in exposing the Fascist Apartheid of Israel! A supposed ally of the U.S. while disregarding the savage IDF attack on the U.S.S. Liberty and decades of flouting pleas of restricting illegal Israeli settlements on... Ver másThe author and publisher are both commended for their courage in exposing the Fascist Apartheid of Israel! A supposed ally of the U.S. while disregarding the savage IDF attack on the U.S.S. Liberty and decades of flouting pleas of restricting illegal Israeli settlements on Palestinian territory. The author, as in “Republican Gomorrah” is a seeker of the TRUTH which in Goliath reveals the hideous fascist State of Israel! The U.S. is in part responsible for the Israeli fascism and the U.S. exhibits similar right-wing conservative values of criminal and corrupt plutocracy, hypocrisy, racism, misogyny and homophobia. The U.S. conservatives reject any funding for Camden, N.J., Youngstown, Ohio, Gary, Ind. or Detroit, Mich. but strongly support billions of aid for Israel, 3 billion a year since 1985! As Truman’s Sec. of State, Gen. Marshall opposed recognizing Israel and prophesized that Israel would result in endless conflicts. Winston Smith of Orwell’s 1984 would immediately know Israel as the totalitarian state of Oceania of Big Brother! A more disturbing comparison is that of William Shirer’s “The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich” of the nightmare of NAZI Germany with Israel’s policies of apartheid discrimination and murderous oppression of the Arabs, Bedouins and Palestinians. The Israeli Shin Bet is but the NAZI Gestapo! Israel holds the U.S. in disdain! Israel believes it has unlimited support of the American Israeli lobby, the religious right and the neoconservative Republicans in Congress. It is obvious Netanyahu, real name Milikovsky, is not interested in a Two State solution of peace. Western policy makers can no longer use the guilt of the NAZI Holocaust as an excuse to disregard the plight of the Palestinians. The Holocaust was the result of centuries of mythical Christian religiosity and anti-Semitic “Pogroms” of the European Jewish communities for any irrational reason, natural disaster, epidemics, etc. However, it is a gross hypocrisy of Israel not recognizing Ottoman Turkey’s horrific genocide of over 1.5 million Armenians but drawing constant attention to the NAZI Holocaust as justification for its oppressive and militaristic policies. As to religion, Judaism, Christianity and Islam are essentially the same religion and there is no difference between the Israeli Rabbis, Christians such as Falwell, Hagee, Gen. Boykin and the Iranian Mullahs, that expound similar intolerances, bigotries, and hatreds. As Voltaire said, “Those who can make you believe in absurdities can make you commit atrocities.” Zionism of Israelis claiming a fictional “divine right” to the “Land of Israel and Judah” is a myth! The author has documented that Israel must be saved from itself; it has chosen demographics over democracy, racism over tolerance, barbaric cruelty over humane compassion! Israel has become a Pariah among civilized nations! Palestinians must be recognized as a Nation State by the U.N. with borders reflecting 1967 borders as per U.N. Resolution 242, etc. with contiguous territory, equal water rights and with access to the Mediterranean Sea. Jerusalem should be established as an International City under the auspices of the U.N. It is a mockery, a delusional fraud that the U.S. is an honest broker in the Israeli-Palestinian negotiations. The Two-State negotiations should be conducted by the U.N. Security Council with a stated completion date and with broad sanctions imposed on Israel for any continued obstruction to include seizure of Israeli assets and embargo of trade.
