Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
Follow the author
OK
Our Lady of Guadalupe: And the Conquest of Darkness Paperback – October 1, 2004
Purchase options and add-ons
Standard histories on the Age of Colonization tell a sad story of the ills inflicted on indigenous peoples by exploitative Western powers. This book offers a realistic corrective. The Spanish conquest of the New World is shown vividly—in its fervor and exuberance, but most importantly, with its central evangelical and civilizing impulse that transformed the Americas from savagery into a central part of Christendom.
- Print length119 pages
- LanguageEnglish
- PublisherChristendom Press
- Publication dateOctober 1, 2004
- Dimensions5.5 x 0.8 x 8.5 inches
- ISBN-100931888123
- ISBN-13978-0931888120
Frequently bought together

Customers who bought this item also bought
Product details
- Publisher : Christendom Press; 1st edition (October 1, 2004)
- Language : English
- Paperback : 119 pages
- ISBN-10 : 0931888123
- ISBN-13 : 978-0931888120
- Item Weight : 3.2 ounces
- Dimensions : 5.5 x 0.8 x 8.5 inches
- Best Sellers Rank: #171,280 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
- #222 in History of Religions
- #364 in History of Civilization & Culture
- #663 in History of Christianity (Books)
- Customer Reviews:
About the author

Discover more of the author’s books, see similar authors, read book recommendations and more.
Customer reviews
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on AmazonCustomers say
Customers find the book engaging, compelling, and well-written. They describe the narrative as well-documented, concise, and powerful. Readers also appreciate the amazing and eloquent stories.
AI-generated from the text of customer reviews
Customers find the book engaging, compelling, and fascinating. They say it's well-written and will hold their interest if they are truth seekers.
"...So well written is this book, it's very likely that after reading it you'll seek out more works by Carroll...." Read more
"...Carroll gets 5 stars for his record of the facts, and his lively and readable prose...." Read more
"An excellent book and valid and reliable documentation of the continuing journey of the Holy Eucharist to and across the Americas: to apply in a set..." Read more
"This book is a surprisingly quick, concise, and powerful read. It begins with the history of Cortez and his battles prior to Our Lady's appearance...." Read more
Customers find the narrative quality of the book well-documented, concise, and powerful. They also say it's a learning experience and an informative easy read. Readers also mention the story-telling abilities and fact-gathering are substantial.
"...Carroll's story-telling abilities and fact-gathering are substantial...." Read more
"...is that not only every page, but every line and every word is pecisely chosen and situated...." Read more
"An excellent book and valid and reliable documentation of the continuing journey of the Holy Eucharist to and across the Americas: to apply in a set..." Read more
"This book is a surprisingly quick, concise, and powerful read. It begins with the history of Cortez and his battles prior to Our Lady's appearance...." Read more
Customers find the stories amazing and eloquent. They say it's an incredible book on historical accounts of Cortez. Readers also mention the book is inspirational and informative.
"...recommend this great book also because it is one of the greatest stories in human history, condensed and viewed from a very interesting point of view..." Read more
"This is an excellent choice for researching or just reading for sound historical interpretation of the early Spanish in Mexico...." Read more
"Inspiring book that came quickly and at a good price. Great seller!" Read more
"This book gives you the historical facts on what Cortez had to deal with and how he miraculously overcame a great and dark evil; human..." Read more
Customers find the book trustworthy, reliable, and valid.
"An excellent book and valid and reliable documentation of the continuing journey of the Holy Eucharist to and across the Americas: to apply in a set..." Read more
"...It follows primary historical sources closely and is highly reliable...." Read more
"...sources, such as the diary of Cortez' right-hand-man Diaz, makes the work trustworthy and it does not suffer from revisionist ideology...." Read more
-
Top reviews
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
By Warren H. Carroll
1983 Christendom Press softcover 123 pp.
"Oh God!", cried Cortes, "Why dost thou permit the devil to be so grossly honored in the land?" He bowed his head and added, "Accept, O Lord, that we may serve Thee in this land." .... then he turned and faced the Hummingbird Wizard, it's obscene bulk rose up before him as though to fill the earth and all the sky. Somewhere near the door was a metal bar. Cortes seized it. He swung it over his head....[he] leapt up in a supernatural way and swung forward holding the bar midway till he struck the idol high up on its eyes, and broke off its gold mask, saying: "We must risk something for God."
And with that came the first blow to a truly evil empire that was being held in thrall to Satan. As the title of the book implies, Warren Carroll's "Our Lady of Guadalupe and the Conquest of Darkness", is a tale of two contiguous events that occurred in the first half of the 16th Century that would forever change the landscape of the New World. The first story - The Conquest of Darkness - is that of Hernán Cortés de Monroy y Pizarro, who's horrific discovery of human sacrifice on a scale unimagined and unparalleled in human history - until the passing of Roe vs. Wade in the 1970's - drove him to overthrow Montezuma's Aztec Empire against fantastic odds. Carroll, as do other historians of the period, relies heavily on the eye-witness accounts of Bernal Díaz del Castillo, and of surviving Aztec records of the events.
The second story, Our Lady of Guadalupe, takes much less room to tell. It's the story of Juan Diego, an Aztec convert to whom the Blessed Virgin Mary appeared on Tepeyac hill. The miracle of the image of Our Lady on the tilma presented to Bishop Juan de Zumárraga was the prelude to another miracle - that of an outpouring of grace that led to the most stunning mass conversion to Christianity since the Apostolic and Patristic ages.
Carroll's story-telling abilities and fact-gathering are substantial. He is always balanced in his presentation, never hiding the sinful side of man that always lurks behind even the most sublime events of history: the shadow of Judas; the tares ever-present among the wheat. So well written is this book, it's very likely that after reading it you'll seek out more works by Carroll. I highly recommend his six-volume history of the Catholic Church, A History of Christendom. The events that take place in this book are digested in volume 4 of that series.
