Now, well into my seventh decade of close, (obviously nonprofessional) dealings with a variety of persons with diagnosed/diagnosable "/mental illness/;" and eleven years after my first reading of Myth...; and reading and taking value from 40 relevant books by the following, I take further instruction from Szasz's knowledge, authority and sensibility: Anon(OCD), Amador,X, BacklarP, Breggin,P, "RoyC"(OCD), Davis,L, Engel,B, Feingold,B, Flach,F, Forward,S, Fumento,M, Glasser,W, Glenmullen,J, Gorman,J, Gottesman,I, Grossman,F, Harvey,P, Hedaya,R, Keefe,R, Landau,E, McKee,W, Miller,A, Moskovitz,R, Papalos, Paris,J, Perlmutter,A, Pfeiffer,C, Podvoll,E, Richette,L, Rosen,L, Sacks,O, Salzman,L, Torrey,EF, Walker,S, Wyden,P&B.
Some quotes:
"I wish...to reintroduce freedom, choice and responsibility into the conceptual framework and vocabulary of psychiatry."
"Mental illness is not something a person has, but is something he does or is."
"...little doubt...that both Freud and Sullivan were correct in identifying painful memories, their repression, and their persistent operation, as significant antecedents in the personal and social behavior of hysterically disabled individuals."
"An integral part of this scientific ethic is the principle that knowledge...must not...be kept a secret by a small group and used as a source of power to mystify and control, stupefy and dominate, other individuals or groups."
"It is important to understand clearly that modern psychiatry - and the identification of new psychiatric diseases - began not by identifying such diseases by means of established methods of pathology, but by creating a new criterion of what constitutes disease."
"The reclassification of non-illnesses as illnesses has, of course, been of special value to physicians and to psychiatry as a profession and social institution. The prestige and power of psychiatrists have been inflated by defining ever more phenomena as falling within the purview of their discipline."
"The phenomenology of body illness is indeed independent of the socioeconomic and political character of the society in which it occurs. But this is emphatically not true for the phenomenology of so-called mental illness, whose manifestations depend upon and vary with the educational, economic, religious, social, and political character of the individual and society in which it occurs."
"...To exhibit, by means of bodily signs - say, by paralyses or convulsions - the idea and message that one is sick is at once more impressive and more informative than simply saying: `I am sick.'"
"(Some) religious teachings...reward sickness and stupidity, poverty and timidity - in short, disabilities of all sorts..." "...the sick person is entitled to help simply because he is sick..."
"...the obligatory nature of the care required generates a feeling of helplessness in the person from whom help is sought. If a person cannot, in good conscience, refuse to provide help - and cannot even stipulate the terms on which he will supply it - then truly he becomes the help-seeker's slave."
"...the hysteric plays at being sick because he is afraid that, if he tried to participate competently in certain real-life activities, he would fail."
"The hysteric's seeming ignorance of what he is doing may also be interpreted as his not being able to afford to know it..."
"...It is precisely those who play these games (of hysteria and mental illness) most skillfully whose performances are likely to prove successful and whose identities will therefore be authenticated as sick..."
"The principal alternative to this dilemma lies...in abolishing the categories of ill and healthy behavior..."
"...even if one could brush aside the pathogenic or pathologic mechanisms, one would have persons who are not at all well-suited to a complex interpersonal environment..."
"...(The) Ganser syndrome... is the strategic impersonation of madness by a prisoner...the patient, being under charges from which he would be exonerated were he irresponsible, begins, without being aware of the fact, to appear irresponsible."
"In the case of malingering, hysteria, and the Ganser syndrome - and, indeed, in all cases of so-called mental illness - psychiatrists actually confirm the patient's self-definition as ill and so help to shape his illness."
"...let me emphasize only that investing hope in religious faith is perhaps one of the best psychological investments a person can make..."
"In the individualistic, autonomous "psychotherapy" which I prefer, the patient himself defines what is good or bad, sick or healthy."
"...our goal should be to enlarge his (the patient's) choices by enhancing his knowledge of himself, others, and the world about him, and his skills in dealing with persons and things."
Comments:
One can take inspiration from the prescient application of Szasz' theory in Helen Keller's story, wherein her live-in teacher, who never heard of Szasz, challenged family opposition and transformed, Helen, who had neither vision, nor hearing, nor speech, nor discipline, into an educated individual superbly valuable to herself and to her society. Surely today's professionals would find her superbly diagnosable.
I believe that the case workers, nurses, social workers, ward assistants, housekeepers etc. have been, to varying degrees using Szasz' principles all along. And Glasser seems to have capitalized on this as expressed in his 1965 book, Reality Therapy. All personnel who had any contact with his confined patients were required to attend the meetings. Teamworking, they realized remarkable success.
My sister, before her passing with cancer in 1991, had been a housekeeper at Maryland's Springfield State Mental Hospital for about 20 years. Fed-up with mopping up one patient's urine she decided to teach this, no doubt "exquisitely diagnosed," individual how to use a urinal. It was easy, and that solved the problem. And, she conducted a spiritual group for the patients, and she counseled them individually, and, in some cases, she had more success than the professionals with enabling them to return home.
Hopefully Szasz' and others' illustrations of psychiatrists' huge cost to our society, combined with the present declines in mental health care funding, will eventually lead us to no longer simple-mindedly admire or gloat about our young who obediently strive to become doctors (perhaps psychiatrists).
There should someday exist a book version for the cognitively-disabled, the less educated and the less-English-language-competent.
It was painful chopping 5000 words out of my booknotes to write this 1000-word review. A wealth of critical information not here is in the book.
Bill Norwood
Loading your book clubs
There was a problem loading your book clubs. Please try again.
Not in a club? Learn more
Join or create book clubs
Choose books together
Track your books
Bring your club to Amazon Book Clubs, start a new book club and invite your friends to join, or find a club that’s right for you for free.
Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
Follow the authors
Something went wrong. Please try your request again later.
There is a newer edition of this item:
Book recommendations, author interviews, editors' picks, and more. Read it now.
Similar items that may ship from close to you
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
Top reviews from other countries
JG
Critique astucieuse et érudite de la psychiatrie
Reviewed in Canada on December 19, 2023
Miguel Angel Cisneros Saucedo
What a disappointment
Reviewed in Mexico on November 26, 2021
