Enjoy fast, free delivery, exclusive deals, and award-winning movies & TV shows with Prime
Try Prime
and start saving today with fast, free delivery
Amazon Prime includes:
Fast, FREE Delivery is available to Prime members. To join, select "Try Amazon Prime and start saving today with Fast, FREE Delivery" below the Add to Cart button.
Amazon Prime members enjoy:- Cardmembers earn 5% Back at Amazon.com with a Prime Credit Card.
- Unlimited Free Two-Day Delivery
- Streaming of thousands of movies and TV shows with limited ads on Prime Video.
- A Kindle book to borrow for free each month - with no due dates
- Listen to over 2 million songs and hundreds of playlists
- Unlimited photo storage with anywhere access
Important: Your credit card will NOT be charged when you start your free trial or if you cancel during the trial period. If you're happy with Amazon Prime, do nothing. At the end of the free trial, your membership will automatically upgrade to a monthly membership.
Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
Follow the author
OK
With the Old Breed: At Peleliu and Okinawa Mass Market Paperback – September 25, 2007
Purchase options and add-ons
In The Wall Street Journal, Victor Davis Hanson named With the Old Breed one of the top five books on epic twentieth-century battles. Studs Terkel interviewed the author for his definitive oral history, The Good War. Now E. B. Sledge’s acclaimed first-person account of fighting at Peleliu and Okinawa returns to thrill, edify, and inspire a new generation.
An Alabama boy steeped in American history and enamored of such heroes as George Washington and Daniel Boone, Eugene B. Sledge became part of the war’s famous 1st Marine Division—3rd Battalion, 5th Marines. Even after intense training, he was shocked to be thrown into the battle of Peleliu, where “the world was a nightmare of flashes, explosions, and snapping bullets.” By the time Sledge hit the hell of Okinawa, he was a combat vet, still filled with fear but no longer with panic.
Based on notes Sledge secretly kept in a copy of the New Testament, With the Old Breed captures with utter simplicity and searing honesty the experience of a soldier in the fierce Pacific Theater. Here is what saved, threatened, and changed his life. Here, too, is the story of how he learned to hate and kill—and came to love—his fellow man.
“In all the literature on the Second World War, there is not a more honest, realistic or moving memoir than Eugene Sledge’s. This is the real deal, the real war: unvarnished, brutal, without a shred of sentimentality or false patriotism, a profound primer on what it actually was like to be in that war. It is a classic that will outlive all the armchair generals’ safe accounts of—not the ‘good war’—but the worst war ever.”—Ken Burns
- Print length384 pages
- LanguageEnglish
- PublisherPresidio Press
- Publication dateSeptember 25, 2007
- Dimensions4.19 x 1.04 x 6.81 inches
- ISBN-100891419195
- ISBN-13978-0891419198
The Amazon Book Review
Book recommendations, author interviews, editors' picks, and more. Read it now.
Frequently bought together

Similar items that ship from close to you
Courage meant overcoming fear and doing one’s duty in the presence of danger, not being unafraid.Highlighted by 2,210 Kindle readers
We were unable to understand their attitudes until we ourselves returned home and tried to comprehend people who griped because America wasn’t perfect, or their coffee wasn’t hot enough, or they had to stand in line and wait for a train or bus.Highlighted by 1,575 Kindle readers
This, I realized, was the difference between war and hunting. When I survived the former, I gave up the latter.Highlighted by 1,263 Kindle readers
Editorial Reviews
Review
“In all the literature on the Second World War, there is not a more honest, realistic or moving memoir than Eugene Sledge’s. This is the real deal, the real war: unvarnished, brutal, without a shred of sentimentality or false patriotism, a profound primer on what it actually was like to be in that war. It is a classic that will outlive all the armchair generals’ safe accounts of—not the ‘good war’—but the worst war ever.”—Ken Burns
About the Author
Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved.
Making of a Marine
I enlisted in the Marine Corps on 3 December 1942 at Marion, Alabama. At the time I was a freshman at Marion Military Institute. My parents and brother Edward had urged me to stay in college as long as possible in order to qualify for a commission in some technical branch of the U.S. Army. But, prompted by a deep feeling of uneasiness that the war might end before I could get overseas into combat, I wanted to enlist in the Marine Corps as soon as possible. Ed, a Citadel graduate and a second lieutenant in the army, suggested life would be more beautiful for me as an officer. Mother and Father were mildly distraught at the thought of me in the Marines as an enlisted man—that is, “cannon fodder.” So when a Marine recruiting team came to Marion Institute, I compromised and signed up for one of the Corps’ new officer training programs. It was called V-12.
The recruiting sergeant wore dress blue trousers, a khaki shirt, necktie, and white barracks hat. His shoes had a shine the likes of which I’d never seen. He asked me lots of questions and filled out numerous official papers. When he asked, “Any scars, birthmarks, or other unusual features?” I described an inch-long scar on my right knee. I asked why such a question. He replied, “So they can identify you on some Pacific beach after the Japs blast off your dog tags.” This was my introduction to the stark realism that characterized the Marine Corps I later came to know.
