Hill Climb Racing 2 Industrial Deals Beauty Little FIres Everywhere Shop new men's suiting nav_sap_plcc_ascpsc New Album by Fergie PCB for Musical Instruments Starting at $39.99 Grocery Handmade Tote Bags Book a house cleaner for 2 or more hours on Amazon Transparent Transparent Transparent  Introducing Echo Show Introducing All-New Fire HD 10 with Alexa hands-free $149.99 Kindle Oasis, unlike any Kindle you've ever held Trade in. Get paid. Go shopping. Shop Now FFII_gno

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

Showing 1-10 of 28 reviews(Verified Purchases). See all 48 reviews
on December 10, 2015
Excellent Book! The title speaks for itself. With no campaigning whatsoever, this speech certainly was the reason why Lincoln won the presidential election in 1860. This book does a great job painting the background picture for the story, and while many may believe some of the background is not necessary, I found it all to be relevant. Within the story, the author points out important quotes from the speech. Additionally, the full speech is in the back of the book with footnotes. Along with the speech are certified resources for every point Lincoln made in his speech, that day at Cooper Union, 27 February 1860. The speech is indicative of Lincoln’s research skills, and how methodical he was in making several points to validate his argument; the abolishment of slavery. Anyone, curious as to Lincoln’s rise to the White House, and the various references to the points in his most important speech, MUST read this book.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on October 16, 2016
The Mecca of New York looms large in the American consciousness for a variety of reasons. It's “The Big Apple,” “The City-That-Never-Sleeps,” and so much more. One of the reasons that it looms so large is the fact that its 10 million inhabitants makes it one of The World's most populous cities, and that, in the most powerful nation on Earth.
It's a complicated city, that has both within its spiritual and material resources, something to please any and everyone. There is nothing that cannot be found in New York. It can be a compassionate place and it can be a downright mean place—both realities exist. For a newcomer, New York can be especially brutal. In the mid-1970's, singer George Benson released a song called “On Broadway,” about a poor aspiring guitarist who shows up in The City seeking fame and fortune. The song is about a lot of things, but its main theme is the narrator's confidence in his guitar-playing ability, a belief of supreme talent, and it is that talent that the singer feels will allow him to make it big “On Broadway.” This confidence is expressed in the lyric, “'Cause I can play this here guitar!” The song feeds into the precept and legend of New York, the idea “That if you can make it here (in New York), you can make it anywhere.”
With “On Broadway” as a backdrop, consider one Abraham Lincoln, arriving in the city in February of 1860, a time when New York was just as much a legend then, as it is now, then containing about 800.000 residents. Mr. Lincoln had spent months and months before that in serious research, marshaling all of the resources of his lawyerly and prodigious mind, to do the research on the Founding Fathers, and what their official votes were, across time, on the issue of slavery. It is said that Mr. Lincoln spent more time researching on the particular speech that he would give in New York, than any other in his life. At the time, Lincoln was a fairly obscure lawyer and politician from The West. He had somewhat made a name for himself several years prior in his heated debates with Stephen A. Douglass, but he was not, in any sense, a household name. His New York speech would change this.
Lincoln knew that he could change his fortunes in New York, if the speech that he had prepared as a result of his research was a Big Hit. He knew this primarily because New York was the media capital of the World, and a good, solid political speech would resonate, through all of the national newspapers, like waves resonating out from a rock that has been thrown into a pond. Lincoln wanted to be meticulously prepared. So, late in February of 1860, Lincoln took the stage at Cooper Union in New York to give the most important speech of his life. On first impression, the audience was rather nonplussed at his slovenly appearance, an uncouth, homely and tall man, standing before them in a wrinkled suit. Lincoln's six-foot-four stature was pronounced by a head full of black hair, that seemed to be all over the place, leaving many to wonder why the speaker had not bothered to comb his hair. The audience sat before him rather dumbfounded.
But, then the speaker opened his mouth, letting the results of his research flow freely in abundant supply. The presentation of his words were so perspicacious that all sat in rapt attention, quickly forgetting the physical appearance of the man before them, and being taken in by the power of the crystal clear logic and sincerity of what he had to say. At the end of the speech, the crowd exploded with a standing ovation, thus laying the groundwork for the newspapers over the next few days to make Abraham Lincoln a national name.
In sum I have just summed up Harold Holzer's book about Lincoln and Cooper Union. For anyone who truly wants to understand the power, intensity and genius of Abraham Lincoln as a powerful intellect, this book might be one of the best. Lincoln knew all that was at stake for his speech at Cooper Union. He prepared for it like no other chore that he had prepared for in his life, and ultimately, the speech that he made reflected his efforts. This book is the story of that, and a damn good one. It is excellent in showing the work ethic and intense efforts that Lincoln put into making his speech a success. It's also a most lucid portrayal of the effect of that speech. As George Benson would say, Lincoln, “Can play that there guitar!” since his effort in New York was a rousing success.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on October 15, 2015
This book is a must read for anyone interested in Lincoln as well as the cause of the Civil War. It was this speech that put Lincoln on the map and set the stage for him becoming President. Moreover, this speech, in Lincoln's own words, leaves no doubt as to the role of slavery in our Civil War contrary to neo-confederate, revisionist historians who would have us believe that the war wasn't fought over slavery.

