Okay donuts are donuts and bagels are bagels, even though they both have holes in them they are not the same. You can’t pass this off as a masterpiece and there are certainly social statements surrounding stereotyping and racism, which is common in Will Smith movies, which may or may not be to your liking. Personally I don’t mind them, though they could be softened a bit.
Regardless of your personal inflection on key social issues, you are going to find it’s a relatively fast paced sci-fi movie with predictable chase scenes. There are some twists and turns which keeps you guessing, but they too are rather predictable.
Overall the cast is great, with Bridget Moynahan performing very well. Admittedly I’ve not seen her acting much outside of this movie but her emotional range is both impressive and her performance convincing. Alan Tudyk is a very good voice actor and he’s done a convincing job here. If there’s opportunity I think it lies in the second tier of the support with Chi McBride’s performance feeling a bit pressed. And then there’s Will Smith himself. At times he shines, but in all due candor there’s just too much showing his physical condition. The shower scene brings no value and does not belong here nor does it bring value. Lastly, this is based loosely on a Asimov’s writing, I get that, but those are short stories made into a feature length movie and there are inevitably comparisons. The affection for nostalgia respective of shoes, CD players, etc., is funny once or twice but wears thin. It feels like a solid interpretation, and I would say it all gels on the end product.
Overall this is a fun movie, full of ups and downs, emotionally and socially grounded. I now watch it once a year and consider it one of Will Smiths’s better outings. It’s just enough CG as to not overwhelm the movie and has a well put together and complimentary cast. If you’re hesitating, pull the trigger, grab some corn, and be thoroughly entertained.