The college year ended the last week of May 1943. I had the month of June at home in Mobile before I had to report 1 July for duty at Georgia Tech in Atlanta.
I enjoyed the train trip from Mobile to Atlanta because the train had a steam engine. The smoke smelled good, and the whistle added a plaintive note reminiscent of an unhurried life. The porters were impressed and most solicitous when I told them, with no little pride, that I was on my way to becoming a Marine. My official Marine Corps meal ticket got me a large, delicious shrimp salad in the dining car and the admiring glances of the steward in attendance.
On my arrival in Atlanta, a taxi deposited me at Georgia Tech, where the 180-man Marine detachment lived in Harrison Dormitory. Recruits were scheduled to attend classes year round (in my case, about two years), graduate, and then go to the Marine base at Quantico, Virginia, for officers’ training.
A Marine regular, Capt. Donald Payzant, was in charge. He had served with the 1st Marine Division on Guadalcanal. Seeming to glory in his duty and his job as our commander, he loved the Corps and was salty and full of swagger. Looking back, I realize now that he had survived the meat grinder of combat and was simply glad to be in one piece with the good fortune of being stationed at a peaceful college campus.
Life at Georgia Tech was easy and comfortable. In short, we didn’t know there was a war going on. Most of the college courses were dull and uninspiring. Many of the professors openly resented our presence. It was all but impossible to concentrate on academics. Most of us felt we had joined the Marines to fight, but here we were college boys again. The situation was more than many of us could stand. At the end of the first semester, ninety of us—half of the detachment—flunked out of school so we could go into the Corps as enlisted men.
When the navy officer in charge of academic affairs called me in to question me about my poor academic performance, I told him I hadn’t joined the Marine Corps to sit out the war in college. He was sympathetic to the point of being fatherly and said he would feel the same way if he were in my place.
Captain Payzant gave the ninety of us a pep talk in front of the dormitory the morning we were to board the train for boot camp at the Marine Corps Recruit Depot, San Diego, California. He told us we were the best men and the best Marines in the detachment. He said he admired our spirit for wanting to get into the war. I think he was sincere.
After the pep talk, buses took us to the railway station. We sang and cheered the whole way. We were on our way to war at last. If we had only known what lay ahead of us!
Approximately two and a half years later, I came back through the Atlanta railway station on my way home. Shortly after I stepped off the car for a stroll, a young army infantryman walked up to me and shook hands. He said he had noticed my 1st Marine Division patch and the campaign ribbons on my chest and wondered if I had fought at Peleliu. When I said I had, he told me he just wanted to express his undying admiration for men of the 1st Marine Division.
He had fought with the 81st Infantry Division (Wildcats), which had come in to help us at Peleliu.* He was a machine gunner, had been hit by Japanese fire on Bloody Nose Ridge, and was abandoned by his army comrades. He knew he would either die of his wounds or be cut up by the Japanese when darkness fell. Risking their lives, some Marines had moved in and carried him to safety. The soldier said he was so impressed by the bravery, efficiency, and esprit of the Marines he saw on Peleliu that he swore to thank every veteran of the 1st Marine Division he ever ran across.
The “Dago people”—as those of us bound for San Diego were called—boarded a troop train in a big railroad terminal in Atlanta. Everyone was in high spirits, as though we were headed for a picnic instead of boot camp—and a war. The trip across the country took several days and was uneventful but interesting. Most of us had never been west, and we enjoyed the scenery. The monotony of the trip was broken with card games, playing jokes on each other, and waving, yelling, and
*Together with the 1st Marine Division, the U.S. Army’s 81st Infantry Division comprised the III Amphibious Corps commanded by Maj. Gen. Roy S. Geiger, USMC. For the Palau operation, the 1st Marine Division assaulted Peleliu on 15 September 1944 while the 81st Division took Angaur Island and provided a regiment as corps reserve. The 81st Division relieved the 1st Marine Division on Peleliu on 20 October and secured the island on 27 November.
whistling at any and all women visible. We ate some meals in dining cars on the train; but at certain places the train pulled onto a siding, and we ate in the restaurant in the railroad terminal.
Nearly all of the rail traffic we passed was military. We saw long trains composed almost entirely of flatcars loaded with tanks, halftracks, artillery pieces, trucks, and other military equipment. Many troop trains passed us going both ways. Most of them carried army troops. This rail traffic impressed on us the enormousness of the nation’s war effort.
We arrived in San Diego early one morning. Collecting our gear, we fell into ranks outside our cars as a first sergeant came along and told the NCOs on our train which buses to get us aboard. This first sergeant looked old to us teenagers. Like ourselves, he was dressed in a green wool Marine uniform, but he had campaign ribbons on his chest. He also wore the green French fourragère on his left shoulder. (Later, as a member of the 5th Marine Regiment, I would wear the braided cord around my left arm with pride.) But this man sported, in addition, two single loops outside his arm. That meant he had served with a regiment (either the 5th or 6th Marines) that had received the award from France for distinguished combat service in World War I.
The sergeant made a few brief remarks to us about the tough training we faced. He seemed friendly and compassionate, almost fatherly. His manner threw us into a false sense of well-being and left us totally unprepared for the shock that awaited us when we got off those buses.
“Fall out, and board your assigned buses!” ordered the first sergeant.
“All right, you people. Get aboard them buses!” the NCOs yelled. They seemed to have become more authoritarian as we approached San Diego.
After a ride of only a few miles, the buses rolled to a stop in the big Marine Corps Recruit Depot—boot camp. As I looked anxiously out the window, I saw many platoons of recruits marching along the streets. Each drill instructor (DI) bellowed his highly individual cadence. The recruits looked as rigid as sardines in a can. I grew nervous at seeing how serious—or rather, scared—they seemed.
“All right, you people, off them damned buses!”
We scrambled out, lined up with men from the other buses, and were counted off into groups of about sixty. Several trucks rolled by carrying work parties of men still in boot camp or who had finished recently. All looked at us with knowing grins and jeered, “You’ll be sorreee.” This was the standard, unofficial greeting extended to all recruits.
Shortly after we debused, a corporal walked over to my group. He yelled, “Patoon, teehut. Right hace, forwart huah. Double time, huah.”
He ran us up and down the streets for what seemed hours and finally to a double line of huts that would house us for a time. We were breathless. He didn’t even seem to be breathing hard.
“Patoon halt, right hace!” He put his hands on his hips and looked us over contemptuously. “You people are stupid,” he bellowed. From then on he tried to prove it every moment of every day. “My name is Corporal Doherty. I’m your drill instructor. This is Platoon 984. If any of you idiots think you don’t need to follow my orders, just step right out here and I’ll beat your ass right now. Your soul may belong to Jesus, but your ass belongs to the Marines. You people are recruits. You’re not Marines. You may not have what it takes to be Marines.”
No one dared move, hardly even to breathe. We were all humbled, because there was no doubt the DI meant exactly what he said.
Corporal Doherty wasn’t a large man by any standard. He stood about five feet ten inches, probably weighed around 160 pounds, and was muscular with a protruding chest and flat stomach. He had thin lips, a ruddy complexion, and was probably as Irish as his name. From his accent I judged him to be a New Englander, maybe from Boston. His eyes were the coldest, meanest green I ever saw. He glared at us like a wolf whose first and foremost desire was to tear us limb from limb. He gave me the impression that the only reason he didn’t do so was that the Marine Corps wanted to use us for cannon fodder to absorb Japanese bullets and shrapnel so genuine Marines could be spared to capture Japanese positions.
That Corporal Doherty was tough and hard as nails none of us ever doubted. Most Marines recall how loudly their DIs yelled at them, but Doherty didn’t yell very loudly. Instead he shouted in an icy, menacing manner that sent cold chills through us. We believed that if he didn’t scare us to death, the Japs couldn’t kill us. He was always immaculate, and his uniform fitted him as if the finest tailor had made it for him. His posture was erect, and his bearing reflected military precision.
The public pictures a DI wearing sergeant stripes. Doherty commanded our respect and put such fear into us that he couldn’t have been more effective if he had had the six stripes of a first sergeant instead of the two of a corporal. One fact emerged immediately with stark clarity: this man would be the master of our fates in the weeks to come.
Doherty rarely drilled us on the main parade ground, but marched or double-timed us to an area near the beach of San Diego Bay. There the deep, soft sand made walking exhausting, just what he wanted. For hours on end, for days on end, we drilled back and forth across the soft sand. My legs ached terribly for the first few days, as did those of everyone else in the platoon. I found that when I concentrated on a fold of the collar or cap of the man in front of me or tried to count the ships in the bay, my muscles didn’t ache as badly. To drop out of ranks because of tired legs was unthinkable. The standard remedy for such shirking was to “double-time in place to get the legs in shape”—before being humiliated and berated in front of the whole platoon by the DI. I preferred the pain to the remedy.
Before heading back to the hut area at the end of each drill session, Doherty would halt us, ask a man for his rifle, and tell us he would demonstrate the proper technique for holding the rifle while creeping and crawling. First, though, he would place the butt of the rifle on the sand, release the weapon, and let it drop, saying that anyone who did that would have a miserable day of it. With so many men in the platoon, it was uncanny how often he asked to use my rifle in this demonstration. Then, after demonstrating how to cradle the rifle, he ordered us to creep and crawl. Naturally, the men in front kicked sand onto the rifle of the one behind him. With this and several other techniques, the DI made it necessary for us to clean our rifles several times each day. But we learned quickly and well an old Marine Corps truism, “The rifle is a Marine’s best friend.” We always treated it as just that.
During the first few days, Doherty once asked one of the recruits a question about his rifle. In answering, the hapless recruit referred to his rifle as “my gun.” The DI muttered some instructions to him, and the recruit blushed. He began trotting up and down in front of the huts holding his rifle in one hand and his penis in the other, chanting, “This is my rifle,” as he held up his M1, “and this is my gun,” as he moved his other arm. “This is for Japs,” he again held aloft his M1; “and this is for fun,” he held up his other arm. Needless to say, none of us ever again used the word “gun” unless referring to a shotgun, mortar, artillery piece, or naval gun.
A typical day in boot camp began with reveille at 0400 hours. We tumbled out of our sacks in the chilly dark and hurried through shaves, dressing, and chow. The grueling day ended with taps at 2200. At any time between taps and reveille, however, the DI might break us out for rifle inspection, close-order drill, or for a run around the parade ground or over the sand by the bay. This seemingly cruel and senseless harassment stood me in good stead later when I found that war allowed sleep to no man, particularly the infantryman. Combat guaranteed sleep of the permanent type only.
We moved to two or three different hut areas during the first few weeks, each time on a moment’s notice. The order was “Platoon 984, fall out on the double with rifles, full individual equipment, and seabags with all gear properly stowed, and prepare to move out in ten minutes.” A mad scramble would follow as men gathered up and packed their equipment. Each man had one or two close buddies who pitched in to help each other don packs and hoist heavy seabags onto sagging shoulders. Several men from each hut would stay behind to clean up the huts and surrounding area as the other men of the platoon struggled under their heavy loads to the new hut area.
Upon arrival at the new area, the platoon halted, received hut assignments, fell out, and stowed gear. Just as we got into the huts we would get orders to fall in for drill with rifles, cartridge belts, and bayonets. The sense of urgency and hurry never abated. Our DI was ingenious in finding ways to harass us.
One of the hut areas we were in was across a high fence from an aircraft factory where big B-24 Liberator bombers were made. There was an airstrip, too, and the big four- engine planes came and went low over the tops of the huts. Once one belly-landed, going through the fence near our huts. No one was hurt, but several of us ran down to see the crash. When we got back to our area, Corporal Doherty delivered one of his finest orations on the subject of recruits never leaving their assigned area without the permission of their DI. We were all impressed, particularly with the tremendous number of push-ups and other exercises we performed instead of going to noon chow.
During close-order drill, the short men had the toughest time staying in step. Every platoon had its “feather merchants”—short men struggling along with giant strides at the tail end of the formation. At five feet nine inches, I was about two-thirds of the way back from the front guide of Platoon 984. One day while returning from the bayonet course, I got out of step and couldn’t pick up the cadence. Corporal Doherty marched along beside me. In his icy tone, he said, “Boy, if you don’t get in step and stay in step, I’m gonna kick you so hard in the behind that they’re gonna have to take both of us to sick bay. It’ll take a major operation to get my foot outa your ass.” With those inspiring words ringing in my ears, I picked up the cadence and never ever lost it again.
The weather became quite chilly, particularly at night. I had to cover up with blankets and overcoat. Many of us slept in dungaree trousers and sweat shirts in addition to our Skivvies. When reveille sounded well before daylight, we only had to pull on our boondockers [field shoes] before falling in for roll call.
Each morning after roll call, we ran in the foggy darkness to a large asphalt parade ground for rifle calisthenics. Atop a wooden platform, a muscular physical training instructor led several platoons in a long series of tiring exercises. A public-address system played a scratchy recording of “Three O’Clock in the Morning.” We were supposed to keep time with the music. The monotony was broken only by frequent whispered curses and insults directed at our enthusiastic instructor, and by the too frequent appearance of various DIs who stalked the extended ranks making sure all hands exercised vigorously. Not only did the exercises harden our bodies, but our hearing became superkeen from listening for the DIs as we skipped a beat or two for a moment of rest in the inky darkness.
At the time, we didn’t realize or appreciate the fact that the discipline we were learning in responding to orders under stress often would mean the difference later in combat— between success or failure, even living or dying. The ear training also proved to be an unscheduled dividend when Japanese infiltrators slipped around at night.
Shortly we received word that we were going to move out to the rifle range. We greeted the announcement enthusiastically. Rumor had it that we would receive the traditional broad-brimmed campaign hats. But the supply ran out when our turn came. We felt envious and cheated every time we saw those salty-looking “Smokey Bear” hats on the range.
Early on the first morning at the rifle range, we began what was probably the most thorough and the most effective rifle marksmanship training given to any troops of any nation during World War II. We were divided into two-man teams the first week for dry firing, or “snapping-in.” We concentrated on proper sight setting, trigger squeeze, calling of shots, use of the leather sling as a shooting aid, and other fundamentals.
It soon became obvious why we all received thick pads to be sewn onto the elbows and right shoulders of our dungaree jackets: during this snapping-in, each man and his buddy practiced together, one in the proper position (standing, kneeling, sitting, or prone) and squeezing the trigger, and the other pushing back the rifle bolt lever with the heel of his hand, padded by an empty cloth bandolier wrapped around the palm. This procedure cocked the rifle and simulated recoil.
The DIs and rifle coaches checked every man continuously. Everything had to be just so. Our arms became sore from being contorted into various positions and having the leather sling straining our joints and biting into our muscles. Most of us had problems perfecting the sitting position (which I never saw used in combat). But the coach helped everyone the way he did me—simply by plopping his weight on my shoulders until I was able to “assume the correct position.” Those familiar with firearms quickly forgot what they knew and learned the Marine Corps’ way.
Second only to accuracy was safety. Its principles were pounded into us mercilessly. “Keep the piece pointed toward the target. Never point a rifle at anything you don’t intend to shoot. Check your rifle each time you pick it up to be sure it isn’t loaded. Many accidents have occurred with ‘unloaded’ rifles.”
We went onto the firing line and received live ammunition the next week. At first, the sound of rifles firing was disconcerting. But not for long. Our snapping-in had been so thorough, we went through our paces automatically. We fired at round black bull’s-eye targets from 100, 300, and 500 yards. Other platoons worked the “butts.”* When the range officer ordered, “Ready on the right, ready on the left, all ready on the firing line, commence firing,” I felt as though the rifle was part of me and vice versa. My concentration was complete.
Discipline was ever present, but the harassment that had been our daily diet gave way to deadly serious, businesslike instruction in marksmanship. Punishment for infractions of the rules came swiftly and severely, however. One man next to me turned around slightly to speak to a buddy after “cease firing” was given; the action caused his rifle muzzle to angle
*“Butts” refers to the impact area on a rifle range. It consists of the targets mounted on a vertical track system above a sheltered dugout, usually made of concrete, in which other shooters operate, mark, and score the targets for those on the firing line.
away from the targets. The sharp-eyed captain in charge of the range rushed up from behind and booted the man in the rear so hard that he fell flat on his face. The captain then jerked him up off the deck and bawled him out loudly and thoroughly. We got his message.
Platoon 984 took its turn in the butts. As we sat safely in the dugouts and waited for each series of firing to be completed, I had somber thoughts about the crack and snap of bullets passing overhead.
Qualification day dawned clearly and brightly. We were apprehensive, having been told that anyone who didn’t shoot high enough to qualify as “marksman” wouldn’t go overseas. When the final scores were totaled, I was disappointed. I fell short of “expert rifleman” by only two points. However, I proudly wore the Maltese Cross–shaped sharpshooter’s badge. And I didn’t neglect to point out to my Yankee buddies that most of the high shooters in our platoon were Southern boys.
Feeling like old salts, we returned to the recruit depot for the final phases of recruit training. The DIs didn’t treat us as veterans, though; harassment picked up quickly to its previous intensity.
By the end of eight grueling weeks, it had become apparent that Corporal Doherty and the other DIs had done their jobs well. We were hard physically, had developed endurance, and had learned our lessons. Perhaps more important, we were tough mentally. One of our assistant drill instructors even allowed himself to mumble that we might become Marines after all.
Finally, late in the afternoon of 24 December 1943, we fell in without rifles and cartridge belts. Dressed in service greens, each man received three bronze Marine Corps globe-and-anchor emblems, which we put into our pockets. We marched to an amphitheater where we sat with several other platoons.
This was our graduation from boot camp. A short, affable-looking major standing on the stage said, “Men, you have successfully completed your recruit training and are now United States Marines. Put on your Marine Corps emblems and wear them with pride. You have a great and proud tradition to uphold. You are members of the world’s finest fighting outfit, so be worthy of it.” We took out our emblems and put one on each lapel of our green wool coats and one on the left side of the overseas caps. The major told several dirty jokes. Everyone laughed and whistled. Then he said, “Good luck, men.” That was the first time we had been addressed as men during our entire time in boot camp.
Before dawn the next day, Platoon 984 assembled in front of the huts for the last time. We shouldered our seabags, slung our rifles, and struggled down to a warehouse where a line of trucks was parked. Corporal Doherty told us that each man was to report to the designated truck as his name and destination was called out. The few men selected to train as specialists (radar technicians, aircraft mechanics, etc.) were to turn in their rifles, bayonets, and cartridge belts.
As the men moved out of ranks, there were quiet remarks of, “So long, see you, take it easy.” We knew that many friendships were ending right there. Doherty called out, “Eugene B. Sledge, 534559, full individual equipment and M1 rifle, infantry, Camp Elliott.”
Most of us were designated for infantry, and we went to Camp Elliott or to Camp Pendleton.* As we helped each other aboard the trucks, it never occurred to us why so many were being assigned to infantry. We were destined to take the places of the ever mounting numbers of casualties in the rifle or line companies in the Pacific. We were fated to fight the war first hand. We were cannon fodder.
After all assignments had been made, the trucks rolled out, and I looked at Doherty watching us leave. I disliked him, but I respected him. He had made us Marines, and I wondered what he thought as we rolled by.
*Camp Elliott was a small installation located on the northern outskirts of San Diego. It has been used rarely since World War II. Thirty-five miles north of San Diego lies Camp Joseph H. Pendleton. Home today of the 1st Marine Division, it is the Marine Corps’ major west coast amphibious base.
Product details
- Publisher : Presidio Press; Reprint edition (September 25, 2007)
- Language : English
- Mass Market Paperback : 384 pages
- ISBN-10 : 0891419195
- ISBN-13 : 978-0891419198
- Item Weight : 2.31 pounds
- Dimensions : 4.19 x 1.04 x 6.81 inches
- Best Sellers Rank: #28,956 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
- #53 in WWII Biographies
- #202 in World War II History (Books)
- #967 in Memoirs (Books)
- Customer Reviews:
About the author

Discover more of the author’s books, see similar authors, read author blogs and more
Customer reviews
- 5 star4 star3 star2 star1 star5 star90%9%1%0%0%90%
- 5 star4 star3 star2 star1 star4 star90%9%1%0%0%9%
- 5 star4 star3 star2 star1 star3 star90%9%1%0%0%1%
- 5 star4 star3 star2 star1 star2 star90%9%1%0%0%0%
- 5 star4 star3 star2 star1 star1 star90%9%1%0%0%0%
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on AmazonCustomers say
Customers find the storyline vivid, violent, and brutal. They also describe the book as well-written, interesting, and hard to put down. Readers find the content factual and rewarding, helping them have a better understanding of what so many went through. They find the emotional intensity deep, meaningful, and graphic. Customers also describe it as the best war memoir they have ever read.
AI-generated from the text of customer reviews
Customers find the storyline vivid, riveting, and depressing. They also describe the descriptions as vivid, detailed, and confirmed by historical research. Readers also say the book is the greatest WWII memoir ever.
"...of man at war and will forever remain one of the most authentic, vivid stories of an enlisted man's experiences on the front lines ever told...." Read more
"...detached way, Sledge's memoirs are surprisingly engaging and even suspenseful...." Read more
"...Sledge managed to retain an amazing amount of detail in his mind (with the aid of some scribbled notes), a task made even more amazing when a reader..." Read more
"This book is a compelling first hand account, from a U. S. Marine private's view, of the hourly and daily horrors American Marines suffered when in..." Read more
Customers find the book very well written, with a clear, direct style. They also say the book is interesting, hard to put down, and brutally honest.
"...The book is a page-turner. Written in a calm, almost detached way, Sledge's memoirs are surprisingly engaging and even suspenseful...." Read more
"The book was very well written. Could not put it down. Highly recomend for anyone to purchase." Read more
"...To me, this was the best kind of writing, it's written from the gut...." Read more
"...The language is harsh and the author brutally honest, down to the most horrific details...." Read more
Customers find the book very factual, straight forward, and honest. They also say it's detailed, informative, and remarkable.
"...an extraordinary tale of man at war and will forever remain one of the most authentic, vivid stories of an enlisted man's experiences on the front..." Read more
"...After reading this relatively short, but detailed book, you will reach several conclusions: first, the Pacific campaigns were absolutely hellish;..." Read more
"...What makes Sledge's account remarkable is his honesty...." Read more
"...He doesn't need to.He is instead very humble and matter-of-fact, realizing that the truth is more than enough to draw you into the..." Read more
Customers find the book deeply meaningful, an eye opener, and a compelling read. They also say it brings tears to their eyes, makes them proud, and profoundly changes their view of war. Readers describe the writing as graphic and truthful, with great depth of feeling, honesty, and clarity. They say it keeps their attention.
"...So, With the Old Breed offers a deeply meaningful and enduring commentary about devotion to duty, loyalty, and brotherhood...." Read more
"...I was struck by Sledge's maturity, bravery, and almost unqualified respect for those in his chain of command...." Read more
"...He doesn't need to.He is instead very humble and matter-of-fact, realizing that the truth is more than enough to draw you into the..." Read more
"...but from what I have read Sledge's is the most real, honest and heartfelt). Without a doubt I would recommend this to any and all...." Read more
Customers find the war memoir the best they've ever read.
"...What we have is perhaps the greatest Pacific War memoir ever, and quite possibly the greatest WWII memoir ever..." Read more
"...One of the best WWII related memoirs you will read, right up there with 'Storm of Steel' and 'Goodbye, Darkness'...." Read more
"This is the best war memoir I have ever read...." Read more
"This is the best first-person combat memoir I have read. I could not put it down...." Read more
Customers find the personal content of the book outstanding.
"The best personal account you will read period. I have read many personal war time accounts, this is by far the best...." Read more
"This book is the best first hand account of what a ww2 Marine in the Pacific went through fighting the Japanese and just living through every..." Read more
"This is a great 1st hand account. A must read for any history buff." Read more
"...It's the best personal military account that I've read." Read more
Reviews with images
Memoir or Masterpiece?
-
Top reviews
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
Sledge's Marines of Kilo Company, 3rd Battalion, 5th Marines (K/3/5) of the storied 1st Marine Division are as tough as they come. Their exploits are the stuff of legends, and through their incredible courage on Peleliu and Okinawa they honor the precious legacy of the many combat Marines to come before them.
The kill-or-be-killed actions of human beings essentially reduced to animals struggling for survival on a tiny coral atoll against a ruthless, fanatical and, yes, even suicidal enemy is difficult for most readers to stomach, much less comprehend. Yet, we find ourselves reading on if for no other reason than to root for the young enlisted Marines who shoulder the heaviest load in this fight. These remarkable Americans demonstrate yet again why they are collectively known as our country's Greatest Generation.
