![Oliver Twist (The Criterion Collection) [DVD]](https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/51TgNkhSGPL._AC_UL160_SR160,160_.jpg)
It would not be a complete exaggeration to say that "Great Expectations" is a nearly perfect film. There are of course many other films that deserve this rating that are its equal, if not its superior. Anything by Truffaut or many things by Bergman. Hitchcock's Vertigo comes to my mind. But David Lean's 1946 masterpiece just has way too much going for it not to be considered one of the truly great works of the British film industry. It starts with Lean who, like Stanley Kubrick hardly ever made a film that one could just call "good". His body of work was of so consistently a high caliber that his loving adaptation of his countryman’s finest novel is like a small, beautiful miniature (Wes Anderson much?) to the later grand Epics like Lawrence of Arabia that cemented his reputation.
It continues with the source material. Like Michael Crichton, or maybe Ernest Hemingway, Charles Dickens wrote novels that are either easy to adapt into film, or so well loved that great directors and screen writers work hard to get them right. Dickens’ own body of work is so vast, and impressive that it is easy to say that Great Expectations is merely one of three or four true masterpieces – Nicholas Nickleby, any one? Bleak House, my pet? – that the great pop culture author produced.
That is not to say Dickens is easy to adapt. His characters are some of the most vividly imagined, his dialogue and description some of the richest ever put to paper. Don’t get me started on plotting, as Dickens can drive even his loyal readers mad with his positively…Dickensian (yes, I went there) story lines. Small wonder Lean himself, along with four others penned the screenplay. And what a screenplay it is, condensing Dickens medium-length novel into a relatively crisp 118 minute running time. I don’t believe all the couple of dozen main characters from the novel made the cut, but the main ones, and the primary story lines survive.
And, what a story it is.
Young Orphan “Pip” is raised in the 19th century by the saintly Joe Gargery – deftly and tear-jerkingly played by Bernard Miles – when he encounters an escaped convict out on the moors. A kind gesture from Pip would seem to go unnoticed. I won’t spoil the Big Reveal for you and say that, fast forward a few years, and one heartbreak, and Pip is living with his good friend in London when a Benefactor blesses him with a fortune. Plots and fates intertwine until the grand Denouement. That is all the needs to be said because you really need to see how it all plays out so skillfully in Dickens’ plotting.
The film won the Best Oscar for Art Direction (now called Production Design, I think) and Cinematography. Both are of course superb. Look at the detail in just one set piece, the nearly Biblical destruction of Miss Havisham’s Great Hall about 1/3 of the way through the film. I was amazed at how dust was flying from the table and furniture. Dust which had to be put in place to resemble dust that would have gathered for decades.
But what it really boils down to is the Cast, and the acting. As would be expected from the Brits – especially during this era – every single actor and actress is superb. From a young Alec Guiness as Pip’s young adult pal Herbert Pocket and the legendary John Mills as an “adult” Pip, to a youthful Jean Simmons as the devilish Estella and of course Martita Hunt in the scene-chewing role as Miss Havisham. I could go on and on, but I need not, because this constellation of characters is ably played by a galaxy of fine British A and B players.
The end result is, as I have said, sheer cinematic magic. And, by the way, the print and transfer on Amazon Prime are both superb. So, no reason not to rent, or buy (as I did) this treasure. It is a worthy addition to any true film lover’s library.
Customers who viewed this item also viewed
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
Customer reviews
The story Dickens tells may be his greatest moral tale because each critical event is presented in life and death terms; the actor must risk his life to save the other. Pip does so in his first encounter with Magwitch, who finally dies in peace after receiving the glorious news that his lost child is alive and well. Even the horrific fiery demise of Miss Havisham can be seen this way, for it breaks the tragic bond she has imposed on Estella who begins her efforts at living a new life. In the same context, when Estella tells Pip she intends to marry without love or a sympathetic heart, Pip dies to all hope for a fulfillment of his life-long passion. The producers of this film have made viewing enjoyable by the way they keep the plot flowing and carrying us along . The acting is first rate with especial mention of Martita Hunt's sincere portrayal of Miss Havisham, so touching that we find ourselves in tears, at one with her in repentance, "What have I done!"
Images in this review
Top reviews from other countries
Amazon Customer
GREAT EXPECTATIONS [1946 / 2008] [Blu-ray]
Reviewed in the United Kingdom 🇬🇧 on February 17, 2016Antonio Robert
Still one of the best Dickens film adaptations
Reviewed in the United Kingdom 🇬🇧 on June 21, 2022
Lokii
Great Expectations for a Great Movie
Reviewed in the United Kingdom 🇬🇧 on March 16, 2018Elleppi
A fantastic blu ray edition of one of Lean's best film. Much better than his following "blockbusters"
Reviewed in the United Kingdom 🇬🇧 on August 28, 2015
The CinemaScope Cat
Simply superb!
Reviewed in the United Kingdom 🇬🇧 on July 27, 2011