A topic mentioned by Carroll at the very end of the book bears some attention because it is a sign of the Holy Spirit working in the Church. One of the compelling facets of the faith is the symmetry that is found throughout it: in scripture, in liturgy, in theology, and in practice - it's literally everywhere in the faith. Sometimes this symmetry will take the form of paradox: the horizontal and vertical of the cross, the 'kissing' of justice and mercy, reaching eternal life through temporal death. Sometimes the symmetry is found in the balance of the archetypes of the Old Testament with their fulfillment in the New: circumcision and baptism, the sacrificed lamb of the Pasch and the sacrificed Lamb of God, the fall through Eve and the redemption through Mary. The reason symmetry is so compelling is because it is an attribute of the beautiful, and beauty is an attribute of God: i.e., one of the things that helps lead us to Him.
The symmetrical beauty found in the theological, scriptural, and liturgical aspects of the Church, also holds true for historical symmetry, and one of the great symmetrical instances of history is that of the conversion of Mexico to the Catholic faith just as, a half a world away, a nearly identical number of Catholics and England were being forcibly removed from the Church by Henry VIII. The timelines are so close, one can only see the hand of God in them. Just as St. Thomas More is being executed for not acquiescing to recognizing Henry as head of the Church in England and the rest of the English bishops are apostatizing, in Mexico, Juan Diego is bearing witness to the Mother of God and it's all that the Spanish bishops can do to keep up with the native people's demands to be baptized. How utterly symmetrical. How utterly Catholic.
I highly recommend this book for all Catholics. If you've seen Mel Gibson's "Apocalypto" and wondered about the historical underpinnings of it, this book will be of enormous value to you. The chapters below show the topics and organization of this book:
1. More Than a World Apart (1487)
Part I: The Physical Conquest of Mexico
2. The Shores of the Nightmare (1517-19)
3. The March of the Skulls (1519)
4. In the Keep of the Hummingbird Wizard (1519-20)
5. The Night of Sorrow (1520)
6. Never Call Retreat (1520-21)
7. The Wizard Dethroned (1521)
Part II
8. Twelve Poor Men (1521-27)
9. Protector of the Indians (1527-31)
10. The Portrait of the Mother of God (December 1531)
11. Nine Million Baptisms (1532-48)
12. "Am I Not Here?"
What most readers should focus on is the important and significant development of alliances with the natives against the Aztecs. The miraculous victories won by Cortes against impossible odds. The futility of 'technology' against hundreds of thousands of hostiles gives away the modern myths of the conquest of Mexico. Rather, the insane level of mass slaughter for the Aztec's gods of war and hell are the true, non-spiritual reason for the victory. And no doubt Cortes had a share of supernatural invincibility around him for the conquest.
Not only does Carroll reprise the history of the conquest, he goes into the great betrayal - not only of Spain's Indian allies who were suddenly cast off and sold into slavery - but of Cortes himself. Before the dead had even been mourned, Spanish conquerors had twisted the victory into a disaster for the very people who fought the war. I am reminded of the Russian soldiers who fought for the motherland in WW2, but were then sent off to death camps by Stalin who feared their patriotism, honor, bravery, and virtue.
Then Carroll turns to the tale of the supernatural vision of Our Lady of Guadalupe. Again skeptics can dismiss it, but it is another of those remarkable coincidences without which the world would be a totally different place. Certainly the vision gave strength to those who wanted to forge a decent Christian nation out of Mexico, but Carroll does not go into that or the Rancero system that effectively turned Mexico into a feudal, Catholic colony with the Indians reduced to serfdom.
Carroll gets 5 stars for his record of the facts, and his lively and readable prose. He also cuts the tale to the quick, and avoids getting bogged down. I would have liked a more detailed follow up regarding the decline of Mexico.
Carroll ignores the tendency of the Roman Church to live in Catholic World and sleep through abuse of the peasants and the corruption of the authorities. Then all of a sudden the Church gets its panties in a wad when the inevitable system collapse comes and the Church is ignominiously kicked to the curb and libeled with many falsehoods going far beyond its collaboration with the previous establishment. I would down-vote the book for that failure, but we live in a time when most students have only heard falsehoods, and have not heard the truth much less the rational and appropriate opprobrium the Church deserves.
Top reviews from other countries
I could not have been more wrong. It is the history of the origins of the conquest of Mexico by the Spanish led by Hernan Cortez. It documents precisely, with dates and times, the Mexico of the 16th century in which the Spanish army found themselves. The rigours endured by the Spanish were particularly harsh and this book leaves the reader with a sense of deep respect for the people who travelled to Mexico with a mission of salvation in mind. I knew nothing of the Aztecs and their religious practices so this book provided grisly information and helped plug some gaps in my knowledge. In case you don't know, the Aztecs practised human sacrifice. Not just occasional human sacrifice but quite genocidal human sacrifice and I particularly recall one passage in the book where the Spanish troops were given food sprinkled with human blood by their Aztec hosts.
The book is subtitled 'And the Conquest of Darkness'. The 'DARKNESS' to which the subtitle refers is obviouly the mass slaughter of human beings -practised in the name of religion.
At no stage is the book preachy and the incident which led to the devotion of the book's title is only dealt with at the very end. It is a fascinating story. The miraculous tilma still exists today and can be seen in Mexico. The author makes the point that the English Reformation, begun in the 16th Century by Henry VIII lost around 9 million Catholics to the European Church, a loss from which the Church has never recovered. However, the 9 million converts to Catholicism in Mexico as a result of the miracle leading to the devotion of Our Lady of Guadalupe occurred at the same time in history as the English Reformation.
It is a well researched book and it makes a fascinating read.







