In this review, I'll compare the KitchenAid and OXO loaf pans. I have yet to bake with either.
The KitchenAid was around $13. The lip is much larger and extends maybe half an inch on the ends. It's an aluminum coated steel pan. I'm thinking the coating isn't the natural color, so some kind of coloring/paint was probably added to give it the silvery gray color. I'm just guessing there. The lip edges are rolled under for increased structural strength. This seems to be a common design. I feel like it could trap water. I noticed a couple notches cut into the rolled piece on the underside of the ends. I wonder if this is to help moisture air out. A side effect is these notches will catch soft sponges/cleaning materials which is a touch annoying.
The OXO was around $21. I have a feeling this pan is noticeable smaller than most loaf pans in the 9x5 range. The difference between the KitchenAid and OXO is pretty obvious. The bottom of the OXO pan is ridged, which supposedly allows for more even baking. I'm a little concerned about all the extra edges when it comes to the coating's longevity, but the pan feels well made. Only time will tell how the ceramic coating does. The coating seems to have goldish beige coloring in the mix. The lip edges are also rolled under, but it's shaped into more of a square. I think I like the design of the lip edges better on the OXO. The only downside might be that it's harder to grab than the KitchenAid. I think it'll be fine with the lip giving something to catch onto when holding the sides of the pan.
Both pans feel pretty solid. Washing each is easy, and water beads up on the nonstick surfaces. I'm expecting each surface to do pretty well in releasing food. The KitchenAid is definitely larger than the OXO. Had I received both in perfect condition, I'm not sure I'd be willing to pay the extra for the OXO. Maybe after some baking I'll find something I like.
I wanted to put this review out before even getting to the baking because of how much of a pain it's been trying to get a pair of KitchenAid pans. I received 4 pans and only ended up keeping 1. The first pan had a scratch in the nonstick coating, so I returned it. The second pan had a small dent but no other noticeable defects. I kept that one. The third pan had a larger scratch in the coating. I returned it. The fourth pan was okay on the inside, but it came with a scuff on the outside, some kind of oily stain, and 4 dents. After Amazon's web app rejected another replacement order, I just returned it and gave up on KitchenAid. The first pan I ordered from OXO has a small scuff on the outside of the pan, but there are no other noticeable defects. So to be done with the quality control roulette game, I'm willing to pay the increased price for the OXO. Now that I've got one of each, I'll get to see how the designs affect baking and cleaning down the road.
Add Prime
to get Fast, Free delivery
$21.62 with 6 percent savings
Typical price: $22.95 
The Typical Price is determined using the 90-day median price paid by customers for the product in the Amazon store. We exclude prices paid by customers for the product during limited time promotions and prices paid in the Amazon Haul store
Learn more
Learn more
Competitively priced item
Amazon's Choice
$17.99 ($9.00/Count)
Frequently bought together
This item: OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro 1 Lb Loaf Pan
$21.62
Get it as soon as Friday, Dec 27
In Stock
+
$31.50
Get it as soon as Friday, Dec 27
In Stock
Total price: $00
To see our price, add these items to your cart.
Choose items to buy together.
Similar items in new arrivals
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
- Rachael Ray Cucina Hard Anodized Nonstick Griddle Pan/Flat Grill, 11 Inch, Gray with Agave Blue HandleAmazon's Choicein Grill Pans
From the brand
-
-
Shop holiday must-haves
-
-
Shop Chef Marcus' must-haves
-
-
Shop coffee & tea
-
-
Shop food storage
-
-
Shop baby & toddler
-
-
-
Shop Outdoor
-
-
Shop kitchen essentials
-
-
Shop cleaning & organization
From the manufacturer
Compare with similar items
This Item  OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro 1 Lb Loaf Pan | Recommendations  |  |  |  |  | |
| Price | -6% $21.62 Typical: $22.95 | -7% $13.50 List: $14.50 | $80.00 | -30% $11.97 List: $16.99 | $19.00 | -7% $27.99 List: $29.99 |
| Delivery | Get it as soon as Friday, Dec 27 | Get it as soon as Friday, Dec 27 | Get it as soon as Friday, Dec 27 | Get it as soon as Friday, Dec 27 | Get it as soon as Friday, Dec 27 | Get it as soon as Friday, Dec 27 |
| Customer Ratings | ||||||
| Sold By | Amazon.com | Amazon.com | Amazon.com | Amazon.com | Amazon.com | abundesia |
| size | 1lb Loaf Pan | 1-Pound | Loaf Pan | Small | 12x6.25 | 5x9 inches (1lb) |
| material | Aluminized steel, ceramic-reinforced, 2-layer coating | Aluminum | Stainless Steel | Alloy Steel | Carbon Steel | High Carbon Steel |
| shape | Square | Rectangular | — | Rectangular | Rectangular | Rectangular |
| upper temperature rate | — | 260 degrees celsius | 315 degrees celsius | 450 degrees fahrenheit | 200 degrees celsius | 450 degrees fahrenheit |
| dishwasher safe | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ |
The Best!
I bake a lot of bread and won't use any other pan. I have several and it is SO worth the price! Perfect heat distribution makes for a perfect loaf.😊
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
- Reviewed in the United States on July 30, 2018Style Name: 1lb Loaf PanVerified Purchase
I've long been on the lookout for a good loaf pan. All the pans I had used so far that I purchased from stores kept resulting in overly cooked / hard bottoms and sides. This OXO loaf pan had great reviews and a unique bottom design so decided to give it a shot.
I just used my bread pan for the first time to make banana nut bread, and I was ecstatic about how well it came out! The crust had risen and browned perfectly without burning on the sides or bottom. My husband said the bread tasted buttery and delicious. Amazing! Check out the picture to see how my banana nut bread looked after baking and starting to cool on a cooling rack.
I was a bit hesitant about the cleaning aspect of it since I saw that another customer complained it being difficult with the bottom design. However, I found it to be easy with a dish scouring (one that's safe for non-stick pans) rag. I can see how it may be more difficult with a regular sponge. There were just a thin layer of bread crumbs on the side and bottom after removing my bread (it plopped right out just by tipping the pan upside down and shaking a bit), and the loaf pan was spotless after cleaning.
I'm excited to try more recipes knowing that my burned-bread days are hopefully over. As the instructions say, be sure to keep an eye on cooking progress since this pan cooks more efficiently and evenly.
To summarize, buy this pan!
Images in this review
Top reviews from other countries
-
Amazon CustomerReviewed in Mexico on February 17, 2020
Excelente producto
Style Name: 1lb Loaf PanVerified Purchase - MCReviewed in Singapore on February 16, 2021
Misleading size but overall good quality
Style Name: 1lb Loaf PanVerified Purchase
The dimensions in the product photo mentions 9.09 inch by 5.09 inch but the product I received is 8.49 inch by 4.49 inch! Not a big difference but I was looking for a 9 by 5. Else, Quality looks good.Misleading size but overall good qualityMC
Reviewed in Singapore on February 16, 2021
Images in this review
- Elmar du RandReviewed in Japan on August 2, 2019
Great Product
Style Name: 1lb Loaf PanVerified Purchase - Jacqueline DunneReviewed in Canada on November 15, 2023
oxo good grips non stick loaf pan
Style Name: 1lb Loaf PanVerified Purchase
