Top critical review
2 people found this helpful
Ordered 2 - One was ROTTEN and the other was not
on August 9, 2013
I ordered two tubes of lipstick in the color, Pink Please, from 5 Star Sales. One was rotten and the other was not. The rotten that I received smelled terrible and was gross to apply on.The product also had cracks and crevices along its sides. Once on and off the lips, the smell remained and lingered. The smell is not the traditional lipstick smell. To me, it smelled like dirty, wet cardboard that was left on the streets. My sister thought it smelled like burnt crayons. One reviewer on this Amazon page said it smelled like "Play-doh".
If you look in the reviews for this products, other customers have also received a foul smelling lipstick. Note the reviews written by meuy, SydneyCWH, and Kylie. Or, search keyword "smell".