Sledge's portrayal of a vicious, man-on-man fight in the South West Pacific to wrest control of a chain of seemingly insignificant islands from the desperate yet determined Japanese is at once both haunting and captivating. One alternately feels revulsion at the atrocities committed on both sides and empathy for the young Marines struggling to survive. Many barely out of high school, these 18 and 19-year-olds are thrown relentlessly into the meat grinder that was part of Admiral Chester Nimitz's Island Hopping counteroffensive. They journey from the innocence of youth into an early manhood spent 'across the sights of a rifle' or kneeling behind a mortar tube.
We witness these young men participating in frontal assaults on Peleliu against an entrenched and well-equipped enemy whose capable use of machine guns and indirect fires (artillery and mortars) steadily reduces K/3/5's ranks. We see Marines desperate to dig fighting positions in virtually impenetrable coral rock... hugging the 'deck' as enemy artillery and mortar rounds bracket their positions.
The Marines' steady attacks are contrasted with their brief defensive stands at night. As darkness descends on the dug-in troops so do the Japanese. The Marines find themselves in frenetic, bare-fisted fights in foxholes against a crazed, marauding enemy with fire in his belly and a rifle with razor sharp 18-inch bayonet in his hands. As we attempt to grasp these men's hellish existence on Peleliu and their struggle to defy the odds and leave the island in one piece, we are left to contemplate the utter senselessness of war... and those shocking conditions that would reduce man to his basest instincts.
In addition to his account of the fight for Peleliu (referred to as the 'Peleliu Campaign'), Sledge relates his experiences during the fight for Okinawa ('the Okinawa Campaign').
The Okinawa Campaign oddly begins quietly as the invasion is largely uncontested. Remarkably, given the island's proximity to the Japanese mainland, the Marines initially do not encounter the same 'chaotic maelstrom' that they experienced on Peleliu. Instead, we readers are treated to descriptions of an idyllic, almost serene, Okinawan countryside and occasional encounters with a few friendly Okinawans.
But the calm the Marines experience belies what awaits them in the deep and dangerous recesses of Okinawa's system of interconnected ridges and draws. Much to K/3/5's horror, on Okinawa the Japanese have perfected the defense in depth and interlocking fires that characterized their defensive tactics toward the end of the war. And they bring to bear all the might of an increasingly desperate empire intent on sealing off their homeland from the Allied onslaught.
The Japanese suck the Marines into kill zones and proceed to pick them apart through carefully targeted machine gun and rifle fire. As the casualties mount, the men of K/3/5 realize they will not have an easy time of it on Okinawa after all. The ensuing weeks find these men in a no man's land feeling Hell's fury as they face off against the bulk of the Japanese Thirty-Second Army.
We readers wonder how the men of K/3/5 keep their sanity and how they are willing to continue slogging through the mud and filth to engage their merciless Japanese adversary. What is even more jaw-dropping about Sledge's experiences and what leaves the reader absolutely awestruck is how these fine, young Americans manage to continue their frontal assaults against an enemy occupying all but impregnable defenses. Amazingly, many a young Marine rifleman leaves the relative security of his foxhole on Okinawa and runs full tilt into a hailstorm of bullets and shrapnel. And falling in behind that Marine is yet another Marine! Unbelievable!
While many are casualties on both Peleliu and Okinawa, it becomes obvious as one reads Sledge's story exactly how others somehow survive. Quite simply, they stay close to the 'Old Breed' - those combat-hardened, veteran Marines who have dedicated their lives to the Corps... some of whom cut their teeth at Belleau Wood in World War I... and many of whom fought on Guadalcanal, in Cape Gloucester (New Guinea) and in those many other battles in the Pacific that have inspired the legend that is the United States Marine Corps. Many of the 'Old Breed' form the vanguard of attacking Marines and set the example for the raw and inexperienced recruits.
We realize then that many of the new troops fight on because they yearn to join the select few - the genuine article, authentic U.S. Marines... and the very pride of the Corps. Men such as Captain Andrew A. ('Ack Ack') Haldane and Gunnery Sergeant Elmo M. Haney, veritable demigods among American fighting men, assume almost mythic proportions to the younger members of K/3/5. Sledge and those like him internalize USMC lore and aspire to be combat Marines who serve selflessly and valorously... and who reflect the finest traditions of the Corps.
As Sledge points out without a hint of humor, men like Haldane and Haney are not 'born of woman, but are issued to the Marine Corps.' To receive the approval of men like these is to finally join the ranks of the few, the proud...
Sledge nearly bursts with pride when he hears 'the simple, sincere personal remarks' of a veteran Marine after his (Sledge's) actions on Peleliu. The veteran Marine offers the following comments to his young comrade:
"But I kept my eye on you on Peleliu and by God you did OK; you did OK."
While the veteran's comments seem modest, Sledge goes on to say that he "carried those words in [his] heart with great pride and satisfaction ever since they were uttered."
With the Old Breed is an extraordinary tale of man at war and will forever remain one of the most authentic, vivid stories of an enlisted man's experiences on the front lines ever told. Sledge's writing is characterized by great depth of feeling, honesty, and clarity. The realism with which he depicts the battlefield enables the reader to practically experience for himself the sights, sounds, and even smells of battle.
