- Hardcover: 192 pages
- Publisher: Indiana University Press (August 8, 2016)
- Language: English
- ISBN-10: 0253022851
- ISBN-13: 978-0253022851
- Product Dimensions: 6 x 0.8 x 9 inches
- Shipping Weight: 12 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
- Average Customer Review: 58 customer reviews
- Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #1,657,920 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
Other Sellers on Amazon
+ $3.99 shipping
+ $3.99 shipping
Hopeless but Optimistic: Journeying through America's Endless War in Afghanistan Hardcover – August 8, 2016
|New from||Used from|
Frequently bought together
Customers who bought this item also bought
This is not a book that directly engages the theories and conceptions of twenty-first-century US military intervention, in its full-spectrum approach from counterinsurgency to development, in numerous working papers, articles, and monographs. It does not invoke 'hard power,' 'soft power,' or 'smart power.' But in this case, that is an asset. Sometimes the most effective response to all the proposals of what could or should be is the observation of what is. (H-Diplo)
On page after page, as Wissing travels around the country, we are told how U.S. operatives continue to repeat the same mistakes over and over, leaving a trail of unfinished/sabotaged projects that have no value to the people of Afghanistan. (OpEd News)
It’s that kind of book. It reminds us of Peter Van Buren’s We Meant Well book on Iraq. (Diplopundit)
Wissing's moving and exceptionally well-written account makes sad reading . . . The book becomes a heart-breaking travelogue, accompanied by Wissing’s own photos. . . . [but] however corrupt and misguided the war, however much damage it has done, Wissing says, 'I met American after American determined to make the world a better place.' (Bloom Magazine)
One of the state’s most intrepid combat reporters, Wissing went to Afghanistan for a third time in 2013, expecting to watch the war wind down. Instead, he found a place still rife with conflict. . . . [Wissing] gives readers a view of both the perils and the many examples of money being wasted in a country where even something as seemingly benign as digging wells has devastating consequences. (Indianapolis Monthly)
A scathing dispatch from an embedded journalist in Afghanistan. . . . Pungent, embittered, eye-opening observations of a conflict involving lessons still unlearned. (Kirkus Reviews)
When historians of the future try to explain how the United States could have accomplished so little in Afghanistan despite spending so much blood and treasure, this trenchant and honest book will be a crucial source. An important read for anyone who cares about American foreign policy in the 21st century. (Alex Berenson author of The Wolves (A John Wells Novel))
If I could recommend one book about Afghanistan to the next president, it'd be this one. If s/he can't learn the lessons of the failed war in Iraq from the ground truth, maybe s/he can learn them from Wissing's brilliant, funny, sad, irreverent, serious, deeply reported, hopeless―but always optimistic―book. Required reading. (Peter Van Buren former US State Department foreign service officer and author of We Meant Well: How I Helped Lose th)
Afghanistan is one huge enigma for most Americans. Wissing's book helps us sort it out. He has repeatedly been in Afghanistan, observed everything, and reports it all in this remarkable volume. This book is the place for most of us to learn about this woebegone, but resilient land, and America’s endless war. (Lee H. Hamilton former US Representative; former vice chairman of the 9/11 Commission and co-chairman of the Iraq St)
As with an album of closeup photographs, Douglas Wissing’s concise essays cast a sharp and revealing light on their subject. Here we confront in granular detail the waste and folly that is America’s war in Afghanistan. An empire in decline does not make for a pretty picture. (Andrew J. Bacevich author of America’s War for the Greater Middle East: A Military History)
This is a fine and troubling book about America’s plunge into the nightmare otherwise known as Afghanistan. Wissing’s concise thirty-odd chapters are like graphic flash-cards conveying the confusing mix of violence and corruption, along with bursts of decency and courage, that define this endless war. And alas! No exit is yet in sight.
I particularly appreciated its account of day-to-day frustrations of US personnel who have scant contact with the ordinary Afghans they are pledged to protect. They remain locked in a bottle filled with venomous scorpions. (Karl E. Meyer former New York Times and Washington Post editorial board member, and co-author of Tournament of Sha)
Hopeless but Optimistic provides a fascinating ground level account of the effect of absurd and inappropriate Washington strategies on Afghans and on American soldiers. Its short hard-hitting chapters illustrate with pithy anecdotes how 'hearts and minds' and other senseless silver-bullet approaches to the war only benefitted well-connected Beltway contractors and Afghan drug traffickers and warlords, and failed to help Afghan farmers and American soldiers. Americans prefer to forget Afghanistan, but that would be a shame because this lost trillion dollar war illustrates the hubris of policies sold by both the Bush and Obama administrations. This book vividly illustrates the cost of this hubris beyond the trillion dollars wasted and the official casualties numbers. (Abdulkader Sinno author of Organizations at War in Afghanistan & Beyond and editor of Muslims in Western Politics)
A seasoned, award-winning journalist systematically and methodically unpacks with brutal honesty the wasting of a trillion US-taxpayers' dollars by America’s Deep State in withdrawal through its longest, privatized, 21st-century-war in Afghanistan. This is Wissing’s most insightful and heartfelt account of his embeds with America’s best and most dedicated warriors, male and female, in the most insurgency-ridden corners of Afghanistan. Hopeless but Optimistic is a well-crafted, often humorous, and candid narration of Wissing’s most intimate encounters with America’s worst US State Department careerists burning money, army officers spinning self-delusional victory spiels, and the highly paid development consultants re-doing the same projects over again. It is a story of America’s military industrial complex–driven wars filled with moral outrage. A must-read for anyone interested in learning why America’s longest war and reconstruction efforts in collaboration with its corrupt partners in Afghanistan have produced hopelessness, though they remain optimistic. (Nazif Shahrani author of The Kirghiz and Wakhi of Afghanistan: Adaptation to Closed Frontiers and War)
Try the Kindle edition and experience these great reading features:
Read reviews that mention
Showing 1-4 of 58 reviews
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
Mr. Wissing's reportage is reminiscent of the great war correspondents of World War II: Ernie Pyle, Richard Tregaskis, George Weller, Cecil Brown and Margaret Bourke-White. He goes everywhere, talks to everyone, sees everything and presents it with gripping descriptive passages. If he has grown weary of the war, he comes by it honestly. You don't need to agree with him to find this book essential reading.
As the subtitle implies, this is a report of a trip through the country, talking to soldiers, reporting on development projects, observing the people. He is genuinely proud of the people who are doing their work right, condemnatory of those who are just in it for the money, and honest enough to make it clear that there is a lot of grey area between the best and the worst. This is not a partisan attack. He does not look to see if there is an "R" or a "D" after someone's name before he passes judgement.
The title sums up what many people feel about Afghanistan. Douglas Wissing has reached that conclusion honestly.
And thus it drags on, and on, and on.
There are two main themes running thru the vignettes. One, the war itself is hopeless. I have heard the author in a talk say that the best path for the United States now is to leave as quickly as possible, and in the long run, that is probably the best path for Afghanistan too. The second theme, the optimism, what little there is, comes mostly from the resiliency of the Afghan people, who have already survived centuries of war. In the words of one: "As an Afghan, I have to be optimistic. I have no other choice." But there are also other examples of basic humanity that Wissing finds in the aid workers and soldiers that have come to the country, as well as in the Afghans themselves.
All in all, this is a good book by which an outsider can get a glimpse into what it was like to be in Afghanistan at a certain point in time. It is reporting, but reporting whose aim is to give impressions and not details. It's almost like a collection of short stories, lyrically written. I highly recommend it.
2. This book should have been obsolete, but ends up fresh as the headlines. Why read about a war that’s over? To learn the lessons from it. But it didn’t end. In fact, according to today’s news cycle, it’s re-escalating. We can be sure that the strategic and cultural blunders Wissing chronicles will be blundered again. Expect even more ferocity against the innocent, for which Defense Secretary “Mad Dog” Mattis became famous as the Marine Commander in Iraq. When will we ever learn?
3. I note that the euphemism Secretary of Defense was adopted after World War II. Before that we had a Secretary of War, a far more honest name.