Lincoln's Cooper Union speech is one of the great speeches in U.S. history.
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on July 23, 2015
Abe Lincoln was truly a great man. Holzer does not disappoint with his coverage of the period leading up to and Lincoln's speech at Cooper Union. It was in Feb 1860 and greatly helped to get him elected. Lincoln
never did return to NY City after that speech. I get the impression that he didn't really care for the city. We get a look into his personal life, various travels and other speeches he made in New England during this specific trip. His photo, taken by Matthew Brady, and on the cover of the book gets lots of well deserved attention. There a many fun anecdotal facts for the reader. I enjoyed this book immensely.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on February 9, 2013
Essential reading on Abraham Lincoln's February 27, 1860, speech at Cooper Union in New York City. Harold Holzer has
written a magnificently researched and synthesized work that is almost spellbinding in its ability to bring the reader into Lincoln's world and perhaps mind as he delivers one of the most important speeches of his life just prior to the Republican National Convention of May 1860 and his election to the presidency in November 1860. In the Cooper Union speech, Lincoln masterfully presents his views on the extension of slavery into U.S. Territories in relation to the U.S. Constitution and the intention of the original 39 signers of the Constitution, his views on the "peculiar institution" so fiercely defended by the South, and the position of the Republican Party regarding slavery as of early 1860. A tour de force by Lincoln, a speech that no doubt made him president, and a tour de force by Harold Holzer. Importantly, the book includes as an appendix the complete Nott-Brainerd version of the speech as it was published in September 1860, with their footnotes.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on July 4, 2015
This was a very narrow subject on which to write an entire book, and therefore the one fault I could find was that there was a good deal of filler material. Still, as one who has read a good number of books on Lincoln, this book did an excellent job of portraying Lincoln as the politician, and rather than being a reluctant dark horse candidate for the Republican nomination for President, Lincoln is seen as an extremely clever pursuer of
the highest office in the land. I will definitely read other works by the author, Harold Holzer.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on August 6, 2015
I've had my eye on this title for a while, and a delighted to finally read it. Holzer is an impeccable researcher who is able to bring Lincoln and this times alive. I greatly enjoyed the little details of the street life of New York City, what it was like to travel by train in 1860, and the personal details of Lincoln's life and personality. If you are a fan of Civil War photography, you will enjoy the cameo appearance of Mathew Brady photographing Lincoln in his New York studio.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on January 4, 2007
There are so many books written on Lincoln and many different prespectives on his life and presidency. Holzer looks at the Cooper Union Speech and shows how Lincoln, the master politician used the speech and his trip East to get the 1860 nomination. Many historians assert that the speech made Lincoln. However, Holzer shows a unique view of the trip and the speech and how Lincoln used the opportunity to campaign in the East before he was officially a candidate. Ironically, Holzer points out that Salmon Chase turned down the opportunity to speak at Cooper Union demonstrating just one more ocassion when Chase blew an opportunity to get to the White House.

