Other Sellers on Amazon
The Question of God: Sigmund Freud & C.S. Lewis
Frequently Bought Together
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
Top Customer Reviews
I won't tell you which way I lean (Freud? Lewis?)... but I will say BUY THIS! SEE IT! It is quite possibly one of the only sources giving equal time to both sides of this age-old issue. If nothing else, you'll be fascinated at the eruption of thoughts/realizations that you-the viewer will most-certainly experience.
As is to be expected (hey, it's PBS :) The Question of God is very well done. Extremely fascinating, and it makes you think. I was so impressed by it that I'm seriously considering buying it. I'm also going to read C.S. Lewis' Mere Christianity.
I was especially pleased with the roundtable discussions of a focus group. It is a delight to see unscripted opinions being expressed in a non confrontative format. The panel is also well balanced, with no shills on either side. This has become my favorite Nova presentation and I highly recommend it to just about anyone interested in a well rounded education.
The DVD successfully intertwines both actors protraying Freud and Lewis and a roundtable discussion of the ideas behind the two men. I found both aspects of the DVD to be very well done. The actors did an amazing job playing Freud and Lewis and the discussions were well intentioned and provided some thought-provoking information.
That being said, I did have a hard time with some of the people participating in the discussion. For the most part, they were well informed and very well educated. Some though, simply did not have any sort of rationale or basis for their opinion/beliefs (either theistic or atheistic). Perhaps experts in this field would have suited the debate better and provided a more meaningful discussion. (i.e. Philosophers, theologans, professors, etc.)
Overall, an excellent DVD.
I'd read his books for years (in fact, I've read MERE CHRISTIANITY several times) but didn't know much about him until I saw the movie SHADOWLANDS with Anthony Hopkins and Debra Winger in 1993. What an introduction! Since then, I've read several biographies, watched the British TV version of SHADOWLANDS, and even attended a stage version. I've actually started reading his Narnia books as well, looking forward to the big-budget Hollywood version heading to screens in Christmas of '05.
So I watched with much interest this PBS show that compared and contrasted the lives of Lewis and Sigmund Freud. The best parts for me were watching the recreations of their lives and intercutting their words into a dialogue or argument. I don't know as much about Freud but I think they did a great job of portraying Lewis and representing what his life and writings meant.
The only part that didn't really work was the roundtable discussions with the professor who taught this study as a class. A couple of people came off as rather shallow since they were trying to sound deep about something they didn't really believe in the first place. There were a few interesting moments, but it felt tedious to be cutting away from the biographical segments that were so much more interesting.
Still, definitely worth having and watching.
Most Recent Customer Reviews
Wonderful reflection on the Question of God by two great figures in history!Published 1 month ago by Lucia Salinas
Content is pretty good, but the format lacks chapter divisions so picking up where you left off is a challenge.Published 2 months ago by Erick N. Larson
Wonderful compare & contrast of the two prevailing life views throughout humanity! Non-emotional, and well reasoned!Published 23 months ago by Wade Guisbert
The way this debate is put together it is easy for a Christian to feel validated and hopeful in the pursuit of Gods Grace.
Loved it, John
I've bought several copies over the years. I give them away frequently and get more. Great stuff! I recommend it.Published on January 17, 2013 by David Duerden
have a question about god? this is one of those debates that will give you reason to set aside the reason(s) and maybe there can be a little crack in the wall. very interesting.Published on December 13, 2012 by Frances T. Colamatteo
I am not sure what I was expecting. I suppose I was looking for more of a theoretical discussion. There was more about the individuals than I expected.Published on November 29, 2012 by Craig Snyder
Set up an Amazon Giveaway
What Other Items Do Customers Buy After Viewing This Item?
Look for Similar Items by Category
- Movies & TV > Christian Movies & TV
- Movies & TV > Genre for Featured Categories > Documentary
- Movies & TV > Genre for Featured Categories > Drama
- Movies & TV > Genre for Featured Categories > Faith & Spirituality
- Movies & TV > Independently Distributed > Documentary
- Movies & TV > Independently Distributed > Drama
- Movies & TV > PBS
- Movies & TV > TV