After months (close to a year) of searching and trialing different baking sheets, I have found the perfect (or two perfect) ones for your consideration. I am hoping this to be a very informative review and I hope you will like it! I hope this is going to be helpful to you. Learn from my experience (and trial and error) so you buy the correct baking sheet the first time—save you time, money, and energy.
This review is going to focus on two of my favorite brand’s QUARTER SHEET BAKING SHEETS. The results may or may not apply to HALF SHEETS or any other sizes. Why? Because a manufacturer may make their products differently for different product lines. Just like Ford may make good truck but not their sedans, or Subaru makes good SUVs but not necessarily pickups. It’s just an analogy! Anyway, Nordic and Vollrath are being compared here. I didn’t get the Chicago Metallic brand… maybe next time!!
To start – I baked side-by-side using both brands and here are my findings:
They are both “standard sized” quarter sheets – but one is slightly larger than the other. The Vollrath brand is slightly larger (or perhaps Nordic is slightly smaller??). Your “standard size” quarter-sheet baking rack will sit perfectly inside the Vollrath sheet flush and flat. On the other hand, the same rack will not sit flush in Nordic pan. In fact, you will have to very carefully balance the rack on the edge of the Nordic quarter-sheet … and if you but it just a little . .. . slush~ the rack will fall into the pan or fall off entirely.
See the attached photos. So, is backing rack an important feature for your particular bake job? If yes, then you will have a hard time using the Nordic brand—either that or you have to buy purposefully smaller sized baking rack than what is “standard sized.” If not, who cares. I do need a baking rack for many of the things I bake—a rack that falls off easily is not acceptable to me. But who needs a rack for cookies? Wings? You have to think about this aspect for your own purposes.
Manufacturing: the Nordic pan was perfect in attention to details. The photo of the back of the quarter-sheet pan shows you how each manufacturer rolled their heavy duty aluminum. Nordic rolled theirs much more perfectly and more detailed. See photo. On the other hand, Vollrath pan was kind of …Meh~ Like as if the manufacturer said “that’s good enough of a roll.” Does the bad rolling job make the Vollrath pan useless? No. The baking result is not impacted from my test-baking. But there’s something to be said about perfection.
True Heavy Weight?: Both brands claim to be “Heavy Duty.” Check out the photos: Vollrath weighs in at 348 grams while the Nordic weighs in at 460 grams. If you do the math, this means the Nordic quarter sheet is approximately 30% more material! Yes, there’s 30% more aluminum in the Nordic quarter-sheet than the Vollrath product. That’s “30% heavier” duty.. I suppose you can put it that way. But the baking result with the Vollrath is not impacted (no warping, food bakes out equally on a side-by-side bake test). So is the extra 30% more material necessary? Thin baking sheet has the problem of bending and warping during baking (this is a known problem). If the product does NOT bend of warp… 348 gm vs. 460 gm ? Hmm. I dunno.
But then again .. . Nordic is heavier weight, great, but it doesn’t accommodate a “standard sized” baking rack!!! Which is more important?? Now that’s where you need to decide for yourself.
If you bake often foods that require a rack, you absolutely need a smaller rack or use the Vollrath quarter sheet to accommodate standard quarter-sheet racks. The Nordic will not fit those. On the other hand, if your bake often foods that sit directly on the pan and do not need a rack, or only uses the rack sporadically, you might be better off getting the Nordic quarter sheet and enjoy its 30% heavier weight and better machine job / better attention to details. Or get both – one Vollrath for one job, one Nordic for another job.
OR, go find a smaller quarter-sheet rack (say, 1/8” smaller each side) to accommodate the Nordic quarter-sheet, then you have the best of both worlds. But that means you have to buy “less than standard sized” baking rack by about 1/8” smaller each side. Why can’t just “standard sized” things work standardly? Why don’t they just work perfectly? That was my frustration with Nordic quarter-sheet this entire time. I love that quarter-sheet but whenever I needed to use a rack, Nordic became useless to me.
Thickness: You can see from the photos that the Nordic quarter-sheet is slightly thicker than the Vollrath. This came from being 30% more weight/material. I am not detecting the benefit of this extra thickness. Better heat retention? More anti-warping? More stable? Heavier? Stronger?
Other things: Both quarter-sheets are NOT (I repeat, NOT) safe in dishwasher. They both need to be hand washed. They both do NOT come seasoned and they are NOT non-stick. Your best bet is put down a sheet of silicon baking sheet. I personally don’t recommend aluminum foil (but that’s what everyone does). My recommendation against aluminum foil is the excessive intake of aluminum which may be associated with Alzheimer’s disease. (This is not a medical preach, please use your own research). I simply recommend you use a silicon baking mat instead of an aluminum foil bottom to avoid getting even more aluminum in your diet. I do NOT recommend baking directly on either Nordic or Vollrath quarter-sheets: food spot will be permanently baked into the pans, black scorch marks and carbon deposits will permanently cook into the aluminum sheets and there is no easy reversal (if at all). I know, it’s only $15 a quarter-sheet so it’s not too expensive. I happen to like my things to last for years. :-)
I hope this has been helpful. Write me comments if you need to ask more questions. I am attaching 8 or 9 photos to help with this review. Thanks!! Happy shopping!!
Enjoy fast, FREE delivery, exclusive deals and award-winning movies & TV shows with Prime
Try Prime
and start saving today with Fast, FREE Delivery
Similar item to consider
Most-loved picks for you
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
From the manufacturer
Naturals Aluminum Bakeware
The superior heat conductivity of aluminum ensures that you achieve consistent, evenly browned results every time you bake. Pure aluminum will never rust, and a reinforced, encapsulated rim prevents warping.
• Nordic Ware pioneered natural aluminum bakeware for the consumer market over 15 years ago and now has over 40 styles available in the collection
• Made of pure, uncoated natural aluminum
• 100% made in USA in Minneapolis, Minnesota
• Encapsulated solid core steel rim
• Pans are made of a special hardened aluminum alloy that provides superbly uniform heat conductivity and maximizes scratch resistance
• Shiny and non-porous natural aluminum provides natural nonstick performance
• Embossed Nordic Ware logo signal quality and value from a trusted legacy brand for over 70 years
Encapsulated Solid Core Steel Rim
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|
Coils of wireHaving an encapsulated steel rim adds structural support to prevent warping of the pan. |
Bending wires to sizeWires are bent to perfectly fit inside the rim of our bakeware sheets. |
A finished wireWires are made of Galvanized Steel and will not rust. |
Steel rim fully encapsulatedAn encapsulated steel rim turns an exceptional baking sheet into a product that will withstand a lifetime of use. |
Use and Care for Natural Aluminum
• Before initial use and after subsequent uses, hand wash with warm, soapy water.
• Dishwasher use is not advised as discoloration will occur due to the cleaning agents used in automatic dishwasher detergent. This discoloration is merely cosmetic and will not affect baking properties or safety of the pan.
• Natural aluminum pans work well with parchment paper, silicone baking mats, and also traditional butter or shortening and flour methods. When roasting savory foods such as vegetables, butter or cooking oil work well.
• Nylon, wood, or silicone utensils are recommended. Metal utensils and scouring pads may scratch natural aluminum pans, but will not affect baking performance
• Aluminum is reactive to acidic ingredients such as vinegar and tomato products. These foods may darken, pit or corrode the pan after prolonged use.
Compare with similar items
 | Nordic Ware Quarter Sheet, Natural, 2 count (Pack of 1) | Nordic Ware Naturals Big Sheet, Silver | Nordic Ware Naturals Big Baking Sheet, 2 Pack, Silver | Commercial Quality Cookie Sheet Pan - 2 Pack Aluminum Half Sheet Baking Pan by Saffron & Sage Home Living - This 13x18 Baking Sheet Set is Rust & Warp Resistant, Heavy Duty, of Thick Gauge | Nordic Ware Full Naturals Baking Sheet, 2-Pack | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Customer Rating | (30655) | (5423) | (9292) | (1412) | (709) | (16) |
| Price | $25.96 | $22.00 | $17.99 | $29.98 | $29.99 | $52.99 |
| Shipping | FREE Shipping. Details | FREE Shipping on orders over $25.00 shipped by Amazon or get Fast, Free Shipping with Amazon Prime | FREE Shipping on orders over $25.00 shipped by Amazon or get Fast, Free Shipping with Amazon Prime | FREE Shipping. Details | FREE Shipping. Details | FREE Shipping. Details |
| Sold By | Amazon.com | Amazon.com | Amazon.com | Amazon.com | Saffron & Sage Home Living | Amazon.com |
| Color | Silver | Natural | Silver | Silver | Aluminum | Natural |
| Material | Aluminum | Aluminum | Aluminum | Aluminum | Aluminum | Aluminum |
Videos
Page 1 of 1Start OverPage 1 of 1
Videos for this product
1:37
Click to play video
Pros and cons of the nordic ware bakers sheet
Danielle & Ziggy
Videos for this product
0:10
Click to play video
Customer Review: Just terrible all the way around
David Murray
Videos for this product
1:45
Click to play video
5 Year Review | How well did they hold up?
Midwest Market
Videos for related products
0:56
Click to play video
Watch to find out why this pan is the right size for my oven
Abi and Ripley
Videos for related products
2:23
Click to play video
Sweet & Sour Meatballs
Publisher Video
Made in America quality, but arrived with a small dent
Reviewed in the United States on May 20, 2023
I often turn this brand and am happy to support products made in America. When cleaning I face the usually challenges with kind of tray (Bar Keeper's Friend cleaning powder helps or take on any stains as a point of pride for being a hardcore baker....) One star deducted as it arrived with a very slight dent, not enough for me to return it but I mention it in case this is a question of quality control when the product is being packaged for mailing. When you buy for a brand from a company with a story and history behind it these things stand out. When you care you want to believe you are part of line from manufacture to delivery that cares also - these little things are visible, even though we also know conditions are out of our hands (overwhelmed workers, shipping can lead to this, too).
Reviewed in the United States on May 20, 2023
Images in this review
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
Reviewed in the United States 🇺🇸 on May 20, 2023
Style: Half SheetSize: 2-PackVerified Purchase
Made in America quality, but arrived with a small dent
Reviewed in the United States 🇺🇸 on May 20, 2023
I often turn this brand and am happy to support products made in America. When cleaning I face the usually challenges with kind of tray (Bar Keeper's Friend cleaning powder helps or take on any stains as a point of pride for being a hardcore baker....) One star deducted as it arrived with a very slight dent, not enough for me to return it but I mention it in case this is a question of quality control when the product is being packaged for mailing. When you buy for a brand from a company with a story and history behind it these things stand out. When you care you want to believe you are part of line from manufacture to delivery that cares also - these little things are visible, even though we also know conditions are out of our hands (overwhelmed workers, shipping can lead to this, too).
Reviewed in the United States 🇺🇸 on May 20, 2023
Images in this review
Top reviews from other countries
B.h
Excellente qualité
Reviewed in France 🇫🇷 on June 11, 2021Style: Half SheetSize: 2-PackVerified Purchase
Marianne
Sturdy
Reviewed in Singapore 🇸🇬 on December 4, 2019Style: Half SheetSize: 2-PackVerified Purchase
Marianne
Reviewed in Singapore 🇸🇬 on December 4, 2019
Images in this review
Mrs. Webb
Do not buy - only one received
Reviewed in Singapore 🇸🇬 on February 16, 2022Style: Half SheetSize: 2-PackVerified Purchase
Mrs. Webb
Reviewed in Singapore 🇸🇬 on February 16, 2022
Images in this review
YC
Disappointed in the quality as these trays are v expensive
Reviewed in Singapore 🇸🇬 on December 28, 2020Style: Half SheetSize: 2-PackVerified Purchase
YC
Reviewed in Singapore 🇸🇬 on December 28, 2020
No star should b given
Images in this review