While dispelling many myths about the speech and Lincoln's trip, Holzer also shows the brillance of Lincoln and the time and effort that he spent in preparation for this speech. He also shows how this speech became Lincoln's stump speech. Once nominated, Lincoln followed the tradition of the time and did not campaign but used the Cooper Union Speech as essentially his platform.

For the person just beginning their interest in Lincoln or the seasoned scholar, this book is well worth the read. To add to that it is a quick and enjoyable read.
0Comment| 6 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on August 1, 2013
The book provided new insights (for me) into this most important period in Lincoln's path to the presidency.

The formatting was almost random. The type face and size changed at odd times. I would have expected the Brady photo to be provided, but again no It was all very distracting.
0Comment| 4 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on March 15, 2013
The chapter on the speech is very good and the appendix with the entire speech and footnotes is excellent. The rest is an amusing but not very important day by day account of the events immediately surrounding the speech.

What is lacking is placing this speech in the context of the political climate in the winter of 1859-60. Later, in 1865, Fredrick Douglass was to say something to the effect that: Lincoln never went as far or as fast as he wanted him to go but never failed to go as far as the country would allow at the moment. The success of Cooper Union is strong evidence that Lincoln knew almost precisely where the sentiments of the "swing" voters lay on the question of slavery on February 27, 1860 and this speech is aimed directly at them.

Lincoln won the election of 1860 with a plurality of 39.8% in a field of four candidates. The Republican base voters were the "black" Abolitionists and free soil Democrats. They would have preferred Seward. The "swing" voters were the "compromise" Whigs who would have allowed slavery where it existed but who also hoped that the federal government would ban slavery forever in the territories that eventually became 16 additional states.

Following the failure of the Missouri Compromise of 1820, the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850, the Kansas Nebraska Act of 1854 and the Dred Scott decision of 1857, the national debate had been reduced to the question of whether new states should be admitted to the Union as slave or free based either on popular sovereignty or the will of the federal government.

If the ultimate goal was abolition of slavery, which Lincoln clearly said it was, then there were huge constitutional problems with this formulation. Lincoln certainly knew what these problems were but he chose to ignore them after 1858. On the abolitionist side, these problems were fully developed and taken to their logical extreme by William Lloyd Garrison before 1840. Chief Justice Roger Taney's decision in Scott v. Sanford (1857) represents the extreme position of the slavers. It should be noted that both Garrison and Taney would have agreed that the Constitution protected slavery. Therefore, Lincoln's position, "let the federal government decide now as the founders would have decided," allows for the possibility that Scott v Sanford was correctly decided. Lincoln said he thought the decision wrong but he did not say what he planned to do about it.

Cooper Union reads like an appellate brief and Holzer correctly identifies the point Lincoln was advocating in the court of public opinion in New York was: We shall now decide the issue of slavery as we understand the founders would have decided it. While this elides over the compromises made between 1820 and 1854 it does not address the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 or the Dread Scott decision of 1857, both of which rest squarely on Art. IV § 2 and the "supremacy" clause of Art. VI, § 2 in the Constitution of 1789.

Cooper Union was aimed directly at the "compromise" Whigs Lincoln needed to bring into the Republican Party to make it a national party that could win the election of 1860 with a plurality of the votes and with himself as its candidate for president. The sad fact is that Union and economic prosperity were more important than liberty and the rights of man to the "compromise" Whigs.

This book begs to be expanded upon by contrasting Cooper Union with the abolitionist position of Garrison (the Constitution stands for the proposition that while any state can enslave a man, no other state than then set that man free and that the supremacy clause in the Constitution made slave catchers of us all) and Taney (the state may decided that some men are not persons within the meaning of the Constitution and that the federal government can not prevent a state from enslaving anybody it may chose and must also prevent another state from setting that man free).

A second question is: How did it come to pass that a political and economic union became infinitely more important than the idea that all men are created equal in the US between 1775 and 1860?
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse