Personal Knowledge: Towards a Post-Critical Philosophy 1st Edition
Use the Amazon App to scan ISBNs and compare prices.
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
- Publisher : University Of Chicago Press; 1st edition (August 15, 1974)
- Language : English
- Paperback : 428 pages
- ISBN-10 : 0226672883
- ISBN-13 : 978-0226672885
- Item Weight : 1.18 pounds
- Dimensions : 5.75 x 1 x 8.75 inches
- Best Sellers Rank: #906,347 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
- Customer Reviews:
Reviews with images
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
On that topic, the preface itself is worth the price of the entire book! It very clearly outlines not just Polanyi's central premises, but Polanyi the person. BUT it must me studied, not read. In Polanyi's own terms, knowledge requires commitment, which implies bias, and profiting from this volume takes a LOT of effort due to the stylistic and special linguistic significance of many terms, which are not used in their ordinary sense.
Of course you could say that about all philosophy of science texts, but this book is unique in that it doesn't "start and end with words" like a lot of texts that seem to just be an ego outing by the author to dance with semantics, but actually helps the reader look at her life through different lenses, frames, focuses and zooms as we examine the practical assumptions we make when jumping from evidence to explanation. Highly recommended, but not for the faint of heart or time constrained soul!
Beyond its application to economics, social theory, and management theory, he offers serious challenges to the popular representational theories of modernity. Our connection with reality is preserved while acknowledging our fallibility, but through a rational criticism of doubt. We contact reality through our indwelling of the media through which we contact reality. The media of our senses, use of tools, and construction of theory are affirmed. Our access to reality requires a commitment on our part; the legitimate role of subjectivity in achieving access to reality is affirmed rather than placed under the rug in the way they are in popular conceptions of science. Polanyi brings much insight here. In many ways his insights about the sociology of science in this regard previewed what Thomas Kuhn would later write. The advantage of Polanyi is that his interpretation of these phenomena are less skeptical on account of the rest of the epistemology that he works out.
Truly an outstanding work. Worth reading 3-4 times.
Secondly, after reading any given section, be it one page long or twenty, write down a couple sentences of takeaway knowledge. Obviously, you can look to Polanyi's italicized sentences for guidance towards the most noteworthy ideas. But search particularly for those keywords that strike you in ways you might not expect. Find the dictional centres around which the rest of the words revolve. In this way you will set yourself up for a third instruction: you are learning a new language.
Consider reading Personal Knowledge less like a philosophy lecture and more like a storybook in a foreign language. Truly, the text demands immersion into the title itself, this new and unassuming paradox coined by Polanyi--this "personal knowledge"--and immersion into all the unexpected stories of which the author draws upon to make his point. Albeit, the logical flow of Polanyi's argument is not contingent upon all of these pieces. Polanyi himself acknowledges time and time again how many parts are "digressions," "beside the point," or "merely interesting." After struggling through chapter five, you may admittedly feel betrayed by the beginning of six: "the previous chapter was a digression" (132). (Not to tempt you with skipping chapter five--don't). I would go so far as to say that, from the standpoint of logician's progress, four-fifths of the text is non-essential material.
That being said, the four-fifths may actually be quite essential in the sense of immersion. Within the four-fifths are surprising stories of all kinds: speech and mathematics, evolution and biology, crystallography and communications and probability, reason, faith, doubt, God, etc. Each of the different narratives pushes and prods our understanding of personal knowledge, and not just that, each narrative expands the meanings of a whole arsenal of words employed by Polanyi to make his point. Of course, describing this expansion is difficult at best, and it really can only be experienced--a gestalt sensation like much of what Polanyi describes. So allow me one final direction for the novice reading.
Do not skip the preface; read it slowly; write a paragraph about what it means to you and proceed with the rest of the book. Then, when you have finished going through every narrative, every dead-end, and every digression, go back to the preface. Read it again slowly and appreciate your new context. In hindsight, the first reading will feel shallow and small, even if it felt fine at the time. Acknowledge how the words are all the same as before, yet they all have new functions and new meanings with a new background. The second preface reading will have all the colours and currents of the deep river in which you submerged yourself for four hundred pages. We may call the shift of colour our second simplicity.
Top reviews from other countries
Good service form this seller, would use them again.
Many (most) people today have only a very hazy idea of what proper scientific method is, and what characterises good science practise. Polanyi shows that far from being all cut and dried as popular mythology would have it, the progress of science depends to a much greater extent than commonly recognised on what he calls "tacit knowledge": the hunch, the smell of a problem, a sense of how it ought to be.
If you want to know how science really works, from a master of the art, and you like engaging in profound thought, then this book is for you.
Yes, by the greatest french intellectual of the 20th century, speaking about the hungarian-british scientist turned philosopher.
Don't lose time reading Sartre, Hegel, Kant, whatever. The esssentials are in this book: real philosophy about real things, only useful abstractions, deep and also vibrant.
This gem has been "hiding", so to speak, since the 1950s. Yes, only a small minority has enjoyed it for over half a century.
You can for around 10 pounds ... And hey, beware: I DO NOT WORK FOR AMAZON, IN SPITE OF APPEARANCES !!!!!!!!!
This is my own personal bible, that's all.