R.E.M. Live CD+DVD, Live
|New from||Used from|
MP3 Music, October 16, 2007
Frequently Bought Together
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
01. I Took Your Name
02. So Fast, So Numb
03. Boy In The Well
05. Everybody Hurts
06. Electron Blue07. Bad Day
08. The Ascent Of Man
09. The Great Beyond
10. Leaving New York
11. Orange Crush
12. I Wanted To Be Wrong
13. Final Straw
14. Imitation Of Life
15. The One I Love
16. Walk Unafraid
17. Losing My Religion
1. What's The Frequency, Kenneth?
3. (Don't Go Back To) Rockville
4. I'm Gonna DJ
5. Man On The Moon
Disc 3 DVD
1.I Took Your Name
2.So Fast, So Numb
3.Boy in the Well
8.Ascent Of Man
9.The Great Beyond
10.Leaving New York
12.I Wanted To Be Wrong
14.Imitation Of Life
15.The One I Love
17.Losing My Religion
18.What's The Frequency, Kenneth?
20.(Don't Go Back To) Rockville
21.I'm Gonna DJ
22.Man On The Moon
Top Customer Reviews
As stated in other reviews, this IS virtually unwatchable.
And that's a shame, 'cause it's a wonderful rock show that sounds great, but looks awful.
Seriously, what could they be thinking when they okayed something that just looks like they set a couple of hyperactive kids loose in the production room, told them to push as many buttons as often as possible, and then instructed the camera crew to just fudge with all the bells and whistles on their equipment, and, oh, every once in a while, for a second or two, show something IN FOCUS?
The concept of concert DVD's is a great one, and one that I've invested a lot of time and money in, as far as owning and watching. There are so many lessons to be learned from watching a Jonathan Demme or Martin Scorsese-shot show...watch The Last Waltz or Heart Of Gold to see what I mean. Why some of these directors find it necessary to give us something so muddied, something so out of sync with the original intent (which I would imagine would be a visual souvenir to go with the CD), is beyond me.
UNLESS...the original intent WAS this headache-causing, nausea-inducing mess.
Again, the music is great, performed well, and is a joy to listen to.
Sadly, the DVD drags the package down to the point where, after one aborted attempted viewing, it will probably never see my DVD player again, unless the government recruits me to torture suspected terrorists, in which case I would slip this in, turn the sound down, leave the room, and wait for the impending screamfest.
Three stars out of five for the music alone.
This is the first official live album release in REM's illustrious career, and what a curious choice it is. This is released 2.5 years after its recording at 2 shows at The Point Depot in Dublin, Ireland (why now, and not say 2 years ago?), when REM was touring behind the "Around the Sun" album, arguably its weakest album ever.
As to the audio CDs, "R.E.M. Live" (2 CDs, 22 tracks, 103 min.) brings a mix of the newer tunes, mixed with some older tracks. The album starts off with the best track on here, a blazing "I Took Your Name" (from the underappreciated "Monster" album). The problem is there are way too many tracks from "Around the Sun", 6 to be exact, bunched up in the first half of the show. Yet, there are some great nuggest as well: "Bad Day", "Orange Crush", "What's the Frequency Kenneth" and "(Don't Go Back to) Rockville", with a guest appearance from Daniel Ryan of The Thrills (from Ireland), obviously getting a huge crowd response.
As to the DVD (105 min.), well it's almost unwatchable, to be honest. Edited in MTV-style, it changes angles literally every second during most songs, just about causing motion-sickness. I couldn't stand for most of it. There are no extras whatsoever on the DVD, no interviews, or other goodies you might expect from this.
R.E.M. released a concert movie once before, "Road Movie", taped in the mid-90s durng their "Monster" tour, and still available as DVD. While the editing is just as migraine-inducing, the music on it is MILES better than this release, so if you wanna explore REM at their height of a live band (with Bill Berry as their drummer), I would highly encourage you to check that out.
But boy was I disappointed when it started -- the DVD was PAINFUL to watch and made both my wife and I nauseous -- it has to be the worst concert DVD I've ever seen -- the editing is beyond frenetic -- I mean, harsh cuts that never last more than 1 or 2 seconds on each shot (you can count them out -- 1, 2, 3 -- CUT; 1,2,3 -- CUT; 1,2 -- CUT; 1 -- CUT), and even worse -- the shots are never steady (as if the director/producer told the cameramen "Don't ever hold your cameras still), they focus on random things (SUPER closeup of Michael Stipe's left eye; grainy footage of video monitors in the editing room; get a good shot of a guitar and then [WHY???] cut to the same shot with green editing graphics over it; a foot); and even worse, they do inneumerable things to distort the picture when the do have a good shot (put a prism in front of the camera [I think], mess with the graininess and/or color).
Despite LOVING the music and generally being a fan of concert videos, we couldn't stand more than 20 minutes of this PAINFUL video -- it gave us both headaches.
So, buy/listen to the CDs, or even play the DVD if you want to hear surround sound, but for your own sake, TURN THE TV OFF IF YOU DON'T WANT TO GET NAUSEOUS or a headache!!!!
Most Recent Customer Reviews
For years I had avoided this album as Reveal had bored me so much that I not only stopped paying attention to them, I stopped playing their older music entirely. Read morePublished 23 months ago by Michael Grabowski
Excellent cd/DVD and I have watched the DVD several times. I hope that rem comes back and starts doing tours again but it is nice to see them in concert on this DVD.Published on February 6, 2014 by Brandon Williams
This is a must have for any REM fan. They sound amazing! I was never able to see REM in person so I really love the live concert sound. The DVD is enjoyable and is a nice touch. Read morePublished on January 11, 2014 by Melissa C. Jurgensen
I’ve rated this box set 5-Stars because the music and the recordings themselves are excellent, capturing the feel and energy of the concert while maintaining excellent recording... Read morePublished on December 27, 2013 by SpinDog
I'm disappointed that R.E.M. would even put something that is so meandering.I own several R.E.M. cd's as well as some live cd's. This by far the worst.Published on May 25, 2013 by George Klavins
This is a puzzling release. The audio portion is pretty good, with a mix of new songs (the ones from Around the Sun are much better here than on that record) and old classics. Read morePublished on July 21, 2010 by J. Hughes