Mozart: String Quartets Nos. 21 - 23 ('Prussian'), K. 575, 589, 590
Frequently Bought Together
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
Top Customer Reviews
With those facts in evidence, I expected to feel restless and irritated, ready to rush back to the echt Viennese style of the Alban Berg Quartet. But a change-up can clear your ears, and I think that happens here. Aided by very realistic, close-up recorded sound, the Emersons succeed in wiping the slate clean, making you hear the notes in perfect proportion and balance, with an emphasis on forward motion and clarity of line. They applied much the same approach to Beethoven, with mixed results since a great sacrifice was made in depth of interpretation. Mozart is more classical and regular in form compared to Beethoven, however, and although the lack of charm isn't a positive, these aren't metaphysical works in a far-reaching Romantic sense. World-class playing counts for a lot.
I stick by the ABQ as incomparable Mozart players, but this new Emerson set gave me a new and rewarding perspective.
To my mind, this is symptomatic of the set's weakness. The Emerson Quartet plays with utmost virtuosity; where Mozart seemingly demands that alone, they are listenable in the extreme (say, the finales of K 575 & K 590). But the boys grapple but fitfully with the "chill" of the Prussians - as such, there is a failure to recognise that these quartets form a tundra-like ecosystem of their own and one that is distinguishable from the earlier `Haydn' Quartets and the Hoffmeister (K 499). Much of this is attributable to their fast tempi. Three other examples come to mind - in each instance, the Chilingirians offer a contrast:
1. the Emersons plays the opening of K 575 in a straightforward fashion; ever so exquisitely, the Chilingirians imbue it with tentativeness: to create is to suffer.
2.Read more ›
final concerts, a Beethoven program which included the Quartets opus 130 and 132 plus
the Grosse Fugue opus played separately. It was extremely dramatic, intense and poetic.
The Grosse Fugue was especially white hot and furious. The Mozart #s 21-23 also seem
more multi-dimensional than usual: technically flawless as usual but less tight than some of their admittedly five star recordings, e.g. the Schubert Quintet and the Mozart Quartets k421 and 465. The slow movements of k 589 and 590 seem to project tragic ambivalence similar to that in the 27th piano concerto, k595. The increased cello role in all three
three is fortuitous given the presence of their great cellist who had recently performed the Beethoven cello sonatas in one concert with his wife Wu Han.
Peers in the Mozart: Tokyo Q, Quartetto Italiano, Amadeus Q
The performance is almost too pristine. The musicians are all so very talented that it seems this is the exact interpretation from the sheet music with very little personality of the performers. The nice thing is that this is an almost clinical example of these quartets. Rather than hearing a too expressive piece (looking at you Itzahk!) instead you hear the music as perfectly as can be, probably as close as it is to hearing it in the late 1700s.
Love or hate the style, the performance is still magical in a very crisp and clean manner. I know that the Emerson can get some passion into their performances, but perhaps this was their interpretation of Mozart's score? One will never be sure. But I am sure that this is an enjoyable collection of three excellent quartets. The clarity of the recording is also excellent and Sony does their normal bang up job. Very rarely does one hear big intakes of breath or sharpness from the strings. Sadly, a collection of Mozart "Haydn" quartets was dulled due to a LOT of heavy breathing that was noticeable on the CDs. Gladly none of that here.
I recommend this collection, but if you're looking for something with more passion then this might not be the disc for you. But check out the Emerson quartet performing a few MUCH more emotional quartets of Mozart: Mozart: String Quartets K. 465 "Dissonance", K. 458 "The Hunt", K. 421.Read more ›
Most Recent Customer Reviews
In both the Mozart Haydn Quartets and Mozart Prussian Quartets, if one compares and contrasts the Emerson Quartet with and against the Berg Quartet, the American String Quartet and... Read morePublished 4 months ago by Amazon Customer
Look at the cover. Repressive tuxedoed old white(ish) guys in a subway. Subways = rush, transport, motorways, tramlines, city, conglomeration, mixing, fastfood, piss, vomit, poor... Read morePublished on June 15, 2014 by The Southerner
Emerson is always blamed for being "too perfect" and flat emotionally. This is simply not true here; they use their powers of sublime technicality as a tool to enlighten the... Read morePublished on January 6, 2013 by ConTroppo
The Emerson Quartet performances are beyond the beyond! Their playing raises me to a higher emotional level whether listening to their CDs or their concerts. Read morePublished on November 14, 2012 by Alfred Strasser