The author and publisher are both commended for their courage in exposing the Fascist Apartheid of Israel! A supposed ally of the U.S. while disregarding the savage IDF attack on the U.S.S. Liberty and decades of flouting pleas of restricting illegal Israeli settlements on Palestinian territory. The author, as in “Republican Gomorrah” is a seeker of the TRUTH which in Goliath reveals the hideous fascist State of Israel! The U.S. is in part responsible for the Israeli fascism and the U.S. exhibits similar right-wing conservative values of criminal and corrupt plutocracy, hypocrisy, racism, misogyny and homophobia. The U.S. conservatives reject any funding for Camden, N.J., Youngstown, Ohio, Gary, Ind. or Detroit, Mich. but strongly support billions of aid for Israel, 3 billion a year since 1985! As Truman’s Sec. of State, Gen. Marshall opposed recognizing Israel and prophesized that Israel would result in endless conflicts. Winston Smith of Orwell’s 1984 would immediately know Israel as the totalitarian state of Oceania of Big Brother! A more disturbing comparison is that of William Shirer’s “The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich” of the nightmare of NAZI Germany with Israel’s policies of apartheid discrimination and murderous oppression of the Arabs, Bedouins and Palestinians. The Israeli Shin Bet is but the NAZI Gestapo! Israel holds the U.S. in disdain! Israel believes it has unlimited support of the American Israeli lobby, the religious right and the neoconservative Republicans in Congress. It is obvious Netanyahu, real name Milikovsky, is not interested in a Two State solution of peace. Western policy makers can no longer use the guilt of the NAZI Holocaust as an excuse to disregard the plight of the Palestinians. The Holocaust was the result of centuries of mythical Christian religiosity and anti-Semitic “Pogroms” of the European Jewish communities for any irrational reason, natural disaster, epidemics, etc. However, it is a gross hypocrisy of Israel not recognizing Ottoman Turkey’s horrific genocide of over 1.5 million Armenians but drawing constant attention to the NAZI Holocaust as justification for its oppressive and militaristic policies. As to religion, Judaism, Christianity and Islam are essentially the same religion and there is no difference between the Israeli Rabbis, Christians such as Falwell, Hagee, Gen. Boykin and the Iranian Mullahs, that expound similar intolerances, bigotries, and hatreds. As Voltaire said, “Those who can make you believe in absurdities can make you commit atrocities.” Zionism of Israelis claiming a fictional “divine right” to the “Land of Israel and Judah” is a myth! The author has documented that Israel must be saved from itself; it has chosen demographics over democracy, racism over tolerance, barbaric cruelty over humane compassion! Israel has become a Pariah among civilized nations! Palestinians must be recognized as a Nation State by the U.N. with borders reflecting 1967 borders as per U.N. Resolution 242, etc. with contiguous territory, equal water rights and with access to the Mediterranean Sea. Jerusalem should be established as an International City under the auspices of the U.N. It is a mockery, a delusional fraud that the U.S. is an honest broker in the Israeli-Palestinian negotiations. The Two-State negotiations should be conducted by the U.N. Security Council with a stated completion date and with broad sanctions imposed on Israel for any continued obstruction to include seizure of Israeli assets and embargo of trade.
Opiniones más destacadas de otros países
- Traducir todas las opiniones al Español
Amazon Customer5.0 de 5 estrellasCompra verificadaExcellent work. Very educational.Calificado en Canadá el 9 de febrero de 2024Great book! As someone who grew up in Israel, I can confirm that the general attitudes of the Israeli public described in this book are right on point. The book illustrates Israel's policies towards Palestine and the role that Zionism plays in shaping policy. Highly...Ver másGreat book! As someone who grew up in Israel, I can confirm that the general attitudes of the Israeli public described in this book are right on point. The book illustrates Israel's policies towards Palestine and the role that Zionism plays in shaping policy. Highly recommended to anyone trying to understand what led recent events in Israel.Great book! As someone who grew up in Israel, I can confirm that the general attitudes of the Israeli public described in this book are right on point. The book illustrates Israel's policies towards Palestine and the role that Zionism plays in shaping policy. Highly recommended to anyone trying to understand what led recent events in Israel.
Lauramath5.0 de 5 estrellasCompra verificadaInsightful and interestingCalificado en Reino Unido el 2 de septiembre de 2024Look into the strange world of Israel's occupation of Palestine. Reading this with the benefit of hindsight is illuminating.Look into the strange world of Israel's occupation of Palestine. Reading this with the benefit of hindsight is illuminating.
Oliver Völckers5.0 de 5 estrellasCompra verificadaIsrael, was ist aus dir geworden?Calificado en Alemania el 19 de diciembre de 2014"These are the stories of people living under a regime of separation, grappling with the consequences of ethnic division in a land with no defined borders“ (Max Blumenthal) Der US-amerikanische Historiker, Journalist und Bestsellerautor Max Blumenthal hat sich...Ver más"These are the stories of people living under a regime of separation, grappling with the consequences of ethnic division in a land with no defined borders“ (Max Blumenthal) Der US-amerikanische Historiker, Journalist und Bestsellerautor Max Blumenthal hat sich insbesondere mit der Politik der Republikanischen Partei und Israels auseinandergesetzt. Sein Vater Sidney Blumenthal war Assistent von US-Präsident Clinton, von daher ist der Sohn gut vernetzt in der politischen Elite der USA und auch Israels, aber ebenso in der alternativen Szene. In Deutschland wurde Max Blumenthal durch das sogenannte Toilettengate bekannt, als er im Deutschen Bundestag zusammen mit dem Israeli David Sheen den Linken-Politiker Gregor Gysi bedrängte, um Antworten auf tatsächliche oder vermeintliche Diffamierungen zu bekommen. In der deutschen Presse wurde Blumenthal dann u.a. als „irrer Israel-Hasser“ beschimpft, was ihm überhaupt nicht gerecht wird. Dieses Buch beschreibt die Politik und Geschichte Israels sowohl aus der Sicht der Zionisten als auch der vertriebenen Palästinenser und der nichtjüdischen Israelis. Blumenthal hat viel Zeit in Israel und Palästina verbracht und unterschiedlichste Menschen interviewt. An diesem Buch hat er vier Jahre gearbeitet. Als jüdischer US-Amerikaner, der Hebräisch und Arabisch versteht, hatte er dabei persönlichen Zugang zu erzkonservativen, kriegerischen Politikern und als linker Aktivist auch zu arabisch-israelischen Demonstranten und Bürgerrechtlern. Das Buch ist in zehn Teile und insgesamt 73 Kapitel gegliedert, zum Teil chronologisch geordnet, zum Teil nach Themen. Die Gliederung habe ich nicht verstanden. Mal schildert Blumenthal historische Gegebenheiten, mal wechselt er zu persönlichen Berichten. Jedes Kapitel ist aber für sich schlüssig und überzeugend und lebendig erzählt. Blumenthal beschreibt u.a. - die Bombardierung der Gaza-Polizei durch Israel nach dem Wahlsieg der Hamas 2008 - den Aufstieg des früheren Türstehers Avigdor Lieberman zum Minister mithilfe russischer Geldquellen - die Vertreibung der Palästinenser angeführt durch Ben Gurion 1948 - den Boykott arabischer Händler, deren Gemüse mit Kerosin überschüttet wurde, ihre Eier zerschmettert - die Zerstörung der Häuser der Vertriebenen, die Enteignung ihrer Orangenplantagen und Olivenbäume - seit 1967 wurden über 26.000 palästinensische Wohnungen abgerissen - Kinder der nichtjüdischen Bevölkerung werden nachts aus dem Bett geholt und verhaftet - dagegen wird seit Jahrzehnten in israelischen Schulen diese Vertreibung verschwiegen, sodass Erwachsene wenig darüber wissen - stattdessen wird der Widerstand gegen die Besatzung nur mit „Antisemitismus“ verklärt - wer dagegen demonstriert, wird von der Polizei überwacht. - Protestierenden Israelis drohen Verhaftungen und Misshandlungen, Nicht-Israelis droht Schusswaffengebrauch - die Zionisten fühlen sich von allen bedroht, die ihrem jüdischen Nationalismus im Weg stehen, also nicht nur Muslime, sondern auch Christen oder afrikanische Flüchtlinge - einige Rabbis warnen jüdische Frauen öffentlich davor, sich mit „Kamelreitern“ einzulassen - ein Prof. Dan Schueftan vertritt das Konzept der hafrada, einer Art Apartheid, deren politische Umsetzung u.a. den Mauerbau beinhaltet Blumenthal belegt alles mit umfangreichen Fußnoten. Soweit ich sehen kann, sind die von ihm berichteten Fakten auch nicht umstritten. Allerdings sind einige Kapitel-Überschriften bewusst provozierend gewählt: „The Silence of the Lambs“, „How to kill Goyim and influence people“, „The Concentration Camp", und Zitate wie „Judeo-Nazis“. Dies hat in Deutschland zu dem Vorwurf geführt, Blumenthal vergleiche Israel mit Nazideutschland. Dabei ist der Autor weit von solchen unangemessenen Beschimpfungen entfernt, auch wenn er empört ist über die Verbrechen und Ungerechtigkeiten der Besatzung. In Israel ist das Trauma des Holocaust bzw. der Shoa allgegenwärtig, daher kommen solche Vergleiche in einer aufgeheizten politischen Auseinandersetzung durchaus vor. Blumenthal hat sich das nicht zu eigen gemacht, aber er zitiert es wiederholt. Diese Feinheiten fallen in einer verkürzten Darstellung etwa in der Zeitung mit den großen Buchstaben gerne unter den Tisch. Das Buch ist unbedingt lesenswert für alle die diesen Konflikt verstehen wollen. Es beschreibt den Hintergrund und die aktuelle Situation Israels aus erster Hand und von allen Seiten. Eine Übersetzung ins Deutsche wäre wünschenswert."These are the stories of people living under a regime of separation, grappling with the consequences of ethnic division in a land with no defined borders“ (Max Blumenthal)
Der US-amerikanische Historiker, Journalist und Bestsellerautor Max Blumenthal hat sich insbesondere mit der Politik der Republikanischen Partei und Israels auseinandergesetzt. Sein Vater Sidney Blumenthal war Assistent von US-Präsident Clinton, von daher ist der Sohn gut vernetzt in der politischen Elite der USA und auch Israels, aber ebenso in der alternativen Szene.