With the Old Breed, however, is about much more than war and the depths of man's inhumanity. Throughout his memoir, Sledge liberally sprinkles humorous anecdotes and subtle musings on the bonds that form between men fighting for survival while exposed to the nightmarish conditions of modern combat. So, With the Old Breed offers a deeply meaningful and enduring commentary about devotion to duty, loyalty, and brotherhood.
Ultimately, though, Sledge's message is really much deeper even than that. As horrifying as his experiences were on Peleliu and Okinawa and despite his decrying war as "brutish, inglorious, and a terrible waste", Sledge acknowledges that we as Americans are sometimes called to sacrifice for our country and for those many freedoms we hold dear.
Freedom is not free!
As The Old Breed is fond of saying, "If the country is good enough to live in, it's good enough to fight for."
A Classic!
With the Old Breed walks us through boot camp, Sledge's training at Camp Elliot, further training at Pavuvu, and then into the battle of Peleliu. I was struck by Sledge's maturity, bravery, and almost unqualified respect for those in his chain of command. How different from so many 18-19 year old men today! Sledge paints a vivid picture of the horrors of war, providing a clear context of the larger scale troop movements and progress while also dwelling on the relationships of the soldiers, the details of daily life (from wet socks, to enjoying scavenged Japanese rations of sea scallops, to "field sanitation"), and countless anecdotes of incidents showing the bravery of the men and their devotion to each other.
In no way does Sledge ever glorify the war. He describes it eloquently as "brutish, inglorious, and a terrible waste." The stress the men endure and the atrocities they witness slowly--or in some cases quickly--dehumanized many of them, to the point that some were guilty of atrocious acts, like looting the gold teeth of a still-living Japanese soldier. Sledge does not spare readers the misery of their surroundings, the terror of being constantly under barrage by machine gun bullets and enemy shells, or the despair at the senseless loss of life.
I was awestruck by the fact that as miserable and fearful as he was in battle, he never once expresses regret. There is a sense that despite all the misery and futility the war was still necessary. But what seemed to motivate Sledge was not the abstract principle of protecting the American way of life. It was the comradeship and commitment he shared with his fellow marines, the knowledge that they were going through this together as friends and that each of them would die to save the others. Still, his quite, underlying patriotism comes out on the last page of the book, where he writes: "If the country is good enough to live in, it's good enough to fight for. With privilege goes responsibility."
The book is a page-turner. Written in a calm, almost detached way, Sledge's memoirs are surprisingly engaging and even suspenseful. I read it very carefully, not wanting to miss a word, feeling as though I was experiencing the war along with Company K (though thankfully without the maggots, flooded foxholes, or constant threat to my life).
Top reviews from other countries
It is absolutely one of the books I'd suggest to anyone who wish to learn more about the Pacific Theater in WW2 through a witnessed account of the events.
1- Tactical: As a member of a mortar team, Sledge wasn't specifically on the very front line of combat. That's a rifleman's position. Still, he was usually only a few dozen feet back, meaning he saw plenty of action. Add to the fact that mortar positions were often targeted at night by Japanese infiltrators, and you get up-close action added to his mortar work. As a private, E. B. wasn't privileged to or responsible for tactical decisions. So there's not a lot of discussion of tactics here, other than by example of what actually happened. He does give good commentary on the effectiveness of various small-unit leaders (sergeants, lieutenants, and captains). Sledge is involved in some of the heavier fighting the Marine Corps was engaged in, so there is more than enough death and action to read about.
2- Strategic: there's even less discussion of strategies beyond blunders. This isn't unusual, as private first class is about as low a rank as you can have in the military. But that's not really the focus of this book, so it's not really a problem.
3- Moral: Sledge pulls no punches here. This is one of the most morally honest WW2 books I've ever read. He doesn't hesitate to praise and blame the enemy, nor his fellow marines. He admits his biases, which are reasonable. He discusses specific actions of soldiers, both heroics, and atrocities, in depth from practical and moral viewpoints. Sledge also makes it clear what his moral view of war in general is. If you want a really frank and honest discussion of the ethics and morals of combat, this is an excellent book.
4- Personal: Once more, Sledge pulls no punches. Fighting on tiny islands, with limited water, food, clothing, and most of all, space, meant that fighting conditions grew nasty. Very nasty. Rotting corpses, human waste, screams of the wounded, bursting shells, mud-filled trenches, etc. all add up to a very unglamorous portrait of war. This wasn't pretty, it was base savagery. He also comments on the few positive experiences of the war. The simple clean smell of a stand of pine trees. A momentary hot meal, or a quick shower. This book really takes the reader into Sledge's world. His experiences, his thoughts, his actions, and his emotions.
As you can tell from the general reviews for this book (almost all 5 stars), this is not an ordinary WW2 autobiography. Sledge is a good writer, who's greatest asset is his ability to bluntly tell the truth about his experiences. Vivid, powerful, and often awful, these experiences are definitely worth reading about so that we can understand, and thus avoid, the true hell of a war like the one he fought.











