Top positive review
107 people found this helpful
2015 Anniversary Blu-ray set indeed contains "Drummer Boy" and all 7 listed tracks! BUT, "Cricket" is a non-HD rip-off!
on December 1, 2015
Ok, first of all, this 2015 Anniversary edition of the BLU-RAY set does indeed contain all SEVEN programs on Blu-ray, FOR THE FIRST TIME EVER, yes, including "The Little Drummer Boy". I bought this (not at Amazon, as they were out of stock), and WATCHED all seven. They are:
1. Rudolph, The Red Nosed Reindeer (1964, 47 minutes)
2. Santa Claus Is Coming To Town (1970, 51 minutes)
3. Frosty, The Snowman (1969, 25 minutes)
4. Frosty Returns (1992, 23 minutes)
5. Mr. Magoo's Christmas Carol (1962, 53 minutes)
6. The Little Drummer Boy (1968, 25 minutes)
7. Cricket On The Hearth (1967, 49 Minutes)
And YES, I encountered the same defect on "Santa Claus Is Comin' To Town" as others have found, the fade to black right in the middle of four scenes, with the first (at 8:31) and fourth (at 42:04) such errors being the most egregious. This defect is NOT on the 2012 Blu-ray or prior DVDs of this show. Other posters have provided a phone number where we can call for a POSSIBLE free replacement Blu-ray disc (888-223-4369, and it works! Though there was no replacement disc promised to me, just the possibility of one.).
[UPDATE - Dec. 15, 2015: I received the replacement disc yesterday, and played "Santa Claus is Comin' to Town," checking the four points where the problems had been. All of the problems are NOW eliminated from that broadcast. This is literally a replacement disc, so it contains the other three items that were on the original, faulty disc, and those broadcasts appear to be exactly the same as before. "The Little Drummer Boy" continues to have just two chapters, as described below, and is the same as before in all other respects. The other two programs I only glanced through, but they appear to be exactly as described previously.]
Mr. Magoo's Christmas Carol looks perfect, just brand-new, sharp, and clean-- couldn't be better, and yet it's the oldest of all the shows (1962).
The Little Drummer Boy is barely sharper than the DVD version, but it has had most dirt and artifacts removed (I compared it head-to-head with the DVD), so it is a substantial improvement. However, it is VERY DISAPPOINTING in that, as with the DVD in prior years, they use a version that is NOT what we have always seen on TV. The animals generally don't make noises in this version (as when the lamb is hit by the chariot and bleats in pain), and they use a male voice-over and not female narrator Greer Garson for one famous line (of hers, originally) near the end (when Aaron beholds the baby Jesus: "And as Aaron looked at the babe, he thought it was the most beautiful sight he had ever seen"). WHY?? The old commercial VHS tape contains the correct version . . . For some reason, this broadcast of Drummer Boy only has two disc "chapters" in it, which is pointless, because the first chapter, of course, is at the absolute beginning, and the second chapter skips past the entire show to AFTER the closing credits, so this is really poorly done as to a simple matter. The other programs all have reasonable chaptering-- every five to ten minutes, taking us to the beginnings of scenes.
Five of the other six programs look quite nice on my Hi-Definition TV, all five are sharp and colorful, but Magoo stands out far above the others in that it simply looks spectacular. Drummer Boy has the weakest picture quality (of all seven), with the blandest coloring, and in the early-on graphics, I cannot read the year, which I know to be 1968, but it isn't sharp enough to read it as such. The show itself is reasonably sharp, but only slightly more so than its DVD version.
Oh yes, as to #7: "Cricket on the Hearth" is NOT "Blu-ray" OR high-definition!! A RIP-OFF! In fact, this is also the only program for which you will have to adjust your TV's aspect ratio to view it, as it does not automatically go to its original 4 x 3 while your TV set is set to 16 x 9, which all of the other six programs do. Moreover, the bit rate for this show varies between ONLY 2.1 Mbps and 6.8 Mbps-- mostly in the 3's and 4's-- LESS than most DVDs!! (Whereas all of the other six programs have more typical Blu-ray bit rates averaging 17 - 22 Mbps, with "Santa Claus is Coming To Town" and "Rudolph" often up at 28-29 Mbps, averaging about 25 Mbps.) Anyway, "Cricket" is certainly quite viewable, but there is nothing sharp or high-definition about it. It is not horribly soft-focus, it's just not particularly sharp or new-looking like the other programs. Its artifacts were mostly cleaned up, it is colorful, but it somehow looks at least slightly less than it could. I'm sure they used the very low bit rate in order to fit this program onto the disc, since they were squeezing 7 programs onto just two Blu-ray discs.
ALSO, in an update to this post prompted by a questioner, I have gone and listened to the entire song, "Silver and Gold," on "Rudolph," and yes, an audio error, which I researched afterward on the internet (to learn its history), DOES still exist on this 2015 anniversary version, per my own viewing. Basically, the word "for" is missing very early in the song, as in: "Everybody wishes for silver and gold"-- except that the word "for" isn't there. This same problem exists on this newest anniversary version, unfortunately, as it did in the prior BR (I own the 2012 Blu-ray as well, checked it yesterday, and this problem exists there, too).
In sum, for $20.00, this set is worth purchasing in order to have the 7 programs of content-- on Blu-ray in their best picture-quality ever-- despite the "Cricket" rip-off, the flaws introduced in this newest Blu-ray version of "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town," a flaw remaining on "Rudolph," and the use of a version of "Drummer Boy" that is slightly different from what we have seen on television for 47 years and vs. the VHS version.