In Deutschland wurde Max Blumenthal durch das sogenannte Toilettengate bekannt, als er im Deutschen Bundestag zusammen mit dem Israeli David Sheen den Linken-Politiker Gregor Gysi bedrängte, um Antworten auf tatsächliche oder vermeintliche Diffamierungen zu bekommen. In der deutschen Presse wurde Blumenthal dann u.a. als „irrer Israel-Hasser“ beschimpft, was ihm überhaupt nicht gerecht wird.
Dieses Buch beschreibt die Politik und Geschichte Israels sowohl aus der Sicht der Zionisten als auch der vertriebenen Palästinenser und der nichtjüdischen Israelis. Blumenthal hat viel Zeit in Israel und Palästina verbracht und unterschiedlichste Menschen interviewt. An diesem Buch hat er vier Jahre gearbeitet. Als jüdischer US-Amerikaner, der Hebräisch und Arabisch versteht, hatte er dabei persönlichen Zugang zu erzkonservativen, kriegerischen Politikern und als linker Aktivist auch zu arabisch-israelischen Demonstranten und Bürgerrechtlern.
Das Buch ist in zehn Teile und insgesamt 73 Kapitel gegliedert, zum Teil chronologisch geordnet, zum Teil nach Themen. Die Gliederung habe ich nicht verstanden. Mal schildert Blumenthal historische Gegebenheiten, mal wechselt er zu persönlichen Berichten. Jedes Kapitel ist aber für sich schlüssig und überzeugend und lebendig erzählt. Blumenthal beschreibt u.a.
- die Bombardierung der Gaza-Polizei durch Israel nach dem Wahlsieg der Hamas 2008
- den Aufstieg des früheren Türstehers Avigdor Lieberman zum Minister mithilfe russischer Geldquellen
- die Vertreibung der Palästinenser angeführt durch Ben Gurion 1948
- den Boykott arabischer Händler, deren Gemüse mit Kerosin überschüttet wurde, ihre Eier zerschmettert
- die Zerstörung der Häuser der Vertriebenen, die Enteignung ihrer Orangenplantagen und Olivenbäume
- seit 1967 wurden über 26.000 palästinensische Wohnungen abgerissen
- Kinder der nichtjüdischen Bevölkerung werden nachts aus dem Bett geholt und verhaftet
- dagegen wird seit Jahrzehnten in israelischen Schulen diese Vertreibung verschwiegen, sodass Erwachsene wenig darüber wissen
- stattdessen wird der Widerstand gegen die Besatzung nur mit „Antisemitismus“ verklärt
- wer dagegen demonstriert, wird von der Polizei überwacht.
- Protestierenden Israelis drohen Verhaftungen und Misshandlungen, Nicht-Israelis droht Schusswaffengebrauch
- die Zionisten fühlen sich von allen bedroht, die ihrem jüdischen Nationalismus im Weg stehen, also nicht nur Muslime, sondern auch Christen oder afrikanische Flüchtlinge
- einige Rabbis warnen jüdische Frauen öffentlich davor, sich mit „Kamelreitern“ einzulassen
- ein Prof. Dan Schueftan vertritt das Konzept der hafrada, einer Art Apartheid, deren politische Umsetzung u.a. den Mauerbau beinhaltet
Blumenthal belegt alles mit umfangreichen Fußnoten. Soweit ich sehen kann, sind die von ihm berichteten Fakten auch nicht umstritten. Allerdings sind einige Kapitel-Überschriften bewusst provozierend gewählt: „The Silence of the Lambs“, „How to kill Goyim and influence people“, „The Concentration Camp", und Zitate wie „Judeo-Nazis“.
Dies hat in Deutschland zu dem Vorwurf geführt, Blumenthal vergleiche Israel mit Nazideutschland. Dabei ist der Autor weit von solchen unangemessenen Beschimpfungen entfernt, auch wenn er empört ist über die Verbrechen und Ungerechtigkeiten der Besatzung. In Israel ist das Trauma des Holocaust bzw. der Shoa allgegenwärtig, daher kommen solche Vergleiche in einer aufgeheizten politischen Auseinandersetzung durchaus vor. Blumenthal hat sich das nicht zu eigen gemacht, aber er zitiert es wiederholt. Diese Feinheiten fallen in einer verkürzten Darstellung etwa in der Zeitung mit den großen Buchstaben gerne unter den Tisch.
