Top critical review
3 people found this helpful
Narrow but comfy -- and pricey
on January 14, 2012
The scarf is soft and feels like it's made of quality material. The problem is that it's narrow, which means that even when you double it up, it probably won't cover your entire neck opening when worn with something like an overcoat that doesn't close up beyond the middle of your upper chest. I had to separately buy a wider scarf at Banana Republic (not cashmere, but almost as comfy and 1/3 the price of this one thanks to a good sale) to wear with my overcoat. I still use this one though for wearing with my sporty jacket, where the opening that needs to be covered is smaller and the scarf's narrowness is actually a plus.
If I had to do it again, I'm not sure I'd spend $50 on a scarf that I can only use in certain situations, especially given the existence of cheaper high-quality alternatives.