Buy new:
$39.50$39.50
$3.99
delivery:
Aug 24 - 25
Payment
Secure transaction
Ships from
All Kinds Of Books
Sold by
Returns
Eligible for Return, Refund or Replacement within 30 days of receipt
Buy used: $17.10
Other Sellers on Amazon
+ $3.99 shipping
91% positive over last 12 months
& FREE Shipping
96% positive over last 12 months
Usually ships within 3 to 4 days.
+ $7.07 shipping
94% positive over last 12 months
Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required. Learn more
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
The New Best Recipe Hardcover – October 15, 2004
Purchase options and add-ons
Flagship book of award-winning series with more than 1000 pages and 800 illustrations. Would you make 38 versions of creme caramel to find the absolute best version? The editors of Cook's Illustrated did. Along with 20 versions of simple recipes such as coleslaw. Now fully revised and expanded this new edition offers more than 1000 recipes for all your favorite dishes from roast chicken and macaroni cheese to creme caramel and chocolate chip cookies. There are also expanded tutorials on grilling, baking, stir frying and much more. This is the ultimate cooking resource for novice and experienced cooks alike.
- Print length1000 pages
- LanguageEnglish
- PublisherAmericas Test Kitchen
- Publication dateOctober 15, 2004
- Dimensions8.6 x 5.25 x 11.18 inches
- ISBN-109780936184746
- ISBN-13978-0936184746
The Amazon Book Review
Book recommendations, author interviews, editors' picks, and more. Read it now.
Frequently bought together

Customers who viewed this item also viewed
Editorial Reviews
From Publishers Weekly
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Review
"Its charm is its over-the-top thoroughness." -- Newsweek Magazine, Decmeber 6, 2004
"This new edition (The New Best Recipe) means business." -- The New York Times Book Review, November 5, 2004
"the book's recipes...you don't need to be a gourmet to pull them off." -- San Francisco Bay Guardian, October 13, 2004
From the Inside Flap
Behind this bookand indeed everything we do at Americas Test Kitchenis a shared understanding of how frustrating it can be to spend time planning, shopping, and cooking only to turn out dishes that are mediocre at best. Have you ever been frustrated by piecrust that shrinks down the sides of the pan once baked? Have you ever spent a -fortune on prime rib only to have it come out dry and tough? Or baked a cheesecake that emerged from the oven with a crack the size of the San Andreas fault? Most of us dont have the time or inclination to spend hours and hours finding the answers to these and hundreds of other common cooking problems. We want recipes that work the first time and every time, and we want clear instructions. With The New Best Recipe in hand, you will have access to a wealth of practical information that will make you not only a better cook but a more confident one as well. No one likes to make mistakes in the kitchen. Thats why we test recipes over and over again (in some cases, more than 50 times)so you dont have to.
Because good technique is also critical, we have included 800 illustrations that show you the best way to do everything from carving a turkey to beating egg whites properly to frosting a layer cake to setting up your grill. And because the right equipment always makes a difference, youll find valuable information on how and when to splurge on that expensive knife or baking pan and when the basic model will do just fine. (In our test, for instance, the $4 Bakers Secret loaf pan trumped competitors with prices four times as high.)
We also explain the science of cooking (for instance, how brining works to ensure juicy meat and why butter should be added before dairy for the silkiest mashed potatoes) because understanding the science of food can help anyone become a better cook. Complete with recipes ranging from appetizers to desserts, The New Best Recipe promises to be a classic and timeless kitchen companion, one that draws back the curtain on our testing process so you learn firsthand what makes even the simplest recipe the best.
Founded in 1980, Cooks Illustrated is renowned for its near-obsessive dedication to finding the best methods of American home cooking. The editors of Cooks Illustrated are also the authors of a best selling series of cookbooks (The Best Recipe Series) as well as a series of companion books to the Americas Test Kitchen public television show (which reaches 2.4 million viewers per episode). Filmed in Americas Test Kitchen (a 2,500-square-foot test kitchen in Brookline, Massachusetts), the show features the editors, test cooks, equipment testers, science experts, and food tasters from the magazines staff.
About the Author
Product details
- ASIN : 0936184744
- Publisher : America s Test Kitchen; 2nd edition (October 15, 2004)
- Language : English
- Hardcover : 1000 pages
- ISBN-10 : 9780936184746
- ISBN-13 : 978-0936184746
- Item Weight : 5.15 pounds
- Dimensions : 8.6 x 5.25 x 11.18 inches
- Best Sellers Rank: #109,940 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
- #379 in U.S. Regional Cooking, Food & Wine
- #432 in Entertaining & Holiday Cooking
- #523 in Quick & Easy Cooking (Books)
- Customer Reviews:
Important information
To report an issue with this product, click here.
About the author

Our mission at America's Test Kitchen is to inspire confidence, community and creativity in the kitchen. We are a digital broadcast company which publishes award-winning cookbooks along with Cook's Illustrated and Cook's Country magazines. Our television shows, America's Test Kitchen TV and Cook's Country TV, are the longest running culinary shows in the US and we enjoy wide home cook appeal as the #1 and #2 shows on PBS. You can also watch our TV shows and original programming on ATK's YouTube and a wide variety of OTT channels. We have a unique creative process with over 50 professional cooks in our 15k square foot kitchen in Boston, MA and are rigorous in our quest to create the best recipes to exceed expectations every time.
Customer reviews
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on AmazonReviewed in the United States on January 13, 2016
-
Top reviews
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
I tell you this so you'll understand how improbable it is that the first thing I tackled from "The New Best Recipe" was chicken stock. A real-deal chicken stock, I'm talking here--the kind that turns to a jelly when cooled, is deep gold, and can improve nearly any dish you add it to--the kind that takes eight or ten hours to make, the classic way.
See, I had picked up this massive (1028-page) book in the bookstore and idly opened to the Soup chapter, where I read a three-page explanation of how to make real chicken stock in one hour. They detailed all the blind alleys they'd explored in trying to come up with the perfect recipe for stock--the different cooking techniques, times, ingredients--until they'd found a way to make rich golden stock in an hour. The technique was, er, unorthodox to say the least, but it all seemed to make perfect sense, so I bought the book and decided to try to make a stock to present to the Cook as a fait accompli.
Holy smoke, it worked! And I gotta tell you, if I can make a couple quarts of chicken stock between the time my daughter gets home from school and the time my husband gets home from work, then you can too.
So, enough anecdote; now for details.
----------
1. The book is a compilations of recipes from Cooks' Illustrated magazine and the America's Test Kitchen TV show (which I've never yet seen). The title seems presumptuous: "best" according to whom? Isn't "best" a matter of taste? Well, yes, but they are at pains to describe for nearly every recipe just what they MEAN by "best." Here's an example, for pound cake:
"...the main difficulty with pound cakes of the classic type is textural. Cakes might be said to have five 'texture points': moist/dry, soft/hard, dense/porous, light/heavy, rich/plain. To contemporary tastes, cakes must be relatively moist and soft; the three remaining texture points are negotiable.
"The problem with pound cake is that we ask it to be moist and soft on the one hand but also dense, light, and rich on the other. This is an extremely difficult texture to achieve unless one resorts to baking powder, with its potent chemical magic. Air-leavened cakes that are light and soft also tend to be porous and plain, as in sponge or angel cakes; moist and dense cakes inevitably also turn out heavy, as in the various syrup-soaked Bundt cakes that are so popular. From pound cake, we ask all things."
Or for broiled salmon:
"We set out to find the best way of cooking a whole side of salmon, enough to feed eight or more guests, in the oven. We wanted fish that was moist but not soggy, firm but not chalky, and nicely crusted, with golden, flavorful caramelization over its flesh. If we would work some interesting flavors and contrasting textures into the bargain, all the better."
Or for roasted potatoes:
"The perfect roasted potato is crisp and deep golden brown on the outside, with moist, velvety, dense interior flesh. The potato's slightly bitter skin is intact, providing a contrast to the sweet, caramelized flavor that the flesh develops during the roasting process. It is rich but never greasy, and it is accompanied by the heady taste of garlic and herbs."
In other words, before telling you how to make X, Y, or Z, they tell you what you're shooting for. I appreciate this. Mostly my goals and theirs coincide, but if they don't I'm aware of it BEFORE I start to cook.
2. After they describe the goal, they tell you the variations they tried to achieve it. This might include fiddling with cooking temperatures and times, number or type of ingredients, cooking techniques, tools, containers, phase of the moon... whatever! The folks in those test kitchens apparently have an infinite supply of time and money, not to mention patience.
So, for the chicken stock, they tried blanching, roasting, and sauteing the chicken; backs, wings, legs, or the whole chicken; carrots, celery, onion: yes or no? A sidebar details issues like what kind of chicken to buy, how to cut it up, and tips for storing the stock once you've made it.
You find out what works, and why, but also what didn't work, and why not. Knowledge really is power. Time after time in the past I've followed a recipe (or so I thought) and messed it up--with no idea of where I went wrong or how to fix it. Most cookbooks assume that cooks just don't make mistakes. This one tells you just about everything you could do wrong, so you won't.
By the way, I LOVE it that they attribute techniques and recipes found in other sources (including, in the case of pound cake, recipes from 1772, 1824, and 1985).
3. Is there some science about your ingredients or techniques or equipment? You'll learn about it. Why is is that butter and eggs for a cake should be at room temperature? Some cake recipes say combine everything at once ("quick mix" technique) and others say to cream suger with butter, then add the eggs and flour. Why do they both work? What's the difference in the end result? And what about those dark non-stick cake pans? Will they change anything? You'll find out.
4. After you understand the issues around your recipe, they give you the recipe itself. Many have three or four variations given after the main recipe. Each step is spelled out clearly, with both visual and time cues (e.g., "until the pork is in small, well-browned bits, about 5 minutes"), often accompanied by clear B&W illustrations and useful sidebars.
5. There are separate mini-essays on ingredients and equipment, comparing them a la Consumer Reports. We learn which are the best brands of chocolate chips for cookies (with different recommendations for thick/chewy vs. thin/crispy, no less!) and which paring knives were rated best.
I found a chart that lists the volume of medium, large, extra-large, and jumbo eggs. For that alone, I'd have bought the book, since the Cook (who's also the shopper) buys XLs, but the Baker's recipes all assume Ls. Now I actually know by how much they differ (8:9 is the ratio, in case you wondered).
6. Have I mentioned that everything I've made so far has rocked?
----
Downside? The Table of Contents and the Index both stink like the stinkiest of stinking fish. Does 22 lines ("Pork... 385", "Cakes... 823") seem to you like enough detail for the contents of a thousand-page cookbook? Me neither, especially as the individual sections don't have their own ToCs. This is ridiculous. But the index is even worse. Tiny print, uniform font sizes for all three levels of indent, no indicator letters at the top of the page to remind you where you are, and a distinct lack of cross-indexing make it a near-total waste of time. Someone could make a lot of people happy by preparing sectional ToCs and a decent index for this massive tome.
We don't accept every single bit of information in this book (the Cook has a serious bone to pick with them vis-a-vis their unflattering assessment of bluefin tuna, for instance), but for each item we disagree with, there are ten that have us nodding in agreement.
It could be described as a scientific cookbook, but that might leave you with the impression that it's dry and colorless. Quite the contrary--I find it fascinating reading, especially the parts about how they screwed up.
The prose is not lyrical or charming, as The Joy of Cooking frequently is, but it's truly engaging in its eagerness to give you all the tools you need to succeed. I doubt there's a cook in America who couldn't learn something from this book. I think it's that rare cookbook that is equally suitable for beginners, experienced cooks, and everyone in between; as much fun to read like a book as it is to use as a manual. Get it!
This is often one of the first books I turn to when considering a new dish. I may not end up making the exact recipe in the book, but if I deviate from it, I usually have a good idea about what will happen because of the detailed background in this book.
There are, however, a few problems that become apparent once you've used the book a lot. Since so many other reviews have described how great this book is, I'll focus on a few significant flaws.
(1) The table of contents is awful. Aside from chapter titles, you don't get any detail of what things are in chapters. You don't have a listing of the useful hints and tips that are inserted in many chapters (which give you background about choosing some ingredient or type of kitchen equipment, or information behind some cooking method). You'll only happen upon these by browsing through the chapters page-by-page, or if you happen upon one of the recipes that mentions this background. Unlike some reviewers, I don't find the index that cumbersome to use, but it would be nice to have a better list of what exactly is in the book to begin with.
(2) Principles are inconsistently applied. For example, some recipe intros note that the authors tried to avoid unusual ingredients when possible. This leads them to reject buttermilk as an ingredient for pancakes (even though the tasters liked them better), since it's less common than regular milk in most people's kitchens. But in the very next recipe (for waffles), they decide that buttermilk is "absolutely crucial," even though its effects are similar. It seems that in quite a few recipes, better ingredients can be chosen or rejected on a whim, despite what the tasters think. A similar problem applies to the supposed amount of work or fuss for a given recipe -- sometimes, the testers reject a step that improves flavor because it's too complicated, but many times they present needlessly fussy recipes.
(3) The tasters choose what they want, regardless of what is "correct." There will always be some disagreement about the best taste for a given dish, and sometimes I just disagree with the tasters. That's fine, and I expect that. But the book also displays a strange attitude toward traditional recipes that require minimal ingredients. They generally end up presenting a hybrid that won't satisfy traditional requirements but also doesn't take advantage of other possibilities. For example, before a standard superbowl party "chili" with kidney beans, ground beef, etc., they give a "chili con carne" recipe that is supposed to be closer to the classic "meat and chili peppers without much else" idea that is prized in Texas and other places. That leads them to throw out beans as an option, but they add tomatoes (even though tomatoes aren't part of traditional "chili con carne"), because they decide that chili without tomatoes is "dull." If they are going to bother to make a traditional dish, why try if all the testers think it tastes bad? In a similar mode, pancetta is rejected in favor of American bacon in their recipe for pasta carbonara, again because the tasters don't like it. What's the logic in restricting the recipe to almost all traditional ingredients, but throwing out one of the most important ones that is almost always part of the dish in Italy? If they can't satisfy their tasters with traditional ingredients, either something's wrong with the recipe or something's wrong with the tasters.
(4) The testers are strangely inept at times, seemingly blindly trying things that would be obvious to most home cooks. For example, they try to cook a pot roast, but apparently they don't realize that longer cooking will make the roast more tender! Only by accident (leaving a roast in the oven way too long) do they realize that their roasts must not just come up to a full simmer near boiling, but they must stay there for a while until the meat breaks down to become succulent and tender. Have they never cooked a pot roast in their lives? And then there is the occasionally strange advice for time-saving or labor-saving measures. When trying to construct a quick-cooking Bolognese sauce (which actually comes out pretty good), they fret that cooks will spend a long time chopping vegetables, so they make a big deal of pulling out a food processor, supposedly cutting down the chopping time from 10 minutes to 2 minutes. What was this crazy amount of chopping? They were *coarsely* chopping 1/2 of a small carrot, 1/2 of a small onion, a few mushrooms, and breaking up a can of whole tomatoes. If it takes 10 minutes for a cook to chop this small quantity of ingredients, I don't know what to say. I'd spend a lot more time getting my food processor out and cleaning it than I would chopping 3 or 4 small vegetables.
(5) Finally, the testers sometimes seem to overlook possible solutions or variations because they get locked into a particular recipe or ratio of a few ingredients or a particular method. This is one of the most common issues, and they do manage to overcome the problem sometimes. Usually, such a problem is signaled in the intro to a recipe when a dramatic turn happens about 2/3 of the way through testing when they happen upon a recipe in a different book or try out some apparently "strange" advice or (like the pot roast) happen upon something by accident. Though they do manage to solve some problems, in other recipes they end up just using a crutch of some sort to get subpar results. (Their use of cornmeal in their waffle recipe to add a false kind of "crunch" because they can't get their waffles to be crispy is a case in point. There are a half-dozen other things they could have done to fix this issue and actually produce crispier waffles.)
I've encountered dozens of other strange choices and inconsistencies, which at times had led me to question the competence of the testers and tasters. But the results are generally pretty good, and even when I don't like the results, the introductions save me a lot of experimentation to home in on a way to change the recipe to be more to my liking. And occasionally there are strokes of genius in the unusual meandering testing methods. For example, the addition of extra flour to a french toast mixture to bulk up and thicken the texture of the resulting toast is very worthwhile and something I haven't seen recommended elsewhere.
In sum, don't assume that all of the recipes in this book are actually the "best" recipe. The testers and tasters are clearly imperfect. But as a learning book to consider the ways a recipe might be varied and what the possible results might be, it's fantastic.
Top reviews from other countries
Some things to note:
1) The recipes are not for those who want a quick dinner. You need to be patient and put in love and sweat in order to get the best meal. Many recipes are best meant for a weekend or an evening when you come home at 6 pm and don't mind eating at 9 pm. But there are plenty of good ones that aren't time consuming as well so don't be discouraged by that. You will be so inspired by your first success, that the time it takes won't phase you because you'll want to improve as you take on more recipes. This book has really made me love cooking even more than I thought I did.
2) You will discover new tools that you will want to make your new found love of cooking even that much better. I since purchased a blow torch for the awesome creme brulee recipe (they recommend one that can be found at Home Depot), a cast iron dutch oven, and a scale ($20 from Costco). The scale is a must by the way and you will surprise yourself by using it more often than you thought you would. I already owned the Al Clad skillet recommended in this book and before this book, hardly used it because I didn't know in what circumstances I would use it. Since owning this book, the skillet gets plenty of use from me and I love it.
3) Your grocery bill is likely to go up, at least it did for me when I started making a new recipe from the book each day for awhile. They suggest the 'best' ingredients to use and cuts of meat which can be pricey depending on what you make. I rationalized that by the quantity made and getting to eat tasty leftovers for lunch the next day.
4) You are guaranteed rave reviews. When my husband took a bite of the oven fries (which are one of my favorites), he also said "these are the best potatoes I've ever had". The book allowed me to make restaurant quality french fries without being deep fried which was wonderful considering I haven't eaten restaurant fries in years to keep slim.
5) The book isn't organized well in terms of the table of contents. It's broken down generically so with over 1000 recipes, sometimes it makes it hard to find a recipe you are looking for. But since I've used it so many times, a quick flip through is good enough for me or the index at the back is excellent. It would also be extremely helpful it they included the total prep and cooking time on each recipe. It can take awhile to read through the steps and add the time up to figure out if it fits your schedule.
6) Don't be turned off by having no glamorous photos of food. There are plenty of instructions and the illustrations are detailed enough that anybody can follow. The instructions are so good, that when I compare them to other cookbooks I love, it just makes me appreciate this book more. I love how the authors tell you what pan to use, what size pan, when to do this or that. The instructions are clear cut and you don't have to make any guesses.
7) I must say also that the recipes are not wildly trendy or 'creative. Most of it is basic North American type of recipes despite a few international ones here and there (e.g., pad thai). Think chicken pot pie, brownies, roast chicken, mashed potatoes, etc.
I have been raving about this book since I purchased it and have called it 'life changing' because it is. It makes you a better cook, will inspire you, and those you love with love your meals and you can actually see them take pleasure in eating what you created. Food brings people together, especially when it is fabulous food. I just purchased this book for a friend and I am looking forward to hearing about her success in the kitchen. Do buy the book!
Book review: Excellent recipes--they have never failed me! You're provided how they got to this recipe combination...why you use a certain pan, cutting techniques, how to properly prep a pan, and what they'e tried and the results. Fabulous book!
Reviewed in Canada on March 15, 2023
Book review: Excellent recipes--they have never failed me! You're provided how they got to this recipe combination...why you use a certain pan, cutting techniques, how to properly prep a pan, and what they'e tried and the results. Fabulous book!
The great thing about Test Kitchen cookbooks is that they do a lot of trial and error and testing to ensure that they've got a solid recipe on their hands. Everything is well explained, and they give good reason why the failed variations of recipes didn't work.
While it is a great cookbook, it's not perfect.
The photos are black and white, so if you're used to glossy photos of food, you're out of luck here.
The layout and structuring of the numbered lists also leaves a lot to be desired. The layout seems to value saving paper (this is one thick tome already) as opposed to presenting a clear and easily read recipe. The layout is a multi-column, text-dense layout, with multiple sentences/instructions per numbered step.
I prefer more whitespace and that unrelated items get their own numbered step. If you're in the middle of following a recipe and going back and forth to the book, you don't want have to re-skim a list to figure out where you were last only to miss a step.
Flaws aside, they are annoying but not deal breakers. This book was the gateway for me buying many of the other Test Kitchen cookbooks.
Each recipe is so well researched and tested that you can't go wrong with any of them.
I especially like the thoughtful and well written explanations of techniques and products. The book is worth buying for that alone.
The bolognese and carbonara recipes are alone worth this purchase.
A must-have cookbook and fantastic option to give as a gift!