Das Buch ist unbedingt lesenswert für alle die diesen Konflikt verstehen wollen. Es beschreibt den Hintergrund und die aktuelle Situation Israels aus erster Hand und von allen Seiten. Eine Übersetzung ins Deutsche wäre wünschenswert.
Christiane Moloney5.0 de 5 estrellasCompra verificadathe banality of evilCalificado en Australia el 26 de mayo de 2014This is a truly devastating book that has shattered the myths I held dear about Israel. It should be compulsory reading for every Israeli citizen, American taxpayer and all who aspire for peace with justice in the Middle East. Would that such a book had been written about...Ver másThis is a truly devastating book that has shattered the myths I held dear about Israel. It should be compulsory reading for every Israeli citizen, American taxpayer and all who aspire for peace with justice in the Middle East. Would that such a book had been written about Germany in the 1930's. How supremely ironic that the 'people of the book' should so slavishly ignore the golden rule: "do unto others ..." I have always wondered how such a sophisticated and cultured society as Germany could slide into fascism and was enlightened by Hannah Arendt's coverage of the Eichman trial and her observation about 'the banality of evil'. Max Blumenthal has written chapter and verse about our collective 'dark side'. We are all capable of such evil and he and Adendt exhort us to think more expansively about the bureaucracy and practices of our various nation states. My own country, Australia, has recently elected a bunch of 'tea party' conservatives to govern our nation who are now taking a wrecking ball to our formerly egalitarian society. I read the ebook version of 'Goliath' and still held doubts as to whether there were some other explanations for the behaviours described in it until I finished the text and toggled through the extensive notes attached at the book's conclusion. The evidence is overwhelming. The book leaves unanswered what those of us who support peace can actually do or is BDS the only answer? Michael JohnstonThis is a truly devastating book that has shattered the myths I held dear about Israel. It should be compulsory reading for every Israeli citizen, American taxpayer and all who aspire for peace with justice in the Middle East. Would that such a book had been written about Germany in the 1930's. How supremely ironic that the 'people of the book' should so slavishly ignore the golden rule: "do unto others ..."
I have always wondered how such a sophisticated and cultured society as Germany could slide into fascism and was enlightened by Hannah Arendt's coverage of the Eichman trial and her observation about 'the banality of evil'. Max Blumenthal has written chapter and verse about our collective 'dark side'. We are all capable of such evil and he and Adendt exhort us to think more expansively about the bureaucracy and practices of our various nation states. My own country, Australia, has recently elected a bunch of 'tea party' conservatives to govern our nation who are now taking a wrecking ball to our formerly egalitarian society.
I read the ebook version of 'Goliath' and still held doubts as to whether there were some other explanations for the behaviours described in it until I finished the text and toggled through the extensive notes attached at the book's conclusion. The evidence is overwhelming.
The book leaves unanswered what those of us who support peace can actually do or is BDS the only answer?
Michael Johnston
Alan Buckle5.0 de 5 estrellasCompra verificadaA very frightening but essential book,Calificado en Alemania el 16 de octubre de 2016A very frightening book, written by a Jewish American reporter who investigated all and spoke to many of all stripes in Israel for a very considerable time. But it is monstrously true, I believe. It adds horribly truely to Illan Pappe's 'The Ethnic Cleansing of...Ver másA very frightening book, written by a Jewish American reporter who investigated all and spoke to many of all stripes in Israel for a very considerable time. But it is monstrously true, I believe. It adds horribly truely to Illan Pappe's 'The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestien.' And I am not anti semitic, but very, very sad, and very disillusioned that my Jewish heroes (I was born in 1937) have let me down.A very frightening book, written by a Jewish American reporter who investigated all and spoke to many of all stripes in Israel for a very considerable time. But it is monstrously true, I believe. It adds horribly truely to Illan Pappe's 'The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestien.'
And I am not anti semitic, but very, very sad, and very disillusioned that my Jewish heroes (I was born in 1937) have let me down.
Escribir una opinión
Cómo funcionan las opiniones y calificaciones de clientes
Las opiniones de clientes, incluidas las valoraciones de productos ayudan a que los clientes conozcan más acerca del producto y decidan si es el producto adecuado para ellos.Más información sobre cómo funcionan las opiniones de clientes en